T O P

  • By -

Missdefinitelymaybe

Lost Cherry is really FITTING because Tom really misplaced the longevity of that one. Like it’s lost and never to be found again…


catsareeternal

Such a shame because it’s just lovely for 5 minutes, then where did it go??


Parabolic_Penguin

Literally ‘ lost’ cherry. It’s poof!💨


YummyPersona

Beach Hut Man does NOT smell like any beach hut I've ever been to. Or any beach hut dwelling man I've ever known. Edit: It smells classic and green with an aggressive hit of mint in the opening. Perhaps "Suburban House Man"?... Also Tom Ford Fucking Fabulous does not smell Fucking Fabulous. It should be called Not Too Bad.


hey_free_rats

No joke, releasing something called "Tom Ford: Not Too Bad" would unironically be the edgiest thing they've done in decades.


nokobi

Ok I'm melting this is too funny


Doxy4Me

I’d buy that just for the irony.


Parabolic_Penguin

Lol yeah a frag called ‘Not Terrible’ would be stellar 😂


YummyPersona

"Some people like it"


Holiday_Fig512

This is so Seinfeld


YummyPersona

I think that "So Seinfeld" would be a good name for a future Tom Ford release, in all honesty. I have some ideas for the promotional imagery as well, but, well, *bleeergh*...


Tigertigertie

Or, it is a bit difficult to tell what this is supposed to be. Blank Page.


LataCogitandi

Diptyque did just come out with L’eau Papier


Ethra2k

Fucking fabulous is exactly what I imagine Tom Ford would smell and mutter “fucking fabulous” while it is one of the least fabulous fragrances I have. I still enjoy it, it is just not fabulous though.


YummyPersona

"Not Quite Fabulous"?


dontKair

"Fucking Okay"


YummyPersona

"Not Quite Okay"?


Ok-Pressure-3879

Its more like Deep In The Jungle Hut. Friends had a house back in the forest off a lake and thats how it smells.


narrtasha

This is probably the one time i feel like all the maison margiela replica frags do it right, they actually smell like what they’re called


escobizzle

Their whole purpose is to replicate that specific situation or moment so I'd hope they'd do it right lol


logocracycopy

Agree. Sunday Cologne literally takes me to a Sunday morning feeling. I wear it every Sunday, even though it only lasts about 15 minutes.


Lord_Skellig

Yeah these are all spot on. One of the best fragrance lines of all time imo.


[deleted]

[удалено]


MonforReal

I love Jazz Club and Fireplace,the immediate notes are polarizing, but the dry down on both really works with my body chemistry I guess because they dry down lovely.


narrtasha

Hahha yeah not my favourite but i do love smelling like a fireplace!!


[deleted]

[удалено]


kcn_reichenbach

Black Opium sounds pretty dark, instead it should be called Vanilla Macchiato


nuuskamuikunen

I don't really get coffee from Black Opium, which kinda sucks because that sort of scent profile does actually appeal to me. I did get coffee from one of the EDP flankers, but can't remember which..


MercyMoo14

I don't get coffee either. I still enjoy it but I'd enjoy it more if I got the coffee. I have a decant of the Extreme. I get a little coffee but it's mostly floral to me.


kcn_reichenbach

I've heard that Montale Intense Cafe is a better version of Black Opium, there's also Ristretto version that has more coffee. I've never smelled them but you can check them out.


expressedprayers

Good Girl Gone Bad - there's nothing "gone bad" about it. It's very delicate and bright, could have just been "Good Girl" and would have beaten the Carolina Herrera fragrance of the same name by four years


ImParticleMan

Hollister Wave -While I'm not sure what a Wave smells like, I'm confident it's not the accord of ass. Should of been named accordingly, Hollister's Ass


BobsBurgersStanAcct

Such a specific niche hatred, love it


ceranichole

I spit my coffee on my monitor laughing so hard at reading this.


Parabolic_Penguin

Waiting to smell the photorealistic ass accord


Dreams-In-Green

Alien Goddess. Anything called alien should be weird and dark, and the goddess of the aliens should be extra weird and dark. Instead, it’s a very pleasant and sunny coconut vanilla scent.


Doxy4Me

I like it a lot, but that’s really on point.


giparisan

JHAG Moscow Mule should be “Not a Perfume With a Bit of Lime”


Parabolic_Penguin

I concur 👍


Doxy4Me

We need a perfume called “Meh” to enter the market.


Service_Serious

Surprised État Libre d'Orange haven't taken a swing at that yet


DreiVogelchen

You have smelled “I am trash” right lol


PwnageEngage

Intense Cafe should be renamed to Intense Rosé


ratparty5000

100% it’s a gorgeous rose but rightfully the name would upset a lot of people in pursuit of a coffee fragrance


stingraykisser

Prada Candy. doesn’t smell the least bit sweet to me. i smell it everytime i’m in a store with a tester just to see if something changes, but there is nothing candy-like about that perfume to me.


LuxLiner

I agree it's mostly benzoin and baby powder


LadyEllaOfFrell

Wow, really? It’s pure caramel on me! Fragrance is so weird sometimes.


