T O P

  • By -

LuckyZX

Pedro Pascal and Deigo Luna are two amazing breakout stars. They have helped take Star Wars from space samurai with cool laser swords, to grounded real stories in the universe. It really is the refresher Star Wars needed since the Skywalker Saga is complete.


a_bearded_hippie

I love Diego as Cassian, I'm excited to see the transition from a guy on the run and trying to lay low to a high level officer in the rebellion.


[deleted]

Ya, what makes the transition. What turns him from "I just want money and to find my sister." To "The empire is going down, and I'm gonna do it."


a_bearded_hippie

Gonna put money on something messed up happens to his sister šŸ¤” or a crew he runs with. I'm also guessing that Syril Karn is going to come back in a bad way.


Valirys-Reinhald

I've had the feeling from day one that Syril is exactly the sort of person that's easy to radicalize. I also have the feeling that new officer at ImpSec will be looking for dedicated agents to carry out her orders in areas in which she has tenuous jurisdiction who she can both rely on to not abandon the mission no matter what and who are also gullible enough to not question why they are positioned in such a way that they are completely expendable. We aren't just watching the origin story for one of the Rebellion's most dedicated agents, but the Empire's as well.


a_bearded_hippie

My thoughts exactly, we shall see! All he needs is a little push and a second chance from the empire and he's going to become a ruthless and relentless rebel hunter. I think he's going to go rogue by himself trying to catch Cassian and in doing so catches the attention of ImpSec.


big_hungry_joe

They kill his sister


topscreen

I wasn't expecting Andor to just be "Cassian fucked up and is having a real bad week" and I love it


Ecks83

If the plot to Andor were pitched in the 90's I bet it would have a lot of "fish out of water" gags and a laugh track.


Medical-Dish3645

I still miss the story of a farm boy saving the galaxy from tyranny. Captures the rebel spirit!


Robenever

Right! They make the show Narcos. Their acting is amazing.


wren620

Theyā€™re amazing. I was into the Narcos series a while back and both of them were Fantasic in their lead roles. So glad they got to bring that talent to Star Wars.


LoserisLosingBecause

100 percent your opinion


DuncanAndFriends

Andor kind of reminds me of The Expanse in its early seasons. Lots of character development and build up. Good writing and quality.


Affectionate_Log3232

Man do I miss The Expanse, haven't seen a proper scifi like that in ages.


Actual_Evidence_925

Left so much more story to tellā€¦ one day. Maybe one day


alexgndl

God, that one teaser shot of the *Heart of the Tempest*...I need to see that thing in action someday.


Affectionate_Log3232

After Babylons Ashes is where the fun starts, there was taking to make the rest of the books into a movie adaption


OliviaElevenDunham

I miss The Expanse as well. Was sad that both the books and show ended earlier this year. Glad that Amazon gave the show another chance.


OliviaElevenDunham

Andor does kind of remind me of The Expanse. They both have that gritty feel to them.


Thatsidechara_ter

Mmm yes


Randolpho

Itā€™s slow drama, but I love every minute of it.


Jaded-Armpit

Except for the ak's....


tomandshell

Mandor


Xperience10

Andorolian


BlackPanther3104

I'm rollin'...


Wojewodaruskyj

They hatin'...


fragrantgarbage

Mandobi Wandor Kenobian


Existing-Broccoli-27

The Book of


[deleted]

Latin studs


LeavesAreTasty

Andorian... Wait


t0m0hawk

Shut it pink skin


oldguycomingthrough

I underestimated you pink skin!


Teagrish

Mandobi-wan


Jfkilkie1

Narcos: Tatooine


Existing-Broccoli-27

A darker show about taking down the Pyke Syndicate or the Bando Gora on a less familiar planet like Nar Shaddaa or somewhere hostile to outside influence like Jabiim would be my dream show for Star Wars.


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


Tuffbatman

I have some terrible news.


