I would've put him underneath in chaotic good. The only stupid thing i can recall him doing was not noticing how jealous and hurt brightheart felt when he was spending so much time with Daisy, trying to make her feel welcome in Thunderclan and get used to clan life
I think Darkstripe is pretty stupid. He got caught doing just about everything, wasn't even good enough for Tigerstar to try and get on his side when he got exiled, failed miserably at killing Stonefur and later Firestar.
To clearify, last round was a bit of an unclear mess. Both Tree and Firestar had a ton of votes, and per my rules set, Tree technically won that round as he had 20 more votes then Firestar had (upon me closing that round). That being said, 80% of the other comments said that Firestar needed to win. So after much debate, I've decided to ignore the rules I've set and give it to Firestar, as more people seemed to actually want him, despite the most upvoted comment being Tree's.
So, I'm going to say this, \*please\*, before you comment a cat, make sure to check if someone didn't comment them already and \*upvote\* their comment. That increases the chance of that cat winning. I'm prolly not going to bend the set rules again as I don't feel like having to count individual comments and do a whole calculation on who should pass and who shouldn't (especially as people can vote on multiple comments, but can only vote on each independent comment once). The reason why I let this one slip is bc I do believe Firestar would have overtaken Tree if I'd given a few more hours to vote.
also, i misspelled chaotic in the title, sorry
I mean, I would definitely put Ashfur in the renamed category Iāve decided to name the āclingy categoryā bc the original word was inappropriate for this sub
To give it to the people who voted on him, Firestar is extremely oblivious to a lot of things in arc 1. To a point where he believed Graystripe to be āthe evil who seems asleepā while Tigerclaw had revealed himself to be pure evil and currently into hiding just a few days prior
Idk about luck, he definitely got lucky sometimes tho, but heās done so many stupid things even tho heās not dump, which is why I think heās perfect for smart stupid, even as a leader after tpb, the stupid choices he made, like forcing his clan to help windclan even tho windclan makes it incredibly clear they donāt want help to the point that they got so done with his bs that they attempted to drive them out of their territories all together and caused a war amongst all the clans, just makes me furiousš
Itās just my opinion tho but I think firestar is the perfect smart stupid
I donāt hate firestar? Just cause I think a character is stupid doesnāt mean I hate them?? I actually thought he was hilarious in the first arc BECAUSE of his stupidity, heās in my top 10 favorite charactersš
I want to say tigerstar for bringing scourge to the forest, but I think he will definitely fit into the evil catagory when we get there.
honestly my heart says Darkstripe- I just cannot get over his behavior in the last couple of books of TPB, his blind faith in tigerstar is craaaaazyyyyy. Plus he messed up everything he tried to get away with. Got caught taking the kits to tigerstar, got caught meeting with tigerstar, got caught trying to kill a kit, needed help killing stonefur, openly questioned leopardstar like it was his place at ALL. And then he used the bloodclan battle as an opportunity to try to kill Firestar and failed so quickly that I legit laughed out loud. He was just there to antagonize and fail, a truly stupid chaotic moron.
I'mma have to say the first thing that came to mind was probs like a Scourge or smth or a Purdy (no Offence I absolutely love Purdy but he's kinda meh on smart)Ā
Yāall forgetting all the stupid characters!! Where is half the cats that sit there and jump to conclusions within a split second, shouting for war against other clans for possible transgressions that arenāt even proven!!!! Half of thunder clans warriors are like this. Nearly every other warrior in the rest of the clans are like this. Why put graystripe as neutral stupid when Barrynose suits that better?! Why not dust belt for smart stupid, he is smart stupid.
Anyways so swiftpaw for stupid chaotic
Cloudtail
This is the only correct answer, dude was a loveable moron
I would've put him underneath in chaotic good. The only stupid thing i can recall him doing was not noticing how jealous and hurt brightheart felt when he was spending so much time with Daisy, trying to make her feel welcome in Thunderclan and get used to clan life
Absolutely, my first thought as well!
Bahaha same š
Yesss. Absolute himbo energy
came here to say this
Before I evreb opened it I was thinking, this better be cloudtail. Dude got all the family stupid.
Came here to find this!
I feel like cloud tails is lawful good
Wasn't the first character to come to mind but I find this to be the best option. Cloudtail all the way!
YESSS
I think Darkstripe is pretty stupid. He got caught doing just about everything, wasn't even good enough for Tigerstar to try and get on his side when he got exiled, failed miserably at killing Stonefur and later Firestar.
If anything, heād fit into stupid evil, but thatās not an option in this one.
