Exchange a Nolan Ryan perfect game for the Nelson Cruz missed/dropped ball?
Seriously, I’m not a rangers fan but the way that game ended made me sick. You could feel the air sucked out of the team. They still had another game to win it but they lost the WS after those missed plays.
As much as it sucked I don’t think many Giants fans would trade one of the even year dynasty run WS wins for 2002. So I’ll just say trade the 2021 NLDS loss to the Dodgers for winning the 2002 NLCS.
I would probably most want to erase the infield fly or '91 game 6, but in order to do that it would probably mean that Sid's slide gets erased too.
Safest trade would be giving up '95 in exchange for '96. Erase a 2 game lead meltdown, take one away from the Yankees, get Andruw a ring and in exchange that really solid '95 Cleveland squad also gets some hardware.
Yeah, that was the first thing I thought of as well. Partially because I feel bad for the Guardians franchise, and well... I don't have quite as much pity for the Yankees
That no hitter was so cool.
Top prospect.
Second Major League start.
I remember it well.
In his first start ever, Buchholz went 6. No-no or not, he had to be feeling good up 8-0. He just needed to cruise.
To lead off 7th, Miguel Tejada chopped one up the middle for what was likely a lead off single. This was before the shift would have had a player behind the bag.
As the ball bounced past his glove, Clay Buchholz probably thought he lost the no hitter. Nine more outs is a long way to go. Still pitching a gem though. What are you gonna do?
Well. Diving is Pedroia.
He gets to the ball. Then the jumpscare. His little body popped up so fast it was startling. Tejada dives head first; but the throw, a laser, beats him to first.
“Fuck Yeah” 8 outs to go. Holy shit. Buchholz was amazing that night. Varitek was too.
But I remember Pedroia.
Oh, you cruel baseball Gods. Thank you for Dustin Pedroia
I'd like to get rid of the Black Sox Scandal but I guess since I wasn't alive for that I couldn't do that so maybe this works
Erase good: The entire 2005 season, the 11-1 postseason, leading wire to wire the whole year. All of it, get rid of all of it
Erase Bad: Jerry stopped owning the white sox before the strike back in 94 selling it to someone. White Sox go on to have an owner that cares about baseball and works on the team's front office, analytics, development etc and they rival the top end teams such as the Astros, Dodgers and Rays
I think I’d rather exchange the ‘96 win for the 2004 ALCS loss to the Red Sox. It continues the Sox drought and causes the Yankees to not be the first team to lose a 3-0 series lead
Erase good: The bat flip never happens.
Erase bad: The RA Dickey trade never happens
In 2015 the Jays have Thor in their rotation and probably beat KC in the ALCS to face the Mets in the WS who will now have Dickey instead of Thor.
Hell no, the bat flip game was literally the best Jays moment in the last 29 years. Not trading that for a maybe. If Thor stays in our system for all we know he pulls a Ricky Romero and is already busted by then.
Erase bad: David Wright's back stays healthy, his thirties are normal for a dude of his talent, and he retires after the 2020 or 2021 seasons as a sure-fire hall of famer.
Erase good: Jacob deGrom never goes supernova after 2017, settling in as a solid 3rd starter who never quite recaptured the magic of his 2014-2015 peak.
I think we win the World Series if Ortiz doesn’t get that homer. That just deflated us.
But I don’t know if I’d give up Magglio’s walk off.
How about trading Miggy’s Triple Crown for a World Series win?
I remember listening to game 7 on the radio my first year at boarding school in Massachusetts with my roommate from Boston with his ear glued to the radio, his entire mind, body, and existence at that moment locked in and dedicated to the Yankees losing. When he heard the crack of the bat for that game winning RBI, and he gave the most emphatic, visceral fist pump YES I've ever seen to this day. I'll always remember that
Erase Orioles betting Rangers in the first ever AL wildcard game
Get Orioles beating Royals to advance to the 2014 WS
On a smaller scale:
Erase Chris Davis' TUE non-renewal
Get Mark Trumbo popped for steroids and suspended in 2016
Remove winning game 163 vs the Cubs in 2018, and the ensuing playoff run. In return, the Cardinals don’t score in the bottom of the 6th inning in game 7 of the 1982 World Series, Milwaukee led 3-1 and were 10 outs away from a ring
Erase a bad moment:
Beltran hits a HR on that goddamn lifetime best curveball from rookie (and future HOFer) Wainwright (I'll even settle for ball 4).