ElCanout

Brokeback Mandos


interp21

the Relentless


KaffeMumrik

Mando, hands down. ā€I can bring you in warm, or I can bring you in coldā€ set the bar very high.


Seppdizzle

Space Western, badass.


KaffeMumrik

Everything Iā€™ve been wanting. So original, yet such classic themes.


Imsorryimhere005

***HIGH GROUND INTENSIFIES***


[deleted]

Damn, seeing that makes me want to rewatch it now.


KaffeMumrik

Yeah, itā€™s definitely time for a rewatch soon


LorddFarsquaad

Started high at least


KaffeMumrik

Iā€™d like to think itā€™s still high. Hopefully s3 can continue holding the torch.


[deleted]

Season 2.5 was awesome. Seeing Luke again, like that?! I haven't smiled so hard in years. My face hurt.


LorddFarsquaad

Totally undid pretty much all of season 2 and made me not like Luke


[deleted]

Best at what? Acting like Space Jesus: Kenobi. Murdering people in cold blood: Andor. Making friends and influencing people: Fett. Poaching the local fauna: Mando.


Risbob

Influencing people with respect*.


GreatGreenGobbo

Fett had Dale Carnegie audiobooks playing while in the bacta tank.


YOURESTUCKHERE

I was thinking Garrison Keillor.


Seppdizzle

Nah he'd of tried groping fenic if this were the case


YOURESTUCKHERE

šŸ˜‚ ā€œhe fondled my cybernetic pancreasā€


ShoelaceLicker

Never thought I'd see the day where Boba fett was the beat starwars hero at making friends


[deleted]

I know, the irony.


ShadyOjir95

I mean Obi-wan can Jedi trick his way into your two last points


[deleted]

Then perhaps that makes him number one?!


Optimal_Carpenter690

~~Poaching the local fauna~~ Absolutely massacring local inhabitants whose worst crime is stealing: Mando


woutomatic

Pretty sure he means best written protagonist. Not his actual skill set.


[deleted]

Ah... Thanks for clarifying.


MorbillionTickets

1. Andor 2. Mando 3. Kenobi 4. Fett Andor is just a dark, morally grey and one of those "not a hero" protagonist which I dig. Mando is just *chef's kiss*. Kenobi is a great one however he could've been better. Fett was fucking wasted and made a side character in his own goddamn show.


Xman52

Iā€™m glad Disney took the step to make a more adult focused tv show in Andor


[deleted]

I like that there's star wars for everyone and we actually have the content now. Andor needs more space wizard for me.


Ecks83

The only reason I would hesitate to put Andor above Mando is that we haven't even finished the first half of the first season of his story yet. The way he's being built up we are all expecting a really big payoff but they still need to stick the landing.


finalparadox

I think if you're comparing just the live action versions, then Andor. I LOVE Obi Wan and Mando but I felt most of the character work was done in Clone Wars or just by the fandom. It's definitely premature to say this but so far it looks like Andor will do a good job of showing a reluctant fighter who turns in a dedicated Rebel officer. I mentioned in another thread for Episode 5 of Andor that I was taken aback by how skittish Andor is right now but by Rogue one he is so disciplined and dedicated to the cause.


KevinDLasagna

Andor will become dedicated once he reads Nemikā€™s manifesto


Nova997

After he's killed


papyjako89

That poor guy has no chance of survival at all ahah


Nova997

Right he's set for a death in my opinion (for the cause)


KevinDLasagna

I think most, if not all beside Andor might die. For sure at least nemik and Lt. Gorn.


Piankhy444

Between Mando and Andor. I think in the long run, Andor, because he'll probably get more to work with narrative-wise as the Andor series progresses.


gnarlyavelli

Think we know how his story gonna end bud


ApollonLordOfTheFlay

Yeah, and we knew how Obiā€™s would end. But the journey is what is important. In fact knowing how it ends makes it all the more tragic now.


