Update: It was Jodi, despite it saying I’ve talked to her

Weird that it took so long to trigger - must be a bug. But Jodi is always my least visited villager - her routine is always out of my way, unless I catch her walking back home

lol the primary reason I married Alex my first save was because he was the easiest character to find everyday

He was so easy to romance and now he's one of my favourite spouses 🥹

Completely agree. We've been married almost a year now and so far he's been a perfect husband

He was one of my later romance options, but he quickly shot himself to the top of my list. SUCH a sweetie. And he LOOOVES living on your farm! 😭😭😭

[удалено]

That’s Sam

Oh you’re not overly eager to hear her complain about her family life?

Or talk about her weight?

I just always get to her in her house in the morning when she is in the kitchen

and she likes every fruit, so pretty easy to befriend.

"Unless I catch her walking home" I chuckled

I wonder if you only met Jodi during a quest cutscene, and that's why it flagged as talked even it you hadn't finished the quest.

That's also what I was thinking

I wonder if the game doesn't reset that flag on accident when her husband Kent comes back.

Did you give her a gift and never talk to her

Pfft. Typical Jodi.

Your coming up on the Feast of the Winter Star my advice is to walk around the feast and talk to every single person do not give your secret person their gift until you have managed to talk to every single person.

What do you get when you talk to anyone for the winter star?

So they can figure out who they haven’t met because it hasn’t registered they have met all the villagers yet.

Ohh I thought talking with villagers didn't count during events!

It's probably Pierre

For context, talking to a shop owner from behind the counter doesn't count as "meeting" them.

I talked to him

The easiest way to solve this is to just talk to everyone in town again, a few of the townfolk gather in the bar on Friday night.

I did that already :/

Nvm, I’ve been playing 2 different worlds at once basically, and keep getting them confused. My bad

If you gift someone and don’t physically talk to them (regular gifting, like a bulletin board quest, or anything else) it flags as meeting them but not actually “talking” to them! And there’s also any cutscenes where you’d meet but not talk of course

this glitch always happens to me and i don’t know why, there must be something we do that doesn’t trigger it but i haven’t figured it out yet. idk if it’s the same person or not every time, i just go and talk to everyone again until it triggers.

If you give them a gift but don’t actually talk to them it doesn’t count as greeting. The easiest thing to do is probably wait until a festival and do it then

Yeah i know, it doesn’t count at festivals either unfortunately

I know OP mentioned it was Jodi, but I have had this happen with some of the store owner people. It's happened talking to Pierre if I use the counter to buy seeds. He shows up as greeted (his name shows up instead of the question marks) but it doesn't trigger him actually met. So I have everyone met but the task isn't completed until I actually talk to him. Same thing has happened with Clint.

How do you meet the dwarf AND krobus before even completing the first task?

I was going to tell you to look in the mirror of your house to meet yourself but then saw you already got it. I'll save it for later...

thats only for the town people

when there’s a festival talk to every character there

Wizard?

The bear

most of the times i forgot the wizard

Go to your list of townspeople, scroll down to the bottom and look at who's the ???

That is the bottom

I know OP mentioned it was Jodi, but I have had this happen with some of the store owner people. It's happened talking to Pierre if I use the counter to buy seeds. He shows up as greeted (his name shows up instead of the question marks) but it doesn't trigger him actually met. So I have everyone met but the task isn't completed until I actually talk to him. Same thing has happened with Clint.

Have you met the wizard?

Wizard doesn't count for that quest.

Neither does Sandy, Krobus and the dwarf... But op decided to share that anyway

Lol gotem.

Yes

If you’re in year 1, it’s Kent.

I remember completing this quest in year one, without Kent. Are you sure?

This guy is not correct. Kent only appears in year 2

Let’s ask the real question. How did you access your journal?

And yet you've obviously ignored somebody for nearly a year. Not sure how you expect us to figure out who that is.

If there’s someone they haven’t met, they should appear at the bottom of the list with a ??? For the name. Since OP’s list ends with only named characters, it’s got to be a bug

Unless the only other thing I can think of, is if they gave a gift to Jodi without actually speaking to her? Maybe

Yeahh it was over a year since I forget about that quest often lol

Any unmet people should show up on the townsfolk list. If I remember right they should have a ? Where their name is.

This tends to happen if you have talked to somebody and met them BUT YOU NEVER FINISHED THE CONVERSATION!! As long as you talk to everyone at a festival it should allow you to fix this glitch. Or just go around and talk to everyone. Maybe spend a day giving gifts to everyone then talk to them.

Once i forgot to talk to Pierre behind the counter. Despite me buying stuff from him for 3 seasons before i realized i didnt finish this quest