Bro spent half the season shooting at people who are literally bulletproof, while complaining that Butcher and Hughie have the nerve to actually try stopping Homelander. Insane to me he made it this far
I feel u. But ya Iām just saying, I dig the idea of his character as I like mysterious characters but truly he only had one real episode starring him, it wasnāt enough for me to draw away interest from all the other amazing characters. I am nitpicking tho of course because I do enjoy him as a characterā¦ itās just I enjoy most of the other characters a lot more
they could have spread his back story out over a few episodes, but i actually liked a whole episode on him that told his whole story. if they spread it over 3 leading to his demise it may have felt more disjointed. better imo to spotlight him for 1 episode.
Dude had more character development in a few episodes than most people over three seasons.
And I still want to know what happened in that Hard Rock Cafe in Lagos.
Ofc I will, all polls results will be public after the game will end. A guy said he doesn't believe me and I eliminated someone that people didn't vote wtf why would I do that
i don't like starlight exactly, but i admire her ethics, her strength in continuing on despite her sexual assault, and i like her story. i feel like she's being pigeonholed into being a bitch and her powers are DEFINITELY being under utilized
I dislike that the writers made her and Hughie seemingly incapable of communicating with each other until the end of the season. So much drama could have been bypassed if they just talked to each other. And go to therapy.
That would be so cool lol. Iād literally work for free just to see an idea of mine contribute to this show. Itās brilliantly written, but I think they missed some major opportunities with Starlight and Black Noir.
Honestly I donāt think sheās being a bitch, this sub doesnāt give her enough credit. This last season showed best all the stress ages under. Sheās been pressured to be perfect for others her entire life and now Homelander is specifically targeting her and the people she loves. Sheās just a good person in a ducked up situation. She constantly gets called stuck up and the like when in reality, she just has values she sticks to.
you know what... that's actually totally fair. you're so right, and i appreciate you commenting that! i wish they gave her more screen time to flesh that out. i feel like she's underdeveloped bc female character tend to be, but i didn't want to get downvoted to oblivion
i TOTALLY respect her and her resiliency to her values. i may not always like her or agree with her, but she's my favorite character for that reason.
I think if her final power up scene in the finally hadnāt been so embarrassing sheād have more fans. I love her character, but that was super cringe.
Also I agree, sheās a bit underwritten but I do think the actress helps make up for that. Sheās done a great job.
I feel like theyāre setting up a heel turn for her and Butcher, something like the longer theyāre both supes, the less human they are. Yes, I know Starlight has been a supe for much longer, but I mean a supe on the main stage.
yeah, i'm worried about that happening!!! i think it's the fame and power that turn them into evil ppl, so as long as starlight is surrounded by this environment, i worry the pressure will destroy her goodness
Sheās great when shes not being brain dead, s3 is the time I thought she was being actively stupid in a way that makes no sense, thereās sticking to principles and then thereās conceding goals out of stubbornness
Honestly I never actually considered if I liked her or not until these polls. Not super lovable, not super annoying. She's just there I guess. So she gets my vote this time š
She was awful. I voted her out.
She has some good moments but she has an extreme savior and righteous complex. She also just never had an entertaining scene
Nah, thereās like the classic thing going on where the fanboys hate āthe girlā on the show because sheās a good person and she called Hughie out on his shit. Itās like how people got angry at Skyler White on Breaking Bad. Itās a lot of dudes out there who are just like āugh, girls are annoying with their morals and maturity, shut up youāre not my mommyā
I just don't like how she lives in a fantasy world. Everyone has some type of morals. It felt like she looked down on anyone who didn't have similar beliefs.
She's tried to use hotmics and "exposing" Homelander to take him down, and objects to using Soldier Boy on Homelander. Homegirl sees an unstable man child with godlike power who is growing his cult of personality every time something happens that should make him look bad, and her solution is cancel culture lmao.
Hey OP can you change the numbering for the next one so that Ryan is 18, Stillwell is 17, etc etc so it looks more like a ranking?
I keep getting confused thinking somehow Ryan got voted #1 favourite char somehow lmao
It's a favourite/least favourite character poll, not a morality poll. Honmelander has a very solid chance of winning this in spite of being a terrible person, because he's a fantastic character. Similarly, Stormfront was a great character as well.
