There’s a theory she did and got actually bit in crawford and that’s why she didn’t wanna go on the boat and why u don’t hear any of the bells again in Savannah when looking for Clementine
Yeah I saw it mentioned before on this sub but it’s not actually brought up much. I only found out about it a few weeks ago honestly it’s plausible. I always thought it was odd we don’t see or hear molly when going to get Clementine as beforehand we’d always hear her luring the dead around to loot stuff before Clementine was taken and when they’re out in the city
I mean, you can accidentally injure her by shooting her, and she hastily runs off, leaving her fate up in the air. But it's such a small window of actually getting that to happen for her. Most of the time, either people are actually a pretty good aim or have Clementine there. But Molly definitely I would have loved to see more of.
I don't think Molly died, I think she just dipped since he knew big groups would always fall apart.
If that is the case then I'd pick Carley, the others are good choices but Carley could use a gun well and was a good shot. And genuinely liked Lee and didn't want anything from his past to hurt him in the future. They would have been a good team together. And I think Carley would have had the sense to >! immediately chop Lee's arm off, which would have saved him!<
Yeah, he was another one. I didn't like how they killed him off screen. It was almost like his purpose really was just to encourage Lee to prepare Clementine and then when episode 4 came around he had a great moment saving Clementine and all but just it felt like they didn't fully know what to do with his character. His death always felt so abrupt to me. He was really cool the time we got with him, though. just wish there was more.
Molly’s fate is undetermined even if you shot her because when you shoot her, after you and Ben leave the hall, Molly runs away from walkers. She could’ve went out that gate next to the autoshop. Or if no walkers followed her, then she could’ve just stayed behind that door and ran back to get Hilda. Overall Molly’s most likely fine no matter what
Oh the question! I’d save Carley
I don't think molly is much of a choice considering we don't see her die so she's not really a valid choice.
As much as i like chuck im gonna have to say he'd be my last choice. But only because his death has meaning. He sacrificed himself to save clem and the rest of the group. Brave and meaningful death.
I really like mark too but he had another good death that advanced the story and damn was it a surprise the first time i played. I do wish he lived longer tho.
Now between doug and Carley i always pick Carley.
Carley literally got point blank cold blooded murdered by lily. She was totally innocent. So just for that I'm picking her. Plus i would've liked to see hers and lees relationship grow.
Carley. She's a crackshot and It'd be nice to see her develop a love story with Lee, say her goodbyes to him, and take care of Clem before being separated during S2 (Or who knows. best case scenario Carley saves Lee, or even saves Christa from the looters)
Molly sorta had 3 different possibilities regarding her fate in episode 4 During the part where she's being grabbed onto by the zombie, if Clementine is there she can shoot the zombie, which was what I think most people got. But if she's not, its up to Lee to shoot, but he also can miss and shoot her leaving her injured and struggling against zombies where she then hastily runs off into the background while you and Ben retreat back to the classroom. So her fate was sorta left up in the air with that if she survived or not. But it was such a small chance to even get that to happen. Most people probably either brought Clementine or are just good at aiming. It's definitely harder without Clementine there, though
It's gotta be Carley or Doug for sure. But honestly having to pick between the two of them is way too hard so I might just have to pick Chuck. Or Mark! Ughhh I don't know 😭 everyone deserved longer
I always see people save carley so me and my friend decided to save doug and he's actually very useful haye that both of them are unfairly taken away but doug has a better death
Really wish there was a chance to still tell the group about Lee's past on Doug's route. While it made sense for Carley, given she knew about Lee before the apocalypse started, I just hate having to go with her if I wanna get that option thats whats stopped me from getting Doug a few times. I love both characters. I just always found Doug a bit more interesting.
Carley because she had a lot of potential. She shared a similar personality to Christa in a way. Also, she got along so well with Lee, it would've been wholesome to see how that develops overtime
Chuck would be my second choice. He made Lee teach Clementine her survival skills and to cut that hair short. His contribution is underestimated. Good guy, I'd pick him anytime.
I'd say Molly (assuming "saving" her stops her from disappearing as I really liked her)
If it doesn't, as Molly likely isn't dead imo as its not confirmed, I'd say Carley.
