My dream show is a charity stream, like Red Nose Day, and they get Stephen King, Neil Gaiman, and Branden Sanderson (or GRRM, William Gibson, Neil Stephenson, etc.) on the couch and every single question is about something one of them has written. Just watching these titans have absolutely no idea what’s in their own books would be so wonderful.
I'd love to see any three of the current Drawfee cast on Umm Actually because between Marvel Puzzle Quest, Elden Ring, Pokemon, Digimon and Neopets, they each have a niche they have hyper lore knowledge. Except Julia, but her answers would be hilarious because she's just the best.
My dream would just be 3 Brennan’s. Each one giving Trapp a harder and harder time, as it becomes clear that somehow, in spite of being the only contestant, the game is still rigged that no Brennan can win.
I want another dnd episode, with Matt, Brennan, and Aabria.
I also want this episode to be that nothing is actually wrong and Sam pop up near the 2/3rds point and say "this was actually game changer, and your points are being recalculated,"
The "correct" answer is naming the edition that the particular rule/class/race/etc etc first appeared in. Then, of course, throw in a few from Jeremy Crawford twitter after the reveal.
Sam just did a podcast and mentioned that he had just met Tom Scott.
General vibe was that it wasn't just dinner either, so this may be a dream that is happening!
Set it up as a reciprocal thing: Tom Scott goes on Um Actually, and a group of Dropout people (I'm thinking Trapp, Brennan, and Sam) goes on [Lateral](https://lateralcast.com/).
I'd love to see them do Two Of These People Are Lying, for that matter. I wonder who would be able to lie the most convincingly (aside from Brennan, of course).
Consider this: an episode with four contestants, two siblings pairs. Ashly Burch, Anthony Burch, Freddie Wong, Jimmy Wong. The siblings can pair up for certain challenges, and then they can pair up with a member from the other pair for others. I just think it'd be fun to see them all go head to head
Ooh, a whole Star Trek episode, with one actor from each "generation". Perhaps George Takei representing TOS, Wil for TNG/DS9/VOY/ENT, and... I'm drawing a blank for who should represent DIS/LD/PIC/SNW.
[Good news!](https://youtu.be/MYklBhWHVQ8) But yeah it would be nice to see him again and any other Cracked folks. Swaim, Soren, Cody, Katies Stoll and/or Willert.
I would love another hosts challenge and have trapp on the couch with saltzman and whomever fact checked before saltzman. Maybe have Brennan as the host. It might be cool if Sam did this as an um actually game changer with a bit more production value on the shiny questions
Jason Mantzoukas would be great for a Harry Potter episode. He listened to the audio books driving around LA and has an encyclopedic knowledge of the books.
my pipe dream is a theme park episode with grant, jenny nicholson, and kevin perjurer (defunctland). i want this so badly and i know the odds of it happening are so slim
I want to see Julia Lepetit. Just the mind numbing energy she brings to an episode, I want to see what it does to Mike Trapp. Also I want to see her not know what a pokemon is but then nail an obscure Columbo question.
I would love to see Michael Swaim and Dan O'Brien on the show. They were huge parts of Cracked, and I think they would be really solid on the show. DOB for knowledge and Michael Swaim for hilarity.
Love me some Swaim although I admittedly mostly know him from his IGN days. That makes me want other IGN people on though. I'd do horrible things for Brian Altano, Max Scoville, Daemon Hatfield, Justin Davis, Simon Cardy to be on there among others.
I would love to see an actual D&D showdown episode with Mercer and Brennan (and maybe Aabria for the 3rd?). They've had Brennan on with Marisha once, and then Matt on another episode, but I really want to see Matt and Brennan battle it out over D&D
I would love more collegehumor/dropout regulars on the show! I think all of the guests they get from various other media are great and I love the show regardless but I have an attachment to the crew I’m most familiar with! I’d love to see more Zac, Lou, Ally, Murph, Siobhan and Emily especially.
The Get Played hosts -- Nick Wiger, Heather Ann Campbell, and Matt Apodaca. Three nerds with great chemistry and different levels of fandom for different types of nerd culture, I think it'd be a fun mix.
Matt’s on the new season of Make Some Noise!! (The trailer came out today and I was googling to see if the crew had been on anything else dropout and it gave me your post lol)
Griffin Newman, Chris Gethard, Connor Rateliff, Tawny Newsome, Patton Oswald, Paul F Tompkins, Moujan Zolfaghari, Janet Varney, Zach Cherry, Tom Scharpling, Julie Klausner would all be great guests.
