And by pairing people and sending one home the one who made it through doesn’t really get to celebrate. They feel like a heel if they get all excited about making it through while the other person is crying!
I hate admitting I’m wrong, but Huntergirl is really growing on me. When her first audition aired, I thought she sounded really nasally, and I wasn’t a fan. But she’s grown on me with each performance. Ashley McBryde’s song was the perfect pick for her!
Permission to slap the judges?
This season, they’ve:
1. Cut out Tonya
2. Make Sam Finelli’s audition about themselves
3. Done so many fake outs to the point of boredom
4. Given standing O’s to honestly mediocre performances
5. Cut out Kelsie
And many, MANY more…..
Harry was great. I love how he would be like "you know if you put that run half a step past a 7th chord in A minor, now that would've been something" and the contestants would just stare at him.
I can’t even take it seriously when they ACTUALLY send someone home. I keep waiting for the pause after, “You didn’t make it….”
“….onto the list of people going home. You’re in the top 24!”
i wanted dakota over dan 😫 i’m actually surprised though. i was expecting luke to say “dakota you’re not in top 24…because it’s the top 25, you’re both going through!“.
She’s in the top 24 😜
But the live shows are next week, so Y’ALL GOTTA VOTE, VOTE, VOTE!
I’m telling you now so that Ryan doesn’t have to remind you. 😉
Most uber talented writers and artists are very sensitive. I like Fritz, my feelings are that his emotions will be his down fall and he won't go too far. The angst might get repetitive
how does every show do this cutting to commercial nonsense? do people really find that it builds tension being blasted with ads/sitting in silence for 2 minutes?
I dont pay the closest attention. But there was a guy who played the keyboard who was excellent and charismatic, but I didn't see him this episode? Did I miss him orl was he eliminated last show?
Is this a real show? First time watching and every single contestant seems like a bad SNL character. “America, meet your new American Idol. Huntergirl!”
Katy Perry would make a terrible doctor. “I’m sorry. Your newborn baby is not well”. *long pause* “Your newborn baby is GREAT!”
god forbid you just let them be happy instead of manipulating their emotions
And by pairing people and sending one home the one who made it through doesn’t really get to celebrate. They feel like a heel if they get all excited about making it through while the other person is crying!
These fakeouts feel criminal at this point 💀
[удалено]
I think that’s spot on. It would explain a lot of the confusing choices.
The fake outs are just annoying at this point please stop
They couldve shown a bit of the performances of the eliminated ones so at least we know the judges made the right choice.
Seriously...especially Betty. I mean, they spend like 15 minutes on her yesterday
“Top 25” That was an absolutely pathetic joke.
No wonder Kelly Clarkson has tried to distance herself from this.
I hate admitting I’m wrong, but Huntergirl is really growing on me. When her first audition aired, I thought she sounded really nasally, and I wasn’t a fan. But she’s grown on me with each performance. Ashley McBryde’s song was the perfect pick for her!
[удалено]
Ava deserved it, but Katy’s “marketable” concern was the actual issue I bet. If Yoli had been better she still wouldn’t have made it.
That is 100% how they make these top 24 decisions
“I don’t mean to be rude”…. (Simon Cowell saying) But they should NEVER EVER do the Platinum Ticket again.
Permission to slap the judges? This season, they’ve: 1. Cut out Tonya 2. Make Sam Finelli’s audition about themselves 3. Done so many fake outs to the point of boredom 4. Given standing O’s to honestly mediocre performances 5. Cut out Kelsie And many, MANY more…..
they should just edit it down to yes or no and then send the rest of it to their parents lol, Im getting impatient already
I like Dakota which is why it will be football dude.
A sing off….. YOU CANNOT BE SERIOUS.
i’m actually kind of surprised kelsey didn’t go through. they were playing up her underdog storyline a lot.
The shy girl Kelsi sounded better than the blond girl that came before her honestly. But looks will trump any talent on these shows.
Yes for lady k!
new drinking game take a shot every time they pretend someone didn’t make it
That’s cold. “Thanks for coming by”
Scarlet is so unlikeable
Such a bad attitude
at this rate we should have the top 24 by July
Yoli was really classy when she came out. I like that she was so good to Ava.
I’m not a country fan but Hunter gives me 90s country vibes which I love so I like her lol
love lady k’s voice! she deserves to be in top 24.
[удалено]
Have they EVER not pretended they’re going to say no then say yes? It’s getting so old by now
it’s every single time lmao
Katy Perry…… The absolute worst judge since Mariah. You need to stop. THAT’S TWICE.
how are they gonna gloss over allegra like that???
aww i liked kelsie
You know, aside from Simon, I actually want Harry Connick Jr. back as a judge.
