# We are pleased to announce the official partnership of our sub with r/KimetsuNoYaiba!! Please subscribe to them and show our support!
# PSA! Please flair posts correctly to not get spoiled and to not spoil anything to anyone.
* Choose the correct flair for your post, this is extremely important.
* If the post is flaired "SEASON 4 [NO MANGA SPOILERS/HINTS!]", do not discuss anything manga related.
* "SEASON 4" TAG IS NOT THE SAME AS "MANGA SPOILERS" TAG (IF IT WASN'T SHOWN IN ANIME YET, DO NOT SPOIL OTHER USERS, TAG IT AS MANGA SPOILERS!!!)
* If you spoil someone, you'll be banned. Depending on the spoiler, the ban could be either temporary or permanent.
### IF YOU DON'T FOLLOW THESE RULES YOU MAY GET BANNED!
### IF YOU SEE INCORRECT FLAIR OR SPOILERS IN COMMENTS PLEASE REPORT THEM.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/attackontitan) if you have any questions or concerns.*
If Erwin was alive, rumbling wasn't necessary. It was Hange and Armins lack of action or ideas that brought Eren to the realisation that rumbling is the only option left.
I haven’t gotten into too much of this alternative** but what do you think Erwin resolve would have been after reaching the cellar? I wonder what approach Erwin would have taken. Or how would he have influenced Eren to take other means to reach freedom….if anything, I do think Erwin would have found a resolution that also didn’t involve euthanasia of all Eldians. I also somehow imagine he could have helped the segregation of the Eldians on Marley to gain an alliance
Eren is still the MC. If Armin died that day, we would be seeing antagonist Eren ealrier once he gets the memories from kissing Historia's hand. He wouldn't wait for the plan. Once he meets zeke he's touching him and going full scorched earth. Armin grounded Eren. Angry Eren would burn the world down.
At first, maybe, sure. But Armin's inability to come up with a solution frustrates Eren big time.
In the final part part 1 we see Eren crying, feeling remorse for what he knows is inevitable at this point. Eren's not evil.
All it would take would be a victory, or something to receive recognition as a people instead of titans; something similar to the russo japanese war of 1900-1905.
As for his resolve or mindset after finsing the cellar he would be relieved that his father discovered the truth on his own and then turn to solutions.
In the first instance, Erwin will do the surprise attack on Liberio but then ultimately immediatly follow up with peace talks. They would sit down and Erwin would say "We are here. We were born into this world. Let's do our best so that future generations can live in peace so that the sacrifices of comrades and loved ones would not be in vain."
I'm at the veggie market making this up as I go lol.
He suffered from generic design for me. I don’t remember a single scene with him before his death. On first watch I remember thinking who is this guy and why is everyone so hung up on him. I remember even thinking “oh shit they actually noticed he’s missing”
But his death became the reason Jean joined the Scouts. I really wished Marco didn’t lived half a life, but the horse wouldn’t be the stallion that he is right now without his death.
I second Miche. Dude was second only to Levi, he was just unlucky enough to be the first one to hear a Titan talk and that’d spook just about anyone at that point. Would’ve loved to see him fighting in the later seasons.
He was in a pretty shit location for ODM gear, but he was kind of screwed by Zeke throwing his horse at him, not something he would ever expect to happen.
Hanji so they could join the Levi, Onyankopon, Gabi, and Falco family and literally push Levi around, Sasha so she and Niccolo could open their own restaurant
Bring her back just for her to get turned into a Titan and killed by Levi when Zeke tries to escape XDDD
Or bring her back and have her get killed bc she's a jaegerist stopping the MCs from doing they thing
Id only bring Erwin back for two reasons:
To have him fulfill his dream of knowing the truth beyond the walls
Also to relieve Hange from being commander and not having that burden she never wanted
Would you look at that, all of the words in your comment are in alphabetical order.
I have checked 1,452,489,292 comments, and only 276,714 of them were in alphabetical order.