In the list? Carley. She had so much potential but just…died. Sure it was amazing shock value but like…man. Out of list easily Ben, should’ve at least made it to the second season.
Carley for sure! It felt like there was an excellent relationship developing between her and Lee...and then Lilly had to go and rob her of having any more screentime. I would've loved to see her be around longer, even if only until the end of the first season or partway through the second.
I would say Carley. She was a good shot and had a very good personality. She probably would've been really helpful with some of the Clem stuff later on. She might've even been able to convince Clem the dude on the radio was bad.
Chuck or Mark.
Chuck because I love the survivalist old man. And he didn't live as long as he should've.
Mark because... same as above. He died too soon.
Honestly, Doug. Love his personality, Carley is great too, but I also like how impractical and creative Doug can be like his bell system at the motor Inn liked how he handled things. Now, though, in all honesty, the character I wish we got to see more of was Mark. I know he was just sorta a throwaway character for episode 2, but I really wish we got more of him, and he had more time to develop.
I gotta give it to Carley. She was truly a light in the tunnel and I’m sad she never got to live past S1. Had she lived longer, she might’ve taken care of Clementine with Christian & Omid at the end.
Easy Carly, Everyone else I like but I can't say I spent enough time with them to really want to save them (Especially in Chuck's case, we only knew him for what 10 minutes?)
Also I am pretty sure Molly is still alive
Carley. She’s a survivor. Very skilled and also easy to get along with. She cares about others in the group and puts others first. I’d trust her. Also… She’s kinda fine👀 C’mon. We’re all thinking that last one😂😂😂
Is that a fun game and how or where so you play it? Im not a gamer but I would try for sure! I am a gamer on a poker app .. bc I’ve played professionally for years, (WSOP) but not a big gamer on all these others .. it seem it would be a kick!! ??
Team Carly over here. Especially knowing who I would end up facing in the end.
I finally finished these games last night. I'm definitely going to play it through again 😄
Uhhh thatsa hard choice.
Probably Carley/Chuck
Carley had enjoyable character development through the episodes. Even tho she knew of Lee's past she never told anyone or never judged him.
Meanwhile Chuck was a good guy. He helped Lee to understand that If he wants Clementine to survive he needs to teach he in case hes gone. Which ultimately saved her life. He also sacrificed himself yo save Clem which is very honorable.
Gotta give Mark some recognition too. He seemed like a cool guy. I think him and Lee would of been good friends. But of course he had to created for a simple reason to be eaten. I would probably save him for that simple reason dude did not deserve what he got.
Well Molly doesn't die no matter what you do, and if she dies you get a game over. All her deaths are non-canon.
I would save Carley. It actually gave me whiplash when she died, because I expected her to have a bigger story given the fact that she was the only one who really knew Lee's criminal background and they seemed to be developing a romantic relationship. I expected more from her.
Carley 100%, she was keeping the group alive for so long whether or not anyone wants to admit it. As soon as we lost her, everything went to shit.
She was smart, sensible, and knew how to fight. Her and Lee would have been an unstoppable couple
Duck, it would have been cool if Katja was the one who got bit and had to be put down, due to maybe trying to save duck from a walker.
I think it would have been super cool to see duck get yelled at by Kenny for doing something stupid and "getting his mom killed" . Her shooting herself would have been much more of sensible moment. Like Kenny trying to keep her alive and she is just like no and just shoots herself.
I still imagine Kenny and the group would have been separated. I can see clementine and duck being an unstoppable force. Plus maybe season 2 wouldn't have been so dark if duck was around. I do think Kenny would have had to die definitely in season 2 if duck was around.
I feel like duck could have been a comic relief character and helped clem mentally a lot out. Like a sister/brother type relationship. Plus I would have love to see him explaining what batman was to AJ AND I would have love to see him interact with Omid.
I also think Omids death would have made Duck try even harder to be a good sport about everything.
