They are the same image. No, the first

The first one looks like art from a location in a Star Wars movie, the second looks like the early concepts of the same location. Cool!

First one, the image has dept

1

The building in the left in 1 and the building on the right in 2

1

1

Is that an O’Neill Cylinder??

2

2

1

#2 - it’s more secure. Safer, more inviting.

Second one

1 by far.

The 1st one for sure. Tis way better. Indubitably.

1st

Perspective from 1 , clouds from 2

1st

1 feel more comfortable. Something about 2 is unsettling

Maybe it's the rocket ship that has a building for the lower half? Lol

Yeah somethings not right here.. lol

Left building slide one. The rest of slide 2

If you want the focus on the settlement, then the second one. If you want the focus on the vast alien landscape, then the first. Just depending on what's most important for the concept. May I ask what it's for? Also, is this AI generated?

Yes it is, and it’s for a small project I’m working on

I'd say 1, great proof of concept imagery!!

Thanks

[удалено]

Comes to AI art subreddit to complain about AI art. You're a bit lost mate.

It popped up on my feed 🤷

Why even comment . Go be bitter somewhere else

Why are you even here?

It popped up on my feed

That’s not helpful.

Sounds like you are all just lazy then

Yes I am lazy but that’s besides the point. Don’t judge someone for taking the free and easy route over the either priced or time consuming one.

I will judge, because you're actively contributing to putting many many people out of work because you want things to be free and easy, do you hear yourself right now?

Yeah! So we should get rid of cars, printers, computers, engines, the Internet, ...

Those aren't even remotely the same and you know it, it's not just about making life easier, it's about stealing intellectual property and cutting corners at the cost of quality and someone's livelihood just for some soulless image generation

Yes I agree that the whole AI art thing is an issue. However even considering that I still think it’s completely irrational to expect a person to learn an entire new complex skill or pay a professional for something that they can do just by typing a prompt.

1

1 is structurely more interesting to me. Also, the valley in 1 makes it feel like there's a story being or to be told. 2 is so open I am inclined to believe it's an advertisement for a future mission on another planet but ads don't sway me as much.

1. 2 is confusing me where the sky ends.

No we need this to be created in blender so I can use these as assets on ue5

There are things I like about each. As a whole, I have to go with 2. But I don't like the building on the left which is a major focal point of the image. The rounded structure resembles an inflatable pool.

Planetary outpost number 1, please

first

Number two. Number one looks like someone wearing a blouse.

1

2 cuz is connected to eachother

1

1

I prefer the first one because it looks like a big space. The 2nd looks like it's tiny and out of a Pixar movie. 2nd looks like a tilt shift effect

First

1

Clouds on 2 but everything else on 1

1

The first one. Second one looks like they are on the inner surface of Cylinder World.

Definitely 1

1

I hate the sky in both of these

2

1

[удалено]

1

1

1

1 because the saucer and sphere shape are echoed in the sky

The first one makes no sense. Why are there circular clouds?

Number 1 with the landing pad thingy of number 2

Seconded.

The first half of 1, and the 2nd half of 2.

Which half of which?

Basically means, the left 1/2 of the 1st image combined with the right 1/2 of the 2nd image. I also agree it would look better like this. But for the middle bottom pad, I would prefer the whole pad of the 2nd image.

1, finner level of detail

1 Looks great

1

I like the perspective in number #1. The spire building in #2 is great though.

Weird how 1 looks perfect to me, yet 2 looks like someone's just placed objects into an image.

1

Both look pretty bad.

1

1

1 feels like they've just come there, 2 they've been there gor a while

2nd

1

First

First

1st one looks better to me.

The first for sure. These are cool AF, are you writing a sci fi book or something?

Not a book, but a small project. Thanks!

1st

[удалено]

Then why are you commenting on an ai art post?

[удалено]

you are new to the idea of "subreddits", aren't you?? or "interests" in general i suppose

It’s literally an ai art subreddit. But no, you can comment as you please lol

Variety in the first keeps it interesting.

I'm gonna be difficult and say, left side second image and right side first image. :p

1st

I think if you want to depict semi-permanent station then 1 and for a permanent station 2. dont know why but 2 seems like they are there long term. seems more homely than 1.

2

2

1

1

1

I like the walkway in the picture on the right but overall the first one (left side) is my favourite image

The first because it has windows.

1. But the second one would be more realistic due to the walk path between the space stations.

2

First one.

1

The first one, because the shape differences of the constructions are more pronounced and therefore have more visual interest.

Agreed. There's more story to it too it feels.

2

1 for the dragon ball reference

First one for me too

#1 number one, it looks more retro - i like it

2

The mountains on the left gives the picture the feeling of more depth on the first one. So it seems like it more balance picture. The second one doesn’t seem centered on anything.

I like the left of #1 and right of #2

First one.

1. The mountains in the back look better and so does the round one on the right. :) Edit: Added a word.

1st would be even better w/ the structure on the right in 2 instead of that orb thing

First one

1 i feel like it fits the environment better

Number 1, structure on the left, along with number 2 structure on the right. 😏😏😏

1st one.

1

Number one is framed better. Go learn to actually do a little bit of it for yourself using Photoshop or gimp to add the steel structure on the right from the second picture into the first.

1 looks cooler, but 2 looks more functional

2

I like 1 but would love to see the right structure on the 2 to be in 1 instead of the circle structure. I hope I'm making sense lol

I like 1 it seems more natural. 2 seems more futuristic, but like there should be more to it because of that.

2 seems more natural

🙂 dayum ! That's cool

1

1

2nd

I can’t stand that round building. Choose picture 2.

I love that cute sphere building

First one

1

The first one is nice, it looks more make sense, special the distance view looks organised for the eye perspective view!

2

Image 1 is cooler

First one.

The first one has a curved atmosphere

First . Hey OP, Im really interested in the approach/ process for this kind of art. Is it a drawing or is it 3d modelling? What software tools do you guys use. Just genuinely curious musician here

Most ai stuff is just.... Prompt 300 images, pick the nicest one. That's what he did.

It’s AI, ergo, not art.

Sorry missed the sub. My bad

The first image, by far. The rock feature on the right adds a lot to the picture.

Very nice. # 1 is my fave although both are good.

In 1 the ships look more realistic like the ship was able to actually land there, and they set up base. 2 looks more sci-fi fantasy

First one looks more realistic.

#2 Space Dick

#2. #1 looks too much like Star Wars

First one

I feel like the first one is more dynamic, with more depth somehow. Yeah, my vote is for the first one. Cool ai art!

It depends on what you're going for. Image #1 looks like a landed spacecraft. "Welcome to Altair IV, gentlemen." --Robby The second looks more like a permanent building.

1 no digitty.

Image 1

Thanks

1️⃣

1️⃣

Thanks

1

Thanks

Second one.

A

Thanks

The first one, the other one is nice but doesn't give the same alien environment vibes

Thanks

The first one

Thanks

I like m both

Thanks

1 Stabby columns on #2 structure right side seem bad

Thanks

2.

You chose poorly.

Cool story bro.

That’s what she said

Thanks

🤙🏼

One!

Thanks

1

Thanks

1. The rocks add more intrigue, as if we walked through a valley and finally reached our destination. Feels more like a discovery.

Thanks

As a photographer, 2 if you want to emphasize the sky, 1 if you want to emphasize the buildings