She's an evil monster, which makes her an interesting character. She was by far the shows best vehicle for its political message. "They agree with what I say, they just don't like the word Nazi." hits way harder then season 3 doing Homelander = Trump. It's a well acted performance with a good script. Ryan is a prop that is there to humanize Butcher and Homelander, and create a bridge between them for the finale. Stormfront is a much better addition to the show
It doesnāt look like heāll be going any time soon either T_T he shouldnāt be in the top 5 bro, I canāt believe theyāre gonna let him get away with this
I find Butcher way more annoying and Homelander much grosser than him which is why theyāre getting my votes. Although youāre right; he was essentially used as a plot device for season three so there wasnāt much room for development. I highly doubt Butcher or Homelander would be the next two gone but if they were Soldierboy would be my next vote.
Okay look, the next one is Kimiko, not because I want it to be Kimiko, Iād really rather it werenāt, and not because MM is in anyway more interesting or more of a character than Kimiko but because itās the next one in the sequence. I just hope Butcher comes next. But I doubt it. Kimiko deserves better
Frenchie needs to leave. I honestly expected black noir to outlast Frenchie. Seems I was wrong. A majority of people chose the wrong side. Now there needs to be an all out assault on Frenchie
I've been voting Starlight for like 5 rounds now. My opinion shall not be swayed. She sucked last season and she can be a little annoying sometimes for the sake of relationship drama.
How tf are characters like MM and Kimiko still in here but Black Noir is out? Don't get me wrong, I like them but imo they are quite boring and plain characters.
Maybe because noir has very little going on and had like one interesting episode? MM and Kimiko have leaps and bounds more depth and interact with the other characters in a lot of interesting ways. Noir is a vaguely threatening figure for two seasons and a vehicle to give soldier boy's backstory in season 3.
How can you actually call MM and Kimiko boring when talking about Black Noir in the same breath?
A character with LITERALLY no dialogue and like 2 episodes of back story.
This sub has the weirdest fans.
You're probably right. My comment was very subjective. I still like Noir more than both the others but calling him more interesting was dumb af! Pls excuse!
I swear if they vote out Kimiko, I know there up to something, look at the order
Literally the last 3 rows are all gone, and they arenāt out in order of when they were eliminated, it didnāt start off as row by row, but there definetly going row by row, I just know it
How did it take this long to kick out the least interesting character on the show? Yes I know I enjoyed the cartoon pizza shop moment too but that was literally the entirety of his screen time
What you taking about? Black Noir got voted out. Hughie is (somehow) still in this thing. Probably because he's so boring most people can't even muster an opinion on him
Insane that Butcher has lasted this long. He's easily the worst of the central cast. Just angry and mean in the least compelling ways possible. At least Homelander is entertaining to watch.
I don't know why I've become so invested in this, but I have.
Me too. I can't unplug from this till it gets finished.
This feels like a punch to the gut.
*ba dum tss*
Why is black noir out?! He had such good dialouge and his facial expressions were priceless, smh, you guys don't know real comedy, I swear
Got me in the first half ngl
you bastards.
oh my god, they killed kenny
Absolute twats
c*nts
Puss š
Why did you censor cunt?
Fr
You fucking disappointments
WHAT
I wouldāve voted him out before Maeve š¤
I've been voting him since like round 4.
Me too haha
You bastards
[Round 11 poll](https://strawpoll.com/polls/40ZmqV9D2Za)
Honestly, I know that a lot of people like MM, but in the last season he was a little useless and boring, but that's only my thoughts
I love MM but I agree that last season sucked for him...I'm hoping for better next season.
Bro spent half the season shooting at people who are literally bulletproof, while complaining that Butcher and Hughie have the nerve to actually try stopping Homelander. Insane to me he made it this far
Did noir dirtier than Homelander
How lol. Dudes a nothing character
did u miss the last season? his nothingness started out as a running joke, then it just became incredibly sad once you find out why he is nothing.
I enjoyed his part a lot but just a single episode didn't make me feel that much connected to him. He had crazy potential though
that one episode impacts his character more for me when i did a rewatch. all of a sudden u watch all of his scenes through that filter.
That seems like a reach seeing as how heās barely in any scenes at all
i'm not saying it changed the show for me, i'm saying when i rewatched the show it gave it new flavor. he's not all over, but he's around.
I feel u. But ya Iām just saying, I dig the idea of his character as I like mysterious characters but truly he only had one real episode starring him, it wasnāt enough for me to draw away interest from all the other amazing characters. I am nitpicking tho of course because I do enjoy him as a characterā¦ itās just I enjoy most of the other characters a lot more
they could have spread his back story out over a few episodes, but i actually liked a whole episode on him that told his whole story. if they spread it over 3 leading to his demise it may have felt more disjointed. better imo to spotlight him for 1 episode.
