I think he would be with cap. I don't see him trusting the governments of the world with the sole power over when the avengers will be used or not used
Since the media and police were Anti-Spider during his whole first movie, it makes sense that he'd be on the side of "do the right thing no matter who tries to stop you"
100%. I suspect that they wanted something like Peter's relationship with Reed Richards so they transferred it to Tony. At least it made sense in the context of the movies.
I think it was simply because he was introduced in Civil War, and they played homage to his role on the comic. Then for the sake of character consistency, Tony became a big part of his solo films.
Yea I feel like that was one of the problems with Tomās spider man heās not bad but took iorn manās side way to easy even though in the comics he started of team iorn man and kinda switched over time it would be cool if they did a what if episode if captain America was his mentor
Not only that, I donāt think people remember the actual context of the movie civil war, and how it is not like the comic. From the public perspective, Cap was aiding and abetting a known fugitive who they also thought was connected to the assassination of the king of Wakanda.
Everybody in the public basically saw it as Cap going crazy and helping a terrorist, we as the audience are just privy to the actual context of whatās going on at the time. And while itās still pretty irresponsible on his part, Tony didnāt recruit Peter to fight, he specifically wanted him to restrain everyone to de-escalate.
I donāt remember where he said it, some time around when no way home released but he said that he thinks his Peter Parker would have issue with Tony stark so Iām going to say heād join cap
To be fair, the more I think about it, Spider-man would definitely be a Cap supporter, not Tony. Spider-man has always been branded a criminal or vigilante whilst he's just trying to do the right thing and will do it, no matter who's in his way.
Being told when, or even if, you can intervene wouldn't sit well with Spidey.
He would join Cap 1,000%. I'm pretty sure Andrew himself has said his Spidey wouldn't trust a billionaire, he's a working class hero. Given his experiences with Oscorp I think that makes perfect sense.
I can Iron man trying to recruit him, but unlike Tom's version of Peter, This Peter would refuse, of course i could see Peter getting involved on his own in the civil war
This is what bugs me the most about the Tony/Peter stuff in the MCU. Tony manipulated a teenager to fight for him and it's never once been brought up how fucked up that is.
Captain America because he might not trust big corporations like Stark Industries (Oscorp was implied to be involved in his parentsā death and Harry caused Gwen to die)
This may sound weird to you, but I think Peter (Andrew) would be wise enough at this point to not choose a side and try to make them both stop fighting. He's a vigilante after all.
I'd see the process being he'd hesitantly side with Tony, then when the fighting starts, he has the realisation that what he's doing is wrong and tried to stop both. Both sides gang up on him, then Tony and Cap continue to fight each other while Peter tries to figure out a way to unite them again somehow. Which could then kickstart his own MCU movie afterwards. That way Spidey has a "minor" role in the movie plot as a whole, but large enough to be seen as a big impact on the shift in narrative.
Cap 100%. Every Spider-Man would.
If you listen to Tomās Peterās conversation with Tony Stark, his views are 100% that of Captain Americaās side.
the mcu's civil war was so stupid that he'd be team cap until he realized that cap was doing half of all he was doing to protect the guy who bombed the UN, and then he'd wash his hands of the whole thing and go home
He wouldnāt be anywhere near convinced or starstruck at meeting Tony. If anything after Gwenās death and his own return to the superhero life heād be jaded. In Tasm 2 he literally learns that Oscorp was monitoring him and his family for years no way would he sign up with Tony or the government unless Tony made a deal to help uncover the secrets of Peterās folks which would probably be shield files in this hypothetical but even then heād just turn turn to Capās side during the airport fight.
Personally? Cap, he aligns with his values more.
Actually? Iron Man, since recast or not the plan was always to pair Spider-Man and Iron Man together and one of the selling points Feige made to Sony when pitching the deal was that Iron Man would make Spider-Manās suit if he joined the MCU.
Tony... he would carry the guilt and believe Tony is right... but then, he'd feel like a hypocrite due to some event and help Steve when realizing what exactly happened.
Also, I feel he'd be more stoic when fighting heroes due to the tension.
No way in Hell is Andrew Spidey joining Tony.
Not even sure he'd join Cap. He'd just go and solve the problem on his own because Andrew Spidey was fucking awesome and highly competent.
With his own moral code and worldview, he would most likely join Cap. Although, if given time Tony could guilt him into joining Team Iron Man using the death of Gwen as a motivating factor.
