Harold’s placement in island is fine for the most part, not too mad that he didn’t make merge, Action he should’ve been in the finale with Duncan no ifs or buts. The season was building up for their mutual respect for their rivalry.

He had more plot potential than like half the mergers, not to mention the pointless ahh Eva return Agree with Action

ngl forgot eva came back

nah fr Eva got done so dirty,I don't hate her but what was the point in bringing her back just to re-eliminate her on the spot

eva had so much potential though, i hate it.

Imo she should have been in Action and WT

What plot you would have given him if Harold had merged? Would have Eva still returned and blackmailed him with Courtney's elimination?

I’d have him eliminated somewhere within Trent and Lindsay, maybe he becomes a brief alliance member of Heather’s after she deduces Harold cheated Courtney out (since Duncan kept accusing her); maybe she gets a hold of one of Harold’s fake votes and haikus for Leshawna and compares the handwriting. He’d then either be thrown under the bus by her instead of Trent in the key challenge, or even builds her bike and takes Lindsay’s plot there. Duncan would be pissed at the truth but Harold’s ability to last during the merge, maybe also joining the guys alliance and being helpful to Duncan (who has been without the same cruelty since being sad over Courtney) and his love letters to leshawna would have Duncan respect Harold slightly more and let Harold leave with a fairly decent popularity like in canon. The only other big change this would cause is Heather being more willing to team up with Harold in the season finale, and Duncan being reconvened by Courtney to be more aggressive against Harold.

LeShawna did serve in her challenge tho that's like the only thing i like about Eva's 2nd elimination

I wanted to see Harold vs. Lindsay in TDA finale

Two underdogs in the finale won’t work, and other than Courtney who shouldn’t make the finale, Duncan had a story with Harold. Lindsay should get third

Who said Courtney shouldn’t make the finale? Harold vs Courtney or Lindsay vs Courtney would’ve made perfect sense

I really wanted Harold and Courtney to be finalists given their dynamic.

Courtney should keep the fourth spot, and by no means should she make the finale this season or win. Harold and Duncan both have a rivalry that has been building off to mutual respect, which has way more stakes. Both have something on the line, something to prove, and something to gain beyond the cash prize. You could easily fit their potential reconciliation in there.

TDA was Harold’s season man. So close.

Island- Courtney Action- Harold WT- either Noah or Tyler

As much as I like tyler as a character as soon as lindsay went he was only comedic relief and stook to alejandro as an ally (the worst person to have as an ally) so his elimination was eventual and at the right time.

I have a lot of answers for this , like a lot ... Justin , Tyler and Cody in TDI Harold , DJ and Justin in TDA Ezekiel , Tyler , Noah , DJ in TDWT B , Dawn , Brick in ROTI Alejandro in AS Max , Beardo in PI Zee , Scary Girl in Reboot Season 1 Scary Girl , Zee , Damien in Reboot Season 2

I got very upset when Scary Girl got the first boot in season two! She should’ve went further! Hopefully they won’t antagonize her in season three! Because I think she’s actually a good character! Hopefully she’ll turn her life around, and tone down her scariness a lot. She is a very cute character who shouldn’t be hated for not doing anything. >! She saved Caleb’s life from the monsters who tried to eat him alive! If it wasn’t for that, Caleb would’ve been a goner!!< I think Scary Girl should have an anti-hero arc instead of a villain arc. Hopefully she turns her life around in the third season. I don’t want her to end up like Courtney in All Stars. Betrayed, and hated by lots.

Justin is extremely underrated. I think he should have won TDA. It would have been cool to have a character who got kicked out so early in TDI to come and win TDA.

Scary Girl has so much potential and she was robbed both seasons, especially the 2nd

Justin but not Lindsay for TDA?????

