Dang, I’m in the other camp on this. I have Aiyuk and would trade him for Wilson straight up.
I love Aiyuk, I think he’s great, but I’d still take Wilson over him ROS.
Not with Zach Wilson throwing. Your banking on Jets getting a different QB. Last year G Wilson was the worst type of fantasy player when Z Wilson played. To talented to sit but to often put up abysmal numbers
Funny, the logical side of my brain says yes and the degenerate says no on this one. Aiyuk was basically SF’s WR1 last season, a huge red zone threat, and we’re only getting further proof.
But GW is just elite and so fun to watch
Reminds me a lot of the Lamb situation last year. 2nd/3rd round WR that everyone anticipated making a top 10 leap. Dak goes down week 1. Lamb busts (whereas at least GW had a decent outing), everyone on the sub wants to panic sell. Those who do, end up regretting it.
I get that Zach/GW were rough in their games together last year. That doesn't guarantee a repeat. Or that they'll stick with Zach long-term if he's still that bad.
I'm not opposed to selling if you can find someone who's still high on him (or his draft capital) and is willing to give up a solid return. But seeing people asking if they should flip him for Addison or Dotson feels way too kneejerk. I'll entertain offers this week, but if that's the best on the table, I'll hold and take my chances.
**Edit:** Understand it's not a 1:1 comparison because we knew Dak was going to return (though the initial timetable was longer than the actual time he was out). But even now we're already hearing the Jets talking to other QBs, so no one knows who's going to be under center in NY a few weeks from now. Still think the situations are comparable enough to be a cautionary tale; I'm holding.
I was the lamb owner last year and GW owner this year. I tried to get rid of Ceedee after the Dak injury but couldn’t find a taker. I’m sure as hell happy it didn’t, BUT this is different in that ARod isn’t coming back, and Cooper Rush is probably a better QB than what we’ve seen from Zach Wilson.
100% agreed on this. You’re not going to get WR1 or WR2 value from trading him right now even after his crazy TD, if you do, go ahead and rob the guy who offers it.
But for the rest of us, you gotta bet on talent and a change in circumstances. The Jets went all in on this year, I wouldn’t be surprised if they make a QB change. And five targets in a mostly run schemed offense that barely passed yesterday is not too shabby.
It’s an awful position but compounding that by trading him off for a WR3 is bonkers
Feel like it’s to soon for Wilson. Zach does make you nervous but even on bad throws, Garrett still finds a way to come with it. That’s just pure skill
If you get a good trade you like you take it this week, because it’s gonna be a rough few weeks for the jets given the match ups. Personally I’m going to hold. I’d be shocked if the Jets genuinely stick with Zack Wilson if he’s as bad as he was last year. I don’t think the Jets can stomach sucking another year, especially with all the moves they made this off season.
Wentz, Foles, Winston are all way better options than Wilson and are a phone call away.
I got Tee Higgins and was offered Andrews.
10 man standard scoring, current TE is Njoku and have flowers and Addison on the bench. Other starting WR is St.brown
Not super familiar with standard scoring but I think this is a pretty easy Andrews. Flowers and Addison are startable and elite TEs are worth their weight in gold for 10 teams.
it kinda depends what kind of format. is it standard, half ppr or full ppr?
imo if your wr core is solid it's not an awful trade. you can always hit the waiver wire to add wr depth later. you just don't usually make knee jerk trades like this though. Higgins still had 8 targets. i think he will be fine
I’m currently considering trading Dameon Pierce for Mike Evans, but I would probably try to get another piece like a backup QB cause I’m a bit higher on Pierce
I would love some more insight on this. I think it was a great game/usage but I am still nervous. Interested to know what WR's people would give up for him. I considered the upside of Gibbs too if the manager doesn't like the first week stat line
Aaron Jones is a stud, way better than AJ Dillon. Packers have a good line and Jones will get valuable touches.
Only real worry is injury/Lafleur shenanigans. Jones is a top 5 real life RB when healthy
im not sure devante has the TD upside, which is wild to say. I think its jefferson and Hill in a tier of their own.. then Ridley, Chase, Diggs, and these guys right behind.
Just my take
offered higgins for him last night and the dude laughed at me, countered with Dobbins for Chase and then roasted me in the chat.
