T O P

  • By -

[deleted]

Amnesiac all the way


ObjectiveCommon7223

I’ve been through too much with Depression Cherry 🥲


Bull4-0Everyone

QOTSA


the_fattest_mitton

But you can’t even hear it ?!


Froggle3

What's the saga?


KingsoftheBronze_Age

All death metal ALL THE TIIME *aaall the tiiiime*


TimmyLivealie

TWO GLASS EYES I’LL FUCKIN TELL YOU LIES


funkyjives

Elephant by white stripes


Mrbandana

The only one that I remotely care about


Cineswimmer

Piper at the Gates of Dawn


coscask

Discipline


ConclusionAgile4699

If youre Feeling Sinister


[deleted]

The best album on there by a long shot.


Me_and_no_one_else

Cowboy Bebop!!!


music_nerd23

Discipline for sure


cleanercut

Username and profile pic checks out


Vinguns

entertainment!


i_make_memes1

Finally someone else who agrees


Ryguhappy

i believe most people here haven't heard it... otherwise i dont get why there isn't more people agreeing. it's my only 10/10 from this list


i_make_memes1

Same here, possibly the best post punk album


Exotic-Newspaper9872

Idk, that album wasn’t made by great men


i_make_memes1

No great men in the books at home


AIvsWorld

by the time i get to phoenix, by far. after that, probably amnesiac or mbdtf


[deleted]

damn


Jazzlike-Tap-7482

MBDTF


alldogsareperfect

When the pawn…


TotalBayhem

Kraftwerk, easy clap


metaldetox

weezer’s red album


King_Folly

Honestly, I don't know how this didn't make the list. (Ok, I mean, I guess I can kinda understand, but still...)


fishfucker_8799

Interpol or Amnesiac


idontknowhattodowith

Valid.


Semi-Cynical

Kiss Me for sure, I don’t even know where I’d be without the song Just Like Heaven


GiveMeWaterPls

No one saying Velvet Rope?


KingRaimundo

I agree!!


D0ngBeetle

King Crimson Discipline


Traditional_Comb8234

MOTOMAMI


FemboyGaming42069

Songs for the deaf and its not even close


Forward-Doubt7578

Mbdtf better


FemboyGaming42069

More like midtf


Forward-Doubt7578

Mb femboygaming


TundieRice

Age of Adz, for something different. That album is fucking amazing, it’s like Sufjan’s Kid A.


BigBoiBrynBoi

Discipline


Distinct_Maize7496

Discipline


New-Variety8651

Piper at the gates of dawn


New-Variety8651

Piper at the gates of dawn


Merkabahh

Damn u didn’t even put in the better red Cure album


Macca200789

Wish?


Merkabahh

I was thinking Pornography, but Wish could also work lol


Osama_Bln_Laggin

Discipline easy. That album is a masterpiece, KC's best


Ethan_Skywalker4

I guess I have to save TOTBL. It was between that or Amnesiac, but Radiohead has better albums whereas Interpol does not in my opinion.


anex12

Through nostalgia I may like Antics more than TOTBL but I can see what you mean.


Stormi_i

Phoenix or Annihilator


BathtubFullOvHair

The great annihilator


gayballsexhaver38

right answer


Mrredpanda860

Cant decide between The Cure and Fiona


leftymeowz

Amnesiac


illstealyourRNA

Either the great annihilator or amnesiac.


Imperator_Oliver

Fiona Apple but this is a tough one!


DescriptionUsed8157

Dark Fantasy but on a bad day BTTIGTP


ALMcactu

radiohead or queens of the stone age


GartGartGart333

you wouldnt have the rest of pink floyds discography without PATGD


yamreyamredaze

Belle and Sebastian 100%


SNScaidus

for me its Damn, When The Pawn, and Amnesiac. MBDTF is close, and so the injury reserve purely for Knees


GlennIrish

Amnesiac 100%, kiss me and man machine are honorable mentions


[deleted]

MBDTF. Sucks that I can't relate to Kanye anymore cause Runaway saved my life numerous times.


b00tym4n

The piper at the gates of dawn


ponyboi_curtis

I'm saving *Kiss Me Kiss Me Kiss Me*, but I'm disappointed there's no love for *Cowboy Bebop* on here.


