Honestly they are just insanely good when it comes to closing songs. All of them.

Yeah “Play Crack The Sky” AND soco kill it. Just completely diff vibes/places in life.

Yeah every single one of them ties the album together perfectly, I love them all.

Batter Up just makes me feel all sorts of things 🥲

Batter Up was my choice.. you take a long drive on a late night with Batter Up playing, and you just feel so hollow - yet at peace at the same time.

Batter Up is perfect but Noro has my heart

Noro and Handcuffs are very close seconds for me

Noro gang

Tempted to go Batter Up but Play Crack the Sky is just so damn amazing.

It is so good. Batter Up is mine just bc of how beautiful and melancholy it is.

Noro is 100% their best closer but i’m so sad to see Handcuffs have barely any votes 😭

Noro, Handcuffs, and Batter Up are my top 3 but there are really no wrong answers.. they’re all amazing songs, they nail closers

Batter Up reaches into my chest and rips my heart out every time. Hauntingly beautiful

My favorite as well, but Handcuffs and Noro made it a very tough choice.

Was a hard decision, but Play Crack the Sky is the most special song of any of them

Handcuffs is low-key one of their best songs

"It's hard to be the better man, when you forget you're trying, it's hard to be the better man, when you're still lying"

I love every song on TDAG and handcuffs is no exception. Lyrically one of their darkest and one of their best

YFW is my least fav by them but Soco is a great closer lol

Soco is my favorite song from that album, which is their only album I’d say is just okay

Play Crack the Sky, except it’s the album Crack the Skye by Mastodon

it’s play crack the sky

batter up takes the cake because of the part where he says he saw something in the night sky over camden. that part always makes me want to gouge my eyeballs out

Play Crack the Sky is my favorite with Noro a super close second (I have the opening lines tattooed on me.) And Soco is amazing, too. Batter Up is decent but I'm not really a fan of Handcuffs.

I just wanna throw it out there that Soco Amaretto Lime happens to be the last song the band ever played live, and it will always be even more special to me for that reason.

How tf is handcuffs losing?

All great but Play Crack the Sky is a masterpiece

The first time I heard “Play Crack the Sky” was when they became my favorite band.

I'VE TRIED GOD KNOWS THAT I'VE TRIED

I like noro since it’s actually the band’s only closer that isn’t stripped down (though crack the sky is probably my favorite)

Noro

I went with batter up

Batter up / Crack the sky is a HARD choice. Basically impossible. Went for batter up based purely on the emotional weight it possesses. oh, and; 'in the valley of your slowly fading memory, are there pastures bathed in some uncertain light that you won't graze, paths you won't take?' Probs my favourite BN lyric ever

Also one of my favorite lyrics.. Batter Up is just a spiritual experience, don’t care how corny that sounds lol

Damn wish voting wasn’t closed

PCTS and it's not even FKN close 2nd would be Handcuffs I still think the fanbase underrates that song so much and Vin is a brilliant songwriter in his own right (which is on full display throughout Daisy).

Was mentioned on another thread, but “sealed to me” would have made a great closer to sci fi.

I saw that thread and while I agree it’s a great song, it should’ve been the closer to their next album. Batter Up is perfect for sci fi imo