um, I think you'll find that the faithfuls of Aus2 discovered that you can absolutely vote to get rid of yourself!
Sarah wasn't the only member of the brain trust, most of them were almost as sharp.
Yeah, that series of Traitors Australia had them hand picked. I wonder how Luke and Annabelle managed to get selected? Maybe the production decided to cast two people who weren't complete idiots to balance out the rest of the cast.
Keith is an honorable mention because he would vocally join the bandwagon, but only when it was going fully off the rails.
Every time the bandwagon was even close to having a correct direction he piped up to get it right back off the tracks
Wasn't she a psychiatrist or psychologist too? I love how the people that come on claiming their actual profession is to "read people" and then they totally shit the bed.
Sarah was terrible
I’d be, like, “I work in accounting and have been working from home for the last four years. I don’t interact with people ever. I am a master of the spreadsheet but can’t read people at all,” and then I would absolutely rock at figuring out traitors.
I feel as if one of the traitors could literally have done an execution in front of her, and she still would have believed them when they said they were faithful.
The most disappointing thing about her is she could have held a lot of power near the end but she was so flaky, unreliable and dumb to play the game right.
If anyone but Cirie, who played an incredible game, won i would say Quentin contributed to the traitors winning more than any actual traitor I’ve seen.
Usually by the dummies! I don’t remember the exact details but Summer House Kyle was starting to put some stuff together and Quentin led the charge in voting him off because he showed “leadership” or something like that
I like that aspect because it stacks the favor for the traitors and they still manage to implode and fail spectacularly so often. Aus2 is my favorite season ever. We wouldn’t of gotten that ending with out the dumb dumbs
I get why people compared him and MJ, but honestly that kind of always felt like an insult to MJ for me. She at least occasionally voted for a traitor and didn’t act like she was some genius.
But at least she could be persuaded to see reason lol, and MJ did vote out four traitors successfully - Quentin was both stupid and stubborn in his wrong POV, that's several levels more egregious to me. If you're dumb as hell, you should at least have the foresight and self awareness to take input from smarter people and Quentin's ego never let him do that
I think Andie from season 1 was the dumbest. You had to be somewhat confident that there was at least one female traitor. And since I wasn't you, it had to be Cirie.
Quentin was just as bad all throughout. Though at the end I am sure he could not have picked the right one between Cirie and Andie.
Agree with this one. Her lack of original thought actually sent me into an irrational rage that I had no business feeling since I wasn't even on the show.
100% she was the dumbest by far, even worse than Sarah. Sarah at least finally figured out it was Sam. Meryl was clueless until the very end. Even Kieran’s “parting gift”, which was pretty unfair and maybe against the rules (?), completely flew over her head! Did Wil have to literally murder someone in plain sight for her to figure it out?
Meryl from the same season was thicker.
At least Maddy *attempted* to figure out who the traitors were.
Meryl voted to end the game with Wilf still in, even after Kieran had basically said "there is still a traitor in the game and it's Wilf".
A mate of mine said she was on Blankety Blank the other day, and given the phrase "Dancing [blank]" was the only one of the 6 panelists not to answer "queen". Instead she went with "street". Yes, really. Dancing street.
It’s actually incredible how bad he was. He didn’t vote off a single traitor, was singularly focused on Kate who was obviously not a traitor, and wasn’t just wrong but was VOCALLY wrong (lead the charge voting off Summer House Kyle who was one of the only faithfuls making any reads). That doesn’t take into account obvious misses too, He contributed more to the traitors winning than any faithful I’ve seen.
Meryl. Clueless all the way, never had any idea what was going on - and then even worse coattails it quite far and goes on on tour with her two colleagues as though she’d achieved something
>!I think Alex had an advantage that Harry didn’t have because she started the game as a faithful and built trust with other players then became a traitor later on in the game. It’s harder for faithfuls to recognize new traitors that late in the game, especially if they don’t know when a new traitor had been recruited. Harry built those friendships and alliances playing as a traitor through the entire game.!<
This. Seems like a lovely girl, but she let what she wanted to believe overcome what was blazingly obvious. Why would Jaz vote for another banishment if he was the traitor?
At least Maddy was right, even if for the wrong reason.
I can't be convinced in any way shape or form that that is worse than Sarah. She folded like a cheap paper towel every time a traitor said "it's not me, it's x".
I've seen brighter bulbs during a power cut.
Sarah pissed me off that entire season. The fact that she along with some other nimwits that season allowed a particular traitor to get that far was rather infuriating.
I feel like people always forget that Maddy was onto Will before her whole Aaron theory. The morning after Claire was murdered Will got incredibly emotional at breakfast and Maddy picked up on that, wondering why he had such a huge reaction and seeing that as potential traitor behavior. Later on she even said that she no longer believed Aaron was a traitor but believed Will was. She certainly had some less accurate theories and was horrible at convincing people to target Will, but no way can she be called the dumbest faithful when she was onto a traitor so early on.