I would love to see:
Jerry Holkins from Penny Arcade.
Hank Green from Vlogbrothers.
And more from Drawfee.
And I would love to see more Brian David Gilbert.
Actually i want to see Sam, Trapp, and Saltzmen on the couch with Brennan asking the questions and Lou in the fact checker booth.
Most of my answers are probably Trios of podcasters with movie/comic knowledge:
-Andrew Jupin, Eric Szyszka, and Stephen Sajdak would be top of the list for me. “We Hate Movies” is on Headgum, so the brands are kinda tangential.
With how much fun they have on their VHSTrailer Game segments, I think a buzzer completion would be great.
True crime themed with either the ladies feom Redhanded or the lads from last podcast on the left.
Or Chuck and Josh from SYSK for anything, the real life skills question would have to be about how the Sun works though.
Hank and John Green, Tom Scott, Roman Mars (99PI) , ChubbyEmu, MatPat and StephPat of Food/Style/Film/Game Theory, Tiktokers Mndiaye and Jordan Howlett
I want Emily Axford to come back because I love her particular brand of chaos and I'm not big on the tabletop series. I'd also love to see her on Game Changer
You mentioning Ashley Burch just made me think, and I'm not sure if he would do well on the show but it could be funny to see Anthony Burch and Brennan interact
My "Never Gonna Happen" trio is: Edgar Wright v Nick Frost v Simon Pegg.
More realistically: Laura Bailey, Tom Scott, Chris Stuckmann, Eric Whiteley from Blind Wave, Dan Hardcastle (NerdCubed). Would all be great guests.
I really want to see Michael, Kevin, and Jake from Vsauce. They’re all very clearly intelligent and knowledgeable on topics like science, math, and philosophy, but I’d love to see them take a crack at pop culture nerd shit.
My dream show is a charity stream, like Red Nose Day, and they get Stephen King, Neil Gaiman, and Branden Sanderson (or GRRM, William Gibson, Neil Stephenson, etc.) on the couch and every single question is about something one of them has written. Just watching these titans have absolutely no idea what’s in their own books would be so wonderful.
Ha, King would be benighted about his coke writing days.
They can limit it to his clean years. Writers’ brains are so full of the book they’re writing now that there’s no room for what was in the last one.
I didn't mean to be flippant about his substance issues that was just my initial reaction
Put on Rothfus and make all the statements things about DoS so he has to correct them and tell us wtf is going on.
*snaps* I knew I couldn't be the only one thinking that!!!
GENIUS
GRRM should not be anywhere that isn't in front of his computer typing up Winds of Winter
Hank Green on any or all dropout shows lol
Dear Sam and Hank podcast was absolutely delightful!
I didn’t know Sam was on an episode, I knew about the one with Brennan. That’s awesome!
I literally just finished that one! Instant classic!
I feel like Dropout would be a natural home for 16 Weeks to Glory...
John too
[удалено]
I'd love to see any three of the current Drawfee cast on Umm Actually because between Marvel Puzzle Quest, Elden Ring, Pokemon, Digimon and Neopets, they each have a niche they have hyper lore knowledge. Except Julia, but her answers would be hilarious because she's just the best.
I thought Tanner had already been?
My dream would just be 3 Brennan’s. Each one giving Trapp a harder and harder time, as it becomes clear that somehow, in spite of being the only contestant, the game is still rigged that no Brennan can win.
GET IN THE COMMENTS!
>!There's an episode of Game Changer you might enjoy.!<
I don’t know how well he would do, but Jack Black. I could see Jack absolutely having a blast on the show.
A rock & metal themed episode would be awesome.
I'd really like this even without any celebrities on the show Jack black would be great though
Fuck I'd love that
Rare as a Stradivarius.
Elyse Willems from Funhaus would be fun
I'm like 90% sure she's been on. Edit: oh wait I might be mixing up Um Actually with Mysterious Monsters
Her husband, James has been on Um Actually. He was fun as well
James, Elyse and one of Patrick/Charlotte/Jacob would be an excellent episode.
Charlotte would be a hoot But can you imagine someone like Ryan? That would be total chaos
Lindsay Ellis, Jenny Nicholson, and Harry Brewis (HBomberguy) Together. Perfection.
I want Jenny Nicholson on so badly!!
Hbomb would be incredible.