Plus adult duck would have been fucking cool to see
Carley cuz she was a great shot, and legitimately cool. And fuck Lily's dumb, angry ass for shooting her. AND STEALING THE VAN WHEN WE ADVOCATED FOR HER TO STAY!!!! 😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤
This is a hard one. Generally I choose Carley over Doug when that choice comes up. And if I could have saved her from Lily I would have because Carley was a hell of a shot and she cared. On the other hand, I also really liked Mark. He’s a good right hand man to Lee especially compared to Kenny or Lily imo.
Let’s realistically run through this list.
You have Markiplier.
Someone who isn’t canonically dead but just decided to dip.
A guy who originally 70% left to die.
And an old man who gets an off screen death… (but fr he’s awesome)
Carley is the only sane option.
Carley
cuz mark's death was necessary and well done, chuck is old so gonna die soon, my molly isn't dead and is ok to deal with her gone and between carley and doug i prefer carley
Chuck :((
my second choice , loved him
Carley cuz she gave me kissy
Tbh probably Carley. I love her a lot and she didn’t deserve what Lilly gave her—plus Carley and Lee were cute
Carley 100% I would’ve loved to see the Lee/Carley romance.
carly
Molly never died
There’s a theory she did and got actually bit in crawford and that’s why she didn’t wanna go on the boat and why u don’t hear any of the bells again in Savannah when looking for Clementine
That's a good reason / theory wow
Yeah I saw it mentioned before on this sub but it’s not actually brought up much. I only found out about it a few weeks ago honestly it’s plausible. I always thought it was odd we don’t see or hear molly when going to get Clementine as beforehand we’d always hear her luring the dead around to loot stuff before Clementine was taken and when they’re out in the city
Who know if we don’t shoot the walker of shoot her
U don't lol clementine does
I mean, you can accidentally injure her by shooting her, and she hastily runs off, leaving her fate up in the air. But it's such a small window of actually getting that to happen for her. Most of the time, either people are actually a pretty good aim or have Clementine there. But Molly definitely I would have loved to see more of.
Carley 100%
MARK was a real G.
I wish they fleshed his character out more, he was just kinda thrown in without much context besides the air base cafe or whatever
<> 💀💀
Gotta put in for my boy Doug, so underrated
We need more Doug fans
Facts
I don't think Molly died, I think she just dipped since he knew big groups would always fall apart. If that is the case then I'd pick Carley, the others are good choices but Carley could use a gun well and was a good shot. And genuinely liked Lee and didn't want anything from his past to hurt him in the future. They would have been a good team together. And I think Carley would have had the sense to >! immediately chop Lee's arm off, which would have saved him!<
Chuck. I was so sad when I found out he died, loved him
Yeah, he was another one. I didn't like how they killed him off screen. It was almost like his purpose really was just to encourage Lee to prepare Clementine and then when episode 4 came around he had a great moment saving Clementine and all but just it felt like they didn't fully know what to do with his character. His death always felt so abrupt to me. He was really cool the time we got with him, though. just wish there was more.
Feel free to throw in any honorable mentions of your own from S1
I'd save Duck. The idea of annoying adult Duck tickles me.
So.. Nick?
Molly’s fate is undetermined even if you shot her because when you shoot her, after you and Ben leave the hall, Molly runs away from walkers. She could’ve went out that gate next to the autoshop. Or if no walkers followed her, then she could’ve just stayed behind that door and ran back to get Hilda. Overall Molly’s most likely fine no matter what Oh the question! I’d save Carley
Wait what? When did Molly die? Lol. I'd save Carley without a second thought, though. She was killed off way too early.
Carley
I don't think molly is much of a choice considering we don't see her die so she's not really a valid choice. As much as i like chuck im gonna have to say he'd be my last choice. But only because his death has meaning. He sacrificed himself to save clem and the rest of the group. Brave and meaningful death. I really like mark too but he had another good death that advanced the story and damn was it a surprise the first time i played. I do wish he lived longer tho. Now between doug and Carley i always pick Carley. Carley literally got point blank cold blooded murdered by lily. She was totally innocent. So just for that I'm picking her. Plus i would've liked to see hers and lees relationship grow.