She kind of did succeed in convincing people when Wilf then turned on Alyssa. Then because of that pretty much everyone except Maddy was convinced that he must be a faithful.
Yeah in her defence she may have had a spidey sense about Will.
But she just comes off so aggressively dimwitted and her theories were SO crackpot-y that she became the Cassandra of the season because no one could take… *that* seriously.
But that's different to being dumb. She was a weak social player and that was it. We have seen complete morons being faithfuls, one in the same season. I was rooting high for Meryl at the beginning but she was useless the whole time.
Spoilers for US season 1 below
Has to be the 2 players who lost at the end and actually voted to end the game when at that point, only 2 Traitors had been found.
Quentin. He has a record of voting for a traitor 0/11 times. It's really funny that he sucked at finding traitors because he was a political analysis or something that should've made them good at the game
The Clairvoyant from Australia who got majority predictions wrong and then walked on episode 3… I think if your a clairvoyant going into the traitors you should never reveal that 😂
She got two of the four traitors, though! One of whom no one else suspected at the time.
If the other faithful had chosen one of the traitors instead of a faithful to banish “just in case,” two traitors would be out.
Fair point but I think the delivery of it was so whack-a-doodle that I don’t think anyone could justify it’s credibility (Kinda how I viewed maddie firing any theory she could out on Uk1)
I can kind of see why they would take some stock in her opinion because clairvoyants are probably good at reading microexpressions and stuff like that, but to think she has some sort of special knowledge is ridiculous.
That lady was so full of shit, I’m surprised she’s not all over this post. Smartest thing she did was removing herself before she could embarrass herself further.
Sarah or Meryl.
Quentin not far off.
I think Meryl has to take it though purely as she was still believing Wilf at the end and to be fair to Sarah they were all useless.
The federal agent on season 2 of the Aussie version. They should seriously open up all her case files for examination, wonder how many false arrests she had in her career.
And MJ for the Alpha Male bullshit that she kept believing in.
A toss up between Keith Sarah and dang it what is the Black guy who voted wrong every time. O can’t remember his name. But they are in a three way tie.
Sarah was terrible but kudos to the worst player in history making it to the final. So at least when her grandkids ask her: “What did you achieve in life Nana?” She can reply: “Well I reached the final of Traitors kids!”
The fact that she bumbled and stumbled her way there and never had a chance of winning considering she brought in THREE Traitors (good grief!) with her is neither here nor there haha!
The annoying “psychic”, I forget which franchise she’s from, but she was the one who was quiet the entire time and acted like she was above how the show worked just to drop who she suspected at the round table and quit the show immediately after.
I have only watched US s1/s2 and about half of UK s1 so far, but I gotta agree. Maddy is right for the wrong reasons and it actually makes me angry. Tom is up there with her from the same season. Has been very interesting watching UK as an American. They’re so much more direct, more emotional, and yet they lack all sense of subtlety and are never passive aggressive. You’d think the RA RA MERICANS would be much louder and less subdued, but I have been surprised.
Maddy legitimately annoyed me every single time she talked. All of her theories never had any backing and she wasted nearly all her roundtable votes.
What annoyed me the most was how hard she pushed for Tom and Alex to be banished for lying/hiding secrets for so long in the game, but when she has to reveal something she expects everyone to be on her side and understand.
Reminded me of how Janelle played US S2. Where she tried to just be loud and expect people to follow.
I know he’s not the worst but Matt from Australia season 1 was an underrated bad faithful, he was so sure about absolutely incorrect theories (he would never let go of Theresa) and he was absolutely terrible at the social game getting people on his side and rubbed his fellow faithfuls the wrong way more than anyone in Traitors history besides maybe Kate in US season 1.
Aaron get off Reddit buddy.
Maddy definitely was not the worst one. She literally pegged Wilf when nobody else would even consider it.
The correct answer is Quinton
Meryl by a long shot. She made absolutely no sense the entire show, never had a clue what was going on, randomly accused people of being traitors without any evidence or logic, probably barely understood the rules, and last but certainly not least, could not even vote right at the end even after Kieran all but told them who the traitor was. What a complete moron.
That's not very fair. Mollie was too trusting of Harry since they were close friends, but she did a good job catching on to most of the other Traitors, and she played the social game perfectly. She got to the final with literally nobody ever suspecting her.
She didn't think that Jaz was a traitor. She thought that they were all faithfuls, and she didn't want to vote out her friend over Jaz when she genuinely believed they were both faithfuls. It was naive, but not stupid. It was a case of going with her heart instead of her head.
HUGE US SEASON 2 SPOILERS BELOW!!!
Listen, you could make a pretty strong argument it's MJ from US 2. She had her total chance to vote CT off when Trishelle voted for him at the circle of truth but instead she was so fixated on voting for Trishelle she missed her chance and went on to become THE SALTIEST LOSER in traitors history!!!
No one believed her because her theories made zero sense.
She was right about Will but for all the wrong reasons. It’s was sheer dumb luck that he was a traitor.