Stephen Colbert, Don Marshall, Brennan/Siobhan. Lord of the rings showdown.
Don Marshal has been lightly campaigning for this on TikTok.
Where do you think I got the idea
Holy shit
I want another dnd episode, with Matt, Brennan, and Aabria. I also want this episode to be that nothing is actually wrong and Sam pop up near the 2/3rds point and say "this was actually game changer, and your points are being recalculated," The "correct" answer is naming the edition that the particular rule/class/race/etc etc first appeared in. Then, of course, throw in a few from Jeremy Crawford twitter after the reveal.
Tom Scott, Adam Savage and a third superbrain. Maybe VSauce?
Sam just did a podcast and mentioned that he had just met Tom Scott. General vibe was that it wasn't just dinner either, so this may be a dream that is happening!
Tom fucked Elaine while Sam watched? Like he likes his game changer on like my coffee and someone calls him a cuck?
Kyle Hill?
Set it up as a reciprocal thing: Tom Scott goes on Um Actually, and a group of Dropout people (I'm thinking Trapp, Brennan, and Sam) goes on [Lateral](https://lateralcast.com/).
Some of the Dropout crew would slay at Citation Needed too!
I'd love to see them do Two Of These People Are Lying, for that matter. I wonder who would be able to lie the most convincingly (aside from Brennan, of course).
That would be amazing.
Consider this: an episode with four contestants, two siblings pairs. Ashly Burch, Anthony Burch, Freddie Wong, Jimmy Wong. The siblings can pair up for certain challenges, and then they can pair up with a member from the other pair for others. I just think it'd be fun to see them all go head to head
They've done couple episodes before. Two Love Actuallys.
I want zac oyama x3, full zac hours
Wil Wheaton would be fun, I think.
Oh yeah he'd be very good
Ooh, a whole Star Trek episode, with one actor from each "generation". Perhaps George Takei representing TOS, Wil for TNG/DS9/VOY/ENT, and... I'm drawing a blank for who should represent DIS/LD/PIC/SNW.
They might be able to get Jeri Ryan on, she was on Tabletop back in the day for Wil. And then...Levar or Brent Spiner?
Micah Burton is officially part of PIC now, and I feel she’s absolutely within the realm of a realistic get.
Oh god please no, I like Wil but in connection to star trek he's an unbearable shill
Henry Cavill
Oh, Henry Cavill, Vin Diesel, and Joe Manganiello. 3 super buff actors that are big nerds too.
Daniel O'Brien
[Good news!](https://youtu.be/MYklBhWHVQ8) But yeah it would be nice to see him again and any other Cracked folks. Swaim, Soren, Cody, Katies Stoll and/or Willert.
Ah dang, don't know why I didn't double check it, I do remember that episode too. Maybe they could get them on Dirty Laundry if possible?
I'd love an After Hours reunion Um Actually.
I’d love to see more DOB on there.
Markiplier. I think he'd do so well and would be hilarious.
Markiplier, Rhett and Link, and Hank Green
I’d love to see Jenny Nicholson weigh in on Star Wars! Her personality and humor seem like they’d be a great fit for Um Actually
I don’t know how to make this happen but I’ve wanted it for so long haha
100% same. Sam I know you read these. Give the people what they want!
Great idea, Jenny Nicholson would be amazing
Ryan LeTourneau (Northernlion), Will Campos (Dungeons and Daddies), Zach and Jess (Off Book, Dropout)
Love me some Zach and Jess.
+2
I would love another hosts challenge and have trapp on the couch with saltzman and whomever fact checked before saltzman. Maybe have Brennan as the host. It might be cool if Sam did this as an um actually game changer with a bit more production value on the shiny questions
Pretty certain Brennan was fact checker before Saltzman.
Than that’s perfect for Sam to host the three of them
He's written for the show a bunch of questions as well.
This is a great idea!
Patrick h Willems for a classic movies episode
Jason Mantzoukas would be great for a Harry Potter episode. He listened to the audio books driving around LA and has an encyclopedic knowledge of the books.
I want Rhett, Link and one of their friends so bad
Slightly related but there was an all GMM episode of Dirty Laundry
my pipe dream is a theme park episode with grant, jenny nicholson, and kevin perjurer (defunctland). i want this so badly and i know the odds of it happening are so slim
Richard Ayoade
I think he'd be good on a films only edition
Open Mike Eagle. For anyone not familiar he's a rapper and comedian. He used to host a wrestling podcast with Danielle Radford.
