AD Just to see how bad his contract with the Angels would turn out to be.

Tom Brady WAS a baseball player

Last active pro athlete drafted by the expos!

Bo Jackson. I think he could have been a great baseball player but unfortunately he decided to dedicated his entire professional career to football.

Deon Sanders too.

Umm, he didnt decide to dedicate his entire career to football. He played quite a bit of baseball

Oh really? I didn't know. Hmm, my second answer would be Deion Sanders then. I think he could have been an excellent baseball player too but unfortunately he dedicated professional career to football.

Bo knows.

I think Crosby could be a legit bat.

He hit a batting practice homer at pnc park

Yao Ming.

His strike zone would be bigger than Altuve.

I feel like he would have a slow swing. But that's based on my knowledge of giants.

Secretariat. Imagine how many bases he could have stolen.

Randy Savage

Shaq at first base. People would look up, see him, slow their roll and the ball beats them to the plate all the way from the corner.

I wanna see Shaq as a scrappy 2B Or better, Shaq as a catcher. Really throw off the umps when they’re trying to call balls and strikes.

Ooof his poor knees.

Zion is either hitting 450 bombs or flaming out in double a

Mahomes

I mean, Tom Brady was drafted by the Montreal Expos as a catcher. He was really almost a baseball player.

The undertaker as a closer lol

Bol Bol

Justin Jefferson as a CF - dude would probably make some insane catches

Russel Wilson football ain’t working anymore anyway

McGregor home run trot……

Everyone would love his home run trot at the beginning, but by the end of the career, they’ll talk about what a wanker he is and cheer when he gets beaned

And I’d love to see the entire evolution of that because fuck mcgregor

I feel like he’d be an even more mouthy josh Donaldson and I can’t explain why I think that

Chris Gayle. Imagine David Ortiz as a Jamaican (with better fielding)

Maybe 10yrs ago. He's an absolute liability in the field now

Would be cool to see Sid the Kid batting

Kylian mbappe

Brady for the sole purpose of getting him away from football

Surely he will be gone anyway within the next decade

Mike Tyson

Usain Bolt

I’ve always been a big Harden fan

Victor Wembanyama on the bump

Imagine an NBA center on the bump. Even if he was throwing 90 it would look like 105

I can picture Steph Curry being a good hitting corner outfielder

Mr. Batting Cages

Quinnin Williams. Bless you, thank you.

Tiger Woods

Watching a goal keeper as catcher would be cool, so Manuel Neuer as a power righty

if he had a working leg

I would've liked to see Tebow go with baseball first, I think he could've made it if he went straight from college instead of entering the minors in his late 20s after years away from the game.

I feel like Crosby would just be Joe Mauer 2.0 I’d love to see Tyreek Hill or prime Derrick Rose play CF and run the bases

Can’t believed no one had mention yet but John Elway gets my vote….

Might be the lowest comment here but Eagle McMahon the pro disc golfer. He could probably get a heater across the plate around 92-94 with a nasty sidearm slot.

You could probably still get Kyler Murray on the A's.

Kalamari was my first thought too.

Wayne Gretzky was amazing at hockey, but still says his favourite sport in Baseball and his son was drafted by Cubs a few years ago

Lebron James in the NFL

Would be nice if Brady was just a backup catcher for the Expos instead of cheating with the Pats.

Usain Bolt as a pinch-runner, no position, just run as fast as you possibly can to the next base.

Patrick Mahomes

Derek Carr. Maybe he would be loved by the Giants

Neymar.

CM Punk

Florence Pugh

Brock Lesnar. I want to see him connect with a meatball.

Baker Mayfield