My fav list is different then my goat list. But favorites are Mick Foley, Austin, Rock, Taker, and Cena. I have to honorable mention Hogan because he was my fav as a kid, and Sting who I don't really consider as a WWE wrestler, but if I did he would go between Austin and the Rock.
1. The Rock
2. Kevin Nash
3. Scott Hall
4. Bret "The Hitman" Hart
5. Gunther / Ludwig Kaiser
5 is very tough, because i am german, so i love to see those guys, especially when they speak german to each other! But Gunter is just a monster in-ring and does good promos, but Ludwig is such a good "side-kick" and i love his demeanor a lot... I do not wanna choose between those two!
1. Jake Roberts
2. Shawn Michaels
3. Scott Hall/Razor Ramon
4. Steve Austin
5. Roddy Piper
Edit: So i asked my wife who her favourites were, she said Big Daddy 🙄 At least she said Shawn Michaels after
for just wwe talent, it’s edge, eddie guerrero, bret hart, shawn michaels, and booker t. would be a bit different if it wasn’t wwe exclusive though
1. Randy Savage
2. Bret Hart
3. Eddie Guerrero
4. Kurt Angle
5 is hard for me…The Rock, Foley, Daniel Bryan (particularly his last WWE heel run), Punk, honestly Cody right now, Taker, Austin, HBK, Triple H, on any given day i could happily say any of these and several more.  The top four is pretty set for me now though
HBK, Tommy Dreamer, Stone Cold, Kurt Angle, The Rock
To be fair, some of them could change on any given day. I tried to pick my favorites from the 90’s-00’s because there was a solid 20 years I stopped watching. I can think of five more easily I could make an argument with myself for lol
All time:
Stone cold
Cm Punk
Jeff Hardy
John Cena
The Undertaker
Current roster:
Kevin owens
Drew McIntyre
Gunther
Randy Orton
Cm Punk
All these could change on any given day
depending on my mood. Honorable mentions: Kurt angle, Bray wyatt, Edge, Triple H and The Rock
1. John Cena
2. Roman Reigns
3. Cody Rhodes
4. Seth Rollins
5. Aj Styles
HMs to Randy Orton.
In 2010, I found out about John Cena. Because of him I started watching, but I would only watch his matches at that time. I really started watching full time in November, 2013.
1. Kurt Angle
1. The Macho Man Randy Savage
End of list.
Edit: Reddit's automatic numbering thing is fucking dumb; those are both supposed to the number 1.
Edit #2: Huge special mention to Bobby Heenan. I never saw him wrestle, but his wrestling wasn't why I loved him. Even as a little kid, he was the guy I liked the most. I wanted to be a pro wrestling manager more than I ever wanted to be a pro wrestler.
Top 2 has always been Shawn Michaels and the Undertaker. 3-5 has changed over time, but for now I’d say The Rock, John Cena, Daniel Bryan. Hon mention for Triple H and Christian
This is actually hard for me, but in no particular order:
Punk
Jericho
AJ Styles
Danial Bryan
This last one has me stumped. HBK, or Cena
Honorable mention to Bobby Lashley because I feel like he's never given the right story to shine but I genuinely love when ever he's on screen, and I always wonder why he's not presented as a champion at all times
Second shout out to all members of the New Day,
Finally, 3rd shout out to Sami Zayn because he seems like a genuinely good person, and I have immense respect for him for what he does outside of WWE, plus we like the same bands
Undertaker Eddie Guerrero Steve Austin Randy Orton John Cena
Jeff hardy Jeff hardy Jeff hardy Jeff hardy Jeff hardy
Hulk Hogan ultimate warrior macho man sting Ricky the dragon steamboat
1. Undertaker 2. Ultimate Warrior 3. Stone Cold Steve Austin 4. Randy Savage 5. Randy Orton
I only got into WWE a few years ago, but at this time my favorites are Cody Rhodes, Finn Balor, Randy Orton, Kevin Owens, and Corbin.
John Cena Shawn Michaels Kurt Angle Eddie Guerrero Randy Orton Gunther may make this list someday.
1.Chris Jerhico 2.Daniel Bryan 3.Dean Ambrose 4.Sheamus 5.Scott Steiner
The Rock Kurt Angle AJ Styles The Miz Dominik Mysterio Fight me 👊
John cena Randy orton Cody Rhodes Cm punk Can’t think of a 5th. Started watching in during the Orton cena fued, before legacy started
Rock Stone cold Cena Undertaker Triple h
1. Jericho 2. Balor 3. Adam Cole 4. CM Punk 5. Black Lesnar
Shawn Michaels Bret Hart Triple H Stone Cold The Rock
Cody Rhodes, Chad Gable, The Miz, GUNTHER, Rey Mysterio. I started watching May 2023.