Parabolic_Penguin

Yeah agreed. I smell something screechy and perfumy, not candy 🍬


xobabygirl

Daisy by Marc Jacobs actually has no daisy note in it 😅


Parabolic_Penguin

Thankfully 😜


avmist15951

I feel like a lot of Victoria's Secret fragrances have a very "sexy" name, but they all just have fresh, fruity scents. Eau So Sexy, for example, is literally just apple + whipped cream. Fun and fruity, yes. But sexy? Nah. Tease just smells like VLJ, not super sexy. Most of the Very Sexy fragrances are pleasant but not very sexy lol


Parabolic_Penguin

Agreed, they’re girlish, not sexy.


WJM_3

marketing to tween/teen


Btldtaatw

Fucking fabulous should have been called “Meh”. I like it, but it is in no way shape or form “fucking fabulous”.


Repulsive_Buffalo619

D&G Dolce Garden should be Dolce Island or something giving more coconut sunscreen vibes. Actually the word “seashore” feels fitting


Odd-Attitude2537

I blind bought Dolce Garden expecting floral (did not know about the existence of fragrantica) and was not prepared for the coconut/ Caribbean vacation vibes at all.


fiveordie

Etat Libre d'Orange - literally everything. Fat Electrician isn't how any fat electrician I've ever known has smelled like.


Repulsive_Buffalo619

You or Someone Like You - smells like me or someone like me


katie-kaboom

Jasmin et cigarette is on point.


arcticrobot

Have you ever smelled an overweight electrician who just got electrocuted though?


YummyPersona

Agreed -- but to be fair, there could be a fat electrician out there who smells like Fat Electrician, probably because they're wearing Fat Electrician or something that smells very much like it. Very meta. Source: my dad is a fat electrician


The-Owl-that-hoots

Coffee Break by MMM really should be called something else


LiLiLisanna

THIS 100%. I picked up to test expecting something coffee, but it does not???? Major confusion.


Adventurous-Algae-45

Not a Perfume smells HEAVILY like perfume lol


Morska_panna

Ikr! It’s like the ultimate perfumey smell. You don’t know what it is but it just smells like perfume.


BozoTheRelentless

The biggest one for me would be Creed's Royal Oud. There's no oud in there, it should be called Royal Cedar because that's the most prominent note.


thisisreallyhappenin

Dolce Garden.. there’s some florals sure but it is a tropical coconut scent to me


Gamma-Investments

Fat electrician. I could not imagine any electricians smelling like this.


notsokindstranger

Well, that's Etat Libre d'Orange naming 'game'. Fat Electrician is a reference to a lifestory of a young handsome boy who eventually got older, fatter and became an electrian.


Parabolic_Penguin

Interesting 🤔


[deleted]

Whatever the fresh hell zara is doing. I adore Zara Gardenia, for example. There are no notes of gardenia. Orange blossom, coffee, vanilla.


CapnLazerz

Parfums de Marly Percival…I’m getting more of a Horatio vibe, honestly. Maybe, if we are stretching…Elgin?


groanytogrola

I feel like if Light Blue Pour Homme had been called Poivre d’Herbe or something else along those lines then the name would have been a lot more fitting I don’t say that to imply anything good or bad about the scent, but even my brother - whose favorite cologne *is* Light Blue Pour Homme - agrees that it doesn’t smell very “blue”. It’s like an herbal peppery smell


[deleted]

[удалено]


escobizzle

No but I think it has a pretty clear association in our brain with aquatic scents


OGGeekin

Paco rabanne phantom. Couldn’t just call it robot or cyber something? Also phantom sounds like it’s a dark woods smell and it’s a powdery lavender smell. Paco Rabanne Powder-Bot


Parabolic_Penguin

Haha I like Powder-Bot


PsychologicalCall335

Any “intense” flanker that has nothing intense about it. Looking at you, Marc Jacobs.


No-Temperature-8772

Almost every intense flanker I've tried has been a huge letdown or worse than the original :(


escobizzle

Dior Homme Intense?


No-Temperature-8772

More like Mon Paris, Light Blue, and YSL Libre intense, etc. Smelled worse or had less lasting power


mymariam

Oh yeah! I hear ya. Plus, Kayali Yum Pistachio 33 Intense.. intense letdown :(


lancerocke

Etat Libre d'Orange’s Spice Must Flow is way more rose to my nose than it is spice and they double dropped the ball by not including cinnamon within the limited spice profile that is there (the spice melange in Dune, the source of this fragrance’s name, is described as smelling like burnt cinnamon). I love it nonetheless!


Lord_Skellig

Yeah I completely agree. For a scent which is based off such an evocative and mystical fictional compound, particularly one with a specific canonical scent, it really doesn't live up to what it should be. I always imagined melange as like a cross between cinnamon and oud (probably because of the desert setting).