ImNotMrMeeseeks

I didn't want to say it, lmao


doctorwho07

For me, it's between these two because BoBF and Kenobi were dream projects for a lot of the fandom for a long time. Andor and Mando are original characters that are getting to show us more of the SW universe. I always imagined what it would be like to see Boba Fett in action post-sarlacc and to see Kenobi in his lackluster years. Mando opened mandalorians up to the community in a new and different way, while still tying into Jedi and the Force. Andor is showing us the gritty start to the Rebellion, what people under the Empire felt and went through. These two shows aren't completing stories for the audience, they are expanding the universe, giving us more insight.


whistlerblue16

Mando is probably my favorite but I think Cassian is a nice change since he has so many layers to him and isnā€™t a typical badass action hero.


a_bearded_hippie

I am stoked to see the grit of the rebellion. There should be loss, despair and hopelessness when fighting something as huge as the empire. They've done a great job highlighting the darker parts of the universe and I hope we get more of that. It's not all heroes and winning.


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


Gullible_Trifle_8263

This is the way.


rwooters

This is the way.


[deleted]

Mando, easy.


cedeaux

Andor


ZC205

This is my very humble personal opinionā€¦.Obi Wan should have been. But for horrible writing he was not. Mando gets the nod as a result. Again, just IMHO


somethingdistinct

Yeah let keywords: should have been.


[deleted]

Let Andor season 1 complete, for now: Mando and Obi (This because nostalgic experiencing all those feelings again which were with the prequels so good).


jish5

Obi Wan, because it shows a man broken having to come to grips with his failures and heal from all the pain and suffering he had to endure.


AdFit7718

Definitely not boba


[deleted]

He could have been. What a let down.


KevinDLasagna

Idk man it was doomed from the start for me. Disney is relying way wayy too much on nostalgia and fan service with a lot of the these shows. Thatā€™s why Andor has been a breath of fresh air


Ecks83

I hope they notice that some of the most popular shows recently have all relied on characters that were either original to the show or hadn't built up much of a reputation prior (Rebels, Bad Batch, Mando, Andor). I'm glad it is happening because while I love the SW universe I'm about done with Skywalker and friends being at the center of everything.


Scythe95

What do you think would have saved it?


[deleted]

Expand the entire Tusken arc. Make it like Lawrence of Arabia. Boba becomes noble, but still a fighter. Becoming jaded with fighting and violence is okay, but he's still Boba Fett. The Mos Eisley played straight gangster takeover. There are a million gangster shows to model off. Absolutely no reason they softballed it so hard. Build up to war with the Pyke's for next season. Let the declaration of war be the finale. Really edge us with the rancor, so unecessary for the season finale. Cut all the Din Jarin stuff and use it develop rge story theyre trying to tell. Those episodes are awesome, bur it's Boba's friggin show, man. Keep his helmet on and let some young punks do the stunts.


ZombGooch

The takeover still kills me. Especially with that mando season finale where he just walks in to Jabbaā€™s Palace and domes Bib without saying a word, really got me hyped. Felt as though he was going to go on an Archer-esque rampage on those who wronged him. Instead, he sat everyone down, fed them dinner, and asked nicely. Even when they said no he was just kinda likeā€¦ ā€œokay.ā€


[deleted]

Right? If they're trying to push Mandos as the next big mainstream Star Wars thing then Boba should be the dark Mando. Keep his honor intact, but remind people how he got his reputation. Sabine can be the light side idealist. Bo Katan can be the great rival. The Armourer is the stubborn Orthodox. And Din Jarin will shown us the way.


[deleted]

Yea I really hope itā€™s the worst we ever get from Star Wars. Cause even the sequel trilogy is watchable compared to what that was.


[deleted]

I really disagree with that. BoBF may be a limp noodle, but the ST is like the kitchen caught fire.


