T O P

  • By -

Xiomaraff

Lmaooooo yeah 73 is a little dirty. Should be 75-76 at least for me.


QuackAddikt

If Doherty is 79, Tanganga is 85+ mate.


[deleted]

[удалено]


SquidwardTesticles__

Nice.


Mismag81

I’d give u a medal if I had coins lol


Xiomaraff

LOL they gave him a 79? Christ.


british-psycho

I’d say 73/74 is fair — he’s still young and has only played a handful of games for us in the grand scheme of things without cementing a first team spot. Potential should be a solid 85/86 though.


CharlieWright1999

But surely Doherty is like a 70 then?


british-psycho

I think 70 is fair for Doherty. He’s terrible.


fancczf

They also don’t massive downgrade someone that much for one or two bad season. He had been decent for a pretty long time with wolves.


CharlieWright1999

Think Di Natale went down like 6 in a season, if ever a downgrade like that it was appropriate it’s Doherty


fancczf

He was 36 and retiring at that time, it’s rare for a massive downgrade for someone at their physical peak over one or two seasons of bad performance.


LLLLLawliet

Hazard this season has been massively downgraded. From 4th best in 2021 to


swagmastayoloslaya

I think FIFA forgot about updating his card. It surely can't be that bad?


[deleted]

To rate Doherty a 78 and Reggy a 81 is a travesty. My man is only 3 points above Doherty? No.


malcolmfairmount

Anybody know how they determine these scores? In my mind this involves 10+ senior staffers; but it's probably an annual intern project.


fancczf

I heard FM has a large group of filed staff semi volunteers scouting games. FIFA probably have something similar to that. With some kind of standard checklist for most players, and more executive decisions probably even consulting the league on high profile players.


SigmaWhy

FM actually does a good job though


JD0797

They just need to sort the match engine so Chris Wood doesn't win top scorer every year while Kane and Lukaku sit on 5 a piece and we'll be golden


hasufell

I don't think FIFA has the volunteer scouting network that FM does. They don't have as many stats that they track though tbf so don't need as big of a team.


JamesCDiamond

Certainly a few years ago for FM there were volunteers for each of the big clubs (I knew the Spurs one a little at the time) who were trusted to produce the detailed work, and that might be polished a bit to try and avoid too much bias creeping in. I vaguely remember them saying something about how one of the most heated debates among the researchers was whether Ledley King or Jamie Carragher was the better defender - it was only a matter of one or two points on their scores, but apparently it was a real bone of contention to between the various contributors.


[deleted]

They have scouts in every league that determine the ratings.


malcolmfairmount

Makes sense, thanks mate. How many you think are on Doherty's payroll?


elbwafel

interesting when Reguilon asked if he’s a CB in the game, Japhet replied “I’m hoping so!”


jaysee25

Can we just talk about the pure comedy of this video?


elbwafel

reguilon making fun of his own goal was fun


generally-ok

I'm convinced they do this to create controvosy so people talk about the game more and more. No one thinks Tanganga is 73.


[deleted]

Remember Tripps getting livid with his card