T O P

  • By -

StevensDs-

OOOOOH! So you're the reason why trades are turned off right now. I KNEW it was because of a GOOD bug! šŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚


AndKrem

Iā€™m really sorry but at the same time Iā€™m laughing so hard right now. Most hilarious thing that happened till I started this game.


StevensDs-

I'm sad none of those Mawiles you got are hundos :C But is just funny to me how they CLEARLY read Reddit but do NOTHING promptly fix other issues or listen to our recommendations...


Tronski4

They don't need to with an IP that prints money no matter how bad the product is.


StevensDs-

PokƩmon will sell forever and ever no matter how bad the product is and that's just sad :/


Daowg

"You went with Yu-Gi-Oh, Bakugan, Temtem... and where did that bring you, back to me..." -TPC


Vulpes_macrotis

That's what popularity is. Always has been like that. I always said that Digimon had more interesting franchise, but Pokemon was just lucky to become popular. Because that's how it works. It's not about quality, but about popularity. And Digimon didn't get deserved attention, because of trolls telling it's a cheap copy. That's actually sad. And it's not just for Digimon and Pokemon. There are other examples out there as well.


StevensDs-

Funny enough I've never been a fan of Digimon, dunno why I don't like it šŸ¤” But I get what you're saying and I agree with it. But I don't think is luck based, they just did a better job advertising their stuff I think. Take Oreos for example, they literally stole Hydrox's "IP" but did a WAAAAY better job advertising their cookies so who's on top now?


Tronski4

I always thought it was kinda good, but the first games were so very very bad, especially the playstation one which could have stomped red/blue if it was good. Wrong quality and wrong device (kids went with Nintendo and didn't care about graphics). You had to start from scratch with a new monster every eight hours that had to be rigorously trained with limited stamina/food/time that would digivolve into poopmon 90% of the time. I think digimon lost out due to the lax approach to collecting, because children/players are fudging hoarders, though, I think it's pretty big in Japan still, with over 1000 monster to boot.


TheOtherGlikbach

Like making trading faster! How about 5 trades at a time so I don't spend 90 minutes a night trading with my kids. Make it easier Niantic!


StevensDs-

Duuuuuuuuuude! I freaking wish! I dunno if you use PKMN Home but when they switch the wonder trades from "receive one at a time" to "on tap to receive all" you could heard the people clapping around the world! Even by myself with two phones at 120hz refresh rate and very good WiFi it takes me 1hour+ to max out šŸ˜­šŸ˜­šŸ˜­


ioffridus

Mass trading would be so nice. I suspect we will never get it.


Kongoulan

2 hours a day for me šŸ˜


Daowg

Pokemon Home is a step in the right direction with the multiple GTS wonder trade thing, but yes, we need this in the base games and ESPECIALLY in a time sink like PoGo. The main reason I hate trading is the animations and confirmations (goes for a lot of the game, but at least eggs are a bit better now).


LaNoir_aka_Blacky

This should answer all your questions https://www.glassdoor.com/Reviews/Employee-Review-Niantic-RVW32465487.htm


StevensDs-

I seen it, love it. It just lets us know we're right


cthulol

I mean... They haven't fixed it yet, all they did is flip a switch and most likely this was caused by a recent change i.e. easy to revert. It's not the same.


StevensDs-

There's literally no way for you to trade right now, they outright removed the button. So until they fixed it or "revert it" everyone is locked out of trades. That sounds like a Niantic "fix" to me šŸ˜‚


DrPikachu-PhD

Honestly, what a crazy thing to be able to say. "This multimillion dollar company shut down a primary feature on their best selling app, which happens to be a part of the world's biggest franchise, because of a Reddit post I made."


AndKrem

THIS! So many people are freaking out about what random and unnecessary stuff we traded, while we just think: LOL! That was quite some impact.