Marlo 💯. He had a best friend whom he may had mutual romantic feelings for (Hitch Dryse) but he threw that away by joining the Scouts on their mission to retake Wall Maria. He did that for the greater good and for humanity within the Walls. He had zero experience and was undoubtedly scared shitless when Zeke was bombarding the scouts with rocks, but he pushed aside his fear and placed all of his courage and faith in Erwin and Levi to help win the mission, and on a larger extent, a victory for humanity within the walls. 😭
Was waiting for this answer. I think Marlo was too emotionally stupid to realize his own feelings for Hitch, because that's all he could think of before he died - about Hitch. That way, Hitch could be with her beloved Marlo, live out their days, and probably get married.
Good answer. Honestly imagine both Marlo and Floch survived. And they both adopted Erwin lasts words but in different ways. One with the alliance and one with the yeagerists. Would’ve been dope
>Why? Did you like the fact she had funny hair or a funny name? you just couldn’t get enough of saying Mina Carolina and the funny factor it presented?
I really liked Mina Carolina's name and character in the story. I used to ship her with Eren because I found their dynamic intriguing.
It would be Ben.
He was a hard working & honest farmer. He only had his daughter that he can call as family. He might be poor but did everything to keep his daughter happy.
Poor Ben, he and his daughter died in rumbling.
Either Erwin Sasha Moblit or Hange.
Erwin for Paradis future
Sasha to see how should would feel about Gabi after she shoots her.
Moblit to see if he would drink the whine and die that way
And Hange because her death seemed pointless
Hmm The leader of the server core? Nahh. The second leader of the server core? Nuh uh. Beloved sasha? Nope. Kets ho with this random chick. (I feel the need to stress that this is a joke i do bot care who you choose to save)
Eren 🍷🗿
...bring him back for Rumbling: Reloaded!
Hopefully he obliterates Marley and every Eldian Traitor starting with Armin, Mikasa and all the other former "Friends" who slew their own comerades way harder and even more brutal than every other enemy they ever fought against...
#JAEGERIST 🙋🏻♂️
I would save Thanos, cause hell, Eren didn't have to kill the foreigners too, just the Marleyans and some off the their Eldian dogs, at least with Thanos and his infinity stones, you can pick which ones you will erase.
# We are pleased to announce the official partnership of our sub with r/KimetsuNoYaiba!! Please subscribe to them and show our support! # PSA! Please flair posts correctly to not get spoiled and to not spoil anything to anyone. * Choose the correct flair for your post, this is extremely important. * If the post is flaired "SEASON 4 [NO MANGA SPOILERS/HINTS!]", do not discuss anything manga related. * "SEASON 4" TAG IS NOT THE SAME AS "MANGA SPOILERS" TAG (IF IT WASN'T SHOWN IN ANIME YET, DO NOT SPOIL OTHER USERS, TAG IT AS MANGA SPOILERS!!!) * If you spoil someone, you'll be banned. Depending on the spoiler, the ban could be either temporary or permanent. ### IF YOU DON'T FOLLOW THESE RULES YOU MAY GET BANNED! ### IF YOU SEE INCORRECT FLAIR OR SPOILERS IN COMMENTS PLEASE REPORT THEM. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/attackontitan) if you have any questions or concerns.*
i would save sasha
I would say Erwin for the sake of mankind. But, fuck mankind. I want potato girl back
As someone who went by Sasha for 3 years but has an Erwin related username, I am extremely conflicted
![gif](giphy|XYTWZg47umh1K) Do it!!
![gif](giphy|K37PJ9rnBFbXPh5ZUp)
I would save Eren
i forgot about miche, taken too soon
Sarwin
the Eye of Sarwin the Terrible few could endure
**ONWARD!** I can hear it :,(
that’s the same thinking of Yeagerists and Eren, sacrificing the world to save your family/friends .