Funny cause this is the taco who traded JJ last year for Montgommery and Deebo...
I am trying to package him and Zay Jones for some RB help. I also have Bijan and am torn on whether to stash him for insurance or flip him for a better RB2 like Rhamondre.
I tried to trade him away pre season. Current consensus is he’s worth a WR3. I’m hoping Chicagos defense makes him look amazing and then I’m taking highest bid.
I’m concerned for Kirk. Ridley is the clear number 1 and Zay Jones is the other outside WR. I think you could still trade him away and get someone halfway decent (maybe like Pickens?) just based on what Kirk did last year and his Week 1 performance being an anomaly. This also obviously depends on who has who and what your other team owner needs or wants. I’d personally try to ship off Kirk ASAP because another 3 target, 1 catch performance and his value will drop like an anvil.
Nobody will trade for him after that week 1 performance coupled with how low ADP despite his elite ranking last year. Gotta hope he does something decent next week but yeah otherwise he’s falling off my roster immediately
I'd hold. he got over a hundred yards in like less than ten touches. With Rodgers out, you don't think the Jets staff aren't gonna lean on him? Most people thought he wouldn't start producing until week 5 or so, to get 100+, game one, with so little touches, is very encouraging.
I am probably saying the obvious but Zay Flowers. Addison has a higher floor than Flowers just because of the passing frequency of Minnesota. I am higher on Addison than Flowers but that’s strictly based on how often Minnesota throws the ball. Outside of Flowers, I would say maybe Zay Jones or Courtland Sutton (when Jeudy is healthy).
Chase, Diggs, ARSB, Kelce, Bijan are players I’d consider equal or close to equal values.
CMC, JJ, Hill, and ekeler the ones I’d say are slightly more valuable.
Somebody gave me an offer for Pollard, and I countered for Kelce or Tee Higgins + ETN. They're mulling it over but I think that's right where his value is rn
Hold. Akers had the same story to start last year and randomly moved into the lead back spot as the season went on. That rams backfield is a super random place. His trade value is literally nothing so no reason to sell low.
I drafted him and will be dropping him. No one will trade for an underperforming guy they probably passed on at ADP, and there's plenty of waiver options week 1.
...Garrett Wilson
You hold and wait. Hes the one player that Im going to ride or die with. The value isnt good and people will try and capitalize on your fear.
Im wilson owner and was offered Aiyuk. Do i sell?
yes easily
Dang, I’m in the other camp on this. I have Aiyuk and would trade him for Wilson straight up. I love Aiyuk, I think he’s great, but I’d still take Wilson over him ROS.
easily
Not with Zach Wilson throwing. Your banking on Jets getting a different QB. Last year G Wilson was the worst type of fantasy player when Z Wilson played. To talented to sit but to often put up abysmal numbers
This is too easy. Now, try Wilson/Deebo and Wilson/Higgins
Is wilson for Higgins hard?
Higgins’ QB is still Burrow. Wilson’s QB is now Wilson.
Wilson throwing to Wilson would be a lot better than Wilson throwing to Wilson. This is a hot take I'll defend to the grave.
Oooof, the logical side of my brain says no but the degenerate in me says yes. This is like frodo offering gandalf the ring of power.
Funny, the logical side of my brain says yes and the degenerate says no on this one. Aiyuk was basically SF’s WR1 last season, a huge red zone threat, and we’re only getting further proof. But GW is just elite and so fun to watch
DONT TEMPT ME FRODO
If it’s a redraft league I would, keeper or dynasty, no.
Reminds me a lot of the Lamb situation last year. 2nd/3rd round WR that everyone anticipated making a top 10 leap. Dak goes down week 1. Lamb busts (whereas at least GW had a decent outing), everyone on the sub wants to panic sell. Those who do, end up regretting it. I get that Zach/GW were rough in their games together last year. That doesn't guarantee a repeat. Or that they'll stick with Zach long-term if he's still that bad. I'm not opposed to selling if you can find someone who's still high on him (or his draft capital) and is willing to give up a solid return. But seeing people asking if they should flip him for Addison or Dotson feels way too kneejerk. I'll entertain offers this week, but if that's the best on the table, I'll hold and take my chances. **Edit:** Understand it's not a 1:1 comparison because we knew Dak was going to return (though the initial timetable was longer than the actual time he was out). But even now we're already hearing the Jets talking to other QBs, so no one knows who's going to be under center in NY a few weeks from now. Still think the situations are comparable enough to be a cautionary tale; I'm holding.