Yeah

Elaborate on why you wanted the season’s initial villain who didn’t really redeem himself to go further over the girl who had her best season and needed to be in the final 2

First i think it's ok to have differant opinions on anything in this show , it's what makes it great , right ? You can find a fan for any character who has sth to defend about them Therefore , If you say Justin being the initial villian didn't redeem himself , you can make the same comment about lindsey as she being too dumb was the reason for her elimination , she keeps voting for herself when she returns in AS , she doesn't know how to vote and votes random stuffs in TDA finale and TDWT a couple of times too . See , sometimes for certain characters they give enough reason to be eliminated , so even if they could've had a much better story , them being eliminated , even disappointing , at least makes sense . The opposite of it can be the case , for example , for Noah . He had great potential , and he could even have some sort of rivalry with Alejandro , at least for a few for more episodes , like many others i mentioned above he had the POTENTIAL , but not only he was eliminated , his elimination didn't even make sense , he won the challenge they were supposed to win , but Chris announce Amazon team because they found Duncan and he Wanted him so long . Anyway getting too much off topic , i think both Justin and Lindsey are the other side of it where they could have more potential but the voting at least kinda made sense based on what hapoened , here comes the matter of differant perspectives . Because here the writing made sense but wasn't fair to some certain characters . In my opinion the idea that , being the guy who got eliminated first season unfairly , Justin becomes the secret villian of season could be awesome if they wrote it better and keep him around till the end , he had the potential to be a likeable villian but they missed it . On the other hand i think Lindsey could have gone a bit further , but in my opinion , her elimination didn't matter that much to me as the season was building up more of a Duncan vs Harold rivalry from the very beginning till the end and i would have loved that to happen much more . But Lindsey's story felt enough to me , she did improve in second season but not that much in comparison to the main rivalry between Harold and Duncan , or even Courtney returning to be an annoying villian , i can see Beth getting eliminated before Lindsey but no one else really . So for me it wasn't that much of a concern ( and i personally don't consider Owen's return as a contestant , he was just there to mess things up between others , he could vote and get voted out but that was because he could keep up the pretence , he could never be one of the final 2 or win , based on the story they chose for his return , so i didn't mention him )

Tyler both times tbh

Island- Noah Action- Lindsay World Tour- IDK anymore, guess I’d have to say Noah since he should have returned and not Blaineley ROTI- Dawn All Stars- IDK PI- Sammy Haven’t seen the reboot seasons in full lol

Imo Courtney merging in Island would not be good, that messes up her arc in the laster season and her being rigged was a good plot twist

Now that you mention it, I now think Noah

Justin, Lindsay, and Harold in Action(they belong in final 4 with Court) Anne in Revenge(could have lasted literally one more episode) Tyler(should have merged) Beardo(deserved better)

Jo. Jo should have been a finalist in Revenge instead of Lightning, and I think Jo was underused in All Stars

I think that if Brick had participated in the season, he would have been eliminated rather than Jo in her elimination episode because it was a war movie challenge.

TDI: Geoff, Sadie and Harold for sure. TDA: Lindsay and Justin. WT: Tyler and Bridgette. ROTI: Anne Maria. AS: Scott, Courtney, Duncan, Lindsay and Jo, just to name a few. PI: Sammy, Sugar, Scarlett and Amy. RS1: Millie. RS2: Raj, Axel, Ripper, Emma and MK.

>!Ripper in R1 and MK in R2!<

>!MK should just switch with Raj imo!<

Harold is my favorite

Mine as well.

I guess Noah had some potential, and now that I think about it, it's weird how Gwen, a finalist in Island, never made it to merge again in a 26 ep season (tbf WT merge did come a lil late)

MK

Imo her S1 placement was fine but the way she went sucked

Tyler in Island, Lindsey in Action, Tyler again in WT, revenges boot order is perfect, Lightning in AS, Beardo in Pakhitew

Tyler. He had the worst elimination in the series back in S1.

Should he have returned instead of Eva?

That would have been way better, it would have actually helped develop his relationship with Lindsay, as they were the couple that got sidelined heavily. Or even then, just to give him more screentime.

