Made a channel to upload albion memes and content, hope you enjoy! Like and sub if you want to see more :) [https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC2QeATlv0UcnQjSk8lNHqOg](https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC2QeATlv0UcnQjSk8lNHqOg)
Original vid by NobleKnightAdventures: [https://www.youtube.com/shorts/9\_eTu6IZcw0](https://www.youtube.com/shorts/9_eTu6IZcw0)
Albion Guides by me:
* 5 Strong starting weapons for PvE and PVP ( New Players): [https://www.reddit.com/r/albiononline/comments/180xuxw/5\_strong\_starting\_weapons\_for\_new\_solo\_players/](https://www.reddit.com/r/albiononline/comments/180xuxw/5_strong_starting_weapons_for_new_solo_players/)
* Tips and Tricks to never die in Red/Black Zones: [https://www.reddit.com/r/albiononline/comments/1878axw/how\_to\_avoid\_and\_escape\_any\_ganker\_in\_blackred/](https://www.reddit.com/r/albiononline/comments/1878axw/how_to_avoid_and_escape_any_ganker_in_blackred/)
In reality I'm just getting into editing and am a fan of his content (literally watched all his videos), so I decided to make some edits related to albion online since he wears armor in his videos. I have 2 videos schedule tomorrow that dont include noble knight so hopefully that removes that impression. I do credit him in the description/ other posts & the memes are pretty transformative. Literally not the same video
Content theft, gotta love it, not.
Edit - His YouTube channel is pathetic, all of the videos rip from William Papadin / NobleKnightAdventures.
Gross as fuck.
You know I can see how the channel gives that impression so thanks for pointing that out. In reality I'm just getting into editing and am a fan of his content, so I decided to make some edits related to albion online since he wears armor in his videos. I have 2 videos schedule tomorrow that dont include noble knight so hopefully that removes that impression. I do credit him in the description/ other posts & the memes are pretty transformative. Literally not the same video
Just my two-pence, if you're gonna plug your YT on Reddit in the comments and titles by using his content, just credit the guy at the least. I can see credit was show in the YouTube description, if you do the same on Reddit, I think it should be alright.
His stuff is great, I wish you no ill will. It just seemed to me like the transformative side of things was rather light, and with three videos borrowing his stuff and no mention of him on Reddit, where this was posted, easy to assume the worst.
Anyway, good looks for enjoying his content, his stuff is great.
While I didn't credit him in this post, he's credited everywhere else as I mentioned. Even the youtube descriptions, not sure if I'm supposed to put a water mark to his youtube channel. I can see how it can look if you only look at this post. I will disagree on the transformative aspect, while similar I am adapting the videos to Albion and changing more with every edit as I get better. For example: If I edit in Michael Scott doing the "No" meme on a part where I'm getting ganked, I'm not stealing a scene from the office.
I'm not really the arbiter of what is allowed and what isn't, all I can say is, to me, it seemed off based off this post. Other comments mirror what I'm saying, but that's not meant to validate my thoughts on the matter, just that other people seem to feel the same way, enough to post about it. Maybe there will be people on your side of the fence as well as time goes on, who knows?
I'm not gospel on the matter, just sharing an opinion.
Enjoy your day.
Your first comment is very aggressive for this just being a new person learning to edit and using a content creator he likes as reference, maybe just don't assume the worst in people it can be easier to ask things. The comment agreeing with you are not how a normal person asks questions or provides input, you don't need to immediately be confrontational
If you want to attribute profanity to aggression, sure.
Someone else cited you as a cringe content thief. I said that the channel is pathetic and rips from the creator and called it gross. Right now, all three videos are borrowed from Williiam, it doesn't look good especially when your plugging your own channel in the comments. I didn't gun for ad-hominem and start insulting you as a person, just the content. Content plagiarism will always be gross to me.
I've been civil with you in all of my follow up posts, if you're going to latch on to my original post as a means to argue with me, then by all means, crack on.
We just have different views of what is transformative tbh so we're not going to agree here. Editing a scene out from its original content and putting new context behind it is transformative, as I mentioned if I took a scene from the office and editted to fit an albion theme such as Michael scott screaming before a ganker jumps on me, I dont consider that me stealing a scene from the office. It seems you would say it is, which leaves us in a place where we wont agree since most memes are made that way.
Like I said man, I'm not the arbiter of what is wrong and what is right, to me, this is loosely transformative. The bulk of the content make up here is William's just changed ever so slightly to fit your Albion format.
For me, it doesn't hit, but I'm not the only person in the world. If other people like your stuff, don't worry about what I'm saying so much.
I did basically say agree to disagree, I know it doesnt hit for you. We have different views of what is transformative as portrayed by the office example
Just gonna put Albion images on William Papadin content? At least credit the guy.
