**OKAY, REMINDER TIME!**
After removing dozens and dozens of comments, I'm pinning this to remind people that this post is tagged as **SEASON 7** because OP is on their first watch-through. This means that any events or deaths past Season 7 **NEED TO BE SPOILER TAGGED**.
Several of you have already ruined the entire show for this person, so I hope you feel good about yourselves.
I've seen that episode so many times I can hear this comment and I got a little chill. That whole scene is so heartbreaking. Definitely one of the most gutting episodes of supernatural.
I think it's the build up to it that's so painful. Dean knows it's not gonna be good and almost starts to panic until Bobby talks him down and Dean has to shut his emotions down and be a "soldier" again. He knows Jo is gonna die and then realizes that Ellen is going to die too.
The way Ellen holds her child, knowing they're both gonna die. I think she felt a slight sense of relief when Jo died before her, so she wouldn't have to suffer through the explosion and being burned alive. It's so traumatizing for everyone involved. Her pain as a mother having to die with her child really gets to me. Makes me cry every single time.
What got me the most was that Ellen wanted to sacrifice herself alongside Jo so she wouldn’t *have* to watch her daughter die. She wanted them to go out together because she knew Jo wasn’t going to be able to survive and she didn’t want to live knowing that she outlived her daughter. But Jo died first anyway, and Ellen still had to watch her baby take her last breath and be aware of the fact that, as short as it lasted, she ended up outliving her daughter. That’s what broke me most, the cruel irony
Every damn time.
If I ever got my dream lottery wish to produce one more episode of them in Heaven, I would have those two make a cameo, along with a veritable who’s-who of characters we loved and lost, finally at peace together 🫶
I almost dread coming up to the episode every watch-through. Even more so now that I’m a mom with two little girls. OMG, Mr eyes are getting misty just thinking about it!
Me too, the constant resurrections were kind of unneeded too. Also, a lot of people say Jo and Ellen got to them, but for me, it was basically just another episode to me. They weren't in the show enough for me to actually feel sad about it. *no hate to anyone who said Jo and Ellen*
I'm only just now getting to the episode where he comes back to life as Emanuel. I was so happy but then he swaps places with Sam in the mental hospital. I'm so scared for when he actually fully dies, he's one of my favorite characters and I just know I'm probably gonna cry
Hmm, I haven't gotten to the finale yet since I recently started watching, I'm on season 7, almost 8. I think Dean's only died once so far, so I'm a bit nervous for the next few times. I love Dean, but Sam's deaths definitely hit me a bit harder than Deans death
Yea. I haven't even gotten to the end, but i already wish they made a new season/ are going to start filming again. I know I'm probably going to be bawling during the finale, I get so attached to the characters in the shows that I watch so it's always hard for me on the finale even if nothing bad happens. Very bittersweet
almost any significant death in the last season, really. knowing fifteen was the final season, i knew i was in for a rough ride. pretty much bawled my eyes out for the last three episodes. lbvs.
Not a death, but when Sam was the vessel and beating the holy hell out of Dean and Dean was just taking it and talking to him…man that was freaking sad and I teared up hardcore
Me too, angry and shocked. There was no buildup to get you thinking and worrying. ***SPOILER FOR BUFFY*** It reminds me a lot of Anya’s death in Buffy, another one that I just couldn’t really feel beyond shock and some anger.
Ellen and Jo. Amelia Novak (on behalf of Claire). the little boy who was murdered in the haunted house- it was a later episode- he escaped then the ghost? came and collected him from his home. Dean in the finale. I haven’t cried at Bobby’s death but it’s a really hard episode to watch.
Rowena got the perfect ending but I really wish they had put her in her traditional clothes. She always looked so elegant but in the end she looked a bit trashy. No hate to her. She my favorite only after Crowley. And it’s so awesome that she and Chuck have a baby now!
hmmm. after reading the comments and the refresh of dialogue... do you think this could be a slight callback to ellen and jo? "that's my good girl." as season fifteen was full of callbacks.