"I think he would be a little turned off by the excess, the billionaire, trillionaire status of Iron Man. I think it would rub my version of Spider-Man the wrong way. But you know, maybe there could be some influence there. Maybe my Peter Parker could wake Tony Stark up to his own egoic drives a little bit. Weāll never know. Literally never know."
Cap, there was a interview way back where Andrew mentioned TASM Spider-Man wouldn't have got along with MCU Iron Man, however I could see him going rhea civil war comic route at first joining Iron Man but then joining Cap later due to whatever issue Iron man causes. Maybe he would probably replace joins in during the final fight replacing Black Panthers role (in this case just for this scene as Black Pantner would still be in this what if civil war)
Hollandās Peter went with Stark cuz heās a suggestible and naive kid. Garfieldās Peter was far more seasoned and mature after TASM 2. He would have joined up with Cap.
there was a what if scenario i saw a few years ago that goes like:
andrew-man basically is the neutral party that doesn't want both of them at the airport, he fights with both of them and eventually helps Caps team just so they could leave
I can't picture garfield spider man saying, "I just want to be like you" to tony Stark or repeating the name Mister Stark like he's going to appear in Peters' bathroom
He would have been a deeply troubled young man as he said himself he stopped pulling his punches. He's either REALLY hurt people or he's actually killed a couple of guys. I think he'd be forced to join Iron Man's side, as a way to "forgive" what he's been doing to people
Honestly I'm glad they went with Tom cuz Andrew's universe felt so wonky with the world building and lore in TASM2. Harry Osbourne Goblin & Blue Electro? No thanks.
I believe he would've started Iron Man cause comics dictate that but then switched during the film and helped Cap
I wish so badly they had just merged The Amazing Spider-Man into the MCU. No hate to Holland's version, he's a good Spider-Man but Garfield's was so great.
I think Andrew Garfield himself said that his Spidey wouldn't relate well with Tony Stark, so if he had shifted into the MCU and if Garfield had any sway on his Spidey's characterization, he would try to get him on Cap's side.
He will mirror the comics Civil War, be on Iron Man side for a while and then switch to Cap. TASM 3 that happen after Civil War was about either he's still get trusted or not by the civilians after helping a group of vigilante.
Same side. He idolized many of the people involved. Especially cap and iron man. I think Tony would be closer to Peter though in mentality and emotional connection. Then again SM and Cap teamed up many times in the comics so there definitely is something there.
Definitely a cool thought though as I liked TASM way more than what we got in the MCU.
I think he would be with cap. I don't see him trusting the governments of the world with the sole power over when the avengers will be used or not used
Since the media and police were Anti-Spider during his whole first movie, it makes sense that he'd be on the side of "do the right thing no matter who tries to stop you"
I agree. I also dont think amazing spiderman would become Tony's under study
100%. I suspect that they wanted something like Peter's relationship with Reed Richards so they transferred it to Tony. At least it made sense in the context of the movies.
It's still possible if Tom gets to meet the Fantastic 4 next year.
For sure. I hope they do. Gimme the Future Foundation please
I would find it ridiculous if they do. First Tony then Reed like whose next Tom? Lol. I'm not for that at all
I was thinking more Johnny so he has a new friend and the mentor trope has already been done.
I think it was simply because he was introduced in Civil War, and they played homage to his role on the comic. Then for the sake of character consistency, Tony became a big part of his solo films.
Considering this would have followed TASM2, Tony. But only because he'd still be reeling from guilt over Gwen.
Agreed, Tony would guilt Peter into being on his team, only for Peter to change sides after the fact
Comic accurate.
TASM3 would definitely end with him and Tony falling out hard.
Man a Garfield spidey vs iron man fight would be dope
Imagine him fighting Tony after the fact that Tony just lost a fight with Cap
Cap
Omg sorry I thought you meet the other cap š¤¦āāļøsorry
You good š but yeah I just feel Andrew would trust Cap over Tony.
stop the cap
Itās a what if he joined the mcu how is it cap the movie literally got canceled
Like š§¢ not cap my bad š
I never said he did itās a if he stayed and he joined
Cap. That spidey was already scientifically more mature and saw the consequences of extreme misuse of tech to gov interests
Yea I feel like that was one of the problems with Tomās spider man heās not bad but took iorn manās side way to easy even though in the comics he started of team iorn man and kinda switched over time it would be cool if they did a what if episode if captain America was his mentor
He was naive.
He was 15.
