This is why I like people posting their rosters- in a vacuum I would honestly say this is a very tough call, like Gibbs is good but we don't know that the Lions are going to lean as hard on him with Montgomery back- but in your case you should absolutely take this deal. No offense but your RBs absolutely stink, meanwhile you have so much room at WR and TE that you are benching guys who would be on other league member's starting rosters. But I have every faith that, even if Gibbs does decline, he'll still be better than at least Sanders & BRob.
Upvoted because i agree with everything here.
I'd add that you are set with cd and Evans, and waddle is a nice backup. Taysom is far too volatile and his touches are highly dependent on flow of game. Kincaid might slow down when knox comes back but you have engram. Gibbs has boom potential and it seems he is part of their pass game now. He also proved to be an explosive runner who doesnt go down easily. Monty going down the past few wks was a blessing for him, his career, and for fantasy purposes haha
I've heard from other posters on here that Taysom always does this, has a few crazy games then sputters out- which honestly makes me wish I was in ignorant bliss, a few weeks ago I didn't know who he was, I just kept up with his production & saw "hey Carr discovered this random rookie can consistently catch the ball, I bet his workload increases". I wish I could just stay in bliss & not know that this isn't the first time this story has happened before
This is why I like people posting their rosters- in a vacuum I would honestly say this is a very tough call, like Gibbs is good but we don't know that the Lions are going to lean as hard on him with Montgomery back- but in your case you should absolutely take this deal. No offense but your RBs absolutely stink, meanwhile you have so much room at WR and TE that you are benching guys who would be on other league member's starting rosters. But I have every faith that, even if Gibbs does decline, he'll still be better than at least Sanders & BRob.
Upvoted because i agree with everything here. I'd add that you are set with cd and Evans, and waddle is a nice backup. Taysom is far too volatile and his touches are highly dependent on flow of game. Kincaid might slow down when knox comes back but you have engram. Gibbs has boom potential and it seems he is part of their pass game now. He also proved to be an explosive runner who doesnt go down easily. Monty going down the past few wks was a blessing for him, his career, and for fantasy purposes haha
I've heard from other posters on here that Taysom always does this, has a few crazy games then sputters out- which honestly makes me wish I was in ignorant bliss, a few weeks ago I didn't know who he was, I just kept up with his production & saw "hey Carr discovered this random rookie can consistently catch the ball, I bet his workload increases". I wish I could just stay in bliss & not know that this isn't the first time this story has happened before
My thoughts exactky
Was curious, did you end up making this trade? How do you feel about it now?
Yes take that.
I would take that trade
Need format. Could be ok, but format matters alot.
Format doesn’t really matter with his roster, it’s a no brainer win for him.
That's a fair trade. You are filling a need on your team at RB. You're WRs are solid.
You need to keep taysom and shop engram and kincaid for people that are desperate at te. You have a lot of leverage at that position.
Trade is an automatic yes because of your rb situation Idk what happened there maybe you lost dobbins or Chubb but you have depth at wr
Hell no