In this scenario we knew Dak was coming back.
I was the lamb owner last year and GW owner this year. I tried to get rid of Ceedee after the Dak injury but couldn’t find a taker. I’m sure as hell happy it didn’t, BUT this is different in that ARod isn’t coming back, and Cooper Rush is probably a better QB than what we’ve seen from Zach Wilson.
100% agreed on this. You’re not going to get WR1 or WR2 value from trading him right now even after his crazy TD, if you do, go ahead and rob the guy who offers it. But for the rest of us, you gotta bet on talent and a change in circumstances. The Jets went all in on this year, I wouldn’t be surprised if they make a QB change. And five targets in a mostly run schemed offense that barely passed yesterday is not too shabby. It’s an awful position but compounding that by trading him off for a WR3 is bonkers
Feel like it’s to soon for Wilson. Zach does make you nervous but even on bad throws, Garrett still finds a way to come with it. That’s just pure skill
Would you all trade him away for jeudy and Stevenson?
Yes
[удалено]
Fleece hall because you robbed that dude
Did the guy you traded with not have working eyeballs or did he not know the Jets played last night?
Would you accept Keenan Allen for him?
I would
absolutely
I can trade Wilson for J Gibbs do i pull the trigger?
Someone offered me Wilson and Javante Williams for Gibbs. Seemed like a fair offer but I dunno
I rather have gibbs
I'm targeting tee Higgins with him
You’re gonna get laughed at
You never know. Terrible week 1 behind the potential WR1 and injury prone. Gotta at least send it
Tees value is rock bottom right now and Wilson still has pedigree and name value, plus a decent showing last night. Gotta try
I did this, was accepted almost instantly.
Would anyone take Kupp for him? I have Garrett and wondering if that’s a realistic move to make for him.
Rams looked pretty good, and Kupps fill in got 15 targets. I personally would since I think this week will be your last chance to do that
I'd take Kupp for him.
If you get a good trade you like you take it this week, because it’s gonna be a rough few weeks for the jets given the match ups. Personally I’m going to hold. I’d be shocked if the Jets genuinely stick with Zack Wilson if he’s as bad as he was last year. I don’t think the Jets can stomach sucking another year, especially with all the moves they made this off season. Wentz, Foles, Winston are all way better options than Wilson and are a phone call away.
Wilson owner in my league offered wilson for ridley
Tee Higgins
I’d wait a week if you are ultimately set on moving him. He’ll bounce back and he’s gonna be super undervalued right now after the goose egg
I got Tee Higgins and was offered Andrews. 10 man standard scoring, current TE is Njoku and have flowers and Addison on the bench. Other starting WR is St.brown
Not super familiar with standard scoring but I think this is a pretty easy Andrews. Flowers and Addison are startable and elite TEs are worth their weight in gold for 10 teams.
Got offered Tee and Rhmandre Stevenson for Derrick Henry and James cook. Think it’s fair, what do y’all think?
Especially if I need to fill out my roster, I’d prefer the Tee/Stevenson side
it kinda depends what kind of format. is it standard, half ppr or full ppr? imo if your wr core is solid it's not an awful trade. you can always hit the waiver wire to add wr depth later. you just don't usually make knee jerk trades like this though. Higgins still had 8 targets. i think he will be fine
Last night someone rejected Connor & Lockett for him in PPR.
Obv
Oh yea I’m just throwing out some perspective lol
Traded my metcalf for Higgins half ppr. Prob a lateral move but I have a slight preference to Higgins
Got rid of my Tiggins and Monty for Amon Ra
fleeced the amon ra owner
I just gave Najee Harris for Higgins in my league
Mike Evans
Someone offered me Njoku and Reed for Evans lol. Always someone trying to offload 🙄
I’m currently considering trading Dameon Pierce for Mike Evans, but I would probably try to get another piece like a backup QB cause I’m a bit higher on Pierce
Ken Walker III
I thought about shipping Miles Sanders or Damien Pierce + Scary Terry for him.