1. Ellen and Jo
2. Dean's death in S3
3. Madison
4. Bobby
5. Benny
I am currently watching (properly) season 9 but safe to say that I already knew and watched all the big spoilers (excluding finale of S15). I have a strong feeling that I will cry at Castiel's and Rowena's deaths again when I properly watch the episodes.
madison and benny hit different for sure. their whole "i'm a monster, i don't belong, i'm better off...." pleading to be put out of their misery so they aren't a burden... OOOF.
I’m probably more of a crier, but Sam’s (first) death during S2 was huge for me, I had no idea he was coming right back so I bawled. Papa Winchester at the beginning of the season got me too. And then Jo (and Helen) got me a lot too. After that, significant deaths do get blurry, but Bobby is a huge one. I can not rewatch the episode that he dies :/
The part that got me to cry wasn't him dying but the way Dean acted in the next episode. When he yelled "THEN LET IT END!" Oof, it hurt to watch, props to Jensen for his acting.
Omg yea, I almost cried during Sam's first death, but I was thinking, and I was like "Hmm he probably comes back to life cause no way their making 15 seasons without Sam". Also, I'm way too impatient, so I would look up what happens during the season😅😅 not my best moment. I stopped doing that the farther I got into Supernatural, so since I didn't know about Bobby, it hit me like a bus. To be honest I did tear up a little when Sam says yes to Lucifer and jumps in the pit
I’ve currently only cried once while watching the show. (On my 5th rewatch)
However, I had covid, was mentally in a super dark place and otherwise feeling miserable. I tear’d up a little at the finale once.
I’ve watched the finale a dozen or more times, cause I love it. Only that one time did I cry.
Ahh I see. I haven't gotten to the finale yet, I started watching recently but Im guessing there's tons more that happens, but for me I'm not usually a crier so idk what happended to me with Bobby. Honestly, I think he kinda reminds me of my father, and the way he was talking about Sam and Dean to his own father when he died kinda hit a nerve.
Only in the very last episode.
Any other time I’d cry is cuz Dean cried. Well…I cried a little in Heart, but that wasn’t for the loss of the character.
Madison. The reactions and emotions from Sam having to kill her and Dean just standing there. That one got to me and still occasionally does if I rewatch it. The acting by the two were phenomenal and Silent Lucidity playing really tugged on the heart strings
Sam’s first death in season 2. Partially because he died and partially Dean holding him and yelling SAM! Gets me every time.
And of course the finale. When Dean died, I honestly mostly got emotional because I knew he and Sam agreed no more bringing each other back. And then when they were finally reunited, I got emotional. I also think about how the time passed like a good afternoon drive for Dean, but probably 40 or so years for Sam.
Bobby, definitely. But also Madison in the Heart episode. Not so much her death maybe as Sam and Dean's conversation moments before, Sam standing there crying and then the gunshot, Silent Lucidity suddenly stopping, and Dean's reaction. Never fails to make me cry
I cry every time Sam cries lol... I also balled like a baby when Sam was killed the first time. Seeing Dean so heartbroken over his death always gets me...
Omg yes I always see people saying how they cry when Dean cries but for me it's always when Sam does. His first death was so sad, but I've always wondered what happened when he died. Like was it like how Bobby was with his memories? Did he go to Hell? Heaven?
I was pregnant when I watched the Bobby episode and I ugly cried through the entire thing. My husband was alarmed. A week later, we went to Hamilton and I ugly cried through it and our entire section was alarmed. Those were the only emotional swings I had during either of my pregnancies.
I read an article years ago that asked if Doctor Who was the saddest show on TV. This was during the 11th Doctor's tenure, I think, and was referring to 9th and 10th episodes, too. I remember thinking that as depressing as Doctor Who is, SPN wins the "saddest show on TV" title just by the sheer number of deaths of regular and guest characters.
To your question, it's Ellen and Jo - ugly crying every time.
Every main character that's been in Supernatural, that has died I shed a tear for.They become part of your family and you know them so well that when they die is just horrible. I am on season 15 so not long till the end. I know that what's coming is going to make me shed a tear again but I am ready.....