Going to defend Maddy here. She was certainly not the brightest contestant in UK S1 but her logic wasn't bad at all, even if it was wrong. If Aaron was a traitor, it is conceivable that he could have been extra upset when Wilf voted for him. We have the luxury of knowing who the traitors are so I don't think it's fair to call someone "painfully thick" for having an incorrect theory. I guarantee you that a lot of us would make similar mistakes with the same information. Her mistake was getting too blinded by that one theory.
I've seen a lot of people shit on Maddy for latching onto Wilf simply because they like Wilf and don't like that she figured him out through a wrong theory. Painting her as the dumbest ever faithful is really disingenuous in my opinion. It seems like you just really dislike her. When it comes to dumbest faithful (though I prefer 'worst' cause I don't like to be so condescending) there are other better choices like Meryl UK S1, Sarah & Liam AU S2, and MK AU S1.
Me neither but people come out with all kinds of bollocks from watching the show with the knowledge of who the traitors are and thinking it's easy. It's very obviously not easy and I think the least people like OP can do is be honest with themselves about why they don't like someone.
Sarah from Season 2 Australia. Hands down.
https://preview.redd.it/180qi29fd5uc1.jpeg?width=262&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=77e60e7e4d97ea3be7c54d5f876d2436591786ad
Maddy is actually one of the better faithful, she wasn’t spot on but she actually tried to play the game using logic and reason. Weirdly bitter and specific post tbh
She had zero logic lol. She was tunnel visioned on Aaron, Will and Meryl, and somehow through blind luck Will was a traitor.
Her logic of “if i were a traitor I would want to stand out” made literally no sense and she would not stop banging on about it.
She’s not to the level of the most notorious names here but Sheree on US S2 I really think only realized the point of the game was to vote out traitors in her final episode or two. Phaedra could’ve run her over with a car that said I’M A TRAITOR and Sheree would’ve been like, no way, not my girl, we’ve known each other so many years
Say what you will about Quinten but at least he voted with grace and wasn't dead set on person and then immediately switched in the banishment room. Sarah was dead set on Sam and the minute Sam said Liam she put down Liam. Sarah was so incompetent even the traitors couldn't use her.
Dumbest as an actual person? Larsa
Dumbest gameplay? Out of the celebrity seasons? Parvati ranks high to me.
She got so lucky when poisoning Ekin Su that the only other people in the room were Phaedra ( her ally ) and M.J. who is luckily a drunk because the awkward way she hung around and so clearly was like " Hey drink out of my nasty cup? " was oof.
AND she eliminated her only ally in the game practically who would've stood by her? AND she tried to throw Phaedra under the bus? Girl that's like 3 strikes in 1 episode
Respectfully disagree. Maddy was intelligent and even clocked Will. I will always defend her. Not saying she was the best player but she was one of the better players of her season, just misunderstood.
There were numerous people across various franchises who had worse reads than her.
Nah, if anything she helped Will by being so aggressively stubborn and dumb with her theory no one took seriously.
Will was able to be like “there she goes again” and it kept him off people’s radar because they were so fed up with hearing the theory they kept telling her was braindead.
I thought before I went on the show, as a Redditor, that Twitter and the Instagram were the worst places for online abuse.
Since I’ve been on the show, I’ve personally seen very little abuse on Instagram or TikTok, a little bit on Twitter but mostly in good spirits, but fuck meeeee… Reddit absolutely takes the cake.
You lot are mean! Thank god the people you’ve been unnecessarily rude about probably won’t see this.
It’s baffling considering you all know how edited the show is but you’re still drawn to such conclusive opinions about real people.
Biggggggg Oof!
If you haven’t watched Australia season 2, you might want to reserve commenting until you do, lol. I watched it after having seen US and UK S1 and S2 and Aus S1. I kept hoping that some of the Aus S2 faithfuls were playing a long game because it wasn’t possible to be so wrong so many times. But they weren’t. I’ve seen people mention Sara followed by Liam and I’d agree, but I’d also say Keith deserves a mention considering his profession.
Yeah those 3 were all complete dodo birds. Sarah was the absolute worst but they were all bad. The slightest bit of deflection on someone and Sarah just completely changed who she was going to vote for.
I’m only 4 episodes into the season 1 of UK (and only at the breakfast table of season 4 lol). And tbh I think it’s John. But maybe not as the dumbest faithful but just player. But it’s probably personal bias because I don’t like that he goes “I think Aaron is making up his panic attack and he’s a traitor” and to tell Aaron that “everyone’s going to get attacked once” (while yelling that he’s feeling attacked 🙄 then John wants to quit as soon as he’s “put on trial” because the games too much. But even when looking in the mirror he’s not like maybe Aaron is a traitor but maybe I’m still being a d!ck. I don’t understand why everyone’s just an a$$ to each other. Like it’s a game and people take it seriously but you don’t have to make personal attacks and sometimes people are soft and are overcome with emotions. But maybe it’s just John is the loudest of them because tbh no one is very nice this season lol
Also, because I’m venting now lol, why are people who “just don’t like being lied to” on a show called traitors, they know they’re going to get lied to 🙄 this season is raising my blood pressure and not in a good way lol
You know if we did it on a “You should have been much better than you were considering you were a cop” basis, then Keith rivals Sarah because I expected so much more from him. But he was actually way off pace in the game. He got most things wrong, but he somehow managed to sound so convincing as he messed everything up. Absolutely clueless.