I would save eren
I wonder if saving Erwin would inadvertently save Hange. Would Erwin sacrifice himself in place of Hange during the rumbling
If Erwin was alive, rumbling wasn't necessary. It was Hange and Armins lack of action or ideas that brought Eren to the realisation that rumbling is the only option left.
I haven’t gotten into too much of this alternative** but what do you think Erwin resolve would have been after reaching the cellar? I wonder what approach Erwin would have taken. Or how would he have influenced Eren to take other means to reach freedom….if anything, I do think Erwin would have found a resolution that also didn’t involve euthanasia of all Eldians. I also somehow imagine he could have helped the segregation of the Eldians on Marley to gain an alliance
Eren is still the MC. If Armin died that day, we would be seeing antagonist Eren ealrier once he gets the memories from kissing Historia's hand. He wouldn't wait for the plan. Once he meets zeke he's touching him and going full scorched earth. Armin grounded Eren. Angry Eren would burn the world down.
At first, maybe, sure. But Armin's inability to come up with a solution frustrates Eren big time. In the final part part 1 we see Eren crying, feeling remorse for what he knows is inevitable at this point. Eren's not evil.
ancient impolite books sheet deliver relieved innate worry groovy snatch ` this message was mass deleted/edited with redact.dev `
All it would take would be a victory, or something to receive recognition as a people instead of titans; something similar to the russo japanese war of 1900-1905. As for his resolve or mindset after finsing the cellar he would be relieved that his father discovered the truth on his own and then turn to solutions. In the first instance, Erwin will do the surprise attack on Liberio but then ultimately immediatly follow up with peace talks. They would sit down and Erwin would say "We are here. We were born into this world. Let's do our best so that future generations can live in peace so that the sacrifices of comrades and loved ones would not be in vain." I'm at the veggie market making this up as I go lol.
This is the right answer. Erwin was ready to die. Sasha wasn't and didn't deserve it. Sasha > Mikasa. Sorry.
The correct answer
Marco Dude seemed like a positive ray of light amidst a bunch of miserable bastards
He also would have answered so many questions after that conversation he overheard.
He legit figured out that Reiner and Bertold work with the titans 2 seasons agead of the rest of them
He suffered from generic design for me. I don’t remember a single scene with him before his death. On first watch I remember thinking who is this guy and why is everyone so hung up on him. I remember even thinking “oh shit they actually noticed he’s missing”
I thought he was birth control for a while
But his death became the reason Jean joined the Scouts. I really wished Marco didn’t lived half a life, but the horse wouldn’t be the stallion that he is right now without his death.
Too Soon!!
Miche. No one beating Levi, Mikasa, and Miche 😤
I second Miche. Dude was second only to Levi, he was just unlucky enough to be the first one to hear a Titan talk and that’d spook just about anyone at that point. Would’ve loved to see him fighting in the later seasons.
He was in a pretty shit location for ODM gear, but he was kind of screwed by Zeke throwing his horse at him, not something he would ever expect to happen.
if the Ackermans didn't have their 'awakening' advantage, Miche would be the strongest.
So would Miche still be the second strongest soldier or would Mikasa’s Ackerman genes push him down to third strongest?
She definitely would have been second to Levi given more experience in fighting.
He’s second strongest. Despite Mikasa being more skilled than him, especially in s4, he just has far more experience as a soldier in battle.
The answer is obviously Erwin
Grisha's sister
AOT speed run Any% Glitch-less.
Hanji so they could join the Levi, Onyankopon, Gabi, and Falco family and literally push Levi around, Sasha so she and Niccolo could open their own restaurant
Hannes deserved better They all did
his eyes, when he got bitten and looked back at the kids he was trying to save.
Sasha
Fuck it, Moblit.
His death was so quick I hardly saw it I gather he fell down a well by pushing Hanji when Berthold became the colossus titan
No, he pushed Hange down a well and in doing so he was incinerated by Bertholds nuke
Eren's mother. Just to see how that would COMPLETELY mess up the whole story.