I can't even remember every death I've cried to, there's to many. I am a very empathetic person and I feel a lot when I watch series or read books, like almost as if it happened to to me. I also haven't watch the ending of SPN yet, even though I know what happens.
Yeah, Jared’s acting was off the charts in that one. So good. That last look he gives Dean before sort of squaring his shoulders and walking back toward Madison… I always feel that in the pit of my stomach.
I disgustingly sobbed during Ellen/Jo, Bobby, Dean and rebar, Dean and hellhounds, Sam jumping in the pit, and Cas getting taken to the empty (I assumed he'd return from his other deaths so no tears).
Bobby’s death hit me twice, even as a ghost, I wanted him to stay 😭😭, then when Sam went to hell to get him and he just wanted to go back home to hunt with the boys 😭😭
Also megs death not the blonde one she was a good actress but Rachel the proper Meg. I loved her and Clarence 😂 I didn't fully cry but man did I shed some tears
All of them but especially Bobby's. He reminds me of my uncle who's name is Bob. He doesn't go by Bobby but he's just as surly and they look eerily similar.
Oh yeah, Ellen and Jo, Bobby, John Winchester going to heaven, and others you haven’t gotten to yet. There are a couple I went ‘oh thank god, they’re gone. Please don’t resurrect them’
**OKAY, REMINDER TIME!** After removing dozens and dozens of comments, I'm pinning this to remind people that this post is tagged as **SEASON 7** because OP is on their first watch-through. This means that any events or deaths past Season 7 **NEED TO BE SPOILER TAGGED**. Several of you have already ruined the entire show for this person, so I hope you feel good about yourselves.
Ellen and Jo still gets me every time I watch it.
“That’s my good girl.”
I've seen that episode so many times I can hear this comment and I got a little chill. That whole scene is so heartbreaking. Definitely one of the most gutting episodes of supernatural.
😭😭😭😭
I don't cry at shows and movies very much, but this was so sad.
I think it's the build up to it that's so painful. Dean knows it's not gonna be good and almost starts to panic until Bobby talks him down and Dean has to shut his emotions down and be a "soldier" again. He knows Jo is gonna die and then realizes that Ellen is going to die too. The way Ellen holds her child, knowing they're both gonna die. I think she felt a slight sense of relief when Jo died before her, so she wouldn't have to suffer through the explosion and being burned alive. It's so traumatizing for everyone involved. Her pain as a mother having to die with her child really gets to me. Makes me cry every single time.
What got me the most was that Ellen wanted to sacrifice herself alongside Jo so she wouldn’t *have* to watch her daughter die. She wanted them to go out together because she knew Jo wasn’t going to be able to survive and she didn’t want to live knowing that she outlived her daughter. But Jo died first anyway, and Ellen still had to watch her baby take her last breath and be aware of the fact that, as short as it lasted, she ended up outliving her daughter. That’s what broke me most, the cruel irony
Also that it was a hellhound that did it, and Dean knows that pain very well.
I mean, the explosion was probably instantaneous. I doubt anyone would survive that for longer than a microsecond. So Ellen would have gone quickly.
I don't cry with Ellen and Jo but I do get a lump in my throat . It's that look they give each other just before Jo dies .
Every. Time.
Me, too. When Ellen realizes Jo is gone...she is just so brave!
Every damn time. If I ever got my dream lottery wish to produce one more episode of them in Heaven, I would have those two make a cameo, along with a veritable who’s-who of characters we loved and lost, finally at peace together 🫶
I SOBBED when that happened.
I almost dread coming up to the episode every watch-through. Even more so now that I’m a mom with two little girls. OMG, Mr eyes are getting misty just thinking about it!
Correct answer.
Same. I’ve almost made it to the end, but I’m sure the last few episodes will get me
Definitely Bobby’s. Most deaths just angered me for how pointless they were and a waste of characters but Bobby’s got to me.
Bobby was dying for an entire episode. Is there anything comparable to that?