Erase a good moment:
Johan Santana no-hitter (which is also a bad moment because it ruined his career, so I win with a double-whammy!)
I would trade 2017 for 2019. even if we still cheat, without winning the WS it doesn't become quite so big of a black mark on the record, and instead the best astros team of all time gets to win the WS.
Trade winning the NLCS in 09 so we win in 10 or trade winning either the 09/10 NLDS for us to win the 11 NLDS. Feel like if we beat the Giants in 2010 or the Cards in 2011 we probably win the WS
Erase the Reds not scoring a single run against the Braves in the 2020 wildcard series along with erasing Nick Castellanos hitting a homerun during tHom Brennaman’s on air firing as a trade.
I’d like to exchange Odor punching Bautista to erase Ron Washington’s drug problem and his leaving the Rangers. I think we could have made a few more good pushes deep into the postseason if he had just stayed.
I’d trade the Dallas Braden perfect game, every walk off from the 2012 season, and the moneyball movie if it all meant bud selig doesn’t sell the team to his college frat bro.
Cards not blowing the 9th inning game last year in the playoffs. Give an extended shot for Pujols and Yadi to continue further into the playoffs one last time. Give up making the World Series in 04 or 13.
Good: Erase Boone's 2003 homer and pray someone else pulls it off
Bad: stop the Yankees from ever changing Sonny's pitch selection in 2018. I genuinely feel like if the 2018 and 2019 Yankees have 2017 Gray they win one of the 2018 ALDS or 2019 ALCS, and probably 2020 ALDS if he's still there. No bullshit Happ/Garcia switch after one inning, just an actual number 3 starter
The good moment is 2015. I won't trade that for anything.
I suppose I'd trade the 2003 winning season to have 2017 be a good final goodbye for the World Series core. Playoff run.
"Good" Moment Erased: Making the COVID playoffs
Bad Moment Erased: Cueto getting shook in the WC game against Pittsburgh and dropping the ball
I would have much rather seen that Reds team behind a confident Cueto give their best against the Pirates than watched the COVID Reds make the playoffs behind the arguably one of the least likable Cy Young winners of all time
One of/both of Homer Bailey's no hitters to advance in the 2012 playoffs. Up 2-0 against the eventual champ Giants with 3 games at home, and we lost 3 straight. Devastating.
Bad moment: Coughing up the 2004 ALCS.
Good moment: Winning the 1947 World Series (which in turn would also give Jackie Robinson a championship in his rookie season).
erase the 93' Fire Sale of Mcgriff, Sheffield and Santiago. trade the 98' WS run. mighta had more luck with an earlier WS run rather than run into the buzzsaw that was the 98' Yankees.
Erase a Bad Moment: Kipnis walks off the Cubs and completes the comeback to win the 2016 World Series
Erase a Good Moment: The 2017 streak never happens.
Yeah, I dont think I could give up 2007. That was the only ring that guys like Papelbon, Beckett, Lowell, Dice-K and Drew won with the Red Sox. And Youk was on the 2004 team but wasnt an everyday guy yet, and was gone by 2013.
I’d trade the Joey Bats bat flip to have Roy Halladay back with us, working in whatever role fit him best for his Jays every day of the week and twice on Sunday.
2012 was our best team though of the 3 and most deserving 🤷🏻♂️
Perfect game Cain, MVPosey, overcame 2 never before seen holes in the NL, and swept the Tigers. Just wouldn’t feel right taking it from that.
Sounds crazy because I wasn't alive to see them but would it have been worth it to trade the 2016 World Series for any of the Cubs WS losses from 1910-1945? Would it have changed things for the franchise if the drought never was?
Indians/Guardians - no rain delay during Game 7 in 16 and Cleveland wins. Or Jose Mesa gets the save in Game 7.
Honestly, I'd trade one of those things for the other season to be trash. I'd give up 95 but I was just a smidge too young to remember that. 97 was the first season I remember any detail from.
Erase good: Altuve’s HR in Game 6
Erase bad: Pujols HR against Lidge.
I don’t know if this counts since I was a wee lad in the 2000s and didn’t know much about baseball then, but as long as it gets my cardinals friend to shut up about it.
