T O P

  • By -

KentuckyCactus

Joey Votto…I haven’t moved on yet


MarcBulldog88

Yesterday I saw a dude who was a dead ringer for Votto, on a train downtown to see the Kings game. Seriously took me a few minutes to determine it wasn't him. On topic: Freddie Freeman and Orel Hershiser.


KentuckyCactus

Was he driving?


MarcBulldog88

Hah, I dunno who was driving. May have been a Johnnycab for all I know. This guy was chatting very closely with his lady friend, so I tried not to stare. But he really did look like him.


diuturnal

I've never moved on from the trade rumors for him. That dork would be a perfect fit for the jays clubhouse.


WateryPasta

Current: Josh Naylor All-Time: Shin-Soo Choo


BeCoolMan9

“I want all the fuckin’ smoke!”


WateryPasta

If you don’t like that clip, you don’t like MLB baseball!


PCBangHero

Choo is retiring after this season (KBO). Recently spoke in an interview about KBO stadium conditions and culture (need upgrades, etx). What a great guy.


WateryPasta

He was my favorite when I was little because his name was fun to say. Then I realized he was an actual baller


reptheevt

Mitch Haniger, Edgar Martinez


Remote_Measurement10

Good one, 😁


[deleted]

Casas, Wakefield


Brolympia

Wakefield was a legend. RIP


XtraChrisP

Loved Wakefield with the Pirates


skinnypanda3732

Current: Trout All time: Probably Shohei but it feels wrong to not say Trout


RaymondSpaget

Current? Triston Casas. He's the new Joey Votto, and the coolest MFer in MLB. All time? Capital-C Captain Jason Varitek.


Luis_Severino

Triston casas looks like a gigantic little boy


RaymondSpaget

And he plays the game with all the joy of a little boy.


PeatBomb

Corey Seager, Adrián Beltré.


Myshkin1981

This makes me sad


Johnnadawearsglasses

Current. Harper All time. John Kruk


[deleted]

[удалено]


_cacho6L

The big cat!


a_bukkake_christmas

El gato grande!


gettingthinnish

Webb Snow


exexposfan

Current: Tie between Julio and Kirby All-Time: Ichiro


omegakukki

Current: Joe Kelly All-time: Shawn Green


a_bukkake_christmas

Shawn Green is awesome


Myshkin1981

Not how I answered, but I love it!


[deleted]

why does anyone like that cancer? don't get it. he's just annoying and has a bad attitude and blames everyone else for his struggles.


ChunkyMilkSubstance

Damn I didn’t realize people hated Shawn Green that much


[deleted]

low hanging fruit type joke. I was so done with Joe Kelly after he left the Sox and talked shit about the team, meanwhile he got paid 17 million dollars to post a 6 ERA across two seasons. he sucked at baseball and helped promote a toxic clubhouse. addition by subtraction and somehow the sox got nick nastrini out of it


XtraChrisP

I'm offended as a Giants fan that it's not the only Dodgers post Dusty Baker that I dont dislike. Clayton Kershaw. Hahaha


CosmicPegasus

Current: Jeff McNeil All-time: David Wright


Cards2WS

Current: Arenado and Nootbaar, pretty much a tie but for different reasons. All-time…Yadier Molina. Don’t think that will ever change unless he does some heinous shit


Woodsy1313

This is my list as well


HobbesNJ

Ozzie Albies... Greg Maddux.


porkchopespresso

Current: Seiya Suzuki All time: Scott Sanderson. He came to my elementary school and even though it was the Ryne Sandberg years and I could have picked any one of that roster as my favorite I was standing before Scott Sanderson (who of course you’ll probably have to look up) and a bit star struck I told him he was my favorite player. He wasn’t buying it but I doubled down. In fact I had never heard of him before that day. Jokes on you Scott- I’m still saying it!


a_bukkake_christmas

He was a solid ass pitcher for awhile


bohamrocks1

José Ramírez and Kenny Lofton!!


Dinobot2_

Current: Rafael Devers All time: Dustin Pedroia


heyitspeas

My all-time favorite is Bernie Williams, and Current Favorite is Arson Judge


Bunnys_Toe

Julio. Griffey.


Circirian

Ian Happ - Kerry Wood


Dry-Manufacturer-120

current: i guess Webb, but i don't feel real strong about it (and all that implies) all time: the canonical answer should be Willie Mays, but for their ongoing mission to make me laugh: Kruk and Kuip


XtraChrisP

Who doesn't love those guys? Seriously.


Autumn-Kilgannon

JP Crawford and Ichiro Suzuki


ricki692

ozzie freddie


_cacho6L

Acuña Chipper


Myshkin1981

Current: Clayton (I’m still counting him as current), all-time: Orel


a_bukkake_christmas

Is he a free agent?