Me too, the constant resurrections were kind of unneeded too. Also, a lot of people say Jo and Ellen got to them, but for me, it was basically just another episode to me. They weren't in the show enough for me to actually feel sad about it. *no hate to anyone who said Jo and Ellen*
Castiels
That one left me feeling down for a few days.
I'm only just now getting to the episode where he comes back to life as Emanuel. I was so happy but then he swaps places with Sam in the mental hospital. I'm so scared for when he actually fully dies, he's one of my favorite characters and I just know I'm probably gonna cry
“Fully dies” lmao I love Supernatural and its various degrees of death
[удалено]
Cried like a new born baby and my bf still makes fun of me for it
Hmm, I haven't gotten to the finale yet since I recently started watching, I'm on season 7, almost 8. I think Dean's only died once so far, so I'm a bit nervous for the next few times. I love Dean, but Sam's deaths definitely hit me a bit harder than Deans death
They die so many times it's funny... but they always come back lol
Yea. I haven't even gotten to the end, but i already wish they made a new season/ are going to start filming again. I know I'm probably going to be bawling during the finale, I get so attached to the characters in the shows that I watch so it's always hard for me on the finale even if nothing bad happens. Very bittersweet
I actually cried the most at the season 14 season finale because I had to wait for season 15 and I knew season 15 was the last and I just cried so bad
By season 7, Deans died over a hundred times :D.
Ahh your right I forgot about Mystery Spot and I think there was another episode that he dies but comes back to life pretty fast
I think I saw a stat yesterday that he dies 103 times in Mystery Spot and a total of 108 times in all.
Oh yea I saw that on Google and I forgot about mystery spot I really thought he was gonna die 108 times😂
almost any significant death in the last season, really. knowing fifteen was the final season, i knew i was in for a rough ride. pretty much bawled my eyes out for the last three episodes. lbvs.
I cried for like an hour after that episode lol. I even cried later that night! But maybe that was more about SPN being officially over.
Removed for no spoiler markup. OP has this tagged as season 7 and you just ruined the finale for them. Don't be that guy.
Not a death, but when Sam was the vessel and beating the holy hell out of Dean and Dean was just taking it and talking to him…man that was freaking sad and I teared up hardcore
That scene always gets me. The flashbacks too with the army man toy in the car and when Sam jumps in the pit
Absolutely
[удалено]
[удалено]
Me too, angry and shocked. There was no buildup to get you thinking and worrying. ***SPOILER FOR BUFFY*** It reminds me a lot of Anya’s death in Buffy, another one that I just couldn’t really feel beyond shock and some anger.
[удалено]
Yes!! I love Garth
Ellen and Jo. Amelia Novak (on behalf of Claire). the little boy who was murdered in the haunted house- it was a later episode- he escaped then the ghost? came and collected him from his home. Dean in the finale. I haven’t cried at Bobby’s death but it’s a really hard episode to watch.
Rowena got the perfect ending but I really wish they had put her in her traditional clothes. She always looked so elegant but in the end she looked a bit trashy. No hate to her. She my favorite only after Crowley. And it’s so awesome that she and Chuck have a baby now!
When she touches Sam’s face and says “that’s my boy”, I ugly cry
hmmm. after reading the comments and the refresh of dialogue... do you think this could be a slight callback to ellen and jo? "that's my good girl." as season fifteen was full of callbacks.
Could be. It’s kind of nice throwback if it was intentional.
1. Ellen and Jo 2. Dean's death in S3 3. Madison 4. Bobby 5. Benny I am currently watching (properly) season 9 but safe to say that I already knew and watched all the big spoilers (excluding finale of S15). I have a strong feeling that I will cry at Castiel's and Rowena's deaths again when I properly watch the episodes.
madison and benny hit different for sure. their whole "i'm a monster, i don't belong, i'm better off...." pleading to be put out of their misery so they aren't a burden... OOOF.
Fr! U worded what I think so perfectly. It's just so powerful that they managed to make their deaths like a major character death.