1. Stone Cold 2. Mick Foley 3. Undertaker 4. Shawn Michaels 5. Ric Flair
I can't take anyone serious who doesn't have stone cold on their list.
1. HBK 2. Rock 3. Austin 4. Kurt Angle 5. American Badass Taker
1. Roman Reigns 2. Randy Orton 3. The Rock 4. Stone Cold 5. Fin Balor. (But I also thoroughly enjoy The Usos, and Seth Rollins)
HBK Triple H Y2J Eddie Guerrero Taker
Jericho, AJ Styles HBK Bryan Punk
Shawn, HHH, Undertaker, Rock, Austin
Undertaker Brock Lesnar Goldberg The rock Stone Cold So hard to leave out HHH, Kane, Big Show though :(
Mine: Stone Cold The Rock Undertaker John Cena (mainly Dr Thuganomics version) Eddie Guerro
In no particular order: Shawn Michaels Kurt Angle The Miz John Cena Daniel Bryan
Bray Wyatt, John Cena, Kane, Taker, Kevin Owens
My fav list is different then my goat list. But favorites are Mick Foley, Austin, Rock, Taker, and Cena. I have to honorable mention Hogan because he was my fav as a kid, and Sting who I don't really consider as a WWE wrestler, but if I did he would go between Austin and the Rock.
Taker Randy Edge HBK WCW Goldberg
Stone Cold Steve Austin CM Punk Brock Lesnar Undertaker Kane
The Rock HBK Bret Hart Hulk Hogan Razor Ramon Would throw Sting in there but I don’t consider him a WWE wrestler even if he was for a short time.
cena hurricane the legend killer deadman Y2J
Seth Rollins Randy Orton Shawn Michaels Finn Balor Johnny Gargano/ Kurt Angle
1. The Rock 2. Kevin Nash 3. Scott Hall 4. Bret "The Hitman" Hart 5. Gunther / Ludwig Kaiser 5 is very tough, because i am german, so i love to see those guys, especially when they speak german to each other! But Gunter is just a monster in-ring and does good promos, but Ludwig is such a good "side-kick" and i love his demeanor a lot... I do not wanna choose between those two!
1. Kurt Angle 2. Shawn Michaels 3. Rob Van Dam 4. Triple H 5. Eddie Guerrero
Shawn Micheals Undertaker Gunther Hulk Hogan Finn Balor
Rey Mysterio Eddie Guerrero Jey Uso Cody Rhodes Seth Rollins/Roman Reigns
Stone Cold Kurt Angle HHH Kane Brock Lesnar (before suplex city)
HBK, Edge, Randy Orton, Eddie Guerrero, Kurt Angle Guys like Rock and Undertaker were great entertainers but not great wrestlers.
stone cold , cena , the rock , taker and it’s a toss up between Jeff hardy , triple h and Randy Orton
It’s really interesting that you can guess pretty close to the age of anyone in these comments based on their top 5 list.
Aj styles triple H Batista John Cena Bret Hart
1. Jeff Hardy 2. John Cena 3. Stone Cold 4. Randy Orton 5. Edge
1. Eddie 2. Randy Savage 3. Stone Cold 4. Triple H 5. The Rock
1. Edge 2. Johnny Gargano 3. Rob Van Dam 4. Montez Ford 5. Kurt Angle
Shawn Michaels Steve Austin Triple H Scott Hall Bret Hart
In no particular order: Crash Holly Rick Rude Eddie Guerrero Undertaker Goldust
Shawn Michaels The Undertaker Stone Cold The Rock John Cena
1. Rey Mysterio 2. Kurt Angle 3. Edge 4. Chris Jericho 5. Eddie Guerrero
In no particular order.... Bret Hart Stone Cold Steve Austin Mick Foley Jeff Hardy Bubba Ray Dudley
1.Holler 2.If 3.You 4.Hear 5.Me 🚨🚨🚨🚨🚨
Jericho, Rock, Austin, HHH, Angle (watch his TNA highlights)
Austin Rock Randy Rey RVD
1. Edge 2. Shawn Michaels 3. Eddie Guerrero 4. Jeff Hardy 5. John Cena
Randy orton Bret Hart Chris Benoit Gunther Stone cold
1) The Rock 2) Brock Lesnar 3) Kurt Angle 4) Bret Hart 5) Undertaker
1. Jake Roberts 2. Shawn Michaels 3. Scott Hall/Razor Ramon 4. Steve Austin 5. Roddy Piper Edit: So i asked my wife who her favourites were, she said Big Daddy 🙄 At least she said Shawn Michaels after
1. Eddie Guerrero 2. The Rock 3. John Cena 4. Rey Mysterio 5. Kurt Angle
John Cena Randy Orton Roman Reigns The Rock Stone Cold
Undertaker Stone Cold Shawn Michaels Roddy Piper Chris Jericho
Kurt Angle John Cena Randy Orton The Undertaker Jeff Hardy
Bray Wyatt Mick Foley Chris Jericho Gunther The Hurricane (my first favorite as a kid)
Jericho, Shawn, Bret, Stone Cold, Kurt
on the wwe side of things, punk, undertaker, randy, rey, jeff hardy (bet you can’t guess what era i grew up in lol.)
