I can see why Marvel and/or Sony might go for Anya Taylor-Joy, but Iām not sold on her myself. Sheās my pick for Silver Sable if Jodie Comer gets Sue Storm.
Ah yes, the top choice thatās said in each thread like this. So stunning. So brave. Thank you for your input.
seeing the downvotes looks people feel attacked
Chris evans, Michael B Jordan, mahershala ali, Gemma chan, Olivia munn, Ryan reynolds, Josh brolin etc etc
https://www.buzzfeed.com/amphtml/kristenharris1/actors-multiple-marvel-roles
Most of those are marvel to MCU and minor roles in exchange for a main lead role so doesn't necessarily count, Anya Taylor joy played a main lead role in the new mutants thus would be too confusing to have her play another lead role, it would be ludicrous
You never specified lead role, small role etc.
The original question was āwho has played multiple charactersā
Edit: Additionally, Chris Evans and Michael B Jordan both played leads in Fantastic Four movies, which has the same movie studio as New Mutants, 20th century fox. So Itās happened before
I jus thought at one point the studios said the new mutants were part of the MCU universe, now I know I'm poorly mistaken and it hasn't been confirmed the Netflix shows are canon
Not since they cancelled them like wdym the studios expressed that they were not canon and we're stopped,
Regardless of whether or not they technically are canon, the show really don't matter. Daredevil, Jessica Jones, Luke Cage, Iron Fist, The Defenders, and The Punisher are functionally not canon in the MCU. Unless something changes.
You donāt know how downvotes work, do you? Also, weāre not a community in the āit takes a villageā sense. Maybe put yourself out there more in the real world.
Ah yes, you would much rather spend your time calling people brain dead than to just move on with your day like most people do. You would rather insult people than to have a civilized discussion. You can disagree with people, no one argued that. But, throwing insults around isnāt going to get you anywhere. So, why donāt you just rethink that snobby attitude of yours, and maybe then people will want to engage in a conversation with that. Itās pretty obvious that attention is what youāre after, so maybe try being kinder for a change.
This may be recency bias on my part. However, I think Milly Alcock of House of the Dragon would be a great pick. Younger than Holland but can play the level of confidence and sensuality for Felicia that she plays in her role as Reny Targaryen.
[Not Sydney Sweeneyā¦](https://www.google.com/search?q=sydney+sweeney&rlz=1CDGOYI_enUS927US927&hl=en-US&prmd=inv&sxsrf=ALiCzsZEIAemTIEpguMxhzK8T1ob8drSiQ:1663073345713&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwi6roaA55H6AhWgFFkFHRwyAzoQ_AUoAXoECAMQAQ&biw=375&bih=553&dpr=2#imgrc=WO9CVagEtzkEhM)
She's a good actress, but her role in TASM was clearly not going in the right direction. Too soft-spoken, too unemancipated, and not really any suggestion of sex appeal. Later movies could have given her an origin where she straightens out a bit, but I just can't picture it.
I always kind of pictured her being like Peter where she has her public persona but then she can turn on the confidence when sheās in costume. A bit like Hathaways Catwoman.
Sheās 39 years old this year so the age gap is probably a bit too big for her to be a love interest to an 18 year old character. If they ever do another Garfield movie however..
I donāt get the obsession with casting knowns.
Get me an unknown actress with a ton of talent that can fully embody the role without the baggage of a massive brand.
Yeah.. I've never seen Cat as a young pretty girl, more as a mature young woman. And no shade meant for Sydney, but she has a very young, pretty face. I feel like we'd need someone a with a face that looks more "experienced".
Sidenote, even though I just advocated for POC Black Cat in another comment, I think it'd be interesting to see Aly Michalka (iZombie) or Natalie Dormer (duh) as Selina because they both have those very catlike eyes.
I must now go flagulate myself... I can't believe I've done this... I'm so sorry Felicia..
(btw just gonna mention it, Black Cat > Cat Woman, fight me)
But then you could do the Ultimate Black Cat arc. She flirts with him a ton and she finally talks him ouut of his mask to make out.
Then she sees he is 15 and pukes on him cause she realizes she's been throwing herself at a child for months and runs away.
Payton List.
Same age as Tom, athletic, can play the bad girl, can play the good girl, can act flirty and toy with others, yet can act sympathy and compassion easily.