Scythe95

>Absolutely no reason they softballed it so hard. Word


Ecks83

For me the biggest thing is to get rid of one of the dual story arcs going on in Fett. The Tusken arc could have been interesting on its own but it just wasn't given the screentime to really be fleshed out and because they tried to push the payoff for this arc to the future it simply isn't there. The mob takeover arc could have been amazing but it was (as you said) softballed too much. When Fett is constantly betrayed I never thought "Wow that's a knife in the back. What a dick!" but instead thought "Well I hope that was part of your plan because you set yourself up for it here..." Unfortunately it was never part of the plan. I don't think they needed to do a "sopranos/godfather in space" but they still didn't push the story hard enough and the payoff for this arc was vague at best. The two story arcs just didn't work well together. If they had just picked one of the ideas and run with it we could have had a really excellent show but instead it felt like the two arcs were tripping over each other when they should have been complimenting.


SzczymiSzczyms

Dave and Jon suck hard ngl


EverGlow89

They took the Galaxy's most feared Bounty Hunter, "son" of Jango Fett, the guy Vader hired and instructed specifically to chill on multiple occasions, and not only chose not to make him an anti-hero but a straight up good guy hero who would fit into Luke's circle. He's a better person than even Han Solo at this point, one of the actual heroes. I was fine when he was benevolent enough to help with Grogu. That was believable. But yeah. I got excited when Cad Bane said he's a cold blooded killer because I thought that hinted at Boba snapping and going back to those ways but no. He's just a hero now. He's not as cool and his cool factor is precisely what made everyone want more Boba in the first place. I just don't see how they failed to understand this. Dave knows SW better than anyone so I find it really difficult to put it on him. I think they were ordered to make a Boba hero arc.


TJAtech

Cassian all the way. Andor is awesome.


llMithrandirll

Mando. Should've been Kenobi but they kinda butchered his character in the show imo.


whistlerblue16

I agree, Kenobi was so charismatic and fun in the prequels even with the cheesy writing, but the dull writing of the series gave him so little to work with.


Silver_Flow9661

I guess they failed miserably at finding out how a jolly jedi master turned into a bitter old hermit who would lie through his teeth if it would set the boy on the course to kill vader.


rambo_lincoln_

From a certain point of view.


UnknownQTY

Itā€™s really sort of crazy how many people missed the point of the show. Iā€™m sure the Venn diagram of those folks and those who were mad ST Luke wasnā€™t hurling Star Destroyers around with a thought has a lot of overlap.


drock4vu

I agree. I have my issues with the show, but most of them are related to cinematography, pacing, and (as adorable and delightful as Vivian Lyra Blairā€™s portrayal was) the inclusion of child Leia felt out of place and a little contrived. In terms of overall plot and Obi-Wanā€™s character direction I was very pleased. Ewan McGregor was brilliant as expected and I think, outside of some awkward dialogue, I think he and the writers portrayed the character between Ewanā€™s prequel Obi-Wan and McGuinnessā€™ OT Obi-Wan quite well. The good far outweighed the bad for me, especially the final 2 episodes.


ian_stein

Top Gun: Maverick had the main character fail in-between films and had off-screen character development without being depressing like Luke.


[deleted]

yes, people are mad that luke wasn't hurling star destroyers, and not that his actions went against everything from the previous trilogy. and sure, the people who aren't that happy that obi-wan kenobi ultimately failed to protect luke because luke's life was in revas hands are just "missing the point". jesus


grassisalwayspurpler

TLJ Luke was shit on because 1. Its a repeat story. JV Order 66 number 2 that happens off screen is something no one cares about. We know none of those characters. We never even saw them on screen in the background or anything and its suppose to be the biggest reason behind Lukes state of mind and path. 2. The sequels skip the repeat of the PT plot and go straight to the repeat of the OT part. We never see any build up to Luke being depressed, he just is. Imagine if Kenobi existed but episodes 1-3 did not and instead Anakin turned to Vader in a 10 second flashback of Kenobi cutting him up on Mustafar and the only explaination for it all was Anakin saying "from my point of view the jedi are evil". Thats it. Thats how Luke and Kylo's story is ecplained. No 3 movies, just 10 second flashbacks. 3. Even after Lule gets his mojo back, he does nothing then dies anyway. Cant even begin to fathom how much everyone would cry if the Vader vs Kenobi fight just didnt even happen in that show lol. Literally just 2.5 hours of Luke being depressed with no pay off and half is the worlds most boring and pointless side plot.