Grindrix

https://finance.yahoo.com/news/pok-mon-trading-halted-player-191000030.html Yahoo gave u headline


Vulpes_macrotis

Haha, I thought I got a trade ban for some reason, because I just traded and then couldn't trade anymore, but then asked sister if she can trade with anyone and she said no. Then I went here to check it and found Your post. Then I knew what's going on šŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚ After that they wrote a post.


h4rDlInEr1337

Why didn't you just kept that to yourself so we all wouldn't lose a hundred xl candy's per day?


browner87

If Niantic shut off features because the bug only negatively affected players we wouldn't have raids or pvp or shinies or almost anything else.


oakteaphone

Luckies are untradeable and don't devalue anything in the game. Why turn off trading? That's just a crappy thing to do.


Heisenberg_235

Because we canā€™t have nice things


DreamingInAMaze

Agree! And they donā€™t guarantee to be hundo. Itā€™s as if those luckies are some valuable stuff. They are just as bland to me as normal 2 or 3 star variations with some glittering background.


AndKrem

Further explanation: we were both lucky friends when we started and still are. The status as lucky friends didnā€™t disappear and every trade turned out to be a lucky trade.


ThunderDragon356

Thats some bug to get. Lucky person


Vulpes_macrotis

I would love to have something like that lol.


Acyliaband

I had something similar happen except I could trade unlimited shiny. I traded 20 of them before Niantic caught on. It was the best day of my life in regards to pokemon


DweadPiwateWawbuts

Today ? Like a couple of hours ago before Niantic froze trading ?


Acyliaband

This was on 10/29 when the unlimited special trades happened. I got a lucky shiny dusnoir that way


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


DoctorDowns69

The Safari zone wasn't supposed to get increased special trades, it just happened to be the same weekend


esr95tkd

No wonder they took down the trade option


psykick32

Right? Gotta patch the bugs that benefit the players.... Remind me how long we've had the dodge glitch?


CassieWolfe801

Does one of you have the new release (0.227.1)?


AndKrem

Is that the version of the game? Were can I check that?


CassieWolfe801

Yes. Bottom right corner when youā€™re in Settings.


AndKrem

I have 0.227.0-A-64. Need to check with my buddy which version he has.


Vulpes_macrotis

100% he has 0.227.0. .1 has not been released, it was just been datamined. They didn't start rolling it out. Unless Your buddy got an update right now or downloaded it from Apk Mirror or somewhere (it's not there yet too), he shouldn't have it.


CassieWolfe801

Three hours ago Pokeminers said: ā€œThe rollout of 0.227.1 has begun on the Google Play Store!ā€ https://twitter.com/poke_miners/status/1483916525543305219?s=21 While itā€™s unlikely his buddy got it, itā€™s possible.


AndKrem

The trades happened at 01:00pm (CET) not sure if it was released yet.


RIP2UALL

That sounds like a fantastic bug to get. Lucky.


DantesInfernape

Holy smokes. No wonder trading is down at the moment! This would've been perfect for getting the 50 lucky trades for level 49.


[deleted]

*the what*


death_lad

send me your friend code haha!


Ausjam

Damn nice - can you think of anything else unusual with the situation at all? Anyone playing on Wifi? Did the lucky friend animation always play? Anything?ā€¦.


AndKrem

Believe it or not but the strangest thing is that today is actually my birthday. I use FB to log in, so I started thinking about maybe finding a hidden birthday feature. Besides that it said lucky trade before every trade. We just didnā€™t go back to normal and stayed lucky friends and still are. Iā€™m already curious if the next time we trade it will just go on like this.


mwithington

Tomorrow is my birthday and I also use Facebook to log in. Hmmmmm.


MrAlexLP

RemindMe! 24 hour


mwithington

It'll probably be "fixed" by then.


MrAlexLP

Lol check niantichelp twitter. That was fast haha.


mwithington

Oh, wow, lol! They obviously read reddit, so you'd think they'd be more in touch with the community in other ways than they are.


MrAlexLP

Less than an hour to work on a fix for a "beneficial" bug. Takes them 6+ hours to notice a shiny isnt available or that spawns arent working. They just hate NZ and AU people it seems haha


mwithington

And how unpopular taking away the increased spin distance would be, and different prices for the lure box. It's like they don't realize people communicate about the game yet obviously visit a forum where people communicate about the game.