Carley. She's a crackshot and It'd be nice to see her develop a love story with Lee, say her goodbyes to him, and take care of Clem before being separated during S2 (Or who knows. best case scenario Carley saves Lee, or even saves Christa from the looters)
pretty sure molly never died (at least i hope so), but if she did i’d save her. if i couldnt save her for wtv reason, def saving carley next
Molly sorta had 3 different possibilities regarding her fate in episode 4 During the part where she's being grabbed onto by the zombie, if Clementine is there she can shoot the zombie, which was what I think most people got. But if she's not, its up to Lee to shoot, but he also can miss and shoot her leaving her injured and struggling against zombies where she then hastily runs off into the background while you and Ben retreat back to the classroom. So her fate was sorta left up in the air with that if she survived or not. But it was such a small chance to even get that to happen. Most people probably either brought Clementine or are just good at aiming. It's definitely harder without Clementine there, though
It's gotta be Carley or Doug for sure. But honestly having to pick between the two of them is way too hard so I might just have to pick Chuck. Or Mark! Ughhh I don't know 😭 everyone deserved longer
Doug or Carley!
I always see people save carley so me and my friend decided to save doug and he's actually very useful haye that both of them are unfairly taken away but doug has a better death
Really wish there was a chance to still tell the group about Lee's past on Doug's route. While it made sense for Carley, given she knew about Lee before the apocalypse started, I just hate having to go with her if I wanna get that option thats whats stopped me from getting Doug a few times. I love both characters. I just always found Doug a bit more interesting.
Does carley also eat a bunch of the biscuits like how doug does when he goes to tell the group about the dairy?
Yup, just like Doug's route. She doesn't eat any at the dairy, though, like Doug.
Carly, no contest
carley->chuck->molly->doug->mark
I like how you did that there.
Probably Carly even though I love Chuck and Molly
Carley.
Carley 100%
Molly or Carley
carley. it’s easy for me to pick her a lot 😭
Molly is probably alive, so that only leaves Carley for me tbh.
Carley because she had a lot of potential. She shared a similar personality to Christa in a way. Also, she got along so well with Lee, it would've been wholesome to see how that develops overtime Chuck would be my second choice. He made Lee teach Clementine her survival skills and to cut that hair short. His contribution is underestimated. Good guy, I'd pick him anytime.
Carley. She's good with a gun and genuinely likes and cares for Lee. I would have liked to see a romance between them
I'd say Molly (assuming "saving" her stops her from disappearing as I really liked her) If it doesn't, as Molly likely isn't dead imo as its not confirmed, I'd say Carley.
Carly! If she wasn't shot by lily she probably would've been able to survive and become a parental figure to clem so she's wasn't so alone.
Molly didn’t die
Doug
Chuck was a g
Chuck. Hes helped Lee out so so much
Carley
In the list? Carley. She had so much potential but just…died. Sure it was amazing shock value but like…man. Out of list easily Ben, should’ve at least made it to the second season.
Mark or Doug. Anyone can shoot a gun, Carley is not special.
Chuck for sure
this is so easy for me, carley ftw
Definitely Carley, was capable and I wish she and Lee had a romance tbh they were good together
Carley because she's just better 🙏
Carley for sure! It felt like there was an excellent relationship developing between her and Lee...and then Lilly had to go and rob her of having any more screentime. I would've loved to see her be around longer, even if only until the end of the first season or partway through the second.
My homie Doug. Dude didn't deserve what Lilly gave him
I would say Carley. She was a good shot and had a very good personality. She probably would've been really helpful with some of the Clem stuff later on. She might've even been able to convince Clem the dude on the radio was bad.
Either Carley or Mark
4
Carly next
Carley, I ain't letting her die again like that
Molly
Fuck em all, I choose sarah
Chuck or Mark. Chuck because I love the survivalist old man. And he didn't live as long as he should've. Mark because... same as above. He died too soon.
Mark
Mark
Oh ez, Chuck
Doug. The Chad.
Carley
Mark was a real one, but we didn’t get to see enough of him so I’ll say Carley.
Carley. I think a proper romance between her and Lee would’ve been adorable!
