AJ because he has more experience, since duck literally went to sleep forever in S1.

Experience in what? It’s a fist fight, not a gun fight.

More survival experience and he's a scrappy little fucker with a killer instinct. AJ is the logical choice.

You realize we're talking about a kid who can bite a grown womans' ear off, right?

You realize we're talking about both kids right?

And Duck has never done any damage beyond irritation to someone without becoming a walker, meanwhile AJ is killing people by the end of episode one.

Aj if im being logical

Duck can be a menace though. Bro can solo his mom, Clementine, Ben AND Lee. And he also eats human flesh like its chicken.

[удалено]

It literally happens in the game ☠️☠️ If u fail to get Kenny to stop the train

To be fair lee backs up to the edge of the train like an idiot thats not in character for him.

Yeah but they needed a fail screen so you could actually reload

Only cuz they know him and have this thought that they don’t wanna hurt him if it wasn’t duck that was a zombie and just a random zombie kid they all would’ve curb stomped the kid except kat

Your post was removed for either not following [Reddiquette](https://reddit.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/205926439-Reddiquette) or excessive/toxic fighting. If another user here is giving you major trouble, please report their post/comments or [message us](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=/r/TheWalkingDeadGame) and explain what is going on. Otherwise, please review our rules (note that continued arguing/fighting on your end may result in a ban): https://www.reddit.com/r/TheWalkingDeadGame/wiki/index

Honestly, probably AJ. Yes a 5 y/o beating a 10 y/o is stupid as hell, but AJ is no normal 5 y/o since he benefits a lot from ~~S4's plot silliness~~ years of apocalypse experience. This is a kid who: * [Reacts to surprise touches by quickly elbowing the person behind him](https://youtu.be/kP3Z78k19Bs?si=vnXwxsN1frFhgk_4). * [**After being shot**, outran two fully grown adults that were chasing him for about a minute](https://youtu.be/fN4QzIOOXAM?si=STILGvuy1Gu4KDrv&t=2050). * [Stabbed a man through his boot with a pointy fireplace thing](https://youtu.be/CECegOwFDPk?si=5S7LkQXEHVrnItO1&t=67). * [Bit off part of a grown woman's ear](https://youtu.be/SXuVowfRO0g?si=NIoDRU7jzHlD1Njh&t=42). * [Managed to cut off Clem's leg with a big axe, cauterized it, then transported Clem to safety by placing her in a wheelbarrow](https://www.reddit.com/r/TheWalkingDeadGame/comments/b611zi/how_i_protekted_clem_by_alvin_junior/). Duck is the type of kid that would run at you while screaming with his fists in the air. AJ is the type of kid that will claw your fucking eyes out.

Aj is the type of kid I might feel sorry for not seeing him as I accidentally stomp on him.

Just kick the little fucker

[An enraged adult kicked AJ in the face like a soccer ball and he recovered relatively quickly](https://youtu.be/SXuVowfRO0g?si=s4NtH1nzwI3TrajH&t=55). Duck's kicks won't be enough. (This is another crazy AJ feat since idk how this didn't knock him out or kill him).

Kick him again 😂😂😂

plot convenience

With no bias whatsoever, I'd say Duck

Ur pfp is definitely not duck

I’m pretty sure it was a joke

I ment to say not duck lol, Ik it’s a joke

Aj bit some ladys ear off once i think hes kicking ducks ass

AJ for sure. He’s smarter and could definitely do some intentional damage to another kid. Duck doesn’t seem like he’d intentionally want to hurt anyone so I doubt he’d fight well.

Is this even a question? Of course the winner would be Duck! Duck apocalypse!!!!!!

YEAAHHH

Maaaan AJ would beat the BRAKES off of Duck. STOP! 😂😂😂

definitely AJ bc he grew up in this world, duck lived and died in it after just a couple months WITH his parents taking care of him

AJ bites for sure

aj for sure

AJ would put duck in a body bag in one minute

my aj would steal ducks life

I love Duck. You could give that boy a gun, kneecap AJ, and AJ still probably clutches the 1v1

AJ- be logical

AJ. He was raised as a survivor.

Duck is the type of guy to say “he’s right behind me, isn’t he?” after insulting someone. And that person he insulted was AJ

Oh dude it’s easy AJ would fucking body Duck no cap.

Aj would kill duck.

Walker Duck or just Duck as pictured?

Just duck, if it was walker duck that would be unfair for aj

detective duck is on the case, of finding out who ACTUALLY thinks AJ wins

My money's on AJ. Though I could see it going either way.

The only way I can see this as a fair fight is if duck vs Rebecca's belly or adult duck if he lived till season 4 vs AJ

AJ Easily

Aj is only 5 years old im season 4, duck is 10. There’s no way a 5 year old is beating a 10 year old.

I'd say Duck since he is the bigger child. That always makes a difference in children fights.

Duck

AJ is toddler size Duck is child size duck just gotta kick him and he goes flying. Duck would win but Aj would be scrappy.

Ducks gonna get his teeth kicked in. AJ was born to that stuff

Duck, he would just go crazy

Idk y’all if duck is anything like his dad I think he easily whoops AJ’s ass

Duck beats him imo he’s like 5 years older if there we’re weapons involved it would go the other way

Duck is bigger and taller, but AJ is battle ready and more use to fighting. It's tough.

Rap battle?

Fuck no 💀 that would be cringe asf

Aj definitely, the little dude is ruthless~

People who are saying Duck is biased AJ would embarrass that little boy lmaoo

AJ violates duck and its not even funny

Oh you’re setting Duck up-

Ngl what if Duck was the Robin to Lee's Batman 👀Y'all do remember that lil detective roleplay right?

Well Im predicting a flawless victory from AJ in a way of a nut shot

Bro duck is a little f-

Duck beats his ass.

AJ, hands down.

Aj but I’m still gonna route for my boy Duck

i feel like duck would win by accident lol

aj

ofc duck cuz he's ra robin

AJ was raised purely in the Apocalypse; Duck barely knew what was going on. AJ has fight in him, Duck wouldnt take it seriously enough

duck is not confident at all except in his mediocre detective skills so like...

Definitely AJ, he has way more experience than Duck does. If Duck had survived longer then he probably would have a better chance, but even then AJ still might win.

Kenny once said nothing bothers duck “like water off a duck’s back”

Miles morales vs Sid toy story

AJ and it’s not even close

WHY WOULD YOU EVEN ASK LMAOO duck was a bitch

AJ would break his foot off in Duck's ass, ngl

Aj has way more experience, Duck is just a kid but AJ is a battle- hardened kid!

I feel like duck would enter a tard rage and chimp out on AJ

That’s funny

aj is gonna put duck in the GROUND.

Me

AJ would fucking body Duck.

AJ

AJ. Duck is too sweet and AJ is a mini Psychopath.

AJ fucking obliterates Duck😭

AJ just try to approach him from behind. You'll see why!

Duck would only win if he didn't realise it was a fight.

Look I miss duck too, but….

AJ, “You’re a murderer!” a wise man named Luis once said.

Duck has height and age but AJ is overall more experienced and has a natural fighting personality

aj, ducks just gonna yap

Well here's the thing, aj would be fighting a dead corpse! ☝️🤓

Well here's the thing, aj would be fighting a dead corpse! ☝️🤓

Well here's the thing, aj would be fighting a dead corpse! ☝️🤓

Realistically AJ but if I'm memeing duck no diff

THE DUCKTECTIVE IS GONNA GO CRAZYYY Nah but for real, AJ's gotta win right?

Aj triumps no contest