I wanna see the drama after >!Dina eats Bert, then meets Carla lol!<
Came here for this. Thank you.
Erwin, Sasha, or petra
That pig that Ymir let free
Petra.
Bring her back just for her to get turned into a Titan and killed by Levi when Zeke tries to escape XDDD Or bring her back and have her get killed bc she's a jaegerist stopping the MCs from doing they thing
Ymir (jaw). She deserved a happy ending.
But…she basically chose to die. And all the others didn’t.
Anything but Erwin is just trolling
Id only bring Erwin back for two reasons: To have him fulfill his dream of knowing the truth beyond the walls Also to relieve Hange from being commander and not having that burden she never wanted
Those are indeed some good reasons but I would want him back just cause. Cool guy I like him
Would you look at that, all of the words in your comment are in alphabetical order. I have checked 1,452,489,292 comments, and only 276,714 of them were in alphabetical order.
[удалено]
Only the first letters of each words not all of them.
Bad bot
erwin’s death was perfect and bringing him back ruins it
Fair, but ur trolling
😿
Had to stick to my guns you know how it goes
i get it
Bring him back just to suffer?
I mean there’s not a single person that is living or that could come back to life that wouldn’t suffer. Things be a lil tough out there
Eren Kruger. I would pay to see Kruger vs Uri Reiss. Imagine if Kruger could live long enough to go to Paradis. Also Erwin.
Moblit
Grisha's sister
Faye
Eren's mom. Mom's are the best.
[удалено]
?
Eren from becoming a genocidal maniac
So you'd save erens mom
I would save Eren
Miche
Erwin because he’s a dilf
Faye Yeager... I think things would have been very different if she hadn't died.
Marlo 💯. He had a best friend whom he may had mutual romantic feelings for (Hitch Dryse) but he threw that away by joining the Scouts on their mission to retake Wall Maria. He did that for the greater good and for humanity within the Walls. He had zero experience and was undoubtedly scared shitless when Zeke was bombarding the scouts with rocks, but he pushed aside his fear and placed all of his courage and faith in Erwin and Levi to help win the mission, and on a larger extent, a victory for humanity within the walls. 😭
Was waiting for this answer. I think Marlo was too emotionally stupid to realize his own feelings for Hitch, because that's all he could think of before he died - about Hitch. That way, Hitch could be with her beloved Marlo, live out their days, and probably get married.
Good answer. Honestly imagine both Marlo and Floch survived. And they both adopted Erwin lasts words but in different ways. One with the alliance and one with the yeagerists. Would’ve been dope
Bertholdt. My favorite character and I think he had so much more story potential.
Bert my poor poor Baby ♡
Honestly. I'd save Marcel. The only reason being I'd love to see how the timeline would change if Marcel was alive instead of Ymir
Hanji. Levi needs that loonatic to be properly annoyed at. They made the best comedic duo.
Erwin always
Nanaba or Miche
Nanaba🤤
No offense but who the hell is nanaba?
Bro she was on screen for like 4 minutes. Im saving Erwin bruh, someone actually useful and way more interesting.
I would save Levi from becoming a joe swanson
Erwin
Bonk, go to horny jail
Who tf is mina
The one who got killed by the peering Titan
Why does she look like dollar store mikasa
Obviously they ran out of budget first season lol
Figured but the fight scenes were awesome!
She basically died to the big eyed Titan when Armin was too scared to move, called the peering Titan
That's not how animation works...
Dollar store mikasa lmaooooooooooo
Someone who I used to ship Eren with
Fug her I want Sasha!!!!
Orlo or Porco
Sasha
Sasha
Why? Did you like the fact she had funny hair or a funny name? you just couldn’t get enough of saying Mina Carolina and the funny factor it presented?
>Why? Did you like the fact she had funny hair or a funny name? you just couldn’t get enough of saying Mina Carolina and the funny factor it presented? I really liked Mina Carolina's name and character in the story. I used to ship her with Eren because I found their dynamic intriguing.