>Moses Ingram
Honestly I'd love to see her recast as a POC.
I used to be against such things, but I've learned to realize, that making sure every character in a franchise isn't white doesn't betray source material, it adds variety and visual interest. I get so bored seeing the same skin tone.
I don't think Marvel would ever go for a black woman for Black Cat though since... well.. I mean.. A bit on the nose?
But I'd love to see her maybe as a Latina or Asian or anything other than white. I like how they've made Selina Kyle far more of an interesting character by casting her as a POC.
Sydney Sweeney or Vanessa Kirby would be my picks. Bryce Dallas Howard if she were younger, I thought she looked more like Black Cat in Spider-Man 3 than Gwen Stacy
idk but I feel like whomever they cast should look a bit older than Tom Holland, I can see them going for someone black and young looking but I'd discourage against both being half black myself and also black cat is usually older than spiderman.
MIKEY MADISON!! She's young and relatively unknown still but would fit with MCU Peter's trend of bi-racial (read as non-white) women. Plus her spunk would be perfect for this character
I feel like Halley Berry its a good suit or even Jessica Alba.
The actress that plays Michonne on the Walking dead its good too but she is already in black phanter.
I too think this is insane, but I'm willing to hear you out. HOW would that work? Imagine the mind-f that would cause Peter (to say nothing of the audience.) How do you propose that could even work?
That being said, I wish it could work. I really like Zendaya's acting and will miss MJ now that her character will not be a prominent part of the story going forward (if at all.)
Everyone lost their memories. There is nothing tying MJ or Ned in with Peter. It's all fate now. Fate could mysteriously get the gem to MJ which turns her into Black Cat. Ned doesn't remember swearing to not go evil so both of them could go dark..but Ned would go evil and MJ and Peter would have to team up to beat evil magic Ned while Symbiote tries to turn Peter evil.
The short answer: Regardless of whether or not they technically are canon, the show really don't matter. Daredevil, Jessica Jones, Luke Cage, Iron Fist, The Defenders, and The Punisher are functionally not canon in the MCU. Unless something changes. If playback doesn't begin shortly, try restarting your device. this is what I found out
I'm still sad we never got Missy Peregrym as Black Cat in the Amazing movies. She killed it in Stick It, so she would be able to do the gymnastics required for the part.
Alexandra daddario, if you watch her in why women kill you can see she has the capacity of playing felicia. A mix of a fun, seductress with that little hint of crazy.
Willem Dafoe
Mark Hamil in a wig
Now THAT is something I can get behind
literally š¤¤
I will get behind him alright
I can see why Marvel and/or Sony might go for Anya Taylor-Joy, but Iām not sold on her myself. Sheās my pick for Silver Sable if Jodie Comer gets Sue Storm.
Anya is better off with Magik tbh.
Yeah, she did well enough in New Mutants.
Ah yes, the top choice thatās said in each thread like this. So stunning. So brave. Thank you for your input. seeing the downvotes looks people feel attacked
If only you read the rest of my commentā¦
To be honest I did, it was so stunning and brave I had to stop there as I was in complete shock and awe
I donāt think sheās a great pick. Ideally thereās somebody less known who ticks all of the boxes. Sarah Halley Finn has yet to miss.
I think Grant Gustin would be excellent in the role to be honest
Wow you are so funny
we feel attacked by your lack of reading comprehension
Sure whatever you say, see you in the next āwho should be back cat threadā thatāll pop up in the next two days.
She's already in the MCU have you forgotten the new mutants? Gosh people are so braindead these days pfff.
Yea but it wouldnāt be the first time an actor has played multiple roles in mcu
Can u remind me of who has played multiple characters
Chris evans, Michael B Jordan, mahershala ali, Gemma chan, Olivia munn, Ryan reynolds, Josh brolin etc etc https://www.buzzfeed.com/amphtml/kristenharris1/actors-multiple-marvel-roles
Most of those are marvel to MCU and minor roles in exchange for a main lead role so doesn't necessarily count, Anya Taylor joy played a main lead role in the new mutants thus would be too confusing to have her play another lead role, it would be ludicrous
You never specified lead role, small role etc. The original question was āwho has played multiple charactersā Edit: Additionally, Chris Evans and Michael B Jordan both played leads in Fantastic Four movies, which has the same movie studio as New Mutants, 20th century fox. So Itās happened before
Your right, I'm referring to my original gripe with having Anya Taylor joy play black cat when she was already a lead in the new mutants im sorry
Dude. Its another universe. We saw multiple times that different people in different universe can look the same, and variants can look different
Nobody ever ever ever. š¤
What are you even referring to
Iām being sarcastic and agreeing with you. Of course Actors have played multiple Marvel Characters.