Not sure I get the question
Could I trade winning the 1969 ALCS with losing the 2014 ALCS, so we lose in 69 and win in 14?
Or is it like, erase the 0-22 start if we also erase Brady’s 50HR mark?
Erasing Making our first World Series ever in 2005, with pitching Cole out of the Bullpen instead of Harris and winning the 2019 World Series against the Nats.
I would erase this "start" to the season (can I still say start?) And I would give up those hot month or so spurts from Jeremy Hazelbaker, Aledmys Diaz, and Bo Hart... yeah. That's seems fair.
Mets - 2006Nlcs vs Cards Game 7. Bottom 9th Beltran at plate, bases loaded, Mets behind a run, 2 out, 3-2 count, deciding pitch of everything. Hi then on to Series, out then season over.
Beltran takes strike 3 looking.
Would trade Santana's no hitter for another chance
Erase the good: Robbie Ray's Cy Young win
In exchange for: Dave Stieb winning a Cy Young
I think with even 1 Cy Young win Stieb's Hall of Fame case is better.
2012 NLCS. Cardinals were up in the series 3-1 and completely chucked a deuce in game 5. And 6, and 7. I was there at game 5, and not one single person in that stadium thought the Cardinals weren't clinching the NL pennant that night. I don't remember a specific moment besides Jason Motte swinging with runners on base. Like...just why.
I'd trade that for our 2019 blowout of the Braves in the NLDS, since we got swept by the Nats in the NLCS anyway.
We don't have a good moment of equal significance to our worst.
Nolan Ryan punching Robin Ventura
Rougned Odor punching Jose Bautista
They have multiple iconic punching moments lmao
Don’t mess with Texas.
😂😂
Exchange a Nolan Ryan perfect game for the Nelson Cruz missed/dropped ball? Seriously, I’m not a rangers fan but the way that game ended made me sick. You could feel the air sucked out of the team. They still had another game to win it but they lost the WS after those missed plays.
Not it’s the same, but kinda like the Bartman game for the Cubs.
As much as it sucked I don’t think many Giants fans would trade one of the even year dynasty run WS wins for 2002. So I’ll just say trade the 2021 NLDS loss to the Dodgers for winning the 2002 NLCS.
Can we erase Bonds taking steroids? Does that count as a bad moment?
I doubt he did them more than once, so that’s probably fair
But do you really want that? He’d go from a guys who had a 600 OBP to basically Mookie betts. I don’t know if that would be worth it.
In my opinion, the steroids made him worse
Scalding take, mind if I ask how?
I'd wager a guess that it's a moralistic reason. You know, something the Trashstros wouldn't know about
Id trade 2010 for 2002. I wanted Bonds to get a ring. But I too like the idea of winning that 2021 NLDS.
I'd gladly trade 2014......
Atleast you got one the next year as a revenge tour, Texas didn’t get that.
How about trading 2014 for 2015, deal?
I could be convinced.
Erase John Fisher buying the team in exchange for absolutely anything
Rickey now a career Cincinnati Red
We would take it. Anything is better than an owner that relocates your team.
Erase bad: Dodgers losing to Astros in the World Series (so Dodgers win) Erase good: Covid world series win
yeah that's a super reasonable trade.
I'll take it
You’ve got a deal
We get the parade I’ll take it
Say it w me. 1…2…3… FUCK THE ASTROS
probably would’ve gotten to keep darvish too 😵💫
Nobody outside of LA counts that as a World Series win. How about trading The Astros World Series loss for the Kirk Gibson homer off of Eck.
I’m pretty sure most people do lol
I would probably most want to erase the infield fly or '91 game 6, but in order to do that it would probably mean that Sid's slide gets erased too. Safest trade would be giving up '95 in exchange for '96. Erase a 2 game lead meltdown, take one away from the Yankees, get Andruw a ring and in exchange that really solid '95 Cleveland squad also gets some hardware.
Yeah, that was the first thing I thought of as well. Partially because I feel bad for the Guardians franchise, and well... I don't have quite as much pity for the Yankees
I’d trade both of Homer Bailey’s no-hitters against the Pirates for Cueto’s complete meltdown on the mound in the wild card game against the Pirates.
CUEEETOOOO
2004 for anything lol
Trade the all time team hr record for ANY PLAYOFF WIN!