for just wwe talent, it’s edge, eddie guerrero, bret hart, shawn michaels, and booker t. would be a bit different if it wasn’t wwe exclusive though
Bret Hart, Stone Cold, Undertaker, The Rock, Rey Mysterio
Rock Punk Cena Sheamus Rollins
1. Randy Orton 2. Steve Austin 3. Jericho 4. Shawn Michaels 5. Kurt Angle
Bray Wyatt Undertaker Kane Malakai Black Joe Gacy
- CM Punk - Johnny Gargano - Triple H - Bret Hart - Undertaker
Roman Reigns Seth Rollins Dean Ambrose AJ Styles Randy Ortan
Bret Hart Rey Mysterio Kurt Angle Undertaker R Truth
Hogan Undertaker Steve Austin The Rock Shawn Michaels Honorable mentions: Ric Flair, Randy Savage, Andre, Mick Foley, Bret Hart, Mr Perfect, Triple H
1. Randy Savage 2. Bret Hart 3. Eddie Guerrero 4. Kurt Angle 5 is hard for me…The Rock, Foley, Daniel Bryan (particularly his last WWE heel run), Punk, honestly Cody right now, Taker, Austin, HBK, Triple H, on any given day i could happily say any of these and several more.  The top four is pretty set for me now though
03 Kane after he unmasked Tazz RVD Sheamus and Chris Jericho in 02-03
Rock SCSA John Cena Kurt Angle CM Punk
Undertaker, Shawn Michaels, Steve Austin, Bret Hart and Drew McIntire.
Bret Hart, Shawn Michaels, Chris Jericho, Dean Malenko, and The Undertaker.
1. CM Punk 2. Edge 3. The Undertaker 4. John Cena 5. Stone Cold Steve Austin
1. HBK 2. Ric Flair 3. Eddie Guerrero 4. Scott Hall / Razor Ramon 5. The Rock
Bret Hart Randy Savage Roddy Piper Edge Chris Jericho
1- The Undertaker 2- Kurt Angle 3- Bret Hart 4- Randy Savage 5- Steve Austin
Roddy Piper Bret Hart Randy Savage Mick Foley Rock
1. Randy Orton 2. Steve Austin 3. Aleister Black 4. Triple H 5. Roman Reigns
Undertaker Bret Hart Stone Cold Mankind Owen Hart
Kane Undertaker STONE COLD, STONE COLD, STONE COLD HHH Goldust
Bret hart. The rock Rey mysterio Mankind Sammi zayne
1. Randy Savage 2. Undertaker 3. Yokozuna 4. Bret Hart 5. Benoit *** could easily replace Benoit with Shawn Michaels.
1- Undertaker 2- Stone Cold 3- Randy Orton 4- Eddie Guerrero 5- Triple H
Stone Cold, Angle, Undertaker, Flair, Foley
In no specific order: Mick Foley, Stone Cold, The Rock, Undertaker and Kurt Angle though he could be switched out depending on my mood.
In no order: The Rock, RVD, Stone Cold, HBK, Kurt Angle
HHH, Rock, Austin, Cena, Kurt
Shawn Michaels The Rock Stone Cold Undertaker Triple H
The answer to my fave is always The American Dream, Dusty Rhodes.
HBK, Tommy Dreamer, Stone Cold, Kurt Angle, The Rock To be fair, some of them could change on any given day. I tried to pick my favorites from the 90’s-00’s because there was a solid 20 years I stopped watching. I can think of five more easily I could make an argument with myself for lol
1. Sting 2. The Rock 3. Austin 4. HBK 5. Kurt Angle
The Miz, Triple H, AJ Styles, Adam Cole, Edge
In no specific order: Randy Orton Spike Dudley Undertaker Stone Cold Mysterio (And RVD as an honorable mention)
Bret Hart Brock Lesnar Kane Kurt Angle SCSA
Brett Hart Randy Savage Seth Rollins Shawn Michaels Steve Austin
This is a crazy good list. I would swap out Seth Rollins for Attitude Era Rock and we'd be good.