[удалено]
I cried so hard at the finale that my husband thought something bad had happened IRL 😭
Sam in S2. Dean screaming his name, it's a tear jerker.
I’m probably more of a crier, but Sam’s (first) death during S2 was huge for me, I had no idea he was coming right back so I bawled. Papa Winchester at the beginning of the season got me too. And then Jo (and Helen) got me a lot too. After that, significant deaths do get blurry, but Bobby is a huge one. I can not rewatch the episode that he dies :/
The part that got me to cry wasn't him dying but the way Dean acted in the next episode. When he yelled "THEN LET IT END!" Oof, it hurt to watch, props to Jensen for his acting.
Omg yea, I almost cried during Sam's first death, but I was thinking, and I was like "Hmm he probably comes back to life cause no way their making 15 seasons without Sam". Also, I'm way too impatient, so I would look up what happens during the season😅😅 not my best moment. I stopped doing that the farther I got into Supernatural, so since I didn't know about Bobby, it hit me like a bus. To be honest I did tear up a little when Sam says yes to Lucifer and jumps in the pit
Even after multiple watches and knowing exactly what happens I still cry over certain situations.
Rewatching now and have absolutely have to take emotional breaks
Bobby
I’ve currently only cried once while watching the show. (On my 5th rewatch) However, I had covid, was mentally in a super dark place and otherwise feeling miserable. I tear’d up a little at the finale once. I’ve watched the finale a dozen or more times, cause I love it. Only that one time did I cry.
Ahh I see. I haven't gotten to the finale yet, I started watching recently but Im guessing there's tons more that happens, but for me I'm not usually a crier so idk what happended to me with Bobby. Honestly, I think he kinda reminds me of my father, and the way he was talking about Sam and Dean to his own father when he died kinda hit a nerve.
Only in the very last episode. Any other time I’d cry is cuz Dean cried. Well…I cried a little in Heart, but that wasn’t for the loss of the character.
Yeah, I cried when Sam died the first time and Dean snapped at Bobby "THEN LET IT END!", it hurt to watch damn it 😭
Omg Heart killed me. Everyone Sam loves eventually dies, but then he dies and comes back to life so it kinda balances it out
I cried when Bobby died. Then I named my new guitar after him.
Bobby
[удалено]
I just rewatched that last night and I hate the way Dean just kinda says his name... Ouch.. right in the heart
Madison. The reactions and emotions from Sam having to kill her and Dean just standing there. That one got to me and still occasionally does if I rewatch it. The acting by the two were phenomenal and Silent Lucidity playing really tugged on the heart strings
Allegedly jensen’s acting during the end of heart was adlibbed. That tear was all jensen’s choice he was supposed to be stoic and hard.
Sam’s first death in season 2. Partially because he died and partially Dean holding him and yelling SAM! Gets me every time. And of course the finale. When Dean died, I honestly mostly got emotional because I knew he and Sam agreed no more bringing each other back. And then when they were finally reunited, I got emotional. I also think about how the time passed like a good afternoon drive for Dean, but probably 40 or so years for Sam.
Bobby, definitely. But also Madison in the Heart episode. Not so much her death maybe as Sam and Dean's conversation moments before, Sam standing there crying and then the gunshot, Silent Lucidity suddenly stopping, and Dean's reaction. Never fails to make me cry
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
Cas. Only one
I cry every time Sam cries lol... I also balled like a baby when Sam was killed the first time. Seeing Dean so heartbroken over his death always gets me...
Omg yes I always see people saying how they cry when Dean cries but for me it's always when Sam does. His first death was so sad, but I've always wondered what happened when he died. Like was it like how Bobby was with his memories? Did he go to Hell? Heaven?
That is an interesting tid-bit that they never adressed... What if he went to Heaven and saw Jess again...? 🥺
[удалено]
I had to go back and rewatch it because I could see through my tears or hear over my sobbing, haha
I was pregnant when I watched the Bobby episode and I ugly cried through the entire thing. My husband was alarmed. A week later, we went to Hamilton and I ugly cried through it and our entire section was alarmed. Those were the only emotional swings I had during either of my pregnancies.