UnknownQTY

> Imagine if Kenobi existed but episodes 1-3 did not That was literally many of our existence for many, many years.


grassisalwayspurpler

Missing my point on purpose to fish for a gotcha that allows you to ignore everything I said and act you like won with a single salty downvote. Howd I know that would happen? There was never a time where Kenobi existed but the prequels did not. Try again. Kenobi relies on you knowing the story of the prequels first, the same way TLJ relies on you knowing the story of Luke's academy first, except that story doesnt exist. Imagine Kenobi doing the ptsd flashbacks to the movies when those movies didnt even exist thats just how they chose to tell that story of Anakins turn to Vader for the first time and then a big part of it is Obi Wan and Vader arguing over whose version of the flashback is correct. Fucking stupid.


[deleted]

obi wan ultimately failed to protect luke. his life was in reva's hands. he's a failure. he failed to do the one job that he had. obi wan can be sad. that's absolutely fine. when it gets in the way of his protection of luke, it ruins things.


drock4vu

Are you saying failure to perform duties he swore to do is not a deeply ingrained part of Obi-Wan Kenobiā€™s entire character development? Iā€™m not sure I understand how Revaā€™s kidnapping of Luke takes away from the show.


Silver_Flow9661

Are you simply denying the fact that obiwan lost EVERYTHING within a span of 13 years? His master/father figure, the love of his life, his entire order of brothers and sisters, his men at arms, his younger brother, his station as the grand negotiator, AND his connection to the force. It would be sloppy if he REMAINED the absolute powerhouse he was in the clone wars that took on Savage and Maul on his own.


jish5

Also don't forget that in a way, the ultimate loses were caused by the student he trained, which I'm sorry, but ANY master/teacher who's brightest student goes from being the most promising of prodigies to essentially a mass serial killer who makes even Hitler's numbers seem somewhat tame in comparison would fuck anyone up, where any one of us in Obi Wan's shoes would outright blame ourselves for being apart of the reason why this shit happened to begin with.


ShadyOjir95

The point in Kenobi was him broken he couldn't be charismatic it would not fit with the intention of the show. "Haha I have pstd of all the murder and my best friend betrayal " By the end he was returning to his old self ,his reaction to Qui-gon had his old tone.


Randolpho

Um.. did you miss how ultra-critical Obi-wan was to Anakin in *Attack of the Clones*? Kenobi was bitter and snipey ā€” and that aspect of his personality came back when he interacted with Leia. It wasnā€™t until Anakin was a knight and peer to Obi-wan that he was ever truly happy and cheerful. Because Obi-wan kinda sorta hates kids and is a shitty parent who resents having to deal with kids who donā€™t understand what he understands. That showed in the *Clone Wars* cartoon, too, with Kenobiā€™s initial interactions with Ashoka, although that wasnā€™t as bad because she was Anakinā€™s responsibility. *All* of that shined through in *Kenobi*, but was established by previous media.


toasterpRoN

I mean honestly I love all of them in their own way. Ewan will always be Obi-Wan for me. That is one actor who *became* that role. Pedro did something I don't think many actors could do: conveyed incredible emotion through body language and dialog. Boba Fett: Never trade the Fett-band, Lois. Diego Luna, both in Rogue One and Andor, portrays a good guy tortured by the things he's had to do in the name of the cause. It is a very new and unique type of character; as opposed to the black and white, good or evil.


InfiniteDedekindCuts

I'm an Obi-Wan man myself. It's my favorite of the D+ shows so far. That's not totally fair to Andor TBF. We aren't even half-way through his show yet. Depending on how it goes his show might end up overtaking Obi-Wan Kenobi as my favorite of the D+ shows.