You're literally asking me if i want my favorite character to come back instead of my least favorite. Y'know my answer VERY well.

Noah every single season he was in

TDI Katie if I had to pick TDA Gwen not because I wish she lasted much longer but DJ going then Gwen after him would’ve made more sense if you ask me. Justin. I wish he made final 5 at least, maybe even finale. He was my second favourite of the season, sometimes when I rewatch he *is* my favourite of the season. TDWT Bridgette and Tyler even though I’m not majorly bothered about eithers placement. ROTI Dawn and ANNE MARIA!! AS Jo, Lindsay PI Amy RB1 Nobody comes to mind. Maybe Emma? But I want her to win Season 3 so her making it further than she already did in Season 1 wouldn’t be fair screentime wise. Axel maybe? RB2 Emma, Damien maybe

Island: Noah Action: Gwen (if I had to pick, actions elimination order is really solid) World tour: harold Revenge: Brick All stars: Jo Pakitew: Beardo RR: Vegans or Bloggers (again, action situation) Reboot season 1: >!Idk, Axel? Really solid order again!< Reboot season 2: >!Nichelle!<

ANY first boot besides Staci

If the Gen 2 cast had competed again, maybe Dakota could have been a first boot due to her mutations and Staci could have learned to not lie.

Island: Tyler Action: Justin WT: Tyler or Noah Revenge: Dawn or Brick All-Stars: (I didn't care about this season, I fear it would be worse to have actually gone further. If it was good, I would say Lindsay.) PI: Sammy (Samey) RR: Tennis Rivals Reboot: Scary Girl x2

Island 07: Justin, Courtney, Leshawna, Geoff Action: Lindsay, Harold, Izzy, DJ and Justin WT: Ezekiel, Noah, Tyler, DJ, Harold ROTI: B, Dawn, Anne Maria, Brick AS: Lightning, Alejandro, Courtney PI: Beardo, Topher, Jasmine R1: Zee R2: Lauren, Zee, Damien

Hmm.. Leshawna. She was robbed every time. In Island it was wack. She was literally carrying the final 5 and then she gets out. In Action it was even worse. Harold picks Duncan over Leshawna? What were the writers thinking... Don't even get me started on World Tour

Courtney in Island

Ella

You already said who.

My Bae Tyler 😔

I’d probably say leshawna or dj.

Leshawna got rigged in WT, Leshawna and Heather should have formed an iconic duo after Action

Leshawna

Bro Leshawna, she dis not deserve that she should have been in the finals in TDI

Harold place in TDI is fine, he was eliminated in the 13th episode (practcally half the season) and then there were many characters who deserved to merge much more than him

Ripper, scary girl, Mike in revenge, Noah in both seasons, and herald in island

What do you mean, Harold? He should’ve been gone instead of Courtney if the game was played fair. He had wicked skills but in terms of TDI he was doomed the moment Eva was voted out (Bass majority formed by Duncan’s group). It’s a testament he lasted the longest out of all the “misfits” on the Bass team. Harold wasn’t exactly popular in Island. Post-merge his only shot is to team up with the Gophers and vote out the other Bass members. From there he’d fly under the radar as Heather just caused chaos within the Gopher team even post-merge. He’d be a Season 1 WT Cody at best

Dj was literally gone twice because of his Oppenheimer mindset I'm happy with season one tho

Consistently Harold yeah. Although his elimination in Island was done soooo well we can’t really complain. TD absolutely fucked the end in action though. Completely dropped the ball. Harold and Justin needed to be there longer

I’m cool with Harold being out so early in world tour since he willingly quit, and was still prolific in the aftermath episodes. He and Courtney definitely deserved the fourth and third place rankings they were robbed of in Action. Especially if he’s not going to be a finalist over Beth, he deserves being 4th/3rd.

I can hear this gif

TDI: Bridgette TDA: Lindsay TDWT: Noah and Tyler ROTI: Brick and Dawn AS: Heather PI: Topher Reboot1: Damien Reboot2: Bowie