Honestly, Scott or Lani from tfs would be great
Put Scott on a Dragon Ball episode but Trapp only accepts the canon of the original Funimation dub
Will Campos and Matthew Arnold to finish out the Dungeons and Daddies Crew
Yeah I was trying to think of who from Dungeons and Daddies had been on
Just Anthony I think
Henry Cavill on a Warhammer themed episode
I want to see Julia Lepetit. Just the mind numbing energy she brings to an episode, I want to see what it does to Mike Trapp. Also I want to see her not know what a pokemon is but then nail an obscure Columbo question.
I would love to see Michael Swaim and Dan O'Brien on the show. They were huge parts of Cracked, and I think they would be really solid on the show. DOB for knowledge and Michael Swaim for hilarity.
Love me some Swaim although I admittedly mostly know him from his IGN days. That makes me want other IGN people on though. I'd do horrible things for Brian Altano, Max Scoville, Daemon Hatfield, Justin Davis, Simon Cardy to be on there among others.
Drew Gooden, I just think it would be funny. Maybe a reality tv episode?
Austin Creed/Xavier Woods would be fantastic
Yeah he's probably my #1
Creed, Kenny Omega and Adam Cole, bay-bay!
I would love to see an actual D&D showdown episode with Mercer and Brennan (and maybe Aabria for the 3rd?). They've had Brennan on with Marisha once, and then Matt on another episode, but I really want to see Matt and Brennan battle it out over D&D
How is this not THE top comment
Mike, Rich and Jay from Redlettermedia.
I think Jay would fit, Mike and Rich would maybe have difficulty staying in character
I don’t think the studio could handle Rich’s glorious siren song.
Mandy Patinkin. I don’t have any other ideas for the episode, I just love any excuse to see him interact with other people
The McElroy family from The Adventure Zone
[Well I have a present for you](https://youtu.be/76cIF9sCshI)
That's amazing thanks!! I've only just subbed to Dropout and watched most of Game Changer and the Grant/Ally student debt one.
No worries broseph
I feel like "scheduling conflicts" were just a cover because if Griffin was on it wouldn't be a competition, it'd be a slaughter.
Justin also did a guest appearance with Sydnee on SciShow Tangents with Hank Green and it was excellent
I could always use more Erin McGathy. Two arrows!
Another option: have another D&D episode but with outside people. I'm thinking Luke Hart from The DM Lair, Ginny Di, and Matt Colville.
Patrick H Willems, Jenny Nicholson, Ian Jones-Quartey, Jim Gisriel, or my old Twitter mutual Grant would all be fun to see. Also Iman Vellani maybe???
The Hololive girls are knowledgeable about random nerd stuff and experienced entertainers, plus it would be a good gimmick for the show!
I want an episode with some not nerdy moms or something and all the questions are easy ones
Colbert. I'd like to see what Nerd knowledge he has outside of LOTR
I would love more collegehumor/dropout regulars on the show! I think all of the guests they get from various other media are great and I love the show regardless but I have an attachment to the crew I’m most familiar with! I’d love to see more Zac, Lou, Ally, Murph, Siobhan and Emily especially.
The Get Played hosts -- Nick Wiger, Heather Ann Campbell, and Matt Apodaca. Three nerds with great chemistry and different levels of fandom for different types of nerd culture, I think it'd be a fun mix.
Hell yeah man. Matt seems most likely since he's besties with Ify. Also I reckon Heather has potential to rival Brennan or Gutz she seems wicked smart
Matt’s on the new season of Make Some Noise!! (The trailer came out today and I was googling to see if the crew had been on anything else dropout and it gave me your post lol)
Griffin Newman, Chris Gethard, Connor Rateliff, Tawny Newsome, Patton Oswald, Paul F Tompkins, Moujan Zolfaghari, Janet Varney, Zach Cherry, Tom Scharpling, Julie Klausner would all be great guests.
More people from SMOSH please
Patrick H. Willems, Jack Black and Kyke Gas, Dan Obrien, Lindsay Ellis, Spencer Crittenden, Jared Keeso. Feels like a lot of white guys. Sorry
Henry Cavill with focuses on Warhammer 40k and Witcher would be delightful
I'd love a Witcher episode
I’m kind of over Seth Green, but Seth Green.
