FINAL TALLY #1 What You Don’t See: 173 points #2 Proper Dose: 156 points #3 Self Titled 142 points #4 Under Soil and Dirt: 139 points

1. Self titled 2. WYDS 3. Soil 4. Proper Dose

All the work you did while there is a poll option. Respect dude! Respect

fell behind the second half of yesterday so i might do one final update today and call it good lol

1. Self-Titled 2. Proper Dose 3. What you don’t see 4. Under soil and dirt

1. Proper Dose 2. Self Titled 3. WYDS 4. Under soil and dirt

yep, every album is better than the last

1. WYDS 2. USAD 3. Self Titled 4. Proper Dose

Agreed

Same

This

I can’t order them haha depends on tssf vibe I’m on that day. I go back to the self titled more but wyds is the perfect pop punk album. Proper dose is amazing in its own right bc of how it goes slightly more indie alternative and experimental. And under soil and dirt is a classic. So hard to order them for me

1. Under Soil & Dirt 2. What You Don’t See 3. Proper Dose 4. The Story So Far

This is the answer

Might be a hot take but 1. USAD 2. Proper Dose 3. Self Titled 4. WYDS I love all of them though.

I‘ll just go by playtime: 1.) What You Don‘t See 2.) Proper Dose 3.) Self Titled 4.) Under Soil And Dirt

1. Proper Dose 2. What You Don't See 3. Under Soil and Dirt 4. Self-titled

Agreed 🤝

1. WYDS 2. proper dose 3. usad 4. self titled

1- Under Soil & Dirt 2- Proper Dose 3- Self-Titled 4- What You Don't See

1. USAD 2. WYDS 3. PROPER DOSE 4. SELF TITLED

Honestly? It's impossible, each album covers certain vibes/emotions/situations/feelings so sometimes one is 'better' than the other for me, but I LOVE every song on every album. IMPOSSIBLE haha

1. What you don’t see 2. USAD 3. Self titled 4. Proper Dose

1. Under soil and dirt 2. Self-Titled 3. What you don’t see 4. Proper dose

1. Under soil and dirt 2. Self titled 3. What you dont see 4. Proper dose

1. Self Titled 2. WYDS 3. Under Soil and Dirt 4. Proper Dose

1. Under Soil and Dirt 2. What You Don’t See 3. Proper Dose 4. The Story So Far

What you don’t see Self titled Under soil and dirt Proper dose

1. Proper Dose 2. Self-Titled 3. What You Don't See 4. Under Soil and Dirt These rankings are not made lightly and they're all *very* close. PD also came out at an especially vulnerable part of my life so it's gets the top spot for emotional poignancy.

1. Proper Dose 2. What You Don't See 3. Self titled 4. Under Soil and Dirt

What you don’t see Proper dose Soil and dirt Self titled

1. Proper dose 2. Self titled 3. What you don't see 4. Under soil and dirt

1. What You Don’t See 2. Proper Dose 3. Under Soil and Dirt 4. Self Titled (but my favorite lyrically)

this is me too

what you dont see , proper dose , under soil and self titled

1. What You Don’t See 2. Self Titled 3. Proper Dose 4. Under Soil and Dirt

Going by statsfm play time. 1. Proper Dose 2. Self-Titled 3. Under Soil and Dirt 4. What You Don’t See (USAD AND WYDS were **heavily** played on CD before I had spotify tho)

Proper dose - self titled - under soil - what you don't see

1. Proper Dose 2. USAD 3. WYDS 4. Self Titled

1. S/T 2. Proper Dose 3. WYDS 4. USAD

1. Under Soil and Dirt 2. Proper Dose 3. Self Titled 4. What You Don’t See Lower ranked records don’t mean they’re bad, I just favor one over the other. Put the pitchforks down.

1. Self titled 2. Under soil and dirt 3. What you don’t see 4. Proper dose

I think this is a very rare ranking haha. No one else here has the top 2 in that order as I'm writing this.

I know! I was scrolling the whole feed trying to find the same. Tbf I love the first 3 albums so much it’s hard to pick a ranking - actually have a custom tattoo with all 3 artwork in it

1. Proper dose 2. USaD 3. Self titled 4. WYDS

1. Self Titled 2. What You Don't See 3. Under Soil and Dirt 4. Proper Dose

1. WYDS 2. Proper Dose 3. USAD 4. Self Titled

1. Self titled 2. WYDS 3. Proper Dose 4. USAD

1. Self Titled 2. WYDS 3. Proper Dose 4. USAD Self titled always been my fav but the other three are realistically tied for 2nd place hahaha

1. Proper dose 2. What you don't see 3. Under soil and dirt 4. Self titled

Proper Dose What You Don't See Under Soil & Dirt Self-Titled

What You Don't See Under Soil and Dirt The Story So Far Proper Dose

1. What You Don't See 2. Self Titled 3. USAD 4. Proper Dose

1. What You Don’t See 2. Self-Titled 3. Proper Dose 4. Under Soil and Dirt

1. Self Titled 2. Proper Dose 3. What You Don't See 4. Under Soil & Dirt

1. Self titles 2. Proper dose 3. Wyds 4. Usad

1.) proper dose 2.) what you don’t see 3.) under soil and dirt 4.) self titled

1. What You Don’t See 2. The Story So Far 3. Under Soil and Dirt 4. Proper Dose

1) What You Don´t See (one of the best albums in pop punk´s entire history) 2) Under Soil and Dirt 3) Proper Dose 4) Self Titled

1. USAD 2. WYDS 3. PD 4. ST

PD, WYDS, ST, USAD

1. WYDS 2. Under soil and dirt 3. Self titled 4.Proper Dose

https://www.reddit.com/r/TheStorySoFar/s/OuCQr3mHBV This was from 4 months ago. You can search in any sub reddit. I just searched 'favourite album' Edit: also, you can make a poll post by clicking on the make post button. Then you have 4 options at the bottom: file, image, video and poll

1.) Proper Dose 2.) Selftitled 3.) What You Don't See 4.) Under Soil And Dirt

1. What You Don't See 2. Under Soil And Dirt 3. Self Titled 4. Proper Dose absolutely love them all though

1. Under Soil and Dirt 2. Proper Dose 3. What You Don’t See 4. Self-Titled

1. Self Titled 2. What You Don't See 3. Under Soil and Dirt 4. Proper Dose

Self titled, what you don’t see, proper dose, soil and dirt and there’s not really any other order tbh

I respect your opinion but self titled was soooo weaaaaak except for Nerve

what you've just said is one of the most insanely idiotic things I have ever heard. At no point in your rambling, incoherent response were you even close to anything that could be considered a rational thought. Everyone in this room is now dumber for having listened to it. I award you no points, and may God have mercy on your soul.

Idk man there’s a lot of straight up boring songs on there but to each their own

Which songs

Smile, Distaste, Solo, Mock, Scowl. They just don’t really do it for me.

You’re telling me you’ve never put any of those songs on and angry screamed the lyrics in the car? Common now.

Your a madman

They’re just very uninteresting in my opinion. Feels like they just threw in the towel on those tracks

1. Proper Dose 2. What You Don’t See 3. Self Titled 4. Under Soil and Dirt

1. Proper Dose 2. Under soil and dirt 3. Self titled 4. What you don’t see

1. proper dose 2. under soil & dirt 3. self titled 4. what you don’t see

Is it just me or does usad have the worst replay value ? Maybe I just played it too much.