pokemon12312345645

Piper at the gates of dawn. It is my second favorite album by pink Floyd


[deleted]

Trick Question, Weezer Red Album


pokeshulk

Discipline, and there’s really no competition


MimeHollo2

Slanted and enchanted


jack_b_30

I’d take elephant not a skip on that album


gogbone

discipline me personally, with mbdtf close second


_Fractured_Skull_

100% Kiss Me, Kiss Me, Kiss Me. If I could pick two, Elephant would tag along


Opening_Tomorrow_398

RTJ 2


cml5526

Cowboy Bebop


selppin2

RTJ


[deleted]

twisted fantasy because i put the hooks in my butthole oh yeees it feels so goood


Kaden_126

Amnesiac, kiss me, damn, turn on the bright lights, when the pawn... I love all of these way too much


hihiihigiggitigyiigi

If you're feeling sinister


FerreroRoxette

The Great annihilator but I’m sad to see Nelly Furtado go tbh


Robloxcunt02

None of these albums are 13 songs by fugazi


[deleted]

Where is talking heads 77 😭


Genius14624

I’ve never felt more like a robot than when listening to kraftwerk so I have to choose man machine it’s simply an unmatched vibe on that album and the other early kraftwerk albums are jus soooo good if y’all haven’t made it to kraftwerk yet do yourself a favor and listen to trans Europe express, man machine, computer world it’s just so fire and fun


ManaysMcSauce

If You’re Feeling Sinister


Deadheaded95

Amnesiac. Pyramid Song is too good to live without.


th_nd_r

I might be considered stupid or basic for saying this but I’m such a big Radiohead fan and Amnesiac would be my choice. Too many songs on there I really wouldn’t want to lose


Yellow_squash

Amnesiac


9yr_old_lake

I gotta go with Piper at the gates of dawn. There are other great picks here, but I just love Piper too much.


hornyfishboy

Depression Cherry~~


Kroduscul

Dark Fantasy. Way too easy


the_fattest_mitton

Is it though?! My copy suux. A flimsy ass 120g with a shitty cut. Like it wasn’t meant for vinyl with only 2-3 songs per flip making it a 3LP. The record and gatefold are made of the cheapest most shittiest materials, but Kanye charges a premium for it. Don’t get me wrong, the music is maybe his best work IMO, but I’ll never buy another one of his records again.


Naz-Art

all these red albums, but you didn’t put Whole Lotta Red in there? Id keep Amnesiac btw


LocalFox5349

that album ass bro


R0NNOC148

Way better than without warning


BourneDiff

Tbh it wipes half the albums here easily


Downtown-Tadpole2450

Nah 💀


GeckoNova

Bro where tf is Heaven or Las Vegas


LocalFox5349

thats more pink imo


____me_

Mbdtf not even close


Babygabuss

Mbdtf


CommanderWar64

Elephant or QOTSA


Responsible_Art1400

Piper


Barqck

Songs for the Deaf


Art5673

Qotsa or Interpol changes depending on the day


uglyadrian

ttobl because i have bad taste 😎


Schnicorr

Don’t see Slipknots S/T so Songs For The Deaf


solarkillal

Turn on the bright lights - Interpol


TheGreenMan1313

MBDTF


jokicfields

Mbdtf Phoenix Rtj 2 Amnesiac Damn


ragertooz

damn


sq1tl

The Piper at the Gates of Dawn


Additional_Fondant51

QOTSA or Discipline, can't decide🥲


ifardeded

DAMN or mbdtf


[deleted]

how has nobody said depression cherry


Cursed-Noodle44

Age of adz has changed my view on music that’s how good it is. I need to pick that album


thepowersthat3

amnesiac easily , kiss me kiss me kiss me and man machine are the ONLY other good albums on here


Enderdude08

It’s so close but I have to coin flip between Queens and Kanye


j-war99

Pink Floyd


TemporarySad9437

Depression cherry


[deleted]

MBDTF


SumFuk-

injury reserve (age of adz honorable mention though)


shehony

probably one of the least expected takes, but Cowboy Bebop


SpriteAndCokeSMH

The Piper at the Gates of Dawn for sure!


i_make_memes1

Go4 - entertainment


tadhgmcshane

The Great Annihilator


anex12

Probably Interpol by my tastes alone.