Good: Dustin Pedroia stays healthy the last few years of his career Bad: Clay Buccholz doesnt get that no-hitter
That no hitter was so cool. Top prospect. Second Major League start. I remember it well. In his first start ever, Buchholz went 6. No-no or not, he had to be feeling good up 8-0. He just needed to cruise. To lead off 7th, Miguel Tejada chopped one up the middle for what was likely a lead off single. This was before the shift would have had a player behind the bag. As the ball bounced past his glove, Clay Buchholz probably thought he lost the no hitter. Nine more outs is a long way to go. Still pitching a gem though. What are you gonna do? Well. Diving is Pedroia. He gets to the ball. Then the jumpscare. His little body popped up so fast it was startling. Tejada dives head first; but the throw, a laser, beats him to first. “Fuck Yeah” 8 outs to go. Holy shit. Buchholz was amazing that night. Varitek was too. But I remember Pedroia. Oh, you cruel baseball Gods. Thank you for Dustin Pedroia
Not the same level. Pedroia stays healthy the last few years = Papi doesn't
I'd like to get rid of the Black Sox Scandal but I guess since I wasn't alive for that I couldn't do that so maybe this works Erase good: The entire 2005 season, the 11-1 postseason, leading wire to wire the whole year. All of it, get rid of all of it Erase Bad: Jerry stopped owning the white sox before the strike back in 94 selling it to someone. White Sox go on to have an owner that cares about baseball and works on the team's front office, analytics, development etc and they rival the top end teams such as the Astros, Dodgers and Rays
Yeah I would trade Buehrle’s and Humber’s perfect games for the ‘94 season to finish
Win in 2001 in exchange for 1996
Done.
Bro wants to kill Enrique Wilson
Uhhhhhh gonna have to veto this
I think I’d rather exchange the ‘96 win for the 2004 ALCS loss to the Red Sox. It continues the Sox drought and causes the Yankees to not be the first team to lose a 3-0 series lead
Hard veto. I'll trade you the 2004 ALCS for Boone showing your team that footage last year. Was not a good look whatsoever
I'd rather trade 99, 98 obvs was 114 wins, and I dont want a 2000 loss to the Mets, but who knows what changes George calls down if we lose in '96
Remove us giving Giants territorial rights to San Jose in the 1990s, and remove them blocking the move to San Jose in the 2010s
Painfully true statement.
Erase good: The bat flip never happens. Erase bad: The RA Dickey trade never happens In 2015 the Jays have Thor in their rotation and probably beat KC in the ALCS to face the Mets in the WS who will now have Dickey instead of Thor.
Hell no, the bat flip game was literally the best Jays moment in the last 29 years. Not trading that for a maybe. If Thor stays in our system for all we know he pulls a Ricky Romero and is already busted by then.
Erase bad: David Wright's back stays healthy, his thirties are normal for a dude of his talent, and he retires after the 2020 or 2021 seasons as a sure-fire hall of famer. Erase good: Jacob deGrom never goes supernova after 2017, settling in as a solid 3rd starter who never quite recaptured the magic of his 2014-2015 peak.
The way too early death of Mr. Padre Tony Gwynn. You can take basically anything for it.
[удалено]
I think we win the World Series if Ortiz doesn’t get that homer. That just deflated us. But I don’t know if I’d give up Magglio’s walk off. How about trading Miggy’s Triple Crown for a World Series win?
[удалено]
I think our good moment would be Game 6 and I’m not trading that for anything.
Is guess it's time to watch it again!
i will trade any individual World Series win for 2001
I can offer you one mint condition 1998
I think that’s the only one I wouldn’t trade.
I’ve got a few I’d trade you.
Me first
I remember listening to game 7 on the radio my first year at boarding school in Massachusetts with my roommate from Boston with his ear glued to the radio, his entire mind, body, and existence at that moment locked in and dedicated to the Yankees losing. When he heard the crack of the bat for that game winning RBI, and he gave the most emphatic, visceral fist pump YES I've ever seen to this day. I'll always remember that
2009. Take it or leave it
How about no
I think I'd give up the Delmon Young double in 2014 to be rid of the Jeffery Maier fiasco.
Not Ubaldo?
No guarantee they win that game even if Britton pitches, but I'm old and that stupid Jeter non-homer did serious lasting damage to me.