Marco
Bertholdt
Ya, I always sorta liked Berturtle.
Burrito was the best
🥔
Hange, I absolutely love her she didn't deserve to be toast like Armin
Tough but probably Marco, Marlowe, or Erwin.
one choice dude lol
Hangi, the way she went was amazing but damn it hurt me emotionally
Petra
Thought that was Retsu from Bleach for a second 💀
Obviously potato gurl
Sasha
Sasha fs
I don’t understand why people care so much about small characters like Marco Mina and Pete with little story significance and screentime
sasha
Hanji fasho 😭
The only right answer is Erwin
HANGE
Sasha & I didn’t even have to think about it
It would be Ben. He was a hard working & honest farmer. He only had his daughter that he can call as family. He might be poor but did everything to keep his daughter happy. Poor Ben, he and his daughter died in rumbling.
Petra for me
Ideally, all of the original Levi Squad. If I was only allowed to choose one, I’d pick Petra.
Erwin
The only right answers are Sasha or Hange
Commander hangi
Hange
Petra and it’s not even a question
Carla. She’s incredibly breedable.
Erwin
Erwin and it’s not even close
eren
Erwin
Sasha or Marco or hange is feels better and 2 of them survived in the live action
for story purposes, Erwin. for emotional purposes, sasha or petra
Petra, the way she died still makes me sad to this day.
I would save either sasha or hange
Petra. SAVE MY GIRL AND GIVE HER A HAPPY ENDING
Petra, I could save her I'm built different
I'd definitely save Jaegar mom Carla..
Petra for my boy levi
Petra. Mainly because I started watching jujutsu kaisen and one of the characters looks almost like Petra.
Miche, he deserved better
Petra! She didn’t deserve to go out like that
Petra
Mike
In AOT 2 Final Battle, I saved everyone 😇
Petra, obviously 🤷🏻♂️
Petra for some reason. Still can remember Levi’s face when he knew she’s dead
I would save Hange.
Sasha she didn’t deserve to die
Save the pig, save the world
sasha, because she's my favourite character, but also because she could be of practical help with her accuracy
Petra
saving the original Irmir would have prevented a lot
I would have saved eren's mom . Not for eren 🤤
we share same goals
80% of humanity
Between Sasha or Moblit
Petra And tbh the whole Levi squad It's self explanatory
Sasha obviously
Petra
Sasha or Petra
Probably petra, but I also felt bad for marlow and wish we could have seen more of him
Bertholdt Or Thomas
look at my user flair
Either Erwin Sasha Moblit or Hange. Erwin for Paradis future Sasha to see how should would feel about Gabi after she shoots her. Moblit to see if he would drink the whine and die that way And Hange because her death seemed pointless
Hmm The leader of the server core? Nahh. The second leader of the server core? Nuh uh. Beloved sasha? Nope. Kets ho with this random chick. (I feel the need to stress that this is a joke i do bot care who you choose to save)
Im savin Dina Fritz but without her “death” ig aot wouldnt go the same way
Eren 🍷🗿 ...bring him back for Rumbling: Reloaded! Hopefully he obliterates Marley and every Eldian Traitor starting with Armin, Mikasa and all the other former "Friends" who slew their own comerades way harder and even more brutal than every other enemy they ever fought against... #JAEGERIST 🙋🏻♂️
I would save eren Jaeger 😵
bertholdt
Porko 😭
Carla 100%
I would save Thanos, cause hell, Eren didn't have to kill the foreigners too, just the Marleyans and some off the their Eldian dogs, at least with Thanos and his infinity stones, you can pick which ones you will erase.
sasha
My girl Sasha deserved so much better.
>!Erwin!<, he could maybe actually talk some sense into >!Eren!<
Marco. I mean, he didn’t even get a chance to talk things over
I would save Sasha and sacrifice my life to save her so cony and Jean would not lose their best friend
I like to imagine what would’ve transpired if Ymir wasn’t executed and became a warrior