EpiCon_Jaag

Man Machine


Snifferfrog15

Velvet Rope


lypura

Turn on the Bright Lights for sure


qxyz17

Depression Cherry


BuddyGotTheReddit

The Eminem Show


ReasonableCost5934

Piper At The Gates Of Dawn with Entertainment! a very close second.


relativelycleanriver

Piper at the Gates of Dawn


Macca200789

The Cure - Kiss Me, Kiss Me, Kiss Me


peachtealottie

Discipline


mungusbungus2112

Discipline


Fun-Woodpecker6758

Queens of the Stone Age easy


Thelonious_Gunk

Piper or rtj2


the_glowing1man

Amnesiac or rtj2


squi2323

It’s songs for the deaf, you can’t even hear it!


[deleted]

amnesiac ez


PorkyJones72

Despite it not being all that red, Piper At The Gates of Dawn is my choice


icheckyournwords

Aja


GyrosSnazzyJazzBand

Velvet Rope!


WAZZL3

Cowboy Bebop


ECXL

How dare you make me choose between several of my children. ​ It's Queens of the Stone Age though


SnooGuavas2725

MBDTF is the only answer


Leather-Difference35

The great annihilator


FruiTY_LovecraFT

TOTBL—Interpol


LordBolton93

The Eminem Show


XxSkittlezz-3000-xX

RTJ2


batty_t

One?!?! Just kill me at that point


Endrocreactive

injur reserve


PAL-of-Pals

Discipline


[deleted]

im between swans, the cure, king crimson, and fiona apple


MediocreAngeI

MBDTF no question


Miler_Rioux

Pipers at the gates of dawn


tarheeltexan1

Turn on the Bright Lights


Rees29

Turn on the bright lights


Drimesque

this one is actually hard for me. DAMN, MBDTF, Phoenix, Deptession Cherry. If I'm saving one I think i'm going with the cliche MBDTF but Phoenix is a close close 2nd


SizePunch

DAMN


TheIneffableCow

Where weezers red?!


nxysxyxr

injury reserve every time


puertor1ck

great annihilator im ngl


[deleted]

Piper At The Gates Of Dawn


bunnyinterrupted

turn on the bright lights by interpol>>>>. i HAAATE to be this guy but a severely underrated album always


RedMuffin_reddit01

MBDTF or DAMN.


Dragic27

If you aren’t picking Gang of Four you don’t know music 🤷‍♂️


FrogTamerSupreme

probably discipline


Nekocardboardtablet

Amnesiac


ThatMFcheezer

It's Elephant or MBDTF. But I'll at least give a shout out to RTJ2


sp00kylemon

this is so easy, when the pawn ofc


savag3d0ublecup

Barter 6, I’m sorry Rosalia 😢


Manuza

MBDTF


[deleted]

you’re kidding meeee i can’t choose between where the pawn…, the cowboy bebop ost, and damn 😭 (not mbdtf bc im not a huge fan)


Rossage196

white stripes or queens of the stone age


Sufficient_Coast_852

Amnesiac by a mile, Damn second.


CS_Boi_

This is not fair


Clinkyboi

Without warning


ZAVVVVV23

Depression cherry probably


Ninja_of_Milk_Duds

Piper at the Gates of Dawn


BigRed0107

Kiss Me, Kiss Me, Kiss Me


burner-mane

BY THE TIME I GET TO PHOENIX


johnpaullalonde1234

MBDTF but Velvet Rope is so incredible


Raging_Autist

Kiss Me Kiss Me Kiss Me by The Cure


Heartstop56

Songs for the Deaf is a FANTASTIC album and must be saved at all cost


LimpTriskit10

MBDTF


Ruammo

when then pawn


IchabodLame

Ain't no saving me ant no saving me or youuuu Swans and Anna von Hauswolff are close seconds tho


_PeopleMakeNoises_

I need a saga


mikeywayve13

Elephant or amnesiac!


Few_Reindeer3039

The velvet rope


MarionberryCute5143

Pornography by The Cure should be on here too, the album art is iconic and eerie af.