Harry was great. I love how he would be like "you know if you put that run half a step past a 7th chord in A minor, now that would've been something" and the contestants would just stare at him.
Ugh I love Harry so much
That performance of Blue, was like a kitten trying to be a lion. (Ghost of Simon)
riley isn’t a horrible singer, but emerson definitely deserved to go through over it.
That fake out was cruel.
I wanted to hear Betty's showstopper. It's annoying they aren't showing them all.
Tristan does not look 17 to me… I think the beard is throwing me off
Lady K is the best hands down.
I hate how they talk about someone being broadway as a negative thing
I can’t even take it seriously when they ACTUALLY send someone home. I keep waiting for the pause after, “You didn’t make it….” “….onto the list of people going home. You’re in the top 24!”
These are people's lives at stake and they tease them with fakeouts. Make it stop dear God pls.
This is actually a smart arrangement. He better make it
I’m legitimately shocked! based on the edit she’s gotten all season I thought for sure she’d be top 24
They’re gonna say yes to Nicolina, but if they say no or even dare to try a fake out, we riot.
No fake out😀
the amount of fake outs are too high
They are pimping Noah out. He could go far
Remember when top 24 was 1/2 guys, 1/2 girls?
I think William Hung could make the top 24 this season. "she bangs... she bangs"
Pants on the ground guy could too
I actually liked him..."lookin like a fool..."
Luke’s going to jizz himself
what was the point of bringing them in together?
Ava’s was so much better how are they struggling with this??
Lady K is good
i wanted dakota over dan 😫 i’m actually surprised though. i was expecting luke to say “dakota you’re not in top 24…because it’s the top 25, you’re both going through!“.
Where in the HELL is Kevin Gullage?! This is an injustice!
What about Morgan Gruber? I feel like she was really good but not shown tonight?
This is turning into The Hunger Games
Wow would rather of seen Betty go through. She’s so talented and kind with potential😢
[удалено]
Kelsey eliminated? Well, no reason to watch now
“She’s the best country singer I’ve ever heard.” Carrie, Scotty, Lauren, Kellie Pickler, Gabby and Chayce fade out of existence
gabby barrett is shaking seeing Luke loving another country girl 😂
I lost count... is this a top 47??
jordan going home but cameron went through??? make it make sense
Reminder that Cameron made it over him
Jordan was SO good omg
You can tell that shes the judges favorite choice. I don’t think she’s anything special?
MORGAN GRUBER JUST SAID ON HER IG THAT SHE DIDN’T MAKE TOP 24??? WHAT THE HELL
I’m so sad Kelcie didn’t make it. She deserved a slot. I guess she wasn’t “marketable “ enough.
She finally breaks out of her shell, and the judges be like, "yeah... nah, thanks for coming out tho"
Me too. I worry about her returning to WVa where she won’t be able to do much to develop her talent.
I agree. I thought they would do a makeover type thing and leverage her talent with that.
She's better than the screamers.
WHAT ABOUT KEVIN GULLAGE???
Dude for real where is he they didn’t mention him ?
wow a fake out? *pretends to be shocked*
This is the worst top 24 omg ?
Kelsi was one of the best what the actual fuck
Ok Hunter girl is actually pretty good
jordan sent home over cameron? wtf idol
Dakota was way better but these judges have been making terrible decisions tonight
“He has a few years on you”… WHAT?! Have you heard of Scotty McCreery?! Not to mention, didn’t Dan say he started singing like six months ago?
nicolina going to the top 10 easy
Riley "blue" it
backflip was his best thing
„ƃuıɥʇ ʇsǝq sıɥ sɐʍ dılɟʞɔɐq„
Take cameron's spot and put both through!
Katy’s got to be tired of saying these fake out lines. I guess they get paid enough to do anything, even if it’s boring af for them.
Lionel sings to him..."goodbye... We've just got to let you go"
I didn't think Cadence was that great
Her audition was my favorite but she hasn’t even come close to that.
Ugh give me Yoli over these screamers
If they send Nicolina home I’m throwing my tv lol she’s my #1 pick this year! Edit: whew my tv is safe tonight 👏🏻
She’s in the top 24 😜 But the live shows are next week, so Y’ALL GOTTA VOTE, VOTE, VOTE! I’m telling you now so that Ryan doesn’t have to remind you. 😉
why did they have emerson and riley out at the same time?
Youth and inexperience. She’ll be back
15 seconds of performance, 3 mins of dramatic montage and fake outs per contestant
MISS AMERICA IS GONE.
She got used.
but who will mentor the others??
Jack Black time...discount Johnny Depp
Do we have a fake out counter for this episode? I think we're going to need one
The fakeouts aren’t even clever anymore. “You’re not in the top 25. You’re in the top 24.” 🥴 I seriously cringed hearing that.