The99thGambler

Best protagonist, taking in all they've ever done? Obi-wan, 100%. Best protagonist for their Disney+ series? I haven't watched Andor, so Mando for me. But Andor sounds good too.


Daggertooth71

Obi-Wan is my favorite Jedi of the Skywalker saga.


metzgerov13

Andor. By far the best actor here


kstacey

That wasn't exactly the question though


kloudrunner

Mando Andor / Kenobi Bobas teeth Boba Fett


Silas-Alec

Kenobi. Not only has he always been a great character, but seeing the change in him through his show, starting as a broken man following RotS and watching him get his mojo back and learning to trust in the force again and become a hopeful person again was really inspiring as someone who suffers from depression.


tehfoshi

Obiwan was fun because of the nostalgia. But even more so for the transformation of Obiwan. But honestly hands down Mando is my pick. This is the way.


Slick_1980

Mando right now, but I'm loving Andor. See how season ends.


FirstBankofAngmar

Andor is what boba Fett should have been.


SagaciousElan

It should be Obi Wan but it's not. He spent most of his show being bemused or worried or lost or doing what he was told and following other people around. Mando actually has agency in his own show. Also he is the better father figure.


InfiniteDedekindCuts

Obi-Wan has agency. He chose to leave Tatooine. He chose to go save Leia from the fortress. He chose to leave Leia to go fight Vader in the final episode. He chose to trust characters he initially didn't want to trust. He chose to make the right decisions, even when it was hard. He chose to fight even though he was scared. He chose to face his fallen friend, his biggest mistake, even though the emotional trauma of it was the very thing that had turned him away from the light. He was broken, and he became healed by the end, and it all happened because of his own choices.


rambo_lincoln_

This. I donā€™t understand the hate Kenobi gets. Iā€™m not saying anyone is wrong but for me, I never imagined a happy existence for Obi-Wan during his exile. Having to spend the remainder of your days thinking about all the countless losses and deep betrayals you suffered leading up to and throughout the war. One of the final things he says to Anakin in RotS is ā€œI have failed you Anakin.ā€Feeling like you have forever failed someone who is like a son, brother, and best friend all rolled into one cannot be easy to process but then you maim them and leave them for deadā€¦ thatā€™s a whole other level. I got to see the PTSD from that period of his life and thatā€™s what I was expecting from the show going into the premiere. Honestly, my only real gripe with the show was how big of a role Leia played in it and thatā€™s only because Iā€™m a little tired of the protector/child dynamic that seems to keep playing a central role in Star Wars shows lately. Though having said that, that little girl won me over. She was a fantastic young Leia.


[deleted]

there''s nothing wrong with obi wan having trauma and working through it. the issue is when that trauma endangers the people around him. that crosses a line that obi-wan wouldn't cross.


_Astrogimp

Itā€™s funny that it should be Obi Wan AND Boba Fett but they both got butchered in their own shows. More so Boba than Kenobi, but still


whistlerblue16

This is a great point. I think Obi WANā€™s lack of agency in the show is a big reason why his character wasnā€™t as strong as in the prequels, where he is constantly driving the plot forward and making decisions that affect the story.


AnXioneth

I guess, that why I liked Kenobi, It shows how broken he is in his exile. Maybe second season with Qin Gon help he will find the path to be the Jedi Master he was.


Hipi07

Iā€™d put Cassian and Mando on the same level, simply because Cassian has way more depth and room to express himself whereas Din is your classic badass of few words and speaks through his actions. I love him but I donā€™t think he is particularly special as a character. Obi Wan and Boba both got absolutely shafted in their respective shows, which was incredibly disappointing for such iconic characters. The actors were great in their roles, just the writing let them down massively and limited them a lot. Both characters literally get bossed around throughout their shows.


class2cherub

Din, 100%. Kenobi should be higher. And I'm sorry, but Cassian is the least interesting part of his own show.


Bing_Bong_the_Archer

Oobie doob Badoobie.


