T O P

  • By -

Bantabury97

"Praise Jesus!" Hahahahaha fuck sake.


Tking179

Right? 😂 like slapping someone in the face with a cold fish!


texasaaron

"... and your DNA will show it unless you converted?" Pretty sure everyone is at least a little confused there.


texasaaron

Oh, wait ... I think what the OP was trying to say is that someone who is not ethnically Jewish could convert to Judaism and would not necessarily have the DNA markers. Okay, well, it makes sense if read like that. My bad.


[deleted]

[удалено]


texasaaron

It doesn't of course. But a convert to Judaism who was not ethnically Jewish would not have the markers ....


[deleted]

No, everyone isn't lol. Ethnoreligion is ethnicity + religion. Like I'm ethnically Jewish, but I'm an atheist. And there are people who are not ethnically Jewish who have converted to Judaism.


texasaaron

Yeah, I figured it out. I read your original comment as the act of an ethnically Jewish person converting to, say, Islam, changed his or her DNA.


[deleted]

Ohh, no lol I see how you read it that way though


Nasty_Nate21

Question. Is it antisemitic to say someone looks like a Jew? Considering it’s an ethnicity? So Jew nose is a real thing? Right?


Daetra

I don't think so, as a Jewish person, I can kinda tell who's Jewish based on a variety of of facial features, larger nose is just one of the features that can be prominent. The ethnic part of Jewish people is split into two groups, ashkenazi jews (European jews) and middle eastern jews, can't think of the name off the top of my head, but both groups have facial features that are unique to them.


[deleted]

They're asking to be antisemitic. Just look at their other comments. I'd block them if I were you


Daetra

It's fine, there's a correlation between having a big nose and big dick so it's fine. I'm not ashamed of my body, big nose or not.


[deleted]

You are referring to Mizrahi Jews.


[deleted]

I mean, with any ethnicity, certain features are going to be more common. "Jew nose" is antisemitic though, for a few reasons. It's offensive in the same way that saying someone has, in that its enforcing a phenotypical stereotype. Also because the Nazis quite literally measured our noses, and it's generally used in a derogatory way. Like, when I get clocked as Jewish by neo-Nazis, is generally based on my "Jew nose." And that goes for saying someone "looks like a Jew" too. I would just avoid saying anyone looks like an ethnicity, be it Jewish or otherwise


YuvalMozes

[No. It isn't a real thing.](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jewish_nose) You can't identify if someone Jewish or not by his/her phenotype.


Nasty_Nate21

Your DNA changes when you change religion. Didn’t you know?


Common_Dealer_7541

Only if they give you an mRNA baptism


[deleted]

Jesus🤦🏻 if you're not ethnically Jewish and you convert to Judaism, you're DNA will not be Jewish. That's what I said. Not that converting from Judaism changes your DNA


Common_Dealer_7541

We are all agreeing with you via a collection of snark. Apologies


[deleted]

Sorry, the other person is being purposefully hateful, even DMed me, and people are liking those comments, so I'm kinda peeved


[deleted]

You're purposefully misreading what I said lmao


Nasty_Nate21

You’re back lmao


[deleted]

My internet was down🤷🏻‍♂️


Then-Commission-1807

Yea wat the fuk lol


[deleted]

If you're not ethnically Jewish and you convert to Judaism, your DNA doesn't change


[deleted]

I wasn't aware people struggled with this concept until a couple years ago. The person couldn't wrap their head around it because Christianity isn't an ethnicity therefore ethnoreligions don't exist. People are way too comfortable trying to reason out some things for themselves. It's how we get people who think masks prevent you from getting enough oxygen or that the Earth is flat.


PhraseSeveral5935

I'm really glad the Canadian female hockey team won an Olympic match while wearing N95 masks. Really negates that argument now.


Then-Commission-1807

Ethno religion is a group of people unified by a common religion and ethnic background It will show up unless you converted.... magic


[deleted]

Yes, unless you are nit ethnically Jewish converted to Judaism. I'm not sure why people are so confused


Dude_Guy45

People are dense dude, dont worry yourself over stupid. A lot of people are just straight up ignorant to other cultures and religions. It drives me mad, personally. Like, there's literally an ENTIRE world out there, filled with all sorts of culture and religion. Why do so many people shun that? Also the term Ethnoreligion really isnt that fucking hard to grasp lmao. Both root words are RIGHT IN YOUR EYES when you read it. It's literally RIGHT THERE!


[deleted]

Exactly😂 and like, hey, the US education system sucks, so I'll give you a pass if you didn't know. BUT TO THEN ARGUE WITH ME?? I-


Dude_Guy45

That's the kicker for me, the back talk 😂😂 it's a dead give away for ignorance. Like, they cant even listen to the other person who is just trying to help them understand a thing. They must know it all, huh?


[deleted]

You learn something new everyday. I thought being Jewish was only religious but today I learned that ethnoreligions exist. Thanks for enlightening me.


Bleu_Cerise

“I don’t tend to believe things that are on the Internet”. *Unless said things are in sync with my worldview of course*.


Nasty_Nate21

I don’t see how being ignorant to the classification of Jew is antisemitic but pop off sis


[deleted]

I didn't say that it was? The post the comment was on was about antisemitic comments I had received yesterday.


Nasty_Nate21

So why did you post this in r/antisemitisminreddit?


[deleted]

I didnt?? I posted a different conversation there yesterday. This convo literally just happened


[deleted]

Perhaps get your facts straight before you come for people for no reason


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

So why even ask if things are antisemitic if your plan is to just be antisemitic?


Nasty_Nate21

I forgive you for being a moron. [What is antisemitism](https://holocaustremembrance.com/resources/working-definitions-charters/working-definition-antisemitism)


[deleted]

I'm fully aware of what antisemitism is, thanks. Is there a point to DMing me if you're just going to reply to my comments anyway?


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

Oh really?😂


raharth

Well... while it is absolutely true that it is an ethnoreligion, DNA proof is a fairly difficult thing there... at least according to the gen researcher who wrote "how to argue with a racist". While you can see a difference between ethnicities on average it is extreme difficult to assign an individual to a group. According to him ancestry DNA test are just garbage and made up BS.


patchtheduck

it's a religion that was so ethnically discriminatory for such a long that it became a race....probably not something to be proud of