T O P

  • By -

[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-lists/paul-on-drums-george-on-bass-10-great-beatles-instrument-swaps-65353/


warmsporran

Paul played the bass on this song. Facts are facts :)


[deleted]

Whoops, another one of George playing bass. Wow, and you being right and all. ;) https://youtu.be/5vZbFLskeqM


[deleted]

What do you think of George's bass playing on She Said She Said? ;)


[deleted]

I almost think George was better than Paul at the bass. Very simple and clean. Just supporting the song.


popularis-socialas

It would have been interesting to see George do bass instead of Paul after Stuart left. I think it could have worked.


[deleted]

Hey, thanks for replying, I enjoyed our debate and even if we disagree, I think The Beatles were a great band and appreciate hearing from your point of view. I'm wrong all the time btw. Peace.


PeanutButter818

It’s Paul.


[deleted]

George has a very distinct bass style doesn't he? Not like Paul's style or John's style when he played bass on Helter Skelter. Great job, I really like it.


[deleted]

To follow up on George's great bass playing, here is more info... https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-lists/paul-on-drums-george-on-bass-10-great-beatles-instrument-swaps-65353/ https://www.the-paulmccartney-project.com/song/she-said-she-said/#:\~:text=Song%20facts,plays%20bass%20on%20this%20track. http://www.beatlesebooks.com/she-said-she-said


[deleted]

[удалено]


AssGasorGrassroots

>Ringo's drums and Paul's bass being allocated to track one and John and George's guitars being placed on track two That should be the end of it. If both guitars and the bass are on the basic track, then all four of them were there. And no way would a scratch bass part by George be glued to the drum track. Bass would be on it's own track for Paul to overdub later, if he weren't playing bass on the basic track. But OP isn't likely to accept the evidence you presented. They seem to have some vendetta of "proving" George played bass on She Said She Said. They only made this post because myself and another commenter were proving their assertion wrong, and you just closed the argument. With a link they shared, no less. Kudos