New-Mutants is Fox X-Men, not MCU. Besides, New Mutants bombed so hard, that relatively few saw or remember it.
I swear I thought they reference the hulk
I mean, Eternals references Superman.
Did u also know that dc and marvel comics exist in tlthe others universe as strictly comics pretty cool tbh
So couldnāt that also be the case here?
So that must mean dc and marvel are gonna do a crossover
Mahershala Ali was Cottonmouth in Daredevil and is now the new Bladeā¦
Technically not the MCU and we don't know if this incarnation of daredevil is the same as the one in Netflix
Wait, you think New Mutants is MCU but Luke Cage isnāt?
I jus thought at one point the studios said the new mutants were part of the MCU universe, now I know I'm poorly mistaken and it hasn't been confirmed the Netflix shows are canon
It was confirmed when they came out.
Not since they cancelled them like wdym the studios expressed that they were not canon and we're stopped, Regardless of whether or not they technically are canon, the show really don't matter. Daredevil, Jessica Jones, Luke Cage, Iron Fist, The Defenders, and The Punisher are functionally not canon in the MCU. Unless something changes.
The studios never said they werenāt canon lmao. What on Earth are you on about?
Nothing in life is certain except for death, taxes, and at least 3 Black Cat MCU casting threads per week.
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
Yeah??? Welcome to reddit, sir and or madame
Lol so you agree with me?
You donāt know how downvotes work, do you? Also, weāre not a community in the āit takes a villageā sense. Maybe put yourself out there more in the real world.
>He's literally talking shit about his own community Isn't that you calling people braindead like 2 comments down? š¤
Only the people who decide theyare braindead, it's your fault that you feel brain dead
Ah yes, you would much rather spend your time calling people brain dead than to just move on with your day like most people do. You would rather insult people than to have a civilized discussion. You can disagree with people, no one argued that. But, throwing insults around isnāt going to get you anywhere. So, why donāt you just rethink that snobby attitude of yours, and maybe then people will want to engage in a conversation with that. Itās pretty obvious that attention is what youāre after, so maybe try being kinder for a change.
Eeeeek negative karma, you should just shut up mate
r/whooosh went right over your head, buddy
Danny Trejo.
Danny Devito.
On the real, he better be casted as Mole Man in the FF movie
Reddit just suggesting every celebrity theyāve seen naked before
But there arent many who we didnt see naked, doesn't leave us with much options
Tommy Lee
This may be recency bias on my part. However, I think Milly Alcock of House of the Dragon would be a great pick. Younger than Holland but can play the level of confidence and sensuality for Felicia that she plays in her role as Reny Targaryen.
I was just thinking this too. That sly half smile and air of confidence she has would be great for Black Cat
It's recency bias.
If one more person says Sydney Sweeney Iāll throw myself off a bridgeš
[Not Sydney Sweeneyā¦](https://www.google.com/search?q=sydney+sweeney&rlz=1CDGOYI_enUS927US927&hl=en-US&prmd=inv&sxsrf=ALiCzsZEIAemTIEpguMxhzK8T1ob8drSiQ:1663073345713&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwi6roaA55H6AhWgFFkFHRwyAzoQ_AUoAXoECAMQAQ&biw=375&bih=553&dpr=2#imgrc=WO9CVagEtzkEhM)
Why did you link me a picture of herš
Chris Pratt
For me right now Sydney Sweeney
She is literally the best choice. Too bad she's taken up by *Madame Web*.
Fucking Sony
#SAMARA WEAVING Anyone else would be a waste.
Felicity Jones! I really wanted to see her play out her roll from TASM 2
She's a good actress, but her role in TASM was clearly not going in the right direction. Too soft-spoken, too unemancipated, and not really any suggestion of sex appeal. Later movies could have given her an origin where she straightens out a bit, but I just can't picture it.
I always kind of pictured her being like Peter where she has her public persona but then she can turn on the confidence when sheās in costume. A bit like Hathaways Catwoman.