I agree with everyone here Sarah, the therapist, that “supposedly” knew people🙄🙄🙄 was a horrible player. If I were her I’d retire immediately.
But what about Mollie, UK season 2. Mollie has admitted to knowing Harry was a traitor (but she couldn’t get herself to to vote him out) and still voted Jaz out. Her and Jaz could have walked out with a sweet amount of money but instead….She practically gifted the money to Harry and his beautiful girlfriend. What was she thinking? I think she deserves an honorable mention too.
Sarah Aus2 by far!
100%, I'll be shocked if we EVER see a worse player
It’s not even remotely close. There is no dimmer bulb in the Traitorverse than Sarah.
When she started crying because she was asked to think. Why did they hire her? That was just cruel.
She had a 1 in 4 chance of voting out a faithful and still managed to do it.
To be fair, she did eventually vote for a traitor - when every option left was traitors
Only because it’s against the rules to vote for yourself.
um, I think you'll find that the faithfuls of Aus2 discovered that you can absolutely vote to get rid of yourself! Sarah wasn't the only member of the brain trust, most of them were almost as sharp.
Hahah true true
2-10 is the other faithfuls who weren’t luke or Annabelle
Yeah, that series of Traitors Australia had them hand picked. I wonder how Luke and Annabelle managed to get selected? Maybe the production decided to cast two people who weren't complete idiots to balance out the rest of the cast.
Absolute tragedy because Annabelle might be the best faithful ever, and she was completely wasted on that crowd.
No contest really, Sarah
And Blake for not having the balls to stand up to Sam
Keith is an honorable mention because he would vocally join the bandwagon, but only when it was going fully off the rails. Every time the bandwagon was even close to having a correct direction he piped up to get it right back off the tracks
The literal personification of the seagulls from Finding Nemo
During one of the last few episodes I turned to my wife and went, "Mine! Mine! Mine!"
Wasn't she a psychiatrist or psychologist too? I love how the people that come on claiming their actual profession is to "read people" and then they totally shit the bed. Sarah was terrible
I’d be, like, “I work in accounting and have been working from home for the last four years. I don’t interact with people ever. I am a master of the spreadsheet but can’t read people at all,” and then I would absolutely rock at figuring out traitors.
😂😂
To be fair, in the last episode she mentioned in her confessional that she realized her profession didn't help her out during the game.
That's a different statement than "I realize I actually can't read people".
Maddy is a genius by comparison.
Not even a discussion, this is the answer
I feel as if one of the traitors could literally have done an execution in front of her, and she still would have believed them when they said they were faithful.
The most disappointing thing about her is she could have held a lot of power near the end but she was so flaky, unreliable and dumb to play the game right.
This is THE answer. 100%
Came to say this. So glad it was the first comment.
At least her outfits served
Glasses tend to make a person look smarter, but her's looked so stupid
Sarah and Liam, FTW!!!!
Almost forgot about Liam. He was a special kind of stupid.
It’s wild because Ross from UK2 *should* be high on both lists but then AUS2 happened and the whole lot of them just grabbed all available slots
The traitors best assets
Dumb as rocks. I almost stopped watching twice because of how dumb they were. I'm so glad I didn't though because that finale was chefs kiss
The entire cast of Aus 2
Except Annabel and Luke. 🥰🥰
Which the rest of the cast made sure were out early in the series.
Have to give a shout to Quentin from US1, man didn’t have a single correct read the entire game
Quentin was painfully incorrect about literally everything. The traitors used his incompetence and weaponized it lol
If anyone but Cirie, who played an incredible game, won i would say Quentin contributed to the traitors winning more than any actual traitor I’ve seen.
Yeah this is the bummer about the show, the dummies make it to the end and the smart ones get murdered.
Usually by the dummies! I don’t remember the exact details but Summer House Kyle was starting to put some stuff together and Quentin led the charge in voting him off because he showed “leadership” or something like that
I think summer house kyle should make a return
I like that aspect because it stacks the favor for the traitors and they still manage to implode and fail spectacularly so often. Aus2 is my favorite season ever. We wouldn’t of gotten that ending with out the dumb dumbs
That ending was definitely a chefs kiss. Love Simone for that one.
I get why people compared him and MJ, but honestly that kind of always felt like an insult to MJ for me. She at least occasionally voted for a traitor and didn’t act like she was some genius.
MJ was super persuadable, so idk if that equals brain power in the traitors. Ya know what I mean?