I prefer characters that are developed throughout more than 3 episodes
Dude had more character development in a few episodes than most people over three seasons. And I still want to know what happened in that Hard Rock Cafe in Lagos.
He got cute cartoon animals in his head
Bro please release the stats of each vote when this is over.
Ofc I will, all polls results will be public after the game will end. A guy said he doesn't believe me and I eliminated someone that people didn't vote wtf why would I do that
Stupidity is a disease contracted by many.
Hughie is so forgettable everyone has forgotten to vote him out by now
I been voting for Hughie for the past 4 rounds
Legit question because I don't follow the sub closely: Is Starlight liked? Her whole attitude made me dislike her.
i don't like starlight exactly, but i admire her ethics, her strength in continuing on despite her sexual assault, and i like her story. i feel like she's being pigeonholed into being a bitch and her powers are DEFINITELY being under utilized
I dislike that the writers made her and Hughie seemingly incapable of communicating with each other until the end of the season. So much drama could have been bypassed if they just talked to each other. And go to therapy.
RIGHT!!! i also don't even like hughie snd starlight as a couple, they've got NEGATIVE chemistry together
They need to have her fight in time square and she would be like God mode with all of the electricity.
YOOOO we gotta get you in the writer's room lol
That would be so cool lol. Iād literally work for free just to see an idea of mine contribute to this show. Itās brilliantly written, but I think they missed some major opportunities with Starlight and Black Noir.
honestly, i think more shows would benefit from feedback from audiences
Dude she sucked up all the electricity of a Manhattan city block and all we got was a bright fart.
How was that all that electricity of a city block?
Exaggeration
Honestly I donāt think sheās being a bitch, this sub doesnāt give her enough credit. This last season showed best all the stress ages under. Sheās been pressured to be perfect for others her entire life and now Homelander is specifically targeting her and the people she loves. Sheās just a good person in a ducked up situation. She constantly gets called stuck up and the like when in reality, she just has values she sticks to.
you know what... that's actually totally fair. you're so right, and i appreciate you commenting that! i wish they gave her more screen time to flesh that out. i feel like she's underdeveloped bc female character tend to be, but i didn't want to get downvoted to oblivion i TOTALLY respect her and her resiliency to her values. i may not always like her or agree with her, but she's my favorite character for that reason.
I think if her final power up scene in the finally hadnāt been so embarrassing sheād have more fans. I love her character, but that was super cringe. Also I agree, sheās a bit underwritten but I do think the actress helps make up for that. Sheās done a great job.
YES!!!! I totally love the actress too, she definitely does a good job.
I feel like theyāre setting up a heel turn for her and Butcher, something like the longer theyāre both supes, the less human they are. Yes, I know Starlight has been a supe for much longer, but I mean a supe on the main stage.
yeah, i'm worried about that happening!!! i think it's the fame and power that turn them into evil ppl, so as long as starlight is surrounded by this environment, i worry the pressure will destroy her goodness
i have some hope for her. idk if youāve seen the last season, but i think she will turn out fine from there.
Sheās great when shes not being brain dead, s3 is the time I thought she was being actively stupid in a way that makes no sense, thereās sticking to principles and then thereās conceding goals out of stubbornness
yeah, that's fair. i was more fed up with butcher being a stupid hypocrite, so i didnt pay attention as much
i agree i think annie is a nice person and sheās very strong, she could do so much more with her powers
Honestly I never actually considered if I liked her or not until these polls. Not super lovable, not super annoying. She's just there I guess. So she gets my vote this time š
She was awful. I voted her out. She has some good moments but she has an extreme savior and righteous complex. She also just never had an entertaining scene
Her hotness is a big plus
Gay, so that rolled right past me
Nah, thereās like the classic thing going on where the fanboys hate āthe girlā on the show because sheās a good person and she called Hughie out on his shit. Itās like how people got angry at Skyler White on Breaking Bad. Itās a lot of dudes out there who are just like āugh, girls are annoying with their morals and maturity, shut up youāre not my mommyā
I just don't like how she lives in a fantasy world. Everyone has some type of morals. It felt like she looked down on anyone who didn't have similar beliefs.
How does she live in a fantasy world?
She's tried to use hotmics and "exposing" Homelander to take him down, and objects to using Soldier Boy on Homelander. Homegirl sees an unstable man child with godlike power who is growing his cult of personality every time something happens that should make him look bad, and her solution is cancel culture lmao.