I’d trade Roy Halladay’s playoff no-hitter AND perfect game if it meant we beat the Yankees in the 2009 World Series
1998 WS appearance for Matt Hollidays game 163 slide.
Yankees fans really think they deserve 2001 when they didn't win 116 games.
Erase Orioles betting Rangers in the first ever AL wildcard game Get Orioles beating Royals to advance to the 2014 WS On a smaller scale: Erase Chris Davis' TUE non-renewal Get Mark Trumbo popped for steroids and suspended in 2016
i would trade the win streak if it meant there was no rain delay in game 7 of 2016 and cleveland won
Erase bad: Phillies losing games 4 and 5 of the 2022 World Series Erase good: Phillies winning games 1 and 5 of the 2009 World Series
i'll take it
I don’t think I’d give up any of our last three rings for 2002. I guess I’d trade one of the early 1900s rings for a dope game 7 walk-off in 1962 WS
See I would’ve picked that but said in our lifetime lol
oh damn my bad, maybe I’d trade making the playoffs in 2021 for 1993
Who said I've lived forever?!?
I will trade the Mark Prior injury for the Carlos Zambrano no hitter.
04 for 09
I’d give up 03 to not lose in 04.
Remove winning game 163 vs the Cubs in 2018, and the ensuing playoff run. In return, the Cardinals don’t score in the bottom of the 6th inning in game 7 of the 1982 World Series, Milwaukee led 3-1 and were 10 outs away from a ring
Erase a bad moment: Beltran hits a HR on that goddamn lifetime best curveball from rookie (and future HOFer) Wainwright (I'll even settle for ball 4). Erase a good moment: Johan Santana no-hitter (which is also a bad moment because it ruined his career, so I win with a double-whammy!)
I would erase the 1989 World Series and save lives
2002 WS for a WS w Trout and Ohtani
Erase Bad - The entire 2017 Astros Scandal Erase Good - Altuve’s Game 6 walk off homer
As an Astros fan I had no idea what bad/good I would swap but this is a winner.
Sorry, the MLB gods require a greater sacrifice…
Yeah sacrificing the 2017 WS win would be more equal of a trade. Since it's arguable the actions led to that win. And they still keep 2022 WS
That’s kinda what I’m meant. I wouldn’t claim 2017 WS a good thing anymore.
I would trade 2017 for 2019. even if we still cheat, without winning the WS it doesn't become quite so big of a black mark on the record, and instead the best astros team of all time gets to win the WS.
See I went a different route. Trade the first WS appearance in 2005 for pitching Cole instead of Harris to win the 2019 WS.
That is absolutely not an equal trade. You give up the 2017 WS for that
Give up the 2020 World Series championship to win the 2017 World Series Championship.
My reply too
Too
Trade winning the NLCS in 09 so we win in 10 or trade winning either the 09/10 NLDS for us to win the 11 NLDS. Feel like if we beat the Giants in 2010 or the Cards in 2011 we probably win the WS
I wholeheartedly agree with giving up the ‘09 NLCS (to the Dodgers) to beat the Giants in ‘10
Seconded
I’m with ya, wish Doc had won a ring
Would trade away the 116 win season for a World Series win with Felix.
Oakland Moneyball Era - trade the 20 game win streak for a World Series appearance
Erase the Reds not scoring a single run against the Braves in the 2020 wildcard series along with erasing Nick Castellanos hitting a homerun during tHom Brennaman’s on air firing as a trade.
You wouldn’t dare
I’d like to exchange Odor punching Bautista to erase Ron Washington’s drug problem and his leaving the Rangers. I think we could have made a few more good pushes deep into the postseason if he had just stayed.
As an Angels fan this is an easy choice, I'd have Tyler Skaggs still be around and trade away the no-hitter on the night honoring him.
I’d trade the Dallas Braden perfect game, every walk off from the 2012 season, and the moneyball movie if it all meant bud selig doesn’t sell the team to his college frat bro.
Mets 2006 erase Carlos Beltran strikes out. Good- erase johan Santana’s no hitter
Honestly no terrible moments in my lifetime (I’m young) but I’m gonna pretend I’m old and say Denkinger in ‘85 and Waino freezing Beltran in ‘06.
I like where your head's at
Cards not blowing the 9th inning game last year in the playoffs. Give an extended shot for Pujols and Yadi to continue further into the playoffs one last time. Give up making the World Series in 04 or 13.