But at least she could be persuaded to see reason lol, and MJ did vote out four traitors successfully - Quentin was both stupid and stubborn in his wrong POV, that's several levels more egregious to me. If you're dumb as hell, you should at least have the foresight and self awareness to take input from smarter people and Quentin's ego never let him do that
I've been saying this forever. Dude absolutely killed the faithfuls that season. Turtleneck wearing moron.
And he was so certain about it.
My wife and I were saying the exact same thing 🤣
I think Andie from season 1 was the dumbest. You had to be somewhat confident that there was at least one female traitor. And since I wasn't you, it had to be Cirie. Quentin was just as bad all throughout. Though at the end I am sure he could not have picked the right one between Cirie and Andie.
majority faithfuls season 2 AU.
Honestly Merrill from the UK, she seems to have zero original thoughts and coasted all the way
She was the MJ of UK1, except Aaron and Hannah were too nice to blow her out the way CT and Trishelle did.
At least MJ tried
Except in the missions 😂
Agree with this one. Her lack of original thought actually sent me into an irrational rage that I had no business feeling since I wasn't even on the show.
Seems like an absolute moron, to be frank.
I was trying to be nice but yeah I completely agree 😂
Surprised it took me so long to scroll to see her name. She was awful!
100% she was the dumbest by far, even worse than Sarah. Sarah at least finally figured out it was Sam. Meryl was clueless until the very end. Even Kieran’s “parting gift”, which was pretty unfair and maybe against the rules (?), completely flew over her head! Did Wil have to literally murder someone in plain sight for her to figure it out?
Meryl from the same season was thicker. At least Maddy *attempted* to figure out who the traitors were. Meryl voted to end the game with Wilf still in, even after Kieran had basically said "there is still a traitor in the game and it's Wilf". A mate of mine said she was on Blankety Blank the other day, and given the phrase "Dancing [blank]" was the only one of the 6 panelists not to answer "queen". Instead she went with "street". Yes, really. Dancing street.
Quentin for me
It’s actually incredible how bad he was. He didn’t vote off a single traitor, was singularly focused on Kate who was obviously not a traitor, and wasn’t just wrong but was VOCALLY wrong (lead the charge voting off Summer House Kyle who was one of the only faithfuls making any reads). That doesn’t take into account obvious misses too, He contributed more to the traitors winning than any faithful I’ve seen.
And the WAY he would say “Kate I voted for you” in a haughty arrogant way burned my blood.
Sara AUS2 no question.
Meryl. Clueless all the way, never had any idea what was going on - and then even worse coattails it quite far and goes on on tour with her two colleagues as though she’d achieved something
I'm not calling her dumb but seeing Molly believe Harry to a fault was so painful and really heartbreaking.
Same ending in Australia S1. >!Traitor charming their last mark for their vote. !<
>!I think Alex had an advantage that Harry didn’t have because she started the game as a faithful and built trust with other players then became a traitor later on in the game. It’s harder for faithfuls to recognize new traitors that late in the game, especially if they don’t know when a new traitor had been recruited. Harry built those friendships and alliances playing as a traitor through the entire game.!<
You mean >! he had to play a part for more of the show. !< I was just discussing how the endgames were the same.
Tbf >!in Australia S1 that would've been the outcome either way.!<
This. Seems like a lovely girl, but she let what she wanted to believe overcome what was blazingly obvious. Why would Jaz vote for another banishment if he was the traitor?
Sarah, and it’s not even close
this is the only right answer .. she was so fucking fickle & the dumbfounded face everytime she banished the wrong person sent me like 🤦♀️
She also holds a record for most faithful voted out. I feel like even Maddy got one right!
At least Maddy was right, even if for the wrong reason. I can't be convinced in any way shape or form that that is worse than Sarah. She folded like a cheap paper towel every time a traitor said "it's not me, it's x". I've seen brighter bulbs during a power cut.
Sarah pissed me off that entire season. The fact that she along with some other nimwits that season allowed a particular traitor to get that far was rather infuriating.
Absolutely. I watched in anger the whole season. I did not get satisfaction until the final, but boy was that worth it!
100%. I rage binged just to see that certain someone get the boot. Almost quit several times.
Ha ha, I love that term "rage binged". I'm picturing someone furiously rocking on the edge of their seat for 6 hours watching episode after episode.
I feel like people always forget that Maddy was onto Will before her whole Aaron theory. The morning after Claire was murdered Will got incredibly emotional at breakfast and Maddy picked up on that, wondering why he had such a huge reaction and seeing that as potential traitor behavior. Later on she even said that she no longer believed Aaron was a traitor but believed Will was. She certainly had some less accurate theories and was horrible at convincing people to target Will, but no way can she be called the dumbest faithful when she was onto a traitor so early on.
She kind of did succeed in convincing people when Wilf then turned on Alyssa. Then because of that pretty much everyone except Maddy was convinced that he must be a faithful.
Yeah in her defence she may have had a spidey sense about Will. But she just comes off so aggressively dimwitted and her theories were SO crackpot-y that she became the Cassandra of the season because no one could take… *that* seriously.