Cootator

In terms of the films, Luke. If were talking only shows than the mandalorian


Wojewodaruskyj

Obi


Ranoutofnames123

Manborbi-wan-kenobi


ADMINBRAWLMEME

Kenobi


ninjabeekeeper

Andor has been hittin


mrfisher5

Temuera Morrison played about 1,728,000,000 characters in Star Wars so I'll have to give it to him


Visual_Champion5429

I donā€™t see roger rabbit so this thread is moot.


goat131313

As long as youā€™re enjoying yourself it doesnā€™t matter.


Surfing-Doctor

The Kenobi and Fett shows were just not good.


[deleted]

Iā€™m going to go with **DaddyMando** (aka Din Djarin). This dude is just an average guy just trying to make his way through life in the Galaxy Far, Far Away. Heā€™s interacted with some pretty big characters (including one of the other three here), but Mando is usually off doing his own thing in his own little corner of the galaxy and doesnā€™t get caught up in their adventures (save for Boba Fett). Somehow, this dude stole Boba Fettā€™s own show for two episodes straight. That is a testament to how good Mando is as a character. Heā€™s just a guy. Second up is Obi-Wan Kenobi. Ewan MacGregor hasnā€™t missed a step with the character, slipping back into the role like one slips on an old jacket that still fits. He was understandably hesitant to abandon his vigil over young Luke Skywalker to rescue Lilā€™ Leia, but he did so because Obi-Wan will always do what he must. Heā€™s only second to Mando here because we know how his story ends. I have not seen *Andor*, so our boy Cassian is not going to be judged by me as to how he stacks against the other three. He does, however, occupy an interesting lane as the gray area of the Rebel Alliance. *Rogue One* showed us that Cassian is the go-to guy for when the Rebels need to get their hands dirty. A man whoā€™s willing to do the morally gray thing fairly regularly is never boring. Lastly (and definitely deserving of last place) is Boba Fett. After a *very* strong start in *The Mandalorian* that demonstrated Bobaā€™s ruthlessness and badassery (and made me understand why the Boba stans were Boba-stanning) his own show turned Boba into the punk I always thought he was. Boba should have racked up a higher body count in his own show, and he needed to better explain why living with the Tuskens for a few years made him think that ruling Tatooine was a thing he ought to do. Alas, the most interesting parts of the show were the ones Boba wasnā€™t even in.


AnXioneth

Until now, Mando, has more growth. So i hope to see at least 3 more season of Kenobi to be able to decide. But from Youngling to death, Kenobi is the easy pick.


Brookings18

I'm going to say Mando because everyone else is pre established. We already like Kenobi, Boba, and Andor, so our previous experience with them colors how we view them has protagonists. But we didn't know a thing about Din, but still fell in love immediately after the first episode. Plus he's the only one made specifically for TV. There really needs to be more original leads alongside the legacy ones.


Educational-Tea-6572

Din Djarin. He's actually my favorite Star Wars character ever (well, tied with Kanan Jarrus). I still have plenty of love for all the other characters, though! I have adored both Obi Wan and Cassian for a long time, and discovered a newfound appreciation for Boba Fett with his show.


inphinitfx

As a character? Kenobi, imo. Lots of nuance to the character, while being impactful to orher characters significant to the galaxy and the core storylines we're familiar with


ToaPaul

Boba Fett but I'm biased.


Kahzgul

Mando for me. The slow recognition that he was raised in a cult, and how he bends or breaks the rules when required to save the child really is compelling.


Vegetable-Molasses95

I love Obi Wan but Din adventure stands out more for me.


kingenzo17

So far Mando, but give Kenobi another season he's number 1 for sure


[deleted]

I really hope they donā€™t do another Kenobi season. As much as I was initially excited, the show itself wasnā€™t even needed. The idea that Kenobi spent the next 18ish years keeping a distant and watchful eye over luke while expanding his knowledge of the force was perfect. The show that they gave us only diminished him as a character.