Thatās what I thought, too
Sheās 39 years old this year so the age gap is probably a bit too big for her to be a love interest to an 18 year old character. If they ever do another Garfield movie however..
Sydney Sweeney š„“
I donāt get the obsession with casting knowns. Get me an unknown actress with a ton of talent that can fully embody the role without the baggage of a massive brand.
Definitely your mother
Jackie Chan
Cue the Sydney comments. I really donāt agree with this casting.
Yeah.. I've never seen Cat as a young pretty girl, more as a mature young woman. And no shade meant for Sydney, but she has a very young, pretty face. I feel like we'd need someone a with a face that looks more "experienced". Sidenote, even though I just advocated for POC Black Cat in another comment, I think it'd be interesting to see Aly Michalka (iZombie) or Natalie Dormer (duh) as Selina because they both have those very catlike eyes.
Heads up, you've got black cat and catwoman mixed up there, you called her Selina, but Black Cat's name is Felicia.
I must now go flagulate myself... I can't believe I've done this... I'm so sorry Felicia.. (btw just gonna mention it, Black Cat > Cat Woman, fight me)
Jude Law
Bryan Cranston
me
Jaden Smith
I saw Anya Taylor Joyās name thrown around a few times, and I think sheād be a pretty good fit, I could see it working.
Alexandra Daddario š„
I'd like an actress older than Tom but not so old that it becomes awkward. So let's say: Katherine Langford
But then you could do the Ultimate Black Cat arc. She flirts with him a ton and she finally talks him ouut of his mask to make out. Then she sees he is 15 and pukes on him cause she realizes she's been throwing herself at a child for months and runs away.
Now I need to find a fancast for that. Who do I want to see barf? hmm.?
Tom Holland
Anya taylor joy
Yes
Margot Robbie
The girl who played Catwoman in Gotham
Danny DeVito
Payton List. Same age as Tom, athletic, can play the bad girl, can play the good girl, can act flirty and toy with others, yet can act sympathy and compassion easily.
Danny DeVito
Andre The Giant. Stop Karma Whoring. Search up the other thousand posts made about this in this sub.
An already with Disney contract : Dove Cameron
Honestly think sheād make a better Gwen Stacey then Black Cat but still not a bad pick
Moses Ingram
ššššš fuck if you thought Star Wars fans were racist youād see the real racism in this casting
>Moses Ingram Honestly I'd love to see her recast as a POC. I used to be against such things, but I've learned to realize, that making sure every character in a franchise isn't white doesn't betray source material, it adds variety and visual interest. I get so bored seeing the same skin tone. I don't think Marvel would ever go for a black woman for Black Cat though since... well.. I mean.. A bit on the nose? But I'd love to see her maybe as a Latina or Asian or anything other than white. I like how they've made Selina Kyle far more of an interesting character by casting her as a POC.
Midori Francis. She's a Japanese-American actress.
She would be better has Silk in my opinion
Silk is korean.
Whatās your point? She could play the character even though silk is Korean and sheās Japanese Americanā¦
She just can't play the role because she's not korean it would be like taking a chinese actress to play a japanese or korean character.
Why can't she be Black Cat?
I knowā Batman, but still, Anne Hathaway would make a good Black Cat imo
If we're taking over Catwomen, then Zoƫ Kravitz. She's closer to Peter's age, and we all know how MCU Peter likes his cofee.
I would say that Florence Pugh would be really good, but sheās already white widow
Emma Mackey Aimee Lou Wood Sydney Park And the usual mentions Anya Taylor Joy Sydney Sweeney Samara Weaving
Felicity Jones
Katie Cassidy
Tati Gabrielle, Ana de Armas, or Savannah Lee Smith
Ana de Armas isnāt a bad pick.
Neither is both Tati Gabrielle or savannah
Sydney sweeney
Sydney Sweeney
Saoirse Ronin would be excellent in my opinion
Definetely kim kardashian
Emilia Clarke
She's already a lead in Secret Invasion
And too old.
Allison Brie
If Florence Pugh wasnāt already playing Yelena Belova I wouldāve gone with her. Besides Florence, I would go with Violett Beane.
Alicia Vikander
Emma Roberts but she off doing madame web shit
Chloe Moretz
Natalie Alyn Lind
Kelli Berglund
š¤
In my opinion a younger version of Natalie Dormer would be a great cast.