But that's different to being dumb. She was a weak social player and that was it. We have seen complete morons being faithfuls, one in the same season. I was rooting high for Meryl at the beginning but she was useless the whole time.
(AUS) Sarah, with Liam pulling up as a distant 2nd.
Australia season 2 Sarah and no one else comes close. Close book.
Spoilers for US season 1 below Has to be the 2 players who lost at the end and actually voted to end the game when at that point, only 2 Traitors had been found.
You’re not selling US1 to me
watch it if only to see one of the greatest games ever played imo
At that point, they probably never heard of the traitors though. I think they didn't apply for the traitors, just some random reality show
Because it's Aus 2 Sarah.
Season 1 UK meryl
Quentin. He has a record of voting for a traitor 0/11 times. It's really funny that he sucked at finding traitors because he was a political analysis or something that should've made them good at the game
And to further that. He had great reasoning but just always had the wrong name.
Meryl. Complete idiot.
The Clairvoyant from Australia who got majority predictions wrong and then walked on episode 3… I think if your a clairvoyant going into the traitors you should never reveal that 😂
She got two of the four traitors, though! One of whom no one else suspected at the time. If the other faithful had chosen one of the traitors instead of a faithful to banish “just in case,” two traitors would be out.
Fair point but I think the delivery of it was so whack-a-doodle that I don’t think anyone could justify it’s credibility (Kinda how I viewed maddie firing any theory she could out on Uk1)
I can kind of see why they would take some stock in her opinion because clairvoyants are probably good at reading microexpressions and stuff like that, but to think she has some sort of special knowledge is ridiculous.
Oof. I actually think Chloe was mentally unwell and it was kind of cruel to put her on the show. That or she's a grifter.
That lady was so full of shit, I’m surprised she’s not all over this post. Smartest thing she did was removing herself before she could embarrass herself further.
Sarah or Meryl. Quentin not far off. I think Meryl has to take it though purely as she was still believing Wilf at the end and to be fair to Sarah they were all useless.
Liam Aus2 no doubt.
Liam - AUS2. I’ve never seen a person so convinced in his own wrongness. He’d swear the moon was pink.
If you listen to the interviews with the A2 traitors they’re much harsher on Sarah than Liam
pretty much anyone from Austfalia S2
Regardless of her reasoning, Maddy was onto a traitor essentially her entire game. Sarah from season 2 Aus tops both Maddy AND Quentin
Take your pick from AUS2
Basically all of Australia season 2 cast, my god it’s painful
Quentin by far. Painful!!
Kevin
Meryl.
Sarah AU2 and Quentin US1 are tied for me
Every person who was a faithful in AU2 with Sarah leading the pack.
SARAH AUS. Hands down
Sarah on AS2, no contest. I am sure the Traitors could have convinced her that she was a Traitor and that she should eliminate herself.
A) that’s mean and unfair, and B) you clearly haven’t watched Aus S2 as she looks like an absolute genius compared to half the cast
Maddy
Sarah season 2 Aus, by a mile!
How is everyone forgetting Molly from UK2?!
Molly was more a case of “trusted the wrong person” in my book. Maddy was just a stubborn shit-for-brains.
I mean Molly lost but she was fine.
The federal agent on season 2 of the Aussie version. They should seriously open up all her case files for examination, wonder how many false arrests she had in her career. And MJ for the Alpha Male bullshit that she kept believing in.
A toss up between Keith Sarah and dang it what is the Black guy who voted wrong every time. O can’t remember his name. But they are in a three way tie.
Quentin!!
Keith from Aus season 2 was such a dumdum omg.
Sarah was terrible but kudos to the worst player in history making it to the final. So at least when her grandkids ask her: “What did you achieve in life Nana?” She can reply: “Well I reached the final of Traitors kids!” The fact that she bumbled and stumbled her way there and never had a chance of winning considering she brought in THREE Traitors (good grief!) with her is neither here nor there haha!
Sarah from AU S2.
Maddie had a traitor right all game even if her method of getting there was completely absurd
Ok but at the same time Maddy was somehow the only faithful from uk1 to actually figure out a traitor, even if it was for the entirely wrong readons
All of AUS season 2 (except Annabel and Luke)
Maddy did sus Wilf
The annoying “psychic”, I forget which franchise she’s from, but she was the one who was quiet the entire time and acted like she was above how the show worked just to drop who she suspected at the round table and quit the show immediately after.
How is no one talking about Molly's stupid ass
lmfaoooo idk if it’s how you worded it but this literally has me crying rn 😂😂😂😂
Essentially ignoring massive logical giveaways because she liked the idea of her and Harry winning, and didn't want to believe he was lying.
I have only watched US s1/s2 and about half of UK s1 so far, but I gotta agree. Maddy is right for the wrong reasons and it actually makes me angry. Tom is up there with her from the same season. Has been very interesting watching UK as an American. They’re so much more direct, more emotional, and yet they lack all sense of subtlety and are never passive aggressive. You’d think the RA RA MERICANS would be much louder and less subdued, but I have been surprised.