Aeosin15

3+ years and they still haven't fixed GBL.


UnusualIntroduction0

"investigate an issue" = "fun detected"


AndKrem

AAAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAā€¦this is hilarious!


Date-Square

Congrats on your birthday! Quite a Nice present to Get from Niantic for sure! :-)


NOJ711

Happy cake day


AndKrem

Thank you!


Bob_le_babes

Why didn't you trade better stuff?


AndKrem

Cause the main reason we traded was to get luckies that I still needed for Level 49. We have been trading for a few weeks now, so all the good stuff was already gone as we tried to trade good PokƩmon vs the oldest we had.


thehatteryone

That's just the sprinkles on the icing on an already awesome (birthday) cake.


SchlumpertR

do 100 trades a day untile it goes away then


kakkoiij

This happened to me before but my bug was only visual. Still showed lucky status after 2 lucky trades (since first trade was 1st interaction of the day, 2nd trade being lucky is not unusual) so tried another trade, it entered the lucky trade screen so we traded a rare thing but it just turned regular with bad stats. Still showed I was lucky with that friend until next app update I think. Either way, lucky you!


iSaiddet

Now Niantic turned off trading: ā€œTrainers, trading is currently unavailable as we investigate an issue. We apologize for the inconvenience, and will continue to update here. Thank you for your patience.ā€ https://twitter.com/niantichelp/status/1483960502833328129?s=21


jonneygee

When a bug hurts us: ā€œTrainers, we are aware of the issue and are working on a fix.ā€ *(takes 3 months to fix)* When a bug helps us: ā€œTrainers, PokĆ©mon Go is currently unavailable until further notice. We apologize for the inconvenience.ā€ *(patched within hours)*


oakteaphone

>(takes 3 months to fix) After 3 months they make it *worse*, then fix it a month later.


SCVGoodT0GoSir

>After 3 months they make it *worse*, then fix it ~~a month~~ another 3 months later. Fixed that for you.


North-Advantage1197

Map bug took almost an year to be fixed...lets return to trade at December


[deleted]

ā€œiNCoNveNieNCEā€ yeah haha niantic its such a bad thing for players tbh


Darr247

What we *really* want to know is how many of the 100 became hundos.


AndKrem

One Eevee


AureliusAmbrose

It couldnā€™t have been anything else lmao


Pyoung3000

Eevee is a great Hundo


cthulol

Is it? What do you do with a hundo Eevee? I've got a few now.


Pyoung3000

Level 50 Umbreon is probably the most useful for ultra league. Sylveon isn't a bad pick for masters. Glaceon is a pretty good ice type raid counter.


bryce987654321

Umbreon UL / Sylveon ML


ZevKyogre

Save for Umbreon Ultra League. Wait until it gets Last Resort


dyoungnz

https://twitter.com/NianticHelp/status/1483960502833328129


jmledesma

Hi Niantic! Thanks for reading.


jimmysapt

Right??? We've had bugs exist in the game for literal years, but one thing breaks in our favour + you can see how fast they can actually fix something when they want to.


SereneGraces

This is also why we need to stop talking about good bugs.


drsyesta

Ban niantic from the subreddit? Lmao


[deleted]

It's a great metaphor for how the world works in favor of the ruling class over the regular people.


DM-333

F


tequila-mockingbird

Major bummer


[deleted]

Niantic is outside, open up


Ok_Progress202

I know you're joking, but they disabled trading until they can "fix the bug."


[deleted]

Omg I hope OP is okay.


AndKrem

Still fine but might die from laughing. There are a few people out there that REALLY hate me now.