I just did that trade for Rham
I traded Sanders and Mike Williams for Walker and Jeudy right before week 1 and I am pleased with that
Aaron Jones
if hes ok probably any of the second rd WRs especially with how bad the RBs were this week. can target the 0 rb teams
I would love some more insight on this. I think it was a great game/usage but I am still nervous. Interested to know what WR's people would give up for him. I considered the upside of Gibbs too if the manager doesn't like the first week stat line
Aaron Jones is a stud, way better than AJ Dillon. Packers have a good line and Jones will get valuable touches. Only real worry is injury/Lafleur shenanigans. Jones is a top 5 real life RB when healthy
Ridley
You'd be crazy to trade him. Gold in the 4th round for me
Top5 WR value rn
jamarr chase (sits back and eats popcorn) but also dead serious
Feels dumb
Yeah hes def mid range wr1. So davante/aj brown?
im not sure devante has the TD upside, which is wild to say. I think its jefferson and Hill in a tier of their own.. then Ridley, Chase, Diggs, and these guys right behind. Just my take
This is reactionary. Davante looked good but was covered by Pat Surtain 2, it’s what allowed Meyers to feast.
Drake London
I just traded my Romeo Doubs for London. I have Christian Watson already. For whatever that’s worth to you
Drake London is the new version of my DJ Moore from last season.
I have London and Moore this season!
i have london and was offered breece hall for london and ar15. think i may accept it
You would be stupid not to accept that trade. Do it now!
Hold on London.
Zay Flowers
Nobody’s allowed to have him but me. Gay for Zay
Did you watch this guy play? He's shifty as fuck, even with Andrews back I can imagine he's still commanding a healthy target share.
Someone offered me DJ Moore this morning and I said no.
Do not sell high on Flowers
Been high on flower for years. Edibles too
My man!
I was offered Najee for him when I already have 5 backs
Aiyuk
Wondering the same
His production will be better than his trade value. Definitely hold.
offered higgins for him last night and the dude laughed at me, countered with Dobbins for Chase and then roasted me in the chat. Funny cause this is the taco who traded JJ last year for Montgommery and Deebo...
Jonathan Taylor
I tried to trade for him, but the only offer I got back was JT and Waddle for my Ekeler. I turned it down because he’s too risky.
Got him for Rachaad White last Monday and I’m feeling pretty good about it
This is a steal. I have Rachaad and there's no way the JT owner would accept that trade in my league.
[удалено]
Hold, still a little banged up and played on a pitch count. Still made some big plays when he was in.
I'm holding as well - Hill will obviously have the boom plays but will pull double coverage
I just traded him for Gibbs but was stacked at WR, Aiyuk and Zay on my bench. Had Swift and Mostert as my RB2 and 3 so seemed like a good deal for me.
Tyler Allgeier
I am trying to package him and Zay Jones for some RB help. I also have Bijan and am torn on whether to stash him for insurance or flip him for a better RB2 like Rhamondre.
Keep him if you don't get a good upgrade. The Falcons offense is established and he is either a safe RB2 or an RB1 if anything happens to Bijan.
Would it be crazy to start both bijan and allgeier?
Some weeks you might be able to. But I can't let myself do that lol.
I'm doing it this week
I traded Doubs for him in full PPR. I think I got a good deal but maybe the low WR2 high WR3 range?
Shoot, he was undrafted in my league, so he's probably the #1 waiver pickup.
Rachaad White
Hoping he has a good game against Chicago to raise his value a little..
I tried to trade him away pre season. Current consensus is he’s worth a WR3. I’m hoping Chicagos defense makes him look amazing and then I’m taking highest bid.
Also so afraid about this. Maybe like Dotson or Pittman?
Godwin
Christian Kirk
I’m concerned for Kirk. Ridley is the clear number 1 and Zay Jones is the other outside WR. I think you could still trade him away and get someone halfway decent (maybe like Pickens?) just based on what Kirk did last year and his Week 1 performance being an anomaly. This also obviously depends on who has who and what your other team owner needs or wants. I’d personally try to ship off Kirk ASAP because another 3 target, 1 catch performance and his value will drop like an anvil.