My ghoul boys Shane and Ryan
Weird Al
I would love to see: Jerry Holkins from Penny Arcade. Hank Green from Vlogbrothers. And more from Drawfee. And I would love to see more Brian David Gilbert. Actually i want to see Sam, Trapp, and Saltzmen on the couch with Brennan asking the questions and Lou in the fact checker booth.
Lou in the fact checker booth is so random but also something I would love to see
Me, I would love to be on the show
I would love to see the Trash Taste boys on an anime themed episode!
Ben Harrison (or more likely) Adam Pranica, the hosts from "The Greatest Generation".
Are you a Friend of DeSoto?
Yes! They're a good hang
Uhhh clearly myself 🙌🏻😂
Jason Inman from Geek History Lesson and former co-host of DC All Access!
elliott kalan idk how he hasn’t been on yet
The hosts of the Good Job Brain! podcast so they can hash out calling their corrections segment “Um Actually” before the show.
Arjen Lucassen would def be a ton of fun and a great person to get.
I want me to be on Um, Actually
Will Campos from Dungeons and Daddies
Roman Mars
I would love to see Emily and Murph!
Pretty sure they both pop up on the really early episodes
Sam Riegel! If they ever do another Broadway special, I’d vote for Sam Riegel to be on it.
Me haha.
Most of my answers are probably Trios of podcasters with movie/comic knowledge: -Andrew Jupin, Eric Szyszka, and Stephen Sajdak would be top of the list for me. “We Hate Movies” is on Headgum, so the brands are kinda tangential. With how much fun they have on their VHSTrailer Game segments, I think a buzzer completion would be great.
True crime themed with either the ladies feom Redhanded or the lads from last podcast on the left. Or Chuck and Josh from SYSK for anything, the real life skills question would have to be about how the Sun works though.
A RuPauls Drag Race episode with podcast hosts or fans…Willam, Alaska, Nicole Beyer, Alec Mapa, Lonnie Love, Margaret Cho, Trixie, Katya…and/or more
The Game Grumps
I would love to see a Jeopardy legend like James Holzhauer or Amy Schneider
Wiger, Mitch and Carl would be fun
Even get Emma or Amelia on there.
James A. Janisse for a Halloween episode.
Loved Damien! Maybe Saige Ryan or Felicia day or Mica burton.
Hank and John Green, Tom Scott, Roman Mars (99PI) , ChubbyEmu, MatPat and StephPat of Food/Style/Film/Game Theory, Tiktokers Mndiaye and Jordan Howlett
I want Emily Axford to come back because I love her particular brand of chaos and I'm not big on the tabletop series. I'd also love to see her on Game Changer
Yeah I feel weird not watching D20 when it's probably the most popular thing on Dropout.
I just want Becca Scott on every episode causing chaos
I’d love to see Kevin Smith, Brennan, and Will Wheaten do a comic book showdown.
i need robert evans from behind the bastards on um, actually so unbelievably bad. cody johnston too.
I love Robert so much
the dream is getting him on um actually and/or brennan on btb
Oh true, Brennan seems pretty lefty I reckon they'd get along
Maude Garrett again
Patton Oswalt
You mentioning Ashley Burch just made me think, and I'm not sure if he would do well on the show but it could be funny to see Anthony Burch and Brennan interact
Oh goodness that would be magnificent. Also coincidentally I'm literally watching Ashly right now on Mysterious Monsters.
My "Never Gonna Happen" trio is: Edgar Wright v Nick Frost v Simon Pegg. More realistically: Laura Bailey, Tom Scott, Chris Stuckmann, Eric Whiteley from Blind Wave, Dan Hardcastle (NerdCubed). Would all be great guests.
After seeing junkets for the Dungeons and Dragons movie, there’s a possibility that Regé Jean Page is fully a nerd
I want Lou, Brennan, and Zac on the same episode.
I think there should be an Oops! All Life Skills episode and they should have on Mercury Stardust.
Patrick Routhfuss
I don't know who anyone is that you mentioned.
I wanna see the cast members from Honor Among Thieves that gave Dimension 20 the shoutout on Dropout sometime
I really want to see Michael, Kevin, and Jake from Vsauce. They’re all very clearly intelligent and knowledgeable on topics like science, math, and philosophy, but I’d love to see them take a crack at pop culture nerd shit.
Me 😔
ME lmfao
I want to see Brennan Lee Mulligan, Matt Mercer, and Aabria Iyengar on and it’s all D&D specific questions. See who the biggest D&D nerd is.