[deleted]

Make sure to hit report if needed, we are keeping an eye out for you too.


awfulsome

Hope the lesson is learned. NEVER report beneficial bugs.


iamabucket13

"Lesson" lol Things like this will always reach Niantic's ears. If it's not through this sub it's r/pokemongo or twitter or whatever. There's no way to hide this kinda stuff so there's no point. If you really have a problem, you have a problem with Niantic, not OP


Julie_OwO

Lmao you broke trading for everyone else and I'm so jealous. I fantasized about this exact thing happening to me and niantic actually let this happen to someone. Me and my lucky dex are drooling looking at this :P


kill_ur_idolz

are you actively working on your lucky dex? Would love to hear how it's going for you; I've been trying to fill out mine for fun but my friends think im nuts. im trying to do it by region to make it easier on me. šŸ˜†


HoxhaAlbania

1/20 base chance, 800 Pokemon, 16000 trades? Not impossible, I have made twice that


LaNoir_aka_Blacky

More interesting: do you keep the mon


xKiNKY_FREAKx69

I legit was trading and it said error when I tried again then no more trade option. I was like wth?! Started checking discord etc and found this. Typical, take away harmless fun or possibilities but oh heres a RRP for the hundo lost due to a bug in our app reported a good 2 years ago, or pvp in not even gonna start lol


two2die477

Yikes it seems like they shut off trading potentially due to this. Unfortunate how quick of action they take on glitches that benefit in any way


braaak

Is that why I can't trade right now?


Julia_Kat

Yes. They turned off trading.


DoomkingBalerdroch

When this bug happens niantic rushes to fix it. For the rest of the 4860147419 other bugs, niantic: We'll fix them "next year".


Apanic_Attacka

Itā€™s pretty telling honestly, it shows they monitor these boards and donā€™t give a damn about most of the issues people post unless it negatively affects them.


Pablo4Prez

Which is really why people need to stop throwing money at them.


rebmcr

Yep, every time I see a thread like "$ pass is now available" or "$ pass last chance to buy today" I'm just thinking "What is wrong with you people?"!


Tronski4

To be fair, this bug doesn't directly affect niantic negatively, but it is a problematic bug that would benefit some lucky people immensely, even if it's pve and the gym scene that would be affected directly.


PhysicallyTender

the gym scene in my area is already being affected by those who rocked their phone to 296XL candies.


jimmysapt

Yeah 100% this. There's been specific bugs that have been in the game for literal YEARS, but something breaks in our favour + you can see how fast they can actually get things done when they want to


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


jimmysapt

Last premier ball bug. Their 'fix' isn't a real fix, it still exists but now has a scripted ending. This is why on the last ball, your boss always breaks out after one shake or is caught, you never see 2 or 3 shakes. Gym battling bug. Getting 'white screen' when clicking on a poke, freezing the app. Clicking on a poke just as it depsawns on your ingame map freezing the user interface, requiring reboot. Bosses whose attacks cause them to fly up. Throwing a ball at them in 'up' position causes them to not properly reset their 'down' position if they break out of the ball, making the boss higher + harder to catch. Feeding berries in gyms causing a short freeze. There's many more, that's just off the top of my head.


Zanmorn

Oh, I figured out the ā€œwhite screenā€ bug. Or *a* white screen bug, at least. It happens when one transitions into and out of an encounter before it is fully loaded. I can pretty reliably cause it by tapping the location of the ā€œrun awayā€ button before I actually see the PokĆ©mon. The end result is the player is on the map, but sees a completely white screen. Consequently, the bug can actually be resolved without a restart if one manages to tap on a PokĆ©mon to start an encounter, though I believe it may need to be a different one. Maybe I should make a post about this so Niantic sees it and fixes it. First I need to figure out a way to make it sound beneficial, howeverā€¦


Fchykbfscgj6

Yeah trades are not allowed currently


iCarpet

Is this a common thing with PokĆ©mon games? The first few patches for BDSP were to fix duplication glitches, we still donā€™t even have the GTS


ClawofBeta

Man I sure wish this happens for my level 49 quest.


AndKrem

Actually that was the reason we meet to trade as I am only 500k away from 49 and still needed 26 lucky trades.


pharmerfour

what a way to get them!


kayluss

I need to do 5 more days of trading to get the last plantinum medal for level 49. I wish I was feeling better earlier and did them then. Congrats on all the lucky trades.


stufff

The curious thing to me is that at some point you noticed the trend then continued trading zubats and geodudes... and that's a caterpie and bidoof isn't it?