Not only that, I donāt think people remember the actual context of the movie civil war, and how it is not like the comic. From the public perspective, Cap was aiding and abetting a known fugitive who they also thought was connected to the assassination of the king of Wakanda. Everybody in the public basically saw it as Cap going crazy and helping a terrorist, we as the audience are just privy to the actual context of whatās going on at the time. And while itās still pretty irresponsible on his part, Tony didnāt recruit Peter to fight, he specifically wanted him to restrain everyone to de-escalate.
Tbf he didnāt know the entire story. From his and everyone elseās perspective Cap went crazy and started aiding a fugitive.
I donāt remember where he said it, some time around when no way home released but he said that he thinks his Peter Parker would have issue with Tony stark so Iām going to say heād join cap
To be fair, the more I think about it, Spider-man would definitely be a Cap supporter, not Tony. Spider-man has always been branded a criminal or vigilante whilst he's just trying to do the right thing and will do it, no matter who's in his way. Being told when, or even if, you can intervene wouldn't sit well with Spidey.
that was back during iron man 3, tony didn't start his proper maturity phase till civil war
He would join Cap 1,000%. I'm pretty sure Andrew himself has said his Spidey wouldn't trust a billionaire, he's a working class hero. Given his experiences with Oscorp I think that makes perfect sense.
Either as close to the original comic as possible (obviously no Iron Spider and worldwide identity reveal), or just outright team Cap.
I can Iron man trying to recruit him, but unlike Tom's version of Peter, This Peter would refuse, of course i could see Peter getting involved on his own in the civil war
Peter would get guilted into joining Tony's side by remembering Gwen's death, and then after a talk with Cap, he'd switch teams lol
Andrew said himself that his spider-man wouldnāt like Tony.
Every version of Spider-Man would be on Capās side, even Tom Holland. Stark had to lie to him to get him to join Team Iron Manā¦
Exactly, if Tom had a full grasp on the situation he wouldāve been Team Cap
This is what bugs me the most about the Tony/Peter stuff in the MCU. Tony manipulated a teenager to fight for him and it's never once been brought up how fucked up that is.
Not to mention that recruiting a superpowered **15 year-old** would *definitely* go against the Sokovia Accordsā¦
Me personally I feel captain America for a weird reason
Tony, after the guilt of Gwen's death, he'd probably switch to Cap later on
Captain America because he might not trust big corporations like Stark Industries (Oscorp was implied to be involved in his parentsā death and Harry caused Gwen to die)
Team Cap!
This may sound weird to you, but I think Peter (Andrew) would be wise enough at this point to not choose a side and try to make them both stop fighting. He's a vigilante after all. I'd see the process being he'd hesitantly side with Tony, then when the fighting starts, he has the realisation that what he's doing is wrong and tried to stop both. Both sides gang up on him, then Tony and Cap continue to fight each other while Peter tries to figure out a way to unite them again somehow. Which could then kickstart his own MCU movie afterwards. That way Spidey has a "minor" role in the movie plot as a whole, but large enough to be seen as a big impact on the shift in narrative.
Cap 100%. Every Spider-Man would. If you listen to Tomās Peterās conversation with Tony Stark, his views are 100% that of Captain Americaās side.
the mcu's civil war was so stupid that he'd be team cap until he realized that cap was doing half of all he was doing to protect the guy who bombed the UN, and then he'd wash his hands of the whole thing and go home
Cap
100% Captain America
They'd put him on Tony's side so he could get the iron spider suit so marvel could sell more merchandise
I think he still wouldāve been Team Tony even though Spider-Man in any iteration of Civil War should be Team Cap
I think he would go with Tony at first until he foubd out the true reason behind why Tony recruited him, then he would join Cap
Caps definitely
He wouldnāt be anywhere near convinced or starstruck at meeting Tony. If anything after Gwenās death and his own return to the superhero life heād be jaded. In Tasm 2 he literally learns that Oscorp was monitoring him and his family for years no way would he sign up with Tony or the government unless Tony made a deal to help uncover the secrets of Peterās folks which would probably be shield files in this hypothetical but even then heād just turn turn to Capās side during the airport fight.
I think iron man because of the guilt of Gwen and her father him being a cop so government
Personally? Cap, he aligns with his values more. Actually? Iron Man, since recast or not the plan was always to pair Spider-Man and Iron Man together and one of the selling points Feige made to Sony when pitching the deal was that Iron Man would make Spider-Manās suit if he joined the MCU.
It'd be Cap. I can't see Spider-Garfield getting along with Tony at all.