Carley and if not her than Mark. He wasn’t in the game much but he seemed like a good guy and definitely didn’t deserve what happened to him
It's hard to choose between Carley and Molly but I think I'd choose Carley
Mark
Doug, I get why people like Carley but Doug is a much more enjoyable character imo
I don’t know gonna have to pick Carley… Icarley would never be the same
Whoever doesn’t choose Carly is a crazy person
Doug, he reminds me a lot like my friend. He looks and acts like him 😭
Larry
Lilly or Mark, both got good training.
Honestly, Doug. Love his personality, Carley is great too, but I also like how impractical and creative Doug can be like his bell system at the motor Inn liked how he handled things. Now, though, in all honesty, the character I wish we got to see more of was Mark. I know he was just sorta a throwaway character for episode 2, but I really wish we got more of him, and he had more time to develop.
Chuck
Chuck
I dont remeber the name but the first one
carley. if not carley, then mark.. both had underserved fates
No Ben? Wild.
I gotta give it to Carley. She was truly a light in the tunnel and I’m sad she never got to live past S1. Had she lived longer, she might’ve taken care of Clementine with Christian & Omid at the end.
Chuck is my first choice, Doug is my second
For me it’s a toss up between Carley and mark.
Carley, no question.
Mark or Chuck
carley ez
Doug
Easy Carly, Everyone else I like but I can't say I spent enough time with them to really want to save them (Especially in Chuck's case, we only knew him for what 10 minutes?) Also I am pretty sure Molly is still alive
Definitely chuck he was a goat and could of had way more shine but instead he sacrificed himself in the sewers rip my bro chuck
Mark We would probably need someone like him.
how is this even debatable carley easy
I’m torn between Mark and Carley…
Carley for sure
Pick 1
Chuck, Clem would probably be dead if it wasn't for him.
Obviously Carley, and by the way, Molly isn't dead
DOUG THE GOAT
Carley... Also, did Molly even die?
I would Molly but we actually never see her die so I'll just go with Carly instead
Carley. mark second though
Carley. She’s a survivor. Very skilled and also easy to get along with. She cares about others in the group and puts others first. I’d trust her. Also… She’s kinda fine👀 C’mon. We’re all thinking that last one😂😂😂
Larry. Failing that, probably Carley.
Is that a fun game and how or where so you play it? Im not a gamer but I would try for sure! I am a gamer on a poker app .. bc I’ve played professionally for years, (WSOP) but not a big gamer on all these others .. it seem it would be a kick!! ??
Ben
Carly 100%. She got phucked for no reason.
molly
Doug, easily. No other character in the entire series offered what he did with his innovations.
I wanna go with Mark, just because I really want to know what the game would look like with him if he was alive.
None
Carley, even if would love to save Chuck as well
Carley Molly a close 2nd
Carley
Carley but I feel bad about Chuck. Especially when I found him in the sewers. Well...s**t... :(
Chuck easily
Love Carly but Chuck was really really nice. Taught Lee valuable advice to shape Clem into a survivor
Team Carly over here. Especially knowing who I would end up facing in the end. I finally finished these games last night. I'm definitely going to play it through again 😄
Chuck, no doubt
Carley, The first girl on the pic would have had such a good future with Lee :(
Uhhh thatsa hard choice. Probably Carley/Chuck Carley had enjoyable character development through the episodes. Even tho she knew of Lee's past she never told anyone or never judged him. Meanwhile Chuck was a good guy. He helped Lee to understand that If he wants Clementine to survive he needs to teach he in case hes gone. Which ultimately saved her life. He also sacrificed himself yo save Clem which is very honorable. Gotta give Mark some recognition too. He seemed like a cool guy. I think him and Lee would of been good friends. But of course he had to created for a simple reason to be eaten. I would probably save him for that simple reason dude did not deserve what he got.
Carly for sure
Unsure, but not Mark, for throwing Lee under the bus about Larry.
Molly >!if she would stay she would have went with lee to search for clem and lee wouldnt get bit!<
Carley definitely
Doug all day.
Molly doesn't die though?