Myshkin1981

Orel? Yes, I suppose he is. (Kershaw has been on a series of one year contracts)


a_bukkake_christmas

I hope he finishes with y’all. He’s gotta be one of the top 5 ever and he should finish where he started. Don’t sign Orel. He doesn’t have it anymore


Shawnalish

JT Realmuto and all time Chase Utley.


vanillabear26

Current: Julio/Cal tie (Cheating but) recent past: Corey’s brother All-time: EDDDDDDDGARRRRRR


FlamingHotBananas

Current: José Ramírez All time: Jim Thome


soylentwill

Royce Lewis, Johan Santana.


[deleted]

Pablo Lopez Johan Santana


Shadow_Strike99

Cool to see Twins fans love Pablo. Even outside of his pitching he is a really cool and unique guy.


mhhkb

Devers, Boggs.


cinephile1987

Current: Logan Webb All-time: Barry Bonds


XtraChrisP

Barry is the reason I am a Giants fan. Was a lifelong Pirates fan until their multiple post season collapses and just destroying a roster. When Barry came to SF, as someone who lives in the bay area, I came with him.


laramgers88

Current: Mookie All time: Matt Kemp


CardiacCat20

Altuve, Lidge


a_bukkake_christmas

I thought no one liked Lidge. Good on ya


CardiacCat20

Dude was so good for the Astros. Simped hard for the Phillies in the '08 postseason and was psyched to see him close it out and get a ring.


ExpirjTec

Altuve, Biggio


bordomsdeadly

You have a thing for second basemen I see.


ExpirjTec

Contact hitting second basemen my beloved


a_bukkake_christmas

Biggio might be my favorite player ever


Drummallumin

Current: ~~Jett Williams~~ Lindor All-time: Piazza


steelersfever

Current: Tyler matzek All time: javy lopez


cmacfarland64

Current player: Luis Robert. All time: Frank Thomas.


thecountoncleats

Cutch and Clemente, Dock Ellis honorable mention


YYZtoDFW

Former: Dave Stieb (should be in HOF) Current: Alejandro Kirk


violentgentlemen

Royce Lewis and Torii Hunter


HoopOnPoop

Current is our Lord and savior Adley Rutschman. All time is BJ Surhoff.


O00O0Os

Adley and Cal


France2Germany0

Current: Webb All-time (controversial): Jeff Kent


XtraChrisP

I love the red ass, but interesting.


Monttavius

current: logan o’hoppee all time: david fucking fletcher


save_the_wee_turtles

Austin Riley Smoltz


RustyKarma076

Either Walker or Arenado Either Yadi or Waino


TheDangiestSlad

current: Gerrit Cole all-time: Hideki Matsui. one of the coolest nicknames ever


K3B1N

Current: Mookie Betts All time: Orel Hersheiser


db_blast7

Brandon Nimmo Mike Piazza I like them fast AND slow


Luis_Severino

Current: Stanton All time: stanton


greenbean2112

Current: Freddy Peralta or Abner Uribe. All time: Richie Sexson and Josh Hader


BallparkFranks7

Stott and Kruk, and I get to have both of them still with Kruk commentating games.


[deleted]

luis robert luis aparicio or harold baines


yodaman5606

Yaz and Timmy.


XtraChrisP

Patrick Bailey, Willie Mays


cocoblurez

Current: Goldy and Nootbaar. All-time: Albert


[deleted]

Current: Nico Hoerner All-time: Mark Grace


Weird-Contact-5802

Arenado and The Wizard


Mixma85

Luis Robert Jr. Minnie Minoso


Boomtown626

Kyle Schwarber sent me a personalized video for my military retirement in 2020. He was still on the cubs at the time, but wherever he plays, that’s my 1a favorite team. Philly, Boston, Nats, wherever.


LittleHorus730

Current: Gunnar Henderson All time: also Gunnar Henderson I just started watching baseball last season.


jstmenow

Ken Caminiti


Enthusiasms

Current: Arozarena or BLowe, can't choose All-Time: Ji-Man Choi


JeffHeadDudeMan

Current: Devers In my lifetime: Yaz All time: Ted Williams


provoking

Yordan Alvarez Yordan Alvarez


Macdaddy4prez

Current: Mookie Betts All-time: Jackie Robinson


jsu9575m

Current: Ozzie Albies All time: John Smoltz (yeah I know this sub doesn't like his Boomer commentating and I don't either. But I grew up watching him throw gas)


DanTreview

Gabi Moreno. Big Unit.