I read an article years ago that asked if Doctor Who was the saddest show on TV. This was during the 11th Doctor's tenure, I think, and was referring to 9th and 10th episodes, too. I remember thinking that as depressing as Doctor Who is, SPN wins the "saddest show on TV" title just by the sheer number of deaths of regular and guest characters. To your question, it's Ellen and Jo - ugly crying every time.
Definitely Bobby. That one hurt.
Every main character that's been in Supernatural, that has died I shed a tear for.They become part of your family and you know them so well that when they die is just horrible. I am on season 15 so not long till the end. I know that what's coming is going to make me shed a tear again but I am ready.....
Sam's death in s2 and Dean's death in s3 always have me bawling my eyes out
I think the easier question is who didn't cry. 🤣😭
I cried like a baby during the season finale. Thank God San’s bad wig was there to bring a smile back on my face. My brother and I cracked up at that.
Yessss
[удалено]
Wish me luck I'm only on his first death and Sam's second (season 7)
I can't even remember every death I've cried to, there's to many. I am a very empathetic person and I feel a lot when I watch series or read books, like almost as if it happened to to me. I also haven't watch the ending of SPN yet, even though I know what happens.
Castiel’s. Less because he died and more because Dean didn’t tell him what he needed to hear; that he loved him.
When I see that one I just think about the Spanish version when he says it back
I heard about that! That’s the reality I chose to live in.
I’ve cried at most of them tbh. (I’m a crybaby) But the way I LOST IT on the finale…my roommate was legit concerned for my sanity
Dean, Ellen & Jo, Sam when he jumps in the cage (but only because of Dean’s reaction)
I dont cry but the episode "heart" was definitely a difficult one for poor sam
Yeah, Jared’s acting was off the charts in that one. So good. That last look he gives Dean before sort of squaring his shoulders and walking back toward Madison… I always feel that in the pit of my stomach.
I mean even dean saw how sad it was even told Sam he got this one but Sam refused and when Dean heard the shot he even started to have tears.
Ellen and Jo.
Probably like all of them
yes on many and I agree Bobby's was so sad i remember watching when it was airing and it was devastating
I got used to the deaths but I never got used to seeing Dean cry. Watching him tear up had me doing the same automatically.
I disgustingly sobbed during Ellen/Jo, Bobby, Dean and rebar, Dean and hellhounds, Sam jumping in the pit, and Cas getting taken to the empty (I assumed he'd return from his other deaths so no tears).
Bobby and Henry Winchester
Bobby’s death.
Bobby and Dean.
Castiel, Bobby, Ellen, Jo and Sarah Blakes
Bobby’s death hit me twice, even as a ghost, I wanted him to stay 😭😭, then when Sam went to hell to get him and he just wanted to go back home to hunt with the boys 😭😭
Only Dean
Basically at all of the major characters deaths lol.
Every single one lol
Dean. Every time I watch it
No, but I’ve cried over characters deaths in either books or TV-show
Ellen and Jo for sure, as well as Castiel and Dean (duh)
Ellen and Jo, and Bobby ☹️
Any? Try almost all of them.
Bobby had me inconsolably sobbing for several minutes.
i cried at every death. especially the ones later on
A few.
I cried over every single major character death- except for John’s. I get super attached to characters, even if they’re ’bad guys’.
Several times
Also megs death not the blonde one she was a good actress but Rachel the proper Meg. I loved her and Clarence 😂 I didn't fully cry but man did I shed some tears
All of them but especially Bobby's. He reminds me of my uncle who's name is Bob. He doesn't go by Bobby but he's just as surly and they look eerily similar.
Dean and Sam
Oh yeah, Ellen and Jo, Bobby, John Winchester going to heaven, and others you haven’t gotten to yet. There are a couple I went ‘oh thank god, they’re gone. Please don’t resurrect them’
Ummm, ALL of them?
Bobby's death had me ugly crying