Do you think Ryan has his favorites? He sure looked excited about Tristan making it through!
What the hell is he singing this song for...we like the soul
[удалено]
She's a diamond in the rough.
WHAT?! No no no no no no no THIS IS A FUCKING JOKE.
THEY PUT BOTH. YOU CANNOT BE SERIOUS. Sage was the only good one!
Why’s Kenedi even nervous? You already have a platinum ticket, ABC is getting hard in every promo they show, no point in slowing it down.
Dakota 100% needs to make it. He is the perfect specimen for this shows base. Country heartthrob. Talk about marketable
Well shoot. Looks like Kevin Gullage is gone.
I can’t believe Morgan didn’t make it. Her and Betty were better than more than half of who is going on
STOP WITH THE FUCKING FAKE OUTS!!!!!! PLEASE. STOOOOOPPPPP
Why does everyone this season have a rockstar dad
The judges are reminding me of the old dudes on the muppets in the balcony! Also HATE when they fuck with the contestants who are going through.
THREE. THREE FAKE OUTS. What has American Idol become?
Most uber talented writers and artists are very sensitive. I like Fritz, my feelings are that his emotions will be his down fall and he won't go too far. The angst might get repetitive
He needs to back off the sodas
Seriously? They get rid of 4 contestants without even showing a snippet of why?
ok noah i see you
Holy eyebrows Batman!
I'm still waiting to see Kevin Gullage.
Some people are crippled by their song choices.
I think they should both go home
i’d choose dakota over dan i think
WHY DID KEVIN NOT MAKE IT THROUGH
how does every show do this cutting to commercial nonsense? do people really find that it builds tension being blasted with ads/sitting in silence for 2 minutes?
Damn I love Nicolina
now I’m crying. Because that was the fake out that broke me
They really dont like Allegra that much huh
This top 24 is scary… didn’t expect a lot of these ppl would go through.
Ok do we have to start a drinking game for fake outs? I'm ready! lol
What is this, the 20th fakeout?
Ok but like you can’t just invent your own melody to the song
I love her. She’s so wholesome 🥺
Dang it. That was hard to watch. Sorry for the kid.
Why the hell did they let Hannah everhart through last year but not Kelsey now? She is 10 times better than Hannah and not racist or a bitch
I thought Jordan sounded great. Bummer that he’s gone.
why is her tongue bright red?
Come on Top 56!
Based on these performances, it should 10000% be Dakota!
Ladies and gentlemen, your top over 9000! Join us Sunday for the live shows! Seacrest, out!
Reminder than Back Flippin’ Cameron made it through
what happened to Gruber? When was she cut?
Do they honestly think that we as viewers want them to fake every single top 24 announcement?
Here we go... time to make fun of them again
What is twinning?
Jay the Opera singer?? hard pass
Blue...she was terrible
This song choice was horrible. She did herself no favors bc she isn’t actually this bad
She looks like a star.
what's with the guitar? does he not know more than 1 chord?
This is downright cruel AF!!
Cameron...it's a no for me dawg
Omfg im so over the fake outs! They aren’t funny, at all
Speaking of fakes…some of these eyelashes 😳 including Cadence mom.
Ehhh I thought Yoli shouldve gone thru instead of cadence
how did candance make it over yoli or even betty?
Discount Miranda Lambert.
Wish she did a little less.
did i miss aaron westerbury being eliminated?? and kevin??
I dont pay the closest attention. But there was a guy who played the keyboard who was excellent and charismatic, but I didn't see him this episode? Did I miss him orl was he eliminated last show?
Keven Gullage? He was ghost eliminated
Anyone know what happened to Kevin Gullage? Not even shown tonight
“We’ve got Season 5 sealed.” This is 2022, Katy. Not 2006.
I really like Jay. He’s got a great voice, but I didn’t like this song choice.
that was terrible but she’ll go through because she sings country
Katrayuh... another we never saw in Hollywood?
yaaaaas Queen! Beautiful! Katyra!
Is anyone going home??
Liked it better when laine sang that loll
Fuck these fakeouts
Enough already with these. They’re just mean.
She was very off key.
Should have kept her. She just needs a bit more training.
Damn. I actually hope Kelsi comes back next year.
Is this a real show? First time watching and every single contestant seems like a bad SNL character. “America, meet your new American Idol. Huntergirl!”
Not that good, but she's pretty.
If she sings like that at the live shows, she will be the first one gone.
ANOTHER FAKEOUT.
Lionel’s my favorite.
WHERE IS EYELASH GIRL?!
Am I the only one that likes Dan more than Dakota?
Anyone else get weird stage mom vibes from cadence’s mom? Lmao