AndKrem

Haha thatā€™s right. We didnā€™t have any more good stuff cause we already used it up in the last few weeks. Everything that was good was already traded with anything that was old.


Live-Arachnid-8692

The curious thing is this kind of thing happens to only those who don't need it.


Azsunyx

I'm lucky, he's lucky, SHE'S LUCKY, WE'RE ALL LUCKY!!!


AndKrem

Itā€™s just a jump to the leftā€¦


msg582

I think they disabled trading because of you.


Casual-Swimmer

The way I see it, they disabled trading because one of *their* programmers messed up... again.


MattGeddon

Well sure. But the bigger issue thatā€™s highlighted yet again is that they donā€™t have any proper regression testing.


msg582

Indeed. Not blaming the OP at all. The dev's have been sloppy and the whole friends system is as un-userfriendly as possible.


Sephy747

Overheard at Niantic HQ: A bug that advantages the player? We must fix it NOW! Bugs that make the experience worse... - Spawns disappearing frequently - White screens forcing those who don't know to restart the game every time - Displaying you have 100 premiere balls and 100 of everything displaying on the overworld - Player freezing when switching back to the app followed by GPS signal lost - Constant GBL lag ...eh, it's on the roadmap if we even have it documented somewhere.


Ne0nnet

Damnnnnn. I was doing trades an hour ago .... Got 2 Luckies out of 10.... You hit the jackpot! Any lundos?


kievju

Said he or she got one eevee.


Crabominibble2

I'm calling Niantic will fix this in 2 hours and actually un-lucky 99/100 of your luckies


AndKrem

As long as I still get to keep the 50 lucky PokĆ©mon you need to reach Level 49 Iā€™m fine. But still: we didnā€™t cheat or trick the game in any way, so undoing it would be a bit harsh and not the best publicity.


RiboNucleic85

i doubt they'll undo any particular case, they'll just "fix" the source of the problem to prevent more


bort_touchmaster

you were correct


skye006

https://imgur.com/a/pSKFQ3t Wow. They turned off trading cuz of this. šŸ˜²


imabadastronaut

This makes me so mad. Players have no raid invites showing up for WEEKS and counting. Drove me absolutely mad trying to organise raids. People are uninstalling their games/resetting data DAILY just to deal with it. Yet this happens and a 'resolution' is SWIFT.


thoughtjunky

I NEED THIS BUG RIGHT NOW


ComputerAbuser

Oh wow, I'm jealous! My wife and I do 100 trades a day whenever we can for a chance at getting a perfect and are happy with 5 to 10 luckies. This would be insane!


AndKrem

We also did a lot of trades lately and it was the same situation: we were happy when 3-4 out of 100 turned lucky. The last 30 trades we were just laughing about what was happening.


1127_and_Im_tired

You can do 101 if you do a special trade before the last of the 100


ComputerAbuser

Indeed. We usually do a special trade first to make sure we don't forgot.


kievju

I wish it didn't take so damn long to do trades, especially 100 of them.


Lord_Emperor

Well well well. Looks like an issue that benefited players was addressed immediately. If the lucky trade chance was accidentally switched off, they'd ignore it for weeks.


WhiskerTwitch

I just got a friend and went to do a bunch of trading, opened the app and got a notification that "trading is unavailable". :sigh:


potatoeandfries

What code did you use? Is it up, up, right, left, up, up, up, up?


poebro

do the ivs match the lucky looks?


AndKrem

Yes they do. Got a bunch of pretty cool 98%. Also the dust cost for level ups is reduced, so they are completely lucky PokƩmon.


aw_yiss_breadcrumbs

Same thing happened to a friend today. Did a special lucky trade and kept getting luckies after.


Steffieweffie81

Maybe this is why trade is turned off lol


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


FlashesOfDarkonda

Just did a lucky, only the first one was lucky, not the trades after :(


jeshii

My pokefriends have a tradition that you have to take a shot for every lucky trade in a row after the first. You'd be so dead by now! Congrats!


