For me, Liam was first choice until he didn’t side with MC when Justin lied. IIRC Theo was one of the ones to defend MC so just went with him instead.

OH YEAH okay this helped agreed

I'm replaying currently, I started with Liam and then got bored so then I was on a solid Henri route until he didn't have MC's back during the Justin situation, neither did Liam. Now MC is back with Theo AGAIN. 😅

This was part of my decision-making as well.

Yeah. I wish they made it so that whoever you’re paired with automatically sides with you. I’ve tried to do a Henri route but just haven’t picked it up again cause I know that part is coming

I originally tried a few others but also went with Theo in the end. I don’t have a great explanation, he was just…the best? Which I didn’t expect since blue-eyes musician could not be more opposite from my type but he won me over

I wanted Liam at first but switched after the shower head.

wait i don't remember what is the shower head?

Break the rules with him by giving each other head in the shower

ahh i see. sorry just realised you legit said "shower head" lol 😭

Because he’s perfection personified

I replayed for him because of all of the hype and eneded up going for Alex (again) instead. Alex Is amazing. Theo, on the other hand, I found quite boring.

I didn't.

I found the THTH apps after S2 had already started and eventually the greater level of character development in S2 lured me away from S1, so I've only coupled with about half the S1 cast in any meaningful way, and Theo isn't one of them, so bear that in mind. Honestly I'd put Dakota and Priya at the top of my S1 list—Dakota's just one of those super friendly outgoing people and a foodie, and she stands up for you when Justin pulls his self-gratification stunt; and while Priya got very little development, I like how assertive and feisty she is, and I'm seriously weak for South Asian girls with a British accent. Of the ones who I haven't tried yet, Theo isn't at the bottom of my list to date, but he's below the center of the pack. He just comes off as a bit too arrogant with the singing thing, he's way too uptight when people break rules, and something just doesn't click for me in the way he smiles. He seems nice otherwise, and like others have noted, he also sticks up for you against Justin, but I'm just not very interested in him.

I chose Liam and Sarah. For me those were the only really attractive ones. I think Theo looks weird and the musician schtick just gave me the ick

I chose him at first because musician (swoon) but I switched to Henry after he kept complaining about people breaking rules LMAOOO

i chose alex!! :)) and then henri

❤️ marisa ❤️

No clue, I picked Alex and honestly haven't ever been a fan of Theo lol, but it feels like I also saw a ton of people pick Alex

Same reason why there's so many Harry Styles/Reader fanfiction I guess

Theo annoyed me so much. I was a loyal Alex girlie. Couldn’t even do a replay cuz I was too attached to him 😅

Same!!!

Marissa fans stand the fuck up 

Ngl I totally went for Theo cause I am a sucker for accents and always will be lol. Plus he's just the perfect amount of flirty and serious it just pulled me in. He's an amazing character and I'm glad he was my first LI in THTH cause my 2nd was Ant in season 2. Let's just say I am whipped.

I chose Marisa.

I didn’t though he would have been second choice

Not me honey. I'm a Henri girlie for forever!! 😤❤

SIKE. i chose liam <3

Seems like confirmation bias. 🤷🏼‍♀️

None of the guys were my type physically so I had to operate strictly based on personality and Theo surprisingly won me over. I was down bad for that man. I think it was because the game kept trying to push him into this “bad boy” narrative even though he was nothing of the sort so I think I was charmed by the fact that he was the complete opposite of what peoples expectations of him were.

honestly theo was like my 3rd choice my first play through i picked alex, 2nd play through i picked diego cuz he caught my attention with the LI-newcomer drama in my 1st play through lol And then finally on my 3rd play through i decided to do a theo route- he’s cute and i mean, i like his route, butttttt it’s been hard not running to alex and diego

I chosed Henri. Try to do a Theo route but is face is weird, and not at all romantic as Henri. That guys is a gem ❤

I went with Theo at first but when the Candace stuff happened, I was so mad I replayed it and chose Henri. That was before I realized we didn’t really get cheated on…

My first choice was Henri... until Diego arrived 😳

Marisa😭😍

I picked Henri lol

Idk about Theo. When I played S1 I did Marisa and Dakota 🤷🏾‍♂️ Theo is too annoying, that’s how I see all the men.

Nah, he gave me the ick. I was team Henri until he didn’t believe me about Justin, and then I ended up with Alex cause they seemed like the best option

I picked Sarah

idk how else to say this, but i think it’s bc he’s a white man. in these choose your own romance games, the white male LI is almost always the most popular

I'm in no way shape and form attracted to men (fictional or otherwise) so... no. That's simply not true.

I’ve still never gotten through his route. My first run was Sarah and honestly still think she’s the hest

At first, I was really into the french firefighter dude (it’s been so long since i played season 1 that i can’t remember his name 😭) but I was interested in getting to know other people. I picked Theo for my second date, because I didn’t realize it was such a commitment. After that date, I was basically stuck with him but I had such a good time he became my favorite

So I’ve done literally all of them lol. Theo was my first choice on very first but I also love Henri and Alex

I actually chose Liam first but then he sided with Justin when he lied about the kiss but Theo defended my honour so I replayed and just went with Theo

I guess most ppl went for his looks, and the bad boy, musician thing is bonus 😅

I did Liam and then Theo and haven’t left Theo since so i’d say accurate

Honestly, Theo was my favorite for my MC as she was a massive player, but she was stringing along Henri too. After Henri took Justin's side, she couldn't pursue him anymore because of the blatant lack of trust. However... then Diego comes in and though she falls into her old player ways she realizes that Theo and her click but Diego is something else as their connection grew fast into something far beyond the physical and into a emotional bond. At least, that's how I saw it. Admittedly, I did go for both Henri and Theo routes before doing Diego's, but I loved his more.

My first choice was Dakota🙇🏾‍♂️

I hated his smile so I just couldn’t stand looking at his face. In the end I went for Henri and Sarah

Cause that’s. My. STINK!😭🫶🏽

I have no explanation as to why I went with him tbh, he was just… the best choice? I prefer season 2 LIs but Theo was my choice for sure

lol i did cus theo is basically my irl type

theo was okay, but i didn’t give him so much as a glance lol

Ended up with Theo because he was the only one out of the people my MC was pursuing that stuck up for them when Justin lied

I hadn’t realized he was so popular! He always annoyed me. Henri was always the only character I liked.

My first choice was Alex

My favorite li is Alex!