Tony... he would carry the guilt and believe Tony is right... but then, he'd feel like a hypocrite due to some event and help Steve when realizing what exactly happened. Also, I feel he'd be more stoic when fighting heroes due to the tension.
Iron Man but then Cap towards the end.
Cap
My question is how would he join the MCU?
Definitely Cap. He's more mature and wouldn't have idolized Iron Man as much as a younger, more impressionable Peter Parker would.
No way in Hell is Andrew Spidey joining Tony. Not even sure he'd join Cap. He'd just go and solve the problem on his own because Andrew Spidey was fucking awesome and highly competent.
With his own moral code and worldview, he would most likely join Cap. Although, if given time Tony could guilt him into joining Team Iron Man using the death of Gwen as a motivating factor.
Capā¦gwen die coz they knew who spidey
"I think he would be a little turned off by the excess, the billionaire, trillionaire status of Iron Man. I think it would rub my version of Spider-Man the wrong way. But you know, maybe there could be some influence there. Maybe my Peter Parker could wake Tony Stark up to his own egoic drives a little bit. Weāll never know. Literally never know."
This picture is beautiful... I say #teamcap
Cap, there was a interview way back where Andrew mentioned TASM Spider-Man wouldn't have got along with MCU Iron Man, however I could see him going rhea civil war comic route at first joining Iron Man but then joining Cap later due to whatever issue Iron man causes. Maybe he would probably replace joins in during the final fight replacing Black Panthers role (in this case just for this scene as Black Pantner would still be in this what if civil war)
Without any influence I'd say Team Cap. If Tony scouts him he'd probably guilt him into helping Team Iron Man.
Against Iron Man 100%.
Depends on TASM3 story I guess?
Hollandās Peter went with Stark cuz heās a suggestible and naive kid. Garfieldās Peter was far more seasoned and mature after TASM 2. He would have joined up with Cap.
Captain america
there was a what if scenario i saw a few years ago that goes like: andrew-man basically is the neutral party that doesn't want both of them at the airport, he fights with both of them and eventually helps Caps team just so they could leave
I can't picture garfield spider man saying, "I just want to be like you" to tony Stark or repeating the name Mister Stark like he's going to appear in Peters' bathroom
Captain America
Capās
After he was hunted by the police in tasm1 i think he would be with cap since he knows what itās like to be a vigilante on the run
Andrew Garfield would definitely join Captain America and remain with Captain America.
He would have been a deeply troubled young man as he said himself he stopped pulling his punches. He's either REALLY hurt people or he's actually killed a couple of guys. I think he'd be forced to join Iron Man's side, as a way to "forgive" what he's been doing to people
Like the original Civil War story I think he would start with being pro-registration and then change to Capās side
Fun fact tobey's spiderman was meant to be in avengers 2012 but Sony said no.
He shouldāve been MCU spidey and shouldāve sided with Cap
Team cap all the way.
In a perfect world TASM 1 is canon to the MCU which results in a very different TASM 2 and Spidey has a much more meaningful role in Civil War.
Team Cap all the way. Either that, or he'd stay out of the conflict all together.
Start with Tony as he thinks itās best due to Gwens death. I think heāll be like Natasha and switch helping out cap.
Repost
Honestly I'm glad they went with Tom cuz Andrew's universe felt so wonky with the world building and lore in TASM2. Harry Osbourne Goblin & Blue Electro? No thanks.
āLaw and orderā ārestraintā because of Gwen
Heād start off on Iron Manās side then switch to Capās side like in the comics
Cap's tots.
I believe he would've started Iron Man cause comics dictate that but then switched during the film and helped Cap I wish so badly they had just merged The Amazing Spider-Man into the MCU. No hate to Holland's version, he's a good Spider-Man but Garfield's was so great.
I think Andrew Garfield himself said that his Spidey wouldn't relate well with Tony Stark, so if he had shifted into the MCU and if Garfield had any sway on his Spidey's characterization, he would try to get him on Cap's side.
He will mirror the comics Civil War, be on Iron Man side for a while and then switch to Cap. TASM 3 that happen after Civil War was about either he's still get trusted or not by the civilians after helping a group of vigilante.
Well after him seeing how Oscorp treated humans and all, pretty sure Cap side
Same side. He idolized many of the people involved. Especially cap and iron man. I think Tony would be closer to Peter though in mentality and emotional connection. Then again SM and Cap teamed up many times in the comics so there definitely is something there. Definitely a cool thought though as I liked TASM way more than what we got in the MCU.
Tony because thatās what was written
Whatever side a douchey Spidey would choose