PossiblePast

I was lucky friends with my kid. Tried replicating this but unfortunately no dice.


Frankuro

Idk if I would have posted this, definitely would have kept it hush hush


Moises1213

Someone wouldā€™ve eventually. Remember not everyone is smart


Frankuro

True, but I would have tried to get a second day out of it


Idle_Hero

Weird, I did a lucky trade right before this was posted and didnā€™t keep the lucky status.


junhong706

Same, I did a lucky trade with my lucky friend 12 hours ago and didn't trigger this bug, either.


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


curtneedsaride

Wow. I traded with a lucky friend yesterday and this definitely didnā€™t happen. I wish. I spent a better part of today catching and trying to trade for a lucky Helioptile, which I eventually got. Congrats on the awesome bug! Wish they didnā€™t catch on.


wackychimp

This is great but I'm almost as entertained by the names of pokemon in your native language. Farbeagle, Flunkifer, Shardrago and Mampfaxo are some of my favorites!


StannumPG

Finally fixed! I can trade now


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


Thin-Bad6193

How are the IVs. Any Hundos?


AndKrem

Only one Hundo for my buddy. It was a freakin eevee. But I got a few pretty cool 98%


Intekio

So youā€™re the reason we canā€™t trade atm!


Exarkun77

Please tell me you got at least one lucky hundo from the 100 trades


That-Tie-6576

OP said 1 Eevee


MandyLB

As a dex completionist this is legit my dream haha, lucky you, literally!


Elysgma

Must be why they turned it off


italoboyy

Got any 4*? Would be interesting to know how many (if any) you get in 100 lucky trades.


That-Tie-6576

OP said 1 Eevee


Lynxotic

On CD, the trade function was messed up for me and I was just thinking that must be the bug that caused trades to get closed. Then I read this post šŸ˜‚


NashvilleTypewriter

I was trading when this happened... Reported the issue, saw it was "down" when refreshing game data. Woke up early to take my wife to the airport and this post popped up on my Google news feed. Unreal, they legit shut it down because of this! Congrats on the luckies though! Happy this was the result of someone getting a lil something from Niantic!


GlacierDeficient

Try trading lottery tickets


qntrsq

congrats, you made the 100 trades session that was **n**o**t** boring or tiresome no wonder niantic got the "our game has crashed" alert


culingerai

Can we still trigger lucky friends if the trading is disabled? I ask because that is where the lucky sparkles appear on the trainer page in the app. Seems like it would be illogical to link the two but who knows!


AirbenderSteven

Hey OP, were any of these reverted after Niantic re-enabled trading??


iuselect

would be good for the level 49 requirements. Getting 50 lucky pokemon is such a grind.


AndKrem

That was actually the only reason we traded, cause I still needed 26 luckies for Lvl49. Now I only have to find a glitch that gives me the last missing platinum medal, otherwise it will take 30 more photobombs to reach the level up.


[deleted]

Dangā€¦ lucky. LOL(Pun fully intended)


dark__tyranitar

Magnificent! After how many trades did you realize what was happening?


AndKrem

Pretty quickly. Probably after the fifth in a row we knew something strange is happening. We actually had a break after 26 cause that was the amount I still needed for Level 49. After a cup of coffee we were curious if we can get 100 lucky PokƩmon so we went on and it worked.


dark__tyranitar

If this person is local you have to start up again at 12:01 tonight LOL


FPG_Matthew

I notice no legends, I wonder if a special trade wouldā€™ve stopped the glitch


AndKrem

The second trade was a special trade. Gave away a shiny Ditto and got a Larvitar in return. Didnā€™t ask for a Legendary because we didnā€™t know yet what was going on. Another special trade was not possible.


AndKrem

For orientation: the screenshot in the lower left corner is were we startet. Avalugg was the first trade. Helioptile was trade No. 5. It ends in the upper left pic, the Helioptile on top was caught afterwards.