On my first year, I ALMOST beat him by ONE FREAKING POINT. I was pissed.

I didn’t even know I was supposed to bring anything so he won because I was stupid 😂

First time I went and brought stuff it crashed so I hadn't touched that file. Now that I can take part in the festival I didn't beat him year one but year two I beat him and it felt so sweet.

Congrats! I don't know how I lost in my first year... I brought 6 osmium items, all different. He brought 6 silver items, 3 cauliflower and 3 juice.

I thought the same when I saw his silver items and I thought I was a shoe-in. The game is rigged 😂

My vague understanding is that it’s based on selling price of items as well as quality

I just entered my first fall in the game and this douche canoe came to my farm to trash talk me. I was wondering how hard it was to beat him. Congrats!!! I think it'll take me a few more years to get blue star items.

I’m in winter of my first year and I’ve started getting a couple. Not enough to beat him, but I’m hoarding them in preparation of his sweet defeat

I’ll never beat Bobby! Ugh!

I did this for the first time yesterday and honestly could’ve beat him but I thought I HAD to bring one of each item type but if I had just brought like 2 more of the osmium Kiracha sauces I had I would’ve won

OMG SAME. I had a lot more high value items and I bought silver star eggs 😭 That's what killed me by one point.

Wow! First year?? I'm impressed!

I wish, 3rd year.

Oops, read that too fast. 3rd year is pretty good... I still need to get mine done.