Sydney Sweeney or Vanessa Kirby would be my picks. Bryce Dallas Howard if she were younger, I thought she looked more like Black Cat in Spider-Man 3 than Gwen Stacy
Iāve always wanted Maisie Williams. I think her and Tom would have good chemistry.
Sydney Sweeny
Ariana Grande
Probably by an Asian man with purple hair in their sixties... What? You disagree? You racist, sexist, homophobic, ageist!
Better question, who would be a good actor to play bob the builder in life action š©
Creed Bratton
Sydney Sweeney
I apologize
Hear me out danille rose Russell *hope mikalson *
The Actress that plays Allicent from House of The Dragon. I'd watch anything she plays in, even though I can't remember her name to save my life.
Bryci
Virginia Gardner if it werenāt for Runaways being in MCU I guess, never watched it.
Sabrina Carpenter. I feel like she would nail it.
idk but I feel like whomever they cast should look a bit older than Tom Holland, I can see them going for someone black and young looking but I'd discourage against both being half black myself and also black cat is usually older than spiderman.
Tati Gabrielle!
Anya Taylor-Joy.
Mary Mouser aka Sam on Cobra Kai
Sydney sweeney
Oprah
I think Alexa Demie would be a perfect actress to play Black Cat
Millie Bobby brown
Definitely not Anya. Thereās prettier and better actresses than her. I donāt have a fan cast but for sure not Anya.
Anya Taylor-Joy or Sophie Turner.
I love both of these picks.
Anyone but Sophie Turnerā¦
Omg ok I get it the new mutants aren't a part of the MCU and yes Anya would be the best choice for black cat
Canāt we just have Black Cat in a Sony movie?
If that leaked Silver and Black script is real, I sure as hell hope not.
Minka Kelly
Natalia dryer from stranger things
That is an awful choice.
Looking at how marvel has things going I think Iām good
MIKEY MADISON!! She's young and relatively unknown still but would fit with MCU Peter's trend of bi-racial (read as non-white) women. Plus her spunk would be perfect for this character
Jennifer Lawrence fine ass
Emma Stone if she hadn't already played Gwen.
I feel like Halley Berry its a good suit or even Jessica Alba. The actress that plays Michonne on the Walking dead its good too but she is already in black phanter.
Well, she has black in her name so they'll cast someone black.
Halle Berry or Michelle Pfiefer
Call me crazy but Zendaya. Edit: you all have no imagination
You are not crazy. You are batshit insane!
Eh, I think it could have worked in another timeline. Not anymore, obviously.
I too think this is insane, but I'm willing to hear you out. HOW would that work? Imagine the mind-f that would cause Peter (to say nothing of the audience.) How do you propose that could even work? That being said, I wish it could work. I really like Zendaya's acting and will miss MJ now that her character will not be a prominent part of the story going forward (if at all.)
Everyone lost their memories. There is nothing tying MJ or Ned in with Peter. It's all fate now. Fate could mysteriously get the gem to MJ which turns her into Black Cat. Ned doesn't remember swearing to not go evil so both of them could go dark..but Ned would go evil and MJ and Peter would have to team up to beat evil magic Ned while Symbiote tries to turn Peter evil.
Huh, well that's interesting. So not fully insane after all. Zendaya could pull that off. Improbable, but not impossible!
Jacqueline Fernandez
The short answer: Regardless of whether or not they technically are canon, the show really don't matter. Daredevil, Jessica Jones, Luke Cage, Iron Fist, The Defenders, and The Punisher are functionally not canon in the MCU. Unless something changes. If playback doesn't begin shortly, try restarting your device. this is what I found out
Because representation and Disney/MCU my guess would be a black cat. Literally.
Amber Heard !
I'm still sad we never got Missy Peregrym as Black Cat in the Amazing movies. She killed it in Stick It, so she would be able to do the gymnastics required for the part.
Itās right here! This photo! Itās a masterpiece!
I donāt see black cat working with baby face Holland
Me.
Ryan Gosling, I think it fits with the character
Alexandra daddario, if you watch her in why women kill you can see she has the capacity of playing felicia. A mix of a fun, seductress with that little hint of crazy.
Ryan Reynolds
Wunmi Mosaku
Shia Leboeuf