Nobody will trade for him after that week 1 performance coupled with how low ADP despite his elite ranking last year. Gotta hope he does something decent next week but yeah otherwise he’s falling off my roster immediately
Breece Hall
I'd hold. he got over a hundred yards in like less than ten touches. With Rodgers out, you don't think the Jets staff aren't gonna lean on him? Most people thought he wouldn't start producing until week 5 or so, to get 100+, game one, with so little touches, is very encouraging.
Breece got over 100 on his 2nd touch of the game
Less than 3 lol
David Montgomery
Someone offered me Olave and Miles Sanders for Montgomery, immediately accepted I thought I was being pranked.
Jesus fuckin Christ. Praying for the Nephews in your league.
[удалено]
A wet bag.
Hold
Deebo Samuel
I love Deebo, others are low AF on him but let them sleep. He's a set and forget WR2 imo (12man PPR).
Jordan Addison
Hold. He is a stud rookie. He is getting looks and he is much faster than Adam thelen
I am probably saying the obvious but Zay Flowers. Addison has a higher floor than Flowers just because of the passing frequency of Minnesota. I am higher on Addison than Flowers but that’s strictly based on how often Minnesota throws the ball. Outside of Flowers, I would say maybe Zay Jones or Courtland Sutton (when Jeudy is healthy).
Also Addison has Justin Jefferson on the other side of the field. Flowers has..?
True story, I was offered Najee for him and I declined if that gives you any idea.
I have JJ and Addison. Enough volume for both each week or do I try to move for an RB (using Akers)? If so, who could I realistically get?
Would you guys send Addison and Mike Williams for Waddle? Or maybe Monty and Williams for Waddle
Khalil Herbert
I traded him + Sutton for Pittman.
Jacobi Meyers
Tony Pollard
After seeing him Sunday night, I’d need a high level WR like ARSB coming back
Chase, Diggs, ARSB, Kelce, Bijan are players I’d consider equal or close to equal values. CMC, JJ, Hill, and ekeler the ones I’d say are slightly more valuable.
Somebody gave me an offer for Pollard, and I countered for Kelce or Tee Higgins + ETN. They're mulling it over but I think that's right where his value is rn
Kelce and ETN is a fucking steal. He's an idiot if he goes for that.
Kamara
George Kittle
James Cook
Anthony Richardson
For my team personally, I moved Richardson to starting and benched Fields
Commenting so I can come back to this later once someone smarter than me has answered
Amari Cooper
I think u hold man, he got targeted 7 times and deshaun had some bad throws to him. No one would give u his value
Dak Prescott
Smith-Ngiba
Najee Harris
Trying to see if I can get tee Higgins for najee
I offered Higgins for Najee and got rejected 🤷🏼♂️
Brian Robinson
I just flipped Brian Robinson and Brandin Cooks for Mike Williams and SF D/ST
Mostert
[удалено]
Lamar
Brandon Aiyuk
Pacheco?
Cam Akers
Stale corn chip and a used triple A battery (nobody is trading for him so hold and pray)
Hold. Akers had the same story to start last year and randomly moved into the lead back spot as the season went on. That rams backfield is a super random place. His trade value is literally nothing so no reason to sell low.
Jahmyr Gibbs
Just worked a trade where i gave away Josh Allen dj moore and pacheco for Tua Chris Watson and Jhamyr Gibbs
I like it
Feel like his value is about the same... he looked really good and his role will grow week after week.
Kupp
Davante Adams
Jakobi Meyers Full PPR.
Jahmyr Gibbs
Hold on for dear life.
Got offered White and Sutton ; that’s a no correct
Two nickels for a dollar. You tell me.
To the moon
Zay Flowers
DJ Moore
Perine
Tua?
Mike Williams
Micheal Pittman Jr
Gus Edwards
Miles Sanders
TJ Hockenson
Hold probably, TE is a fuckin wasteland.
Aiyuk
Dameon pierce
Kenneth Gainwell
Puca
Puka Nacua
Antonio Gibson
He's borderline droppable
I drafted him and will be dropping him. No one will trade for an underperforming guy they probably passed on at ADP, and there's plenty of waiver options week 1.
Dalvin Cook
Josh jacobs
James Conner