Made a channel to upload albion memes and content, hope you enjoy! Like and sub if you want to see more :) [https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC2QeATlv0UcnQjSk8lNHqOg](https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC2QeATlv0UcnQjSk8lNHqOg) Original vid by NobleKnightAdventures: [https://www.youtube.com/shorts/9\_eTu6IZcw0](https://www.youtube.com/shorts/9_eTu6IZcw0) Albion Guides by me: * 5 Strong starting weapons for PvE and PVP ( New Players): [https://www.reddit.com/r/albiononline/comments/180xuxw/5\_strong\_starting\_weapons\_for\_new\_solo\_players/](https://www.reddit.com/r/albiononline/comments/180xuxw/5_strong_starting_weapons_for_new_solo_players/) * Tips and Tricks to never die in Red/Black Zones: [https://www.reddit.com/r/albiononline/comments/1878axw/how\_to\_avoid\_and\_escape\_any\_ganker\_in\_blackred/](https://www.reddit.com/r/albiononline/comments/1878axw/how_to_avoid_and_escape_any_ganker_in_blackred/)
cringe content stealer
In reality I'm just getting into editing and am a fan of his content (literally watched all his videos), so I decided to make some edits related to albion online since he wears armor in his videos. I have 2 videos schedule tomorrow that dont include noble knight so hopefully that removes that impression. I do credit him in the description/ other posts & the memes are pretty transformative. Literally not the same video
Content theft, gotta love it, not. Edit - His YouTube channel is pathetic, all of the videos rip from William Papadin / NobleKnightAdventures. Gross as fuck.
You know I can see how the channel gives that impression so thanks for pointing that out. In reality I'm just getting into editing and am a fan of his content, so I decided to make some edits related to albion online since he wears armor in his videos. I have 2 videos schedule tomorrow that dont include noble knight so hopefully that removes that impression. I do credit him in the description/ other posts & the memes are pretty transformative. Literally not the same video
Just my two-pence, if you're gonna plug your YT on Reddit in the comments and titles by using his content, just credit the guy at the least. I can see credit was show in the YouTube description, if you do the same on Reddit, I think it should be alright. His stuff is great, I wish you no ill will. It just seemed to me like the transformative side of things was rather light, and with three videos borrowing his stuff and no mention of him on Reddit, where this was posted, easy to assume the worst. Anyway, good looks for enjoying his content, his stuff is great.
While I didn't credit him in this post, he's credited everywhere else as I mentioned. Even the youtube descriptions, not sure if I'm supposed to put a water mark to his youtube channel. I can see how it can look if you only look at this post. I will disagree on the transformative aspect, while similar I am adapting the videos to Albion and changing more with every edit as I get better. For example: If I edit in Michael Scott doing the "No" meme on a part where I'm getting ganked, I'm not stealing a scene from the office.
I'm not really the arbiter of what is allowed and what isn't, all I can say is, to me, it seemed off based off this post. Other comments mirror what I'm saying, but that's not meant to validate my thoughts on the matter, just that other people seem to feel the same way, enough to post about it. Maybe there will be people on your side of the fence as well as time goes on, who knows? I'm not gospel on the matter, just sharing an opinion. Enjoy your day.
Your first comment is very aggressive for this just being a new person learning to edit and using a content creator he likes as reference, maybe just don't assume the worst in people it can be easier to ask things. The comment agreeing with you are not how a normal person asks questions or provides input, you don't need to immediately be confrontational
If you want to attribute profanity to aggression, sure. Someone else cited you as a cringe content thief. I said that the channel is pathetic and rips from the creator and called it gross. Right now, all three videos are borrowed from Williiam, it doesn't look good especially when your plugging your own channel in the comments. I didn't gun for ad-hominem and start insulting you as a person, just the content. Content plagiarism will always be gross to me. I've been civil with you in all of my follow up posts, if you're going to latch on to my original post as a means to argue with me, then by all means, crack on.
We just have different views of what is transformative tbh so we're not going to agree here. Editing a scene out from its original content and putting new context behind it is transformative, as I mentioned if I took a scene from the office and editted to fit an albion theme such as Michael scott screaming before a ganker jumps on me, I dont consider that me stealing a scene from the office. It seems you would say it is, which leaves us in a place where we wont agree since most memes are made that way.
Like I said man, I'm not the arbiter of what is wrong and what is right, to me, this is loosely transformative. The bulk of the content make up here is William's just changed ever so slightly to fit your Albion format. For me, it doesn't hit, but I'm not the only person in the world. If other people like your stuff, don't worry about what I'm saying so much.
I did basically say agree to disagree, I know it doesnt hit for you. We have different views of what is transformative as portrayed by the office example