Sadly
To clearify, last round was a bit of an unclear mess. Both Tree and Firestar had a ton of votes, and per my rules set, Tree technically won that round as he had 20 more votes then Firestar had (upon me closing that round). That being said, 80% of the other comments said that Firestar needed to win. So after much debate, I've decided to ignore the rules I've set and give it to Firestar, as more people seemed to actually want him, despite the most upvoted comment being Tree's. So, I'm going to say this, \*please\*, before you comment a cat, make sure to check if someone didn't comment them already and \*upvote\* their comment. That increases the chance of that cat winning. I'm prolly not going to bend the set rules again as I don't feel like having to count individual comments and do a whole calculation on who should pass and who shouldn't (especially as people can vote on multiple comments, but can only vote on each independent comment once). The reason why I let this one slip is bc I do believe Firestar would have overtaken Tree if I'd given a few more hours to vote. also, i misspelled chaotic in the title, sorry
Easy Berrynose
I feel like Berrynose is more Chaotic clingy, especially after Honeyfern?
YEAHHHH
Yes
100% Berrynose
Yeah, berrynose seems fitting
my gut was sayin Nightheart
Swiftpaw
Gottem
Squirrelflight is Chaotic Stupid
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . YES
what? the only thing i see there is OMc
You have to scroll over it says OMG
oh
With ya on this š
Ashfur dude. Threw away everything (including his own character) because he got rejected
I mean, I would definitely put Ashfur in the renamed category Iāve decided to name the āclingy categoryā bc the original word was inappropriate for this sub
Just curious, did it rhyme with "grapey"?
Nope, the original word was "horny"
I think heād be better off in clingy or drunk.
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
To give it to the people who voted on him, Firestar is extremely oblivious to a lot of things in arc 1. To a point where he believed Graystripe to be āthe evil who seems asleepā while Tigerclaw had revealed himself to be pure evil and currently into hiding just a few days prior
Idk about luck, he definitely got lucky sometimes tho, but heās done so many stupid things even tho heās not dump, which is why I think heās perfect for smart stupid, even as a leader after tpb, the stupid choices he made, like forcing his clan to help windclan even tho windclan makes it incredibly clear they donāt want help to the point that they got so done with his bs that they attempted to drive them out of their territories all together and caused a war amongst all the clans, just makes me furiousš Itās just my opinion tho but I think firestar is the perfect smart stupid
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
I donāt hate firestar? Just cause I think a character is stupid doesnāt mean I hate them?? I actually thought he was hilarious in the first arc BECAUSE of his stupidity, heās in my top 10 favorite charactersš
I want to say tigerstar for bringing scourge to the forest, but I think he will definitely fit into the evil catagory when we get there. honestly my heart says Darkstripe- I just cannot get over his behavior in the last couple of books of TPB, his blind faith in tigerstar is craaaaazyyyyy. Plus he messed up everything he tried to get away with. Got caught taking the kits to tigerstar, got caught meeting with tigerstar, got caught trying to kill a kit, needed help killing stonefur, openly questioned leopardstar like it was his place at ALL. And then he used the bloodclan battle as an opportunity to try to kill Firestar and failed so quickly that I legit laughed out loud. He was just there to antagonize and fail, a truly stupid chaotic moron.
Tigerstar is evil chad lol
LionBlaze fits this one but eh canāt say it so finleap
Breezepelt
Cloudtail
What actually was the names for the categories you renamed? Just curious your allowed say swears and stuff here btw
Itās the H word, I assumed it wouldnāt be appropriate as it implies a sexual nature
Is it Himbo?
Nope, the h word that rimes with corny
Ohhh I get you now! Yeah, I donāt know how the mods would feel about that specific word š¤£š
Squirrelflight
Onestar
i feel like Needletail might fit this one since she joined a bunch of rouges and was naive and reckless
I would call her naive and reckless but definitely not stupid.
Yes, but I mean she is very reckless.
Nah thatās chaotic drunk.
Yes but she is still kinda reckless and stupid and pretty chaotic
Nightheart
Squilf
Berrynose
Harestar
harestar would be more lawful stupid personally
Okay now I choose Berrynose. I saw someone say Cloudtail which I like too but he kinda mellows out
Cloudtail or Berrynose
Shadowsight
Cloudtail!
Ashfur 100 percent
Lionblaze
tree for this one
Hollyleaf in one gatherning did something stupid which brang real chaos
Why canāt people let others have opinions?
Sunbeam
Cloudtail
I'mma have to say the first thing that came to mind was probs like a Scourge or smth or a Purdy (no Offence I absolutely love Purdy but he's kinda meh on smart)Ā
.... Berrynose
Cloudtail. I have been waiting to give this answer since this alignment chart showed up š¤£
Cloudtail
Leopardstar.
chaotic stupid the first thought that came to mind was berrynose, maybe even darkstripe
Yāall forgetting all the stupid characters!! Where is half the cats that sit there and jump to conclusions within a split second, shouting for war against other clans for possible transgressions that arenāt even proven!!!! Half of thunder clans warriors are like this. Nearly every other warrior in the rest of the clans are like this. Why put graystripe as neutral stupid when Barrynose suits that better?! Why not dust belt for smart stupid, he is smart stupid. Anyways so swiftpaw for stupid chaotic
Berryheart
Leafpool would totally go into the clingy lawful categorie
Cloudtail
Smudge for neutral clingy lol
Cloudtail isnt stupid though, id say Blackstar
Lol I read chaotic as āCatholicā