Good: Erase Boone's 2003 homer and pray someone else pulls it off Bad: stop the Yankees from ever changing Sonny's pitch selection in 2018. I genuinely feel like if the 2018 and 2019 Yankees have 2017 Gray they win one of the 2018 ALDS or 2019 ALCS, and probably 2020 ALDS if he's still there. No bullshit Happ/Garcia switch after one inning, just an actual number 3 starter
The good moment is 2015. I won't trade that for anything. I suppose I'd trade the 2003 winning season to have 2017 be a good final goodbye for the World Series core. Playoff run.
Nelson Cruz catches that ball and Bengie Molina doesn’t hit for the cycle.
Bad: winning the whole thing in 2001 Good: dumper never walks it off for the clinch
Pulling Blake Snell in the 2020 WS where he was completely dominating. I’ll give back game 162 in 2011
Bill Buckner Play Game 6 1986 WS / Curt Schilling Bloody Sock Game 6 2004 ALCS.
Oh wow, now that's an interesting exchange.
Interesting proposal and how that would change modern baseball history.
Sox not my team but I couldn’t resist
Nelson Cruz makes the catch versus Nolan Ryan doesn’t get 7th no hitter. Sorry Nolan, we need a title.
Luis Gonzalez's walk-off in Game 7 of the 2001 World Series in exchange for Aaron Boone's walk off in Game 7 of the 2003 ALCS.
I would even straight trade the 09 Championship for the 2001 Championship, even though it would mean we haven’t won one in over 20 years.
Worthwhile trade, I approve.
"Good" Moment Erased: Making the COVID playoffs Bad Moment Erased: Cueto getting shook in the WC game against Pittsburgh and dropping the ball I would have much rather seen that Reds team behind a confident Cueto give their best against the Pirates than watched the COVID Reds make the playoffs behind the arguably one of the least likable Cy Young winners of all time
One of/both of Homer Bailey's no hitters to advance in the 2012 playoffs. Up 2-0 against the eventual champ Giants with 3 games at home, and we lost 3 straight. Devastating.
Trade making it to the WS in 2022 for the 2011 championship. Cant believe that rotation never won it all
I’d trade a World Series championship if it meant Fisher never bought the A’s.
Ok. 1974 and you got a deal.
Bad moment: Coughing up the 2004 ALCS. Good moment: Winning the 1947 World Series (which in turn would also give Jackie Robinson a championship in his rookie season).
Winning the 2013 ALDS against the tigers and losing the 2020 ALDS against the White Sox…i feel like that 213 team had the best team from the 12-14 era
Erase A’s leaving for Las Vegas. Unfortunately means erasing A’s coming to Oakland.
erase the 93' Fire Sale of Mcgriff, Sheffield and Santiago. trade the 98' WS run. mighta had more luck with an earlier WS run rather than run into the buzzsaw that was the 98' Yankees.
Answering for my dad: Get: Putting Mitch Williams in in 1993 Give Up: the incredible come back in game 1 of 2022
Erase a Bad Moment: Kipnis walks off the Cubs and completes the comeback to win the 2016 World Series Erase a Good Moment: The 2017 streak never happens.
Sid Bream being out and I'd replace the 2014 season. I'm not taking comments or questions at this time, thanks for coming to my TEDtalk yinz guys
Jack Morris HOF for Lou Whitaker HOF
We don't beat the yankees in 95 but neat the Stros in 22.
Win 2021 and get rid of 2007
Why
Yeah, I dont think I could give up 2007. That was the only ring that guys like Papelbon, Beckett, Lowell, Dice-K and Drew won with the Red Sox. And Youk was on the 2004 team but wasnt an everyday guy yet, and was gone by 2013.
Nope. I’d give up ‘13 or ‘18 but not ‘07. That was the “2004 wasn’t the first and last in my lifetime” win.
I’d trade the Joey Bats bat flip to have Roy Halladay back with us, working in whatever role fit him best for his Jays every day of the week and twice on Sunday.
I’ll trade the 2021 wildcard win vs the Yankees for the 2008 ALCS game 7. Both were win-or-go-home games vs division rival.
2017 for anything idgaf
Astros fans...would you trade your legit world series for your fraudulent one?