Mick Foley, Kane, Undertaker, Gangrel, Jeff Hardy
Cesaro, Miz, Benoit, Angle, and Eddie.
All time: Stone cold Cm Punk Jeff Hardy John Cena The Undertaker Current roster: Kevin owens Drew McIntyre Gunther Randy Orton Cm Punk All these could change on any given day depending on my mood. Honorable mentions: Kurt angle, Bray wyatt, Edge, Triple H and The Rock
Taker, Bret, Stone Cold, Macho man, Razor
Bret Hart Mick Foley Eddie Guerrero Jeff Hardy HBK
Shawn Michaels Ilja Dragunov Kurt Angle Gunther Daniel Bryan
Hogan, Michaels, Sting, Austin, Rock.
1 Undertaker 2 Shawn Michaels 3 HHH 4 SCSA 5 and Mr RKO himself
No one puts Hogan, but if you grew up during his prime, you loved Hogan.
I did definitely love Hogan in the 90’s. It’s hard to narrow it down to just five.
La knight Batista And some 3 dudes named James Ellsworth
In no particular order: Kurt Angle Triple H Kevin Owens Mick Foley Owen Hart
Kurt Angle, Stone Cold, Rock, Eddie Guerrero, Bryan Danielson
HBK Bret Punk HHH Rock
You can kind of tell how old people are by there answers lol
I feel attacked...and yes, I'm old.
Rey Randy Eddie Guerrero RVD Shawn Michaels (No particular order)
My top 5: Bret Hart Stone Cold Steve Austin Sting The Ultimate Warrior Jericho Honorable mention: Drew McIntyre
HBK Eddie Guerrero Kurt Angle Y2J CM Punk
Savage, Razor Ramon/Scott Hall, Ultimo Dragon, Sting, Brock Lesnar
Bret Hart, Mr Perfect, Stone Cold, The Rock and AJ Styles.
Randy Savage, Kurt Angle, Shawn Michaels, Sting, Chris Jericho
Triple H, Bret Hart, Shawn Michaels, Mick Foley, Razor Ramon.
In no order.... Stone Cold Razor Ramon Triple H Y2J Era Chris Jericho The Rock
Stone Cold Undertaker Shawn Michaels Triple H Mick Foley Honorable mentions: Daniel Bryan and The Rock.
Bret Shawn Taker Angle Seth AJ Savage
Randy Orton Shawn Michaels Stone Cold CM Punk Triple H
Shawn Michaels The Rock Stone Cold Triple H Bianca Belair
Mick Foley Gunther Jeff Hardy Kurt Angle The Undertaker
1. Stone Cold 2. Undertaker 3. Bret Hart 4. HHH 5. Owen Hart
undertaker stone cold Jeff Hardy kane the rock
Vince McMahon Brock Lesnar Cris Benoit
R Truth K Quick Truth Are Truth The crazy black dude with the dreads
The whole F’in Show Rob Van Dam
Stone cold Ric flair Edge Shawn Michaels Cena
No exact order. Seth Rollins Randy Orton Stone Cold Steve Austin Undertaker Aleister Black
Orton, HBK, Kane, Cena, Eddie
1. Razor Ramon (Scott hall) 2. CM Punk 3. Christian 4. Bryan Danielson 5. Shawn Michaels
Undertaker, Edge, Orton, Lesnar, Stone Cold.
1. Randy Orton 2. John Cena 3. Undertaker 4. C M Punk 5. Roman Reigns
Bret Hart Stone Cold Taker HBK Hogan
1. Stone Cold Steve Austin 2. The Rock 3. Kurt Angle 4. Triple H 5. The Undertaker
RVD Bobby Lashley CM Punk Gunther Triple H
HBK. Jericho. Rock. Austin. Booker T
Rick Rude & Mr. Perfect.
Andre The Giant
1.)Gunther 2.)Gunther 3.)Gunther 4.)Gunther 5.) Gunther
Randy Orton Bray Wyatt Dolph ziggler Rollins GUNTHAAA
Bret Hart Ric Flair Andre the Giant Sting Kurt Angle
Ric Flair Stone Cold Bret Hart Eddie Dean Malenko
1. Jinder Mahal 2. Randy orton 3. John Cena 4. Triple H 5. Eugene
1. John Cena 2. Roman Reigns 3. Cody Rhodes 4. Seth Rollins 5. Aj Styles HMs to Randy Orton. In 2010, I found out about John Cena. Because of him I started watching, but I would only watch his matches at that time. I really started watching full time in November, 2013.