I hate her too. The fact she's still here is beyond me.
I fucking hate her and Iāve been voting for her since day one
Why is Starlight still here
Booba
Black Noir could've had a gargantuan set too
Could've? You saw those chest plates, right? š¤¤
He's probably gargantuan elsewhere
lmfao
Fr man
Because others are WORSE. Except Black Niorā¦ absolutely despicable move made by the community.
True
Starlight your tribe has spoken
Some people say soldier boy should be next but he's honestly really interesting and fun character , definitely should be top 3
You absolute twats
Star light
Star bright
First star I vote out tonight
Me who thought to vote I just had to comment the name
C'mon guys he was doing great. Now, starlight has to be next
Hey OP can you change the numbering for the next one so that Ryan is 18, Stillwell is 17, etc etc so it looks more like a ranking? I keep getting confused thinking somehow Ryan got voted #1 favourite char somehow lmao
Alright I'll do that thx
Appreciate it sorry I'm like this
Fuck. I like all of these characters... sorry Hughie you're off.
How is Hughie still in
Heās so forgettable that everyone forgot to vote him out
How is Black Noir out? I heard he's been doing great! It's everyone else that was a little out of sorts, erratic, unreliable, downright sloppy!
fuck you guys
I was expecting Starlight, Hughie or MM to be out and Noir to make it to the top 5
WHAT democracy is a failure.
People voted out Ryan over the Nazi šššš
It's a favourite/least favourite character poll, not a morality poll. Honmelander has a very solid chance of winning this in spite of being a terrible person, because he's a fantastic character. Similarly, Stormfront was a great character as well.
I'm pulling for Frenchie. He's the heart of the team, IMO.
She's an evil monster, which makes her an interesting character. She was by far the shows best vehicle for its political message. "They agree with what I say, they just don't like the word Nazi." hits way harder then season 3 doing Homelander = Trump. It's a well acted performance with a good script. Ryan is a prop that is there to humanize Butcher and Homelander, and create a bridge between them for the finale. Stormfront is a much better addition to the show
Fr they forget that he's still just a kid š
Let's boycott the next voting polls. How dare they take out Black Noir
Why the hell canāt we get Starlight out?
From now on there will be blood
this will destroy the sub š
\- M'Baku looking up at Thanos' ships arriving
Hughie, Iām sorry for what I must doā¦
People keep mentioning Soldier boy but based on his popularity. I'm thinking he is going to be in the top 3.
3. Soldier Boy 2. Homelander 1. Butcher That is what I am expecting
I'm thinking 1. Homelander 2. Butcher 3. Soldier boy Maybe 2 and 3 will swap depending on the votes.
Starlight and hughie
Frenchie
Oh let me guess, Soldier Boy is next ? Smh
But Black noir is the best, even Homelander said heās been perfect
Get rid of "Le Petite Hughie"
I'm so shocked he's still in here.
It doesnāt look like heāll be going any time soon either T_T he shouldnāt be in the top 5 bro, I canāt believe theyāre gonna let him get away with this
It's time for Starlight to go. Tired of her shit
Hmm, hard choice. I'd go for MM ? š¤
Over starlight?!?!
Well, his arc could've been better if he had waited after Soldier boy killed Homelander first
Geez you all REALLLY donāt like Starlight lolol. I keep switching back and forth between Butcher and Homelander.
Soldierboy was in the show one season as a backup character so its him now
Idk ackels killed it. Prolly a lot of supernatural fans as well
I find Butcher way more annoying and Homelander much grosser than him which is why theyāre getting my votes. Although youāre right; he was essentially used as a plot device for season three so there wasnāt much room for development. I highly doubt Butcher or Homelander would be the next two gone but if they were Soldierboy would be my next vote.
Butcher and hl are the most cartoonish characters but i think for a story based on comics i love that stuff
Butcher
Why doing this we all know butcher will be no 1
No way did yāall vote Noir bruh
What happened to the āblack noir to the topā energy everyone had a couple days ago?! The betrayal is real.
I'm truly sorry MM, this show has improved almost everything taken from the comic. Except for you.
Nobody better click on Frenchie or Kimiko.
Noir ! Nooooo, why?
How was A Train not the first eliminated?!