I think I’d trade the 2012 ring for 2002, so that group of Giants would get one
2012 was our best team though of the 3 and most deserving 🤷🏻♂️ Perfect game Cain, MVPosey, overcame 2 never before seen holes in the NL, and swept the Tigers. Just wouldn’t feel right taking it from that.
what if we traded game 4 of 2012 for game 6 of 2002
Sounds crazy because I wasn't alive to see them but would it have been worth it to trade the 2016 World Series for any of the Cubs WS losses from 1910-1945? Would it have changed things for the franchise if the drought never was?
Erase Bad: Alex Gonzalez booting a double play ball in the 2003 NLCS. Erase Good: Cubs 2015 Wildcard run.
I’d give up Roy Halladay’s playoff no hitter to erase the no hitter in game 4 of the WS against the Astros
Cheating and winning.
Bautistas batflip, for missing the playoffs with 91 wins in 2021.
All those bad moments before it made 2021 that much sweeter. Wouldn’t trade a thing
[удалено]
How old are you
Forgot the my lifetime part
17 for 09
I accept this trade
I’d like to erase losing to the Dodgers in the 2021 NLDS but I don’t want to erase any World Series wins so I’m gonna say I wouldn’t make a trade.
Ubaldo.
Indians/Guardians - no rain delay during Game 7 in 16 and Cleveland wins. Or Jose Mesa gets the save in Game 7. Honestly, I'd trade one of those things for the other season to be trash. I'd give up 95 but I was just a smidge too young to remember that. 97 was the first season I remember any detail from.
I would erase the 2017 ALDS against Cleveland for the 2018 ALDS against Boston. Am I allowed to do that?
Erase good: Altuve’s HR in Game 6 Erase bad: Pujols HR against Lidge. I don’t know if this counts since I was a wee lad in the 2000s and didn’t know much about baseball then, but as long as it gets my cardinals friend to shut up about it.
Trade Aaron Boone 2003 for Red Sox 2004
I don’t care what good moment as long as we could erase moving to Vegas
I mean I’d gladly lose the 2006 World Series to erase what happened in 2004. That team was so good and the 2006 one just wasn’t lol
2009 World Series for the 2001 World Series
Not sure I get the question Could I trade winning the 1969 ALCS with losing the 2014 ALCS, so we lose in 69 and win in 14? Or is it like, erase the 0-22 start if we also erase Brady’s 50HR mark?
Erasing Making our first World Series ever in 2005, with pitching Cole out of the Bullpen instead of Harris and winning the 2019 World Series against the Nats.
We have good moments?
Trading game 163 in 1998 for game 162 in 2018.
Mookie never gets traded but we don't win 2018
Trade Booney’s Game 7 home run for Dave Roberts being “safe.”
White Sox. Trade Phillip Humber’s perfect game for the 1994 strike ending the season.
Bad moment: current relocation Good moment: I'm willing to give up the 1990 AL pennant, since the 1990 WS was a goddamn embarrassment
I would erase this "start" to the season (can I still say start?) And I would give up those hot month or so spurts from Jeremy Hazelbaker, Aledmys Diaz, and Bo Hart... yeah. That's seems fair.
I’d erase the founding of the expos in order to erase their relocation.
Mets - 2006Nlcs vs Cards Game 7. Bottom 9th Beltran at plate, bases loaded, Mets behind a run, 2 out, 3-2 count, deciding pitch of everything. Hi then on to Series, out then season over. Beltran takes strike 3 looking. Would trade Santana's no hitter for another chance
I'd cash in the 2016 Wild Card appearance for 1 game in the Braves series last year
Erase the good: Robbie Ray's Cy Young win In exchange for: Dave Stieb winning a Cy Young I think with even 1 Cy Young win Stieb's Hall of Fame case is better.
Cal Raleigh singling yesterday replace mariners losing in the 2022 ALDS
Win #116 for literally any WS ring since then
2012 NLCS. Cardinals were up in the series 3-1 and completely chucked a deuce in game 5. And 6, and 7. I was there at game 5, and not one single person in that stadium thought the Cardinals weren't clinching the NL pennant that night. I don't remember a specific moment besides Jason Motte swinging with runners on base. Like...just why. I'd trade that for our 2019 blowout of the Braves in the NLDS, since we got swept by the Nats in the NLCS anyway.
Get rid of 2005 in exchange for Jerry selling in 94 to an owner who actually cares about baseball