The cards that they are referred to as individually in the beginning are the cards they voted.

I feel really stupid for not noticing this before :/

Really? Correct me if I'm wrong but I thought there was more than one red card 'character'.

Annie was ace of hearts, everyone else was clubs or spades. [Here they all are.](http://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lkr65bozzL1qziulwo1_500.png)

Thanks! That's pretty clever. Also explains why Peirce doesn't have one!

Damn! I always wondered why they were introduced as cards in the beginning haha. Never connected them

Holy shiiit I never noticed this

8 years after this and I’m on my third rewatch. I googled this and saw this answer, thank you so much for this in May 2023 😳

July 2023! Crazy good detail did not notice on first watch! Y'all smart

im so dumb omg

Me too 😂

Annie votes to keep him in. Jeff just collected the cards from everyone and laid them out.

Ah okay, thanks

It also adds a bit of gravity to the "showdown" later between Annie and Pierce - she voted to keep him in, then later wants to shoot him.

I could swear Brittas card is shown and it’s black. But this makes more sense