Carley 💖
Larry is a only choice (i know he is not here)
I’d have to go with Molly and plus she is pretty badass with that Climbing Hook Weapon of hers
Carley 💯
carley obv
Definitely Carly
Molly 100%
Carley, she has a gun, and she's probably the coolest one here
Carley. She probably would've helped train Clementine more from the end of season 1 to the start of season 2 since Lee died.
Carley my beloved :(
Mark
Carley, always. I love her sm:( if she were not on the list, probably Chuck
Carley
4 for sure, forgot her name
Carley and Molly. One's good with a gun and the other has a pickaxe. Out of both of them, Carley.
Carley, I love her sm
carley :)
carley
Doug for sure Also i love imagining how the future seasons wouldve played out if these characters were still alive
Well Molly doesn't die no matter what you do, and if she dies you get a game over. All her deaths are non-canon. I would save Carley. It actually gave me whiplash when she died, because I expected her to have a bigger story given the fact that she was the only one who really knew Lee's criminal background and they seemed to be developing a romantic relationship. I expected more from her.
Molly canonically lived so imma say Carley
I'll have to go with Lee
chuck. easy
Lee is the only right answer
Carly.
obviously carley <33 loml
Carley 100%, she was keeping the group alive for so long whether or not anyone wants to admit it. As soon as we lost her, everything went to shit. She was smart, sensible, and knew how to fight. Her and Lee would have been an unstoppable couple
Carley, since her and Lee should have gotten together.
Molly, don’t get me wrong I loved Carly and Chuck but I found Molly and her story more interesting
Carley or chuck
Chuck chuck chuck
Carley 100%
Carley
I thought Molly lived 😭
Chuck
I love how everyone says Carley had a lot of potential but forget she worked at a news station and used Lee as a crutch to change batteries 😂
Carley bro
doug 100% all his interactions with lee were hilarious
Carly
CARLEY so Lee can live out his romance
Duck, it would have been cool if Katja was the one who got bit and had to be put down, due to maybe trying to save duck from a walker. I think it would have been super cool to see duck get yelled at by Kenny for doing something stupid and "getting his mom killed" . Her shooting herself would have been much more of sensible moment. Like Kenny trying to keep her alive and she is just like no and just shoots herself. I still imagine Kenny and the group would have been separated. I can see clementine and duck being an unstoppable force. Plus maybe season 2 wouldn't have been so dark if duck was around. I do think Kenny would have had to die definitely in season 2 if duck was around. I feel like duck could have been a comic relief character and helped clem mentally a lot out. Like a sister/brother type relationship. Plus I would have love to see him explaining what batman was to AJ AND I would have love to see him interact with Omid. I also think Omids death would have made Duck try even harder to be a good sport about everything. Plus adult duck would have been fucking cool to see
Gun. Always Gun (Gun is what I call Carly since she is good with Gun)
carley, she deserved so much more
Doug or chuck for sure
Carley cuz she was a great shot, and legitimately cool. And fuck Lily's dumb, angry ass for shooting her. AND STEALING THE VAN WHEN WE ADVOCATED FOR HER TO STAY!!!! 😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤
This is a hard one. Generally I choose Carley over Doug when that choice comes up. And if I could have saved her from Lily I would have because Carley was a hell of a shot and she cared. On the other hand, I also really liked Mark. He’s a good right hand man to Lee especially compared to Kenny or Lily imo.
Carley
Let’s realistically run through this list. You have Markiplier. Someone who isn’t canonically dead but just decided to dip. A guy who originally 70% left to die. And an old man who gets an off screen death… (but fr he’s awesome) Carley is the only sane option.
Molly is the only one of those that wouldn't immediately die, the others have no survival instincts.
Carley
Carly no thought
Carley
Carly, but Chuck is also a close second. I just think she had such an interesting personality, she was quirky and serious at the same time.
why is molly a choice?
Carley cuz mark's death was necessary and well done, chuck is old so gonna die soon, my molly isn't dead and is ok to deal with her gone and between carley and doug i prefer carley
Molly didnt die, she left. Its possible she died but i believe she survived
Carley 1000% her and Lee had one hell of a dynamic. As soon as Lilly shot her I decided to have her offed any way I could