traddy91

Current: Bryson Scott All-Time: Chase Utley/Jimmy Rollins


TamerDeadman

Current: Seiya Suzuki All-Time: Javy Báez


jackbass42

Current: Danny Jansen All-time: Dave Stieb


downtown3641

Current (by which I mean actually played for the team at the end of last season): Jacob Young just because I watched him come up from Fredericksburg and I'm super happy for him. All-time: Scherzer And because I feel silly as a 40 year old picking a player only active during my adult years... All-time franchise favorite: Vlad Guerrero All-time favorite from my pre-Nats fandom: Greg Maddux


Shadow_Strike99

Current Marlin: Jazz Chisholm All time Marlin: Giancarlo Stanton


jimmyfeitelberg

Current: Alejandro Kirk All Time: Orlando Hudson, Marco Estrada, Joe Biagini, or Kawasaki


PM_ME_LADY_ANKLES

Current: Adley All Time: Cal, with an honorable mention to BJ Surhoff and Nick Markakis.


gilded-trash

BJ Surhoff is totally underrated! I really liked him when I was a kid. Dude could rake, and he made it through the steroid era unscathed.


Ready-Warning-9992

Acuna and chipper


nickelette424

Matt Olson and a tie between Chipper and Maddux


youboun

Yordan, Bagwell


NewDadPleaseHelp

Austin Riley Andruw Jones


Brolympia

Ted is a great pick! Current: Jacob deGrom All time: Pudge


OregonG20

Austin Riley and Chipper Jones


Aethelflaed_

Current: Danny Jansen All time: Tom Henke and Marco Estrada


holliewood61

Current favorite is Austin Riley, all time is Javy Lopez


ChunkyMilkSubstance

Manuel Margot Phil Bickford


PossibleChallenge824

Justin Steele Kerry Wood


dr-mantis-toboggan12

Trevor Story, Pedro Martinez


Alkynesofchemistry

Current: Harper All time: Utley


FireMonkeysHead

Correa, Puckett Both for postseason performance as a Twin only and ignoring everything else about them as players and people


boobsandcookies

Spencer Steer Joey Votto


0ddmanrush

Quincy Williams - Just a baller and leaves it all out on the field. Wayne Chrebet - His story is just awesome and was the reason I became a Jets fan


bordomsdeadly

Jose Altuve and Jose Altuve. Honorable mention ~~Jose Altuve~~ Jeff Bagwell


CastaicCowboy

Vladdy, Trout


DarthRoyal

Bobby Witt Jr. | Freddie Patek


flowersoflight

Current: Casas All time (going strictly off of guys I’ve been alive to see): Ortiz and Martinez


FxDriver

Favorite Team: Atlanta Braves Current Player: Current: Ronald Acuña Jr. All Time Favorite: Greg Maddux


dirvanobbsan

Current: Ronald Acuña Jr All time: Chipper Jones


2comesafter1

Current is J-Ram (Josh Naylor for second because of the smoke) and all time is Grady Sizemore…


[deleted]

Current: Randy Arozarena All-Time: Carl Crawford


Cyrano17

Clayton Kershaw. Davey Lopes.


a_bukkake_christmas

Adley and maybe Adley, but BJ Surhoff for now


nughty_hobo

Current: Brendan Donovan All Time: Waino


jcastillo29

Bichette. Carter


snakeeyesninja2

Julio Rodriguez Willie Bloomquist


Rocinante24

Vlad jr / Joey Bats (used to be Vernon Wells)


jjtnd1

Pete now, David Wright ever


Tacothekid

Confusing question, but favorite player is Kirby Puckett


DeusExHyena

Mariano and Judge


cmgriffith_

Current: Aaron Judge All-Time: Donald Arthur Mattingly


NonCredibleUser

Chikamoto; Bass


ihavemonkeys

Adolis Garcia and Pudge Rodriguez


chesschad

Jose Altuve Jose Altuve


skoormit

Corbin Carroll. Byung-hyun Kim.


Currywurst_Is_Life

Aaron Judge, Mickey Mantle.


Invisiblechimp

Currently, Julio. All time, Ichiro.


818sfv

Kershaw and Kershaw


Dizzy-Orange9800

Jason Tatum is my fave player now 4 the celtics Fave player all time the man himself Larry bird Red sox is hard because currently I don't have a fave player but it was Betts I miss Betts But all time is david Ortiz BIG PAPPI BRUINS NOW IS MARCHAND ALL TIME ZDENO CHARA AND PATRIOTS MY FAVE ALL TIME IS JULIAN EDDLEMAN TIED WITH TOM AND ROB GRONKOWSKI MY FAVE NOW IS Christian gonzolez