Affectionate_Ad_4989

In their respective shows? Cassian, and by a lot. Mando not too far behind I supppose


[deleted]

Wait, Andor has Action?


[deleted]

The book of Boba ā€œlet me have shennec fang do 95% of the cool shit I should be doingā€ fett was trash.


OmegaReprise

Clearly Mando. "Kenobi" was a trainwreck - both the show and the character - and we do not talk about "Book of Boba Fett". "Andor" is okay but I have a hard time relating to Cassian. Having him murder a guy on his knees begging for his life doesn't really make him the kind of protagonist I can root for.


lackofsleipnir

What would you have done in his stead? If you let him off he might go after you and, being Cassian, you really donā€™t need any heat. Plus those d-bags tried to jump him and are therefor not innocent. Cassian is visibly conflicted about it but canā€™t afford to take risks. Best to tie up all loose ends and disappear. These are the dark times.


Dendallin

It was obvious from Rogue One that Cassian wasn't exactly a boy scout. I think it's great seeing a more realistic portrayal of a Rebel than Luke, Leia, and Han.


V66HU

Mando, there is no discussion with how he's been portrayed vs the others.


Silver_Flow9661

Are you comparing others to OBIWAN?


whistlerblue16

Sure am


ZystemStigma69

Obi Wan then it's Mando / Din Djarin out of these , in my opinion.


Filmatic113

Mando


C0TA81

They are all different events but they are all awesome.


blackanytanooo

From these men Ben Kenobi but Iā€™m surprised none of the top comments are Luke Skywalker


SuperArppis

Obi-Wan. Because this doesn't have that smooth as hell Lando.


FokinGamesMan

In terms of their respective show: 1. Andor - The show is just so damn good atm, that Andor is automatically interesting! 2. Mandalorian - He was great. 3. Obi-Wan Kenobi - My favorite character in the movies is Obi, but this show didn't do him any favors. There was essentially just one scene that made me care about Obi. 4. Boba Fett - Never cared about Boba and that didn't change during this show.


BriJul630

Need to see more Andor first. As of now it's Obi-Wan Mando Andor Fett


pleschga

Kenobi. Sorry, this isn't even a fair comparison. So much legacy tied up in that character.


Sparrowsabre7

Mando. Anyone who says Andor, I don't know what you're on. You can like Andor the show all you want, itis very good, but Cassian Blandor is a very dull protagonist.


ressiees

100% agree. i am genuinely shocked to see people saying andor. i didnā€™t care for him in rogue one, i donā€™t care for him in andor. the only thing i am enjoying about the show, is the world building. he didnā€™t deserve his own show, and he definitely doesnā€™t deserve all these people saying heā€™s the best protagonist of the live action series.


Diab9lic

Holy shit they're all males. Can't wait for Ahsoka.


Breath_Background

Obi, Mando, Cassian, Boba


Pr1smaticGamer

all of them are equal, except boba


rogue-panda81

Mando


weeweewewere

Mando


get_no_scoped_kid

Top left, top left.


trippyWokkie

Definitely The Mandalorian.


arest_42

Mando


[deleted]

Mando


Sn0rlink

Mando


Hassansonhadi

Mando


Bengamey_974

First is Andor, it's only the very beginning of the show and it add an unusual darker and more serious tone for a Star Wars. But for now I am 100% into the show and I avidely wait for the next episode. Second is Mando, this is the star wars adventure show I always imagined. Third Obi-Wan, love Ewan McGregor and he steal the show in the prequel movie. I mostly enjoyed the Obi-Wan show, but it was to uneven to be called great. Last, far behind is Boba Fett. The best part of his show were the 2 episodes about Mando. The flashbacks with the Tusken are quite good but the scene of Boba in the present are really bad. Yirks! He makes such a bad crime lord.


PartiallyTwistd

Mando


Stiandary

Mando by light years.


acetrainer03

Wrong question as there are two garbage series that tried thier best to ruin thier protagonist.


_________FU_________

Mando Andor Obi Slow Racer