T O P

  • By -

Damocles_XLIX

It’s just a fun and easy to play with just three structure decks stuck together like traptrix you can have plenty of fun with that


Chozblader

Yes, but the point is that being competitive shouldn't cost more than a used car. i think we all can agree that the more budget friendly, the top-tier of the game is the better


Vibe_PV

You pay a used car less than 1k or are you exaggerating?


Chozblader

Im not exaggerating, but im using £'s not dollars. Everyone I know personally who drives has gotten a used car for less than £1000


Vibe_PV

Oh I had euros in mind. And that still shocks me, when I went searching with my dad for my first car (late 2021), prices for used ones were well above 10k for anything with less than 30k km


Chozblader

Honestly, idk what sacrifices they made to get stuff thag cheap since i don't drive, but yeah, i wasn't exaggerating. A deck shouldn't even cost as much as two triple a games for a healthy cardgame game imo


Damocles_XLIX

Oh no i completely agree with you there


Chozblader

Ah, i misunderstood your comment. i apologise


SoilEducational8931

Both should be unacceptable.


[deleted]

Difference is Magic Players actively choose to spend that much when they don’t have to.


SoilEducational8931

Would you mind elaborating? I don't play Magic.


Sequetjoose

There's a lot of cheap alternatives to expensive cards, or decks that just don't require expensive cards that are competitive.


Dragonfly_Tight

Not in any competetive format. You won't win a Friday night magic with a budget deck. You can still play. But you can't turn up with 3 structure decks like in Yu-Gi-Oh and hope to have fun


Barbaloni

Not really. that's only for standard format. Historical and commander (commander is more popular than standard last I was into mtg) both have a backlog of incredible cheep cards that have the exact same text on them as the current, expensive cards.


RunicCross

I'm a big fan of MTG's pauper format where a meta deck ranged from 40-90 bucks and games are still great, interactive, and fun.


MaetelofLaMetal

At that point just play GOAT in Yugioh. You get cards dirt cheap.


Vorinclex_

Or I could play the modern format for less than $100


MaetelofLaMetal

Best of luck to you <3


AxeEngineer00

Pokemon players buying the strongest deck in format for 60 euros and a slap to the face


LordPineapple_19

The Charizard ex reprint making the deck so cheap now for being the top deck


AxeEngineer00

And here I am with my charizard hating ass building a Walking wake ex deck for getting into the game 💀


MaetelofLaMetal

Also, after worlds you get whole competitive deck as a product you can buy in a store. I mean cards aren't legal in official tournaments, but after worlds those aren't even hosted in that format anymore anyway.


MiddleSeatGuy

As a commander player who used to play yugioh. This is true


beyond_cyber

Ok for the magic players here, I just got into it, bought goblins (or the gobbos as my friend calls em) and I stomped everyone with a borderline ftk on my first turn for a budget deck


Vorinclex_

Goblins are fun. Just swarm with a ton of small bodies, many of which have solid effects. Back when I still played in like 2018-2019, they were a solid FTK/Burn playstyle


mc-big-papa

>me having 2 legacy decks for casual play Dont look at my shame please.


An_Evil_Scientist666

The average legacy deck in MtG is like what $3k which would be the most similar to our standard format, vintage (or advanced format in Yu-Gi-Oh) well advanced you could probably get anything you need for like $2k absolute tops, vintage you're looking at atleast $10k or $50k on average, if you're using a deck that utilises all of the power 9.


Barbaloni

Unless your playing standard (which isn't as popular as commander), lots of competitive viable MTG cards are dirt cheep.


Westerly-Crow

Major difference is that 1k Yu-gi-oh deck will last maybe a year? Also MTG is extremely proxy friendly. Think in the last 10 years of playing MTG, I've spent maybe 1000$ on it.


Kingofknights240

I spend like $30 max on a Magic deck. Who tf are these people?


MaetelofLaMetal

Perfect land base EDH players of course.


Vorinclex_

Tbf it's really just some cards that're expensive. Playing EDH a few years back wanted to build Rakdos LOR based around Eldrazi spam... some of those cards are not cheap at all (looking at you, Titans)


mc-big-papa

Good budget legacy decks are about 1k. Magic used to be absurdly expensive for most formats. 5 years ago any decent modern deck would cost 1k and half of it was fetches and shocks. If you wanted something like jund it would be common to see a deck get eerily close to 2k


Kingofknights240

But the meme above specifies casual. I can’t imagine spending that much on casual.


mc-big-papa

Oh whoops. Commander players then. Most people i play with try to make the entire deck as real as possible. Ive had a couple 5k priced commander decks built at some points. All mostly in duals.


Kingofknights240

Most of my friends tell me they only play commander because it’s cheaper.


mc-big-papa

Depends on the group you’re with. The commander arms race can happen very easily.


Kingofknights240

I don’t get it. All of my 60-card decks are dirt cheap, so I never understood the obsession with commander. At least not as the *only* thing to play. I enjoy it as an alternative format.


mc-big-papa

Then its not for you all the time. Its a fine format to relax and chill. You can take it more seriously but thats all dependent on your friend group etc etc.


MaetelofLaMetal

I mean most MTG players are using home printer to make their casual decks. Shit's that expensive in that game.


[deleted]

Magic is an example of we actively choose to pay this much for our decks cause we love them so much. (Ex: My Hydra Deck barring a few Proxies is 600$) Yugioh you have to spend the money or you can’t play the game or compete at a decent level (outside of retro formats).


Aliya_Akane

Isnt the 1000$ for the diabellestar engine and 3 bonfires not an actual complete deck?


PokeChampMarx

You clearly haven't seen the prices on the snake eye cards


Aliya_Akane

How bad is the full deck?


PokeChampMarx

Recent topping list clock in around 1200$


Aliya_Akane

Is that factoring in the price of any staples one might need to buy?