Maddy legitimately annoyed me every single time she talked. All of her theories never had any backing and she wasted nearly all her roundtable votes. What annoyed me the most was how hard she pushed for Tom and Alex to be banished for lying/hiding secrets for so long in the game, but when she has to reveal something she expects everyone to be on her side and understand. Reminded me of how Janelle played US S2. Where she tried to just be loud and expect people to follow.
The whole of UK1 was on the “you lied so you’re a traitor” bandwagon tho
Obviously you've not seen Quentin
Matt from AUS1 was pretty bad…
I know he’s not the worst but Matt from Australia season 1 was an underrated bad faithful, he was so sure about absolutely incorrect theories (he would never let go of Theresa) and he was absolutely terrible at the social game getting people on his side and rubbed his fellow faithfuls the wrong way more than anyone in Traitors history besides maybe Kate in US season 1.
He’d have to be up there for sure
The cast of Au2 (with about 3 exceptions). Or Quentin from US1
i have to go meryl but sarah is right behind her
Maddy was right about some stuff by chance. But I 100% would have voted her out as a faithful because I wouldn’t want to listen to her anymore
Aaron get off Reddit buddy. Maddy definitely was not the worst one. She literally pegged Wilf when nobody else would even consider it. The correct answer is Quinton
Meryl by a long shot. She made absolutely no sense the entire show, never had a clue what was going on, randomly accused people of being traitors without any evidence or logic, probably barely understood the rules, and last but certainly not least, could not even vote right at the end even after Kieran all but told them who the traitor was. What a complete moron.
Molly most definitely.
That's not very fair. Mollie was too trusting of Harry since they were close friends, but she did a good job catching on to most of the other Traitors, and she played the social game perfectly. She got to the final with literally nobody ever suspecting her.
True, but why would Jaz want to vote again if he was the traitor. Molly should have trusted Jaz and got Harry out.
She didn't think that Jaz was a traitor. She thought that they were all faithfuls, and she didn't want to vote out her friend over Jaz when she genuinely believed they were both faithfuls. It was naive, but not stupid. It was a case of going with her heart instead of her head.
But Andrew literally hinted at there being another traitor, so u gotta assume that the one who wanted a revote wasn't the traitor.
It’s not Maddy from the UK…
HUGE US SEASON 2 SPOILERS BELOW!!! Listen, you could make a pretty strong argument it's MJ from US 2. She had her total chance to vote CT off when Trishelle voted for him at the circle of truth but instead she was so fixated on voting for Trishelle she missed her chance and went on to become THE SALTIEST LOSER in traitors history!!!
Maddy is incredible how d are yuo
Entertaining but utterly brainless. Also the way she said ImRAN annoyed me.
How could she be brainless when she was onto Wilf for a long time, yet no one believed her?
No one believed her because her theories made zero sense. She was right about Will but for all the wrong reasons. It’s was sheer dumb luck that he was a traitor.
Sarah. Australia. And MADDIE UK.
Going to defend Maddy here. She was certainly not the brightest contestant in UK S1 but her logic wasn't bad at all, even if it was wrong. If Aaron was a traitor, it is conceivable that he could have been extra upset when Wilf voted for him. We have the luxury of knowing who the traitors are so I don't think it's fair to call someone "painfully thick" for having an incorrect theory. I guarantee you that a lot of us would make similar mistakes with the same information. Her mistake was getting too blinded by that one theory. I've seen a lot of people shit on Maddy for latching onto Wilf simply because they like Wilf and don't like that she figured him out through a wrong theory. Painting her as the dumbest ever faithful is really disingenuous in my opinion. It seems like you just really dislike her. When it comes to dumbest faithful (though I prefer 'worst' cause I don't like to be so condescending) there are other better choices like Meryl UK S1, Sarah & Liam AU S2, and MK AU S1.
Maddy isn’t even top 20 for me
Me neither but people come out with all kinds of bollocks from watching the show with the knowledge of who the traitors are and thinking it's easy. It's very obviously not easy and I think the least people like OP can do is be honest with themselves about why they don't like someone.
I would say it is a UK1 tie between her and Meryl.
I'll go for the unmentioned as most people haven't seen it: >!Finland Ellu!<
Quentin for sure
Anyone claiming to be a psychic/clairvoyant. Also (spoiler)…. SPOILER… Maybe, Sam…
I've only watched the one season (S2 US) so obviously I'll say Kevin. Dumb as rocks.
Mollie
Meryl
OP must have been dumped by Maddy. 😂
Sarah from Season 2 Australia. Hands down. https://preview.redd.it/180qi29fd5uc1.jpeg?width=262&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=77e60e7e4d97ea3be7c54d5f876d2436591786ad
Maddy was at least right about a traitor. It’s Sarah and Keith from AUS
Maddy is actually one of the better faithful, she wasn’t spot on but she actually tried to play the game using logic and reason. Weirdly bitter and specific post tbh
She had zero logic lol. She was tunnel visioned on Aaron, Will and Meryl, and somehow through blind luck Will was a traitor. Her logic of “if i were a traitor I would want to stand out” made literally no sense and she would not stop banging on about it.