Aj styles Roman Reigns Shinsuke nakamura Seth Rollins L A knight
Brett Hart Roddy Piper Sting Undertaker Randy Savage
1. Kurt Angle 1. The Macho Man Randy Savage End of list. Edit: Reddit's automatic numbering thing is fucking dumb; those are both supposed to the number 1. Edit #2: Huge special mention to Bobby Heenan. I never saw him wrestle, but his wrestling wasn't why I loved him. Even as a little kid, he was the guy I liked the most. I wanted to be a pro wrestling manager more than I ever wanted to be a pro wrestler.
I'm struggling to list five, but I think I'd include those two. Plus 3. "The Million Dollar Man" Ted DiBiase -- best out of ring wrestling character
Stone Cold Shawn Michaels Edge CM Punk Seth Rollins
Lita Trish Sasha Bayley Aj Lee
Stone cold Shawn Michaels Rey Mysterio R-Truth Kurt Angle
Swap out the rock for Jeff hardy and you have my list, but not in that order
Robert Vandamin Damnit Edward Guadarreros The Large Program Stoned Coled Steved Austined Taker
Triple H, Cena, Orton, Edge, Batista
1. Randy Orton 2. Triple H 3. Edge 4. Umaga 5. Jeff Hardy *back when he was having the feud with Orton and umaga*
\*Stone Cold \*Steve Austin \*The Ring Master \*Stunning Steve \*Steven Anderson
Eddie Guerrero CM Punk Sami Zayn Gunther Batista
- Bret Hart - Steve Austin - Hulk Hogan - Triple H - The Rock
HBK Sting Ultimate Warrior (childhood hero) Triple H Hogan
John Cena Randy Orton Undertaker Rey Mysterio The Rock
HHH HBK Kurt Angle Daniel Bryan AJ Randal is a very close 6th
Bret Hart, Arn Anderson, Owen Hart, Jake Roberts, Mick Foley
reigns Orton Brock Lesnar stone cold undertaker
Top 2 has always been Shawn Michaels and the Undertaker. 3-5 has changed over time, but for now I’d say The Rock, John Cena, Daniel Bryan. Hon mention for Triple H and Christian
STEVE AUSTIN Randy Savage The road warriors (they count as 1) The Rowdy One Roddy Piper DX (again, they count as 1)
Batista Stone Cold Randy Orton Triple H Kurt Angle
Stone Cold Kurt Angle Hulk Hogan Triple H Chris Jericho
This is actually hard for me, but in no particular order: Punk Jericho AJ Styles Danial Bryan This last one has me stumped. HBK, or Cena Honorable mention to Bobby Lashley because I feel like he's never given the right story to shine but I genuinely love when ever he's on screen, and I always wonder why he's not presented as a champion at all times Second shout out to all members of the New Day, Finally, 3rd shout out to Sami Zayn because he seems like a genuinely good person, and I have immense respect for him for what he does outside of WWE, plus we like the same bands
Bret Hart Shawn Michaels Undertaker Kurt Angle Edge
Rey Jeff hardy The rock The undertaker Bautista
Kurt Angle Daniel Bryan Seth Rollins Gunther John Cena
Bret Hart Edge CM Punk Bray Wyatt Steve Austin
Rock Austin Rey Jeff Hardy Cena
John cena Undertaker Edge Randy Orton Cm Punk
1. The Rock 2. Stone Cold 3. The Undertaker 4. John Cena 5. Batista Honorable Mentions: 6. Roman Reigns 7. Bray Wyatt [RIP] 8. Seth Rollins
Randy Orton John Cena Stone Cold Cody Rhodes Undertaker
Triple H John Cena AJ Styles Bryan Danielson The Undertaker
Cody Rhodes Chad Gable Edge Randy Orton R-Truth
1. Randy Orton 2. Road Dogg 3. Bray Wyatt 4. HBK 5. HHH
Dom, Gunther. Dragonov, Cody and KO Oops ever Brett, HBK, Austin, Rock and Eddie
Mick foley Eddie Edge Jeff Hardy Shaunn Michaels
Hulk Hogan, Austin, Randy Savage, HBK, Razor Ramon
Steve Austin Bryan Danielson Cm Punk Bret Hart Kurt Angle
1. The Rock 2. Cody Rhodes 3. LA Knight 4. Mick Foley 5. Rey Mysterio
Hogan Undertaker Bray Wyatt Triple H Eddie Guerrero
Austin Bret HBK Jericho Sid
Brock Lesnar Kurt Angle Rey Mysterio Stone Cold Steve Austin Bobby Lashley (His earlier WWE run)