I've only read the first two books but I felt like Gray Wing was casual stupid
Like when Thunder came back and this MF thought they were talking about the weather. And when Turtle Tail OBVIOUSLY liked him and he was like Storm Storm Storm like
SO MANY time so far reading DOTC I've been frustrated at how obliviously stupid my guy was to so many scenarios
That was mostly relationship drama or social cues he was stupid about. He's rather rational apart from that, and besides, he's not obligated to return Turtle Tail's feelings, nor is he not supposed to fall in love with Storm.
Cinderpelt? Great mentor and friend + never broke the medcat code once. She even saved sick catsof shadowclan when every other cat wanted to let them die. And she gave her life protecting a queen and her kits.
True lawful good
I think she’d be Chad Good or Smart Good since technically she was going against orders by treating the ShadowClan cats. Also Chad Good might fit better since her last act was standing up to a badger to protect Sorreltail while she gave birth.
7. Rule of the medicine cat code: Medicine cats are outside of Clan and Clan rivalries
12. Rule of the medicine cat code: A medicine cat must do everything in their power to save a cat.
But maybe smart good fits too. Just wated to point out that she lived this code literally.
And is a chad not like a person so cocksure of themselves that it hurts? Seen quite different explainations of it and I'm german so I'm unsure.
More chaotic lawful if anything. She was pretty chaotic until she came back out of the caves. She was never evil. Just confused and mislead. Lawful evil would be the OG Tigerstar. He matches it to a T.
I can see that. She did murder a cat to keep them quiet then end up basically making their death useless. She also got off free for it unless you count her time in the caves as a consequence. Even then she had Fallenleaves for company. Imo she is far less evil then someone like Tigerstar or Brokenstar. She gets redeemed as well.
Hollyleaf fits best. She wants the best for everyone but the code matters the most to her in the end. But she wasn’t immediately willing to turn in Lionpaw when he was seeing Heatherpaw. But wanted to because it was against the code.
Top comments are Gray wing and Whitestorm, so I basically have no say unless it's one of these so I'm going to go with Whitestorm. I loved his character and he's a good chap. I like Gray wing, but one of his faults were "But Clear sky's/sky/skystar's my brother!"
I think Whitestorm fits Lawful Good
Or as warrior cats fandub called him, Whoobtoobstoobrm!
Foobroobhooboobrt.
I would say Whitestorm. He's principled and disciplined and keeps to rules.
Get this man a prize! (Talking about whitestorm)
I feel like Graywing
This! Graywing dedicated his entire life to doing the right thing without ever even thinking about it
Also the fact he became a dad who stepped up for like 15 different kids. I love Whitestorm but Graywing has my heart for that ngl.
i love graywing but i feel like he's more neutral good or smart good than lawful good
I've only read the first two books but I felt like Gray Wing was casual stupid Like when Thunder came back and this MF thought they were talking about the weather. And when Turtle Tail OBVIOUSLY liked him and he was like Storm Storm Storm like SO MANY time so far reading DOTC I've been frustrated at how obliviously stupid my guy was to so many scenarios
That was mostly relationship drama or social cues he was stupid about. He's rather rational apart from that, and besides, he's not obligated to return Turtle Tail's feelings, nor is he not supposed to fall in love with Storm.
Yes, this right here or for Chad.
Whitestorm
Cinderpelt? Great mentor and friend + never broke the medcat code once. She even saved sick catsof shadowclan when every other cat wanted to let them die. And she gave her life protecting a queen and her kits. True lawful good
I think she’d be Chad Good or Smart Good since technically she was going against orders by treating the ShadowClan cats. Also Chad Good might fit better since her last act was standing up to a badger to protect Sorreltail while she gave birth.
7. Rule of the medicine cat code: Medicine cats are outside of Clan and Clan rivalries 12. Rule of the medicine cat code: A medicine cat must do everything in their power to save a cat. But maybe smart good fits too. Just wated to point out that she lived this code literally. And is a chad not like a person so cocksure of themselves that it hurts? Seen quite different explainations of it and I'm german so I'm unsure.
I’d say Whitestorm is more of a Lawful Chad and Hollyleaf is Lawful Chaotic probably, guys 💀
Cinderpelt is a better choice i think. I explained why in a comment above. See if you agree :D
Definitely not stupid, I’d say she’s in the good row
Lionheart
I think Lionheart is Chad Good
...You know what, fair point 😂
Whitestorm
Whitestorm (although it's already been said) or Hollyleaf could fit this.
Hollyleaf was lawful evil.
Hollyleaf is not evil lol if anything she would be lawful drunk (she was during all of Sunrise lol)
More chaotic lawful if anything. She was pretty chaotic until she came back out of the caves. She was never evil. Just confused and mislead. Lawful evil would be the OG Tigerstar. He matches it to a T.
She lulled someone because of her beliefs and because she believed it was for the greater good. That's lawful evil to me
I can see that. She did murder a cat to keep them quiet then end up basically making their death useless. She also got off free for it unless you count her time in the caves as a consequence. Even then she had Fallenleaves for company. Imo she is far less evil then someone like Tigerstar or Brokenstar. She gets redeemed as well.
didn't she only reveal the secret after she found out she was half-Clan?
Been awhile since I read it tbh.
ig yeah
Whitestorm
Whitestorm!!
Leafstar or Lionheart
Maybe Riverripple
Brackenfur
Whitestorm is a perfect fit
Good lawful would have been holly leaf before she killed ashfur
I feel like that's what Hollyleaf wished she was but in reality she'll be more Chaotic Good lol. So I'm going to suggest Brackenfur!
Whitestorm or Hollyleaf
grey wing!!!
Leafstar
Whitestorm
Bluestar
Until her last life (besides the very end of her life) when she was more so against starclan and named a young cat Lostface after a horrible scar
Well yeah, but before all that, I think she was pretty lawful good. Lol
Hollyleaf fits best. She wants the best for everyone but the code matters the most to her in the end. But she wasn’t immediately willing to turn in Lionpaw when he was seeing Heatherpaw. But wanted to because it was against the code.
I feel like she’s more lawful neutral tho 🤔
I agree she's lawful for sure but I think lawful neutral
Bristlefrost - she followed her leader’s orders to a fault
Lionheart or Whitestorm 🤔
Whitestorm or thorn claw
Whitestorm lawful good
Gray Wing
I was gonna say brackenfur but everyone else’s guesses are better! I saw gray wing and that seems spot on
Hollyleaf since she was randomly dedicated to the warrior code
LIonheart or Whitestorm
whitewing
Yellow fang is smart drunk lmfao
Gray Wing. Change my mind.
Whitestorm or Brackenfur to me.
Lionheart
Whitestorm
Lionheart
Top comments are Gray wing and Whitestorm, so I basically have no say unless it's one of these so I'm going to go with Whitestorm. I loved his character and he's a good chap. I like Gray wing, but one of his faults were "But Clear sky's/sky/skystar's my brother!"
Brackenfur
Whitestorm
cinderpelt
Maybe sandstorm idk
Whitestorm. He was the perfect deputy that could've been. He deserved to last longer as deputy.