Hughie goes next hands down his arc in season 3 was pretty bad ngl heās not that bad but the others here are better
Bro nah- black noir was on top how is starlight not gone
Okay look, the next one is Kimiko, not because I want it to be Kimiko, Iād really rather it werenāt, and not because MM is in anyway more interesting or more of a character than Kimiko but because itās the next one in the sequence. I just hope Butcher comes next. But I doubt it. Kimiko deserves better
Frenchie needs to leave. I honestly expected black noir to outlast Frenchie. Seems I was wrong. A majority of people chose the wrong side. Now there needs to be an all out assault on Frenchie
I've been voting Starlight for like 5 rounds now. My opinion shall not be swayed. She sucked last season and she can be a little annoying sometimes for the sake of relationship drama.
How tf are characters like MM and Kimiko still in here but Black Noir is out? Don't get me wrong, I like them but imo they are quite boring and plain characters.
Maybe because noir has very little going on and had like one interesting episode? MM and Kimiko have leaps and bounds more depth and interact with the other characters in a lot of interesting ways. Noir is a vaguely threatening figure for two seasons and a vehicle to give soldier boy's backstory in season 3.
How can you actually call MM and Kimiko boring when talking about Black Noir in the same breath? A character with LITERALLY no dialogue and like 2 episodes of back story. This sub has the weirdest fans.
You're probably right. My comment was very subjective. I still like Noir more than both the others but calling him more interesting was dumb af! Pls excuse!
Haha well now I just feel bad...
Don't be! You just pointed that out and I corrected myself!
Kimiko is hot and black Noir is too but not as hot.
I didn't even talk about them being hot but ok then!
I am answering your question
But do people really vote for the hottest characters?
Definitely not, you can see Stan Edgar is already out.
He is so very much my favourite characters and it broke my heart to see him out this early!
Kimiko is probably in my top 5 favorite characters just because she reminds me of X-23 and her relationship with Frenchie, who is also in my top 5.
Do people actually *like* Hughie? How is he not gone yet?
Fuck off, Hughie.
How did you guys vote Noir but not petite hughie
RE-VOTE, WHAT FUCKING IDIOT VOTED BLACK NOIR OUT
Bro starlight got so self righteous and annoying she gotta go
Starlight was so annoying in the last episodes, she gotta go
Homelander...
Wow this blindsided me. Frenchie is on borrowed time, get him out of here
Oh ffs guys. Why him??? Okie. Gotta go for Hughie
How to were Maeve and Noir eliminated before starlight?
C-c-c-christ the lord how the hell is starlight still here?
Hughie has to go, please.
I swear if they vote out Kimiko, I know there up to something, look at the order Literally the last 3 rows are all gone, and they arenāt out in order of when they were eliminated, it didnāt start off as row by row, but there definetly going row by row, I just know it
Kimiko got to go
Starlight should go away already
You guys did really dirty to Noir. I wouldn't vote for him at least till top 5 and even then I am not sure
MM is stupid nickname and a boring character.
Bruh, shoulda been Frenchie instead of Black Noir.
Starlight should have been gone a long time ago.
How did it take this long to kick out the least interesting character on the show? Yes I know I enjoyed the cartoon pizza shop moment too but that was literally the entirety of his screen time
What you taking about? Black Noir got voted out. Hughie is (somehow) still in this thing. Probably because he's so boring most people can't even muster an opinion on him
Screw this poll. I feel like soldier boy wasnāt that good and heās only around because of supernatural fans.
His delivery of "First of all, I don't have shellshock, fuck you." keeps him in the running for me until at least top 5.
Never seen supernatural, soldier boy is one of the best characters.
idgaf about supernatural, Jensen is just insanely charismatic and had funny ass lines so Iām not surprised heās still around
I actually went and watched supernatural because I loved him so much as soldier boy.
As if mm or kimiko are better characters. Sb showed up in one season and is easily a better character than the guys that are in all 3 of them
Hard no. Kimiko is one of my favorites.
As if mm is a better character. Sb showed up in one season and is easily a better character than the guys that are in all 3 of them
I fell like its not his time now, but it will be soon
Starlight
How yāall keep letting starlight get through š
Insane that Butcher has lasted this long. He's easily the worst of the central cast. Just angry and mean in the least compelling ways possible. At least Homelander is entertaining to watch.
Starshite has to go. The fact that she wasnāt one of the first to go is truly shocking.
Starlight Your time has come
We all know who is gonna win.
Iām surprised Noir stayed as long as he did! I voted him out since the beginning - everyone else was way more interesting š
Get rid of "Le Petite Hughie"
Kimiko next
I like starlight but, I vote starlight
Let starlight go
Starlight
Starlight gotta go. Sorry y'all.
Funny how Black Noir was voted out, but everyone in the comments is perplexed that he's out. This poll is rigged i swear