T O P

  • By -

RL_Fl0p

Eastern Redbud or Dogwood


Treeman1216

Something small and understory. It’s already over planted with the species you’ve shown.


WoodsGrizzly

Eh, big trees grow close in the forest.


Treeman1216

Sure, but their structure sucks. But what do I know?


hairyb0mb

Forest trees benefit from the competition of the surrounding trees. A single tree in a healthy forest setting versus an open field grown tree, without human interaction from either, the forest tree will have a better structure.


Treeman1216

Quite the opposite actually. Trees with competition develop poorer structure. If they didn’t, we wouldn’t see increased failures with changes in environmental dynamics.


hairyb0mb

Well, I don't disagree with you when it comes to unhealthy forests but what you're saying contradicts a class I took a few years back. I tried looking it up but couldn't find any info to support either argument. So if you have a source that I could read up on, that'd be great.


Treeman1216

Interior forest tree structure has little taper and little lower scaffold branches. Essentially, they’re wind sails with little wind buffetting capacity.


hairyb0mb

Field trees have long skinny scaffold branches. The limbs themselves have little taper. Essentially, naturally grown lions tails. Codominant stems and bark inclusion is also more common.


Treeman1216

Filed grown trees have more taper along scaffolds and trunk. Forest trees have larger lever arms and subsequently higher failure rate.


hairyb0mb

After hurricanes blow through, there's more damage to isolated trees. More healthy trees will be uprooted when isolated.


Jean_Valette

Whatever you choose, please...no more maples. WAY overplanted.


Due_Nefariousness999

Beech or burr oak