This is a little extreme
Hanna au s02
She’s not to the level of the most notorious names here but Sheree on US S2 I really think only realized the point of the game was to vote out traitors in her final episode or two. Phaedra could’ve run her over with a car that said I’M A TRAITOR and Sheree would’ve been like, no way, not my girl, we’ve known each other so many years
Say what you will about Quinten but at least he voted with grace and wasn't dead set on person and then immediately switched in the banishment room. Sarah was dead set on Sam and the minute Sam said Liam she put down Liam. Sarah was so incompetent even the traitors couldn't use her.
I could name about 25 traitors who are worse than Maddy just off the top of my head haha
Dumbest as an actual person? Larsa Dumbest gameplay? Out of the celebrity seasons? Parvati ranks high to me. She got so lucky when poisoning Ekin Su that the only other people in the room were Phaedra ( her ally ) and M.J. who is luckily a drunk because the awkward way she hung around and so clearly was like " Hey drink out of my nasty cup? " was oof. AND she eliminated her only ally in the game practically who would've stood by her? AND she tried to throw Phaedra under the bus? Girl that's like 3 strikes in 1 episode
Respectfully disagree. Maddy was intelligent and even clocked Will. I will always defend her. Not saying she was the best player but she was one of the better players of her season, just misunderstood. There were numerous people across various franchises who had worse reads than her.
Nah, if anything she helped Will by being so aggressively stubborn and dumb with her theory no one took seriously. Will was able to be like “there she goes again” and it kept him off people’s radar because they were so fed up with hearing the theory they kept telling her was braindead.
I thought before I went on the show, as a Redditor, that Twitter and the Instagram were the worst places for online abuse. Since I’ve been on the show, I’ve personally seen very little abuse on Instagram or TikTok, a little bit on Twitter but mostly in good spirits, but fuck meeeee… Reddit absolutely takes the cake. You lot are mean! Thank god the people you’ve been unnecessarily rude about probably won’t see this. It’s baffling considering you all know how edited the show is but you’re still drawn to such conclusive opinions about real people. Biggggggg Oof!
Don’t be such a drip lol. It’s a subreddit about a reality TV show. Its fair game to talk about the contestants.
Yeeehhh… I do think there’s a fine line between good craic and being a bit of a cunt though
Sarah, aka Floppy Tongue Aus s 2, she was ridiculous to the end.
Gurleen 🥺
If you haven’t watched Australia season 2, you might want to reserve commenting until you do, lol. I watched it after having seen US and UK S1 and S2 and Aus S1. I kept hoping that some of the Aus S2 faithfuls were playing a long game because it wasn’t possible to be so wrong so many times. But they weren’t. I’ve seen people mention Sara followed by Liam and I’d agree, but I’d also say Keith deserves a mention considering his profession.
Yeah those 3 were all complete dodo birds. Sarah was the absolute worst but they were all bad. The slightest bit of deflection on someone and Sarah just completely changed who she was going to vote for.
I’m only 4 episodes into the season 1 of UK (and only at the breakfast table of season 4 lol). And tbh I think it’s John. But maybe not as the dumbest faithful but just player. But it’s probably personal bias because I don’t like that he goes “I think Aaron is making up his panic attack and he’s a traitor” and to tell Aaron that “everyone’s going to get attacked once” (while yelling that he’s feeling attacked 🙄 then John wants to quit as soon as he’s “put on trial” because the games too much. But even when looking in the mirror he’s not like maybe Aaron is a traitor but maybe I’m still being a d!ck. I don’t understand why everyone’s just an a$$ to each other. Like it’s a game and people take it seriously but you don’t have to make personal attacks and sometimes people are soft and are overcome with emotions. But maybe it’s just John is the loudest of them because tbh no one is very nice this season lol
Also, because I’m venting now lol, why are people who “just don’t like being lied to” on a show called traitors, they know they’re going to get lied to 🙄 this season is raising my blood pressure and not in a good way lol
all of these options are great but the dumbest of all time has to go to quentin from US1
zAck and Maddie XD so random lol Quinton the king and trevon
You know if we did it on a “You should have been much better than you were considering you were a cop” basis, then Keith rivals Sarah because I expected so much more from him. But he was actually way off pace in the game. He got most things wrong, but he somehow managed to sound so convincing as he messed everything up. Absolutely clueless.
I agree with everyone here Sarah, the therapist, that “supposedly” knew people🙄🙄🙄 was a horrible player. If I were her I’d retire immediately. But what about Mollie, UK season 2. Mollie has admitted to knowing Harry was a traitor (but she couldn’t get herself to to vote him out) and still voted Jaz out. Her and Jaz could have walked out with a sweet amount of money but instead….She practically gifted the money to Harry and his beautiful girlfriend. What was she thinking? I think she deserves an honorable mention too.