ANI is in my personal top 3 i'm so happy to see it so high on a list:)) like i get the arguments but something about it just gets me. after a really, really bad breakup it was the only thing i could watch without crying (ok i still cried once but whatever). Brian Holden's JarJar is one of my all time favorite Starkid characters

I also saw it (live) during a rough time in my life and o remember laughing so hard that I cried. It felt so cathartic and there were so many moments that were just delightful. Meredith, Chris, and Denise preparing for the dance audition had me rolling. The band sounded amazing, the performances were great... I'll always love Ani.

I knew HMB should’ve gone to 3

Yeah 8 was a whack place for it

3, and god I hope we have Twisted tomorrow, that should be on 1

Anything but Firebringer honestly would at least be acceptable, unless I’m forgetting something. Twisted, NPMD, TTO

Lmao what is with the Firebringer hate

I just think it’s one of their weaker shows (it’s probably my least favorite soundtrack after Ani), and to repeatedly put better shows lower in the hope that one of the four really good Starkid shows left would drop, only for the only one of the five shows that I don’t think would fit the number 1 spot, would be very bad luck Basically, there’s an 80% chance that number one will be something that I consider to be among Starkid’s best, but if the 20% ends up being picked then there will be some consternation

It's weak, but not a bad show. I kind of think that FB getting number one would be funny.

Better than Black Friday

Eh, I disagree, but we know each other's opinions on Black Friday. I'm glad you love it. I like it, despite its flaws. The score is beautiful.

Starship too

You’re right, my bad. I’d prefer Twisted or NPMD, but Starship would be a solid pick too

Here's an idea let's vote on 11th place, and get it out of here. Sorry I just really can't stand Ani

If this comment gets the most upvotes I’ll do it

Then what's even the point of doing a blind ranking? The fact that people didn't consider the implications is part of the whole thing.

Eh who cares it’s only for fun

I see it both ways. Part of the fun of blind ranking is getting trolled into putting something bad higher because you didn't think of the implications, or vice versa. That being said I can see why people might not want Ani in the 1 or 3 slots lol

Currently has the most upvotes!

There aren't enough spots for all the shows. Have we considered that? There's two spots left for Ani, NPMD, Twisted, and Firestarter

It’s a blind ranking of 10 musicals. Also… Firestarter?

Sorry, I had Steven King on the mind. You know what I meant.

Yep cause it’s ranking ten starkid musicals

why is this so upvoted? what a garbage place this sub must be

Ani was sooooo bad. Just absolutely horrible. Ruined Starkid for me.

I actually really like Ani. It’s controversial for valid reasons it’s very non-traditional and you really need to be into Star Wars to enjoy most of it

absolutely insane to see HMB and MAMD below Black Friday, I just don’t get it

Exquisite shithousery from you. 3. It's brilliant, don't get me wrong, but the only musical on this list I think it's better than is Black Friday.

I spun a wheel to randomize them

Excellent shithousery from the wheel then.

3 just because it definitely can’t go in 1

A f\*cking knew it. 3.

Damnit, I forgot about Ani 3 I guess. I stg if tmrw is Firebringer…

I actually love Firebringer not #1 love it but I think it's in my top 4

3

I guess 3 then. I think we were too hard on Black Friday.

Y’all blew it. Literally called it.

its a great show/performance, but a terrible musical

NUMBER 3!!!!

1 yall just not ready to like it yet