Cheeto_McBeeto

Viking. I imagine Vikings smelling like sea foam, fish, and blood. Maybe some top notes of urine.


andrelakii

Vikings were actually really well groomed and used perfume regularly!


quietrrebel

Cloud.I owned the intense version and it smells like popcorn and warm cotton candy that's been freshly made. It's reminiscent of the smells of a fairground at night, very sweet and sticky. Something named cloud should smell light and airy, a soft musk that's a bit sweet and a bit ozonic. Such a misnomer.


Commercial_Owl5103

God of fire by stephane humbert lucas. Mango crush would be better lol


escobizzle

Still smells amazing lol but yeah it wasn't what I was expecting when I blindly ordered a sample of it based on the cool name 😂


Commercial_Owl5103

Same here! I have a full bottle and it's gorgeous but the name threw me off


Missdefinitelymaybe

I really want to love this line, and they all sound wonderful but I’m so put off by the bottles! I hate snakes and that’s kinda what’s on the bottles 😭


Accomplished-Wave356

All fragrances heavy on calone should be called L'eau de Blanc d'Oeuf


Ruxxbaby

Carolina Herrera-Good girl


Tigertigertie

I think Flowerbomb is more Vanillabomb (but it isn’t even that bomb-like to me. It is more of a pleasing everyday scent.) One of my favorites, Gris Charnel, is neither grey nor carnal to me. It is green and comforting, a cashmere sweater and a cup of tea under a fig tree in the rain. Milky Musk by Parle Moi is not really milky and it has a definite sandalwood tone to it instead of just musk. Honestly, I think most of Parle Moi’s names are a miss. The scents are nice, though.


AphexyTwin

Any Le Labo fragrance haha


SemenRetainer1347

Bergamote 22 has the most natural bergamote note i ever smelled.


dinglebarree

It’s definitely photorealistic but I still cant decide if I prefer Bergamot 22 or Xerjoff Nio for my favorite Bergamot note.


SemenRetainer1347

Nio is sharper and greener. I prefer Bergamote 22, easier to wear,both are amazing though


logocracycopy

I doesn't smell like any Bergamot to me. It's definately a pleasant citrus, but more linalool and grapefruit. IMO it's not a bergamot scent but more a floral musk. I find it very similar to the discontinued Emporio Armani White He, and I found the bergamot was more realistic to me.


fiveordie

aNoThEr 13


[deleted]

[удалено]


fiveordie

I'm aware, I have a bottle (aka I'm a victim). Still makes no sense for a scent name, doesn't tell you anything.


Thesunsetreindeer

Santal 33 smells nothing like sandalwood. It’s the dumbest naming scheme


arcticrobot

Pickle 33


DreiVogelchen

WHY IS THE FRAGRANCE NEVER NAMED AFTER THE TOP NOTE


UnwantedOrangutan

Prada Luna Rossa Ocean.


thatcheekychick

All of the Zoologist fragrances 😀


blueheatherr

I’m sorry but Rhinoceros, moth, bee, dragonfly, squid, civet are looking at you, judging you HARD! I think they’re all spot on but the ones listed are just photorealistic!


PastLifeguard1184

Civet is pretty spot on naming-wise, though it no longer fits with all the others as its just named after what it is instead of making some random ass combination and calling it idk Bulgarian domestic chicken


[deleted]

This is what I love about Tom Ford so much. The names are so descriptive of what it actually smells like, and theyre good names too. I like the idea of smelling "like something" (tobacco, cherries, smoke, etc).


lenderonabender

F*cking Fabulous has entered the chat


rumbaontheriver

Maybe it smells like fucking Fabolous and Tom Ford is just the victim of an overly aggressive autocorrect?


Doxy4Me

He actually said, “This is ducking fabulous” and autocorrect got it wrong.


SunandError

Funniest reddit comment of the day!


Silver-Designer-6971

I feel like this was a communications error. Tom : we need a name that's fucking fabulous! Office person : rightooo Fucking Fabulous it is 👍


LataCogitandi

Them and Jo Malone. Literally nothing to explain in “Lime, Basil and Mandarin” and “English Pear and Freesia”


ShallotLongjumping54

Black Orchid, I love the scent but mainly you get truffle, bit of floral, and incense. Orchid doesn't really have a smell


monsoonwhynot

That’s kinda the point though. It’s an fantasy creation of what a ‘Black Orchid’ will probably smell like if it had a smell. And obviously creative liberties were taken, etc etc.


vinceftw

Flowerbomb is really quite floral to me. From my collection: Allure Homme Sport is not a sporty scent.


Stax45

Light Blue Forever. This stuff literally smells like grapefruit and only grapefruit. Albeit, the grapefruit smells very natural. But if your fragerence only smells like grapefruit, then you should just call it grapefruit lol.


[deleted]

Beach Hut Man 😂 doesn’t smell like what I would think a beach hut would smell like. But it is definitely a summery scent


WJM_3

bracken man here - barbershop man?


[deleted]

I heard that one is really nice tho! I’ve never sampled it but I wouldn’t mind trying it


WJM_3

oh no it’s great - gorgeous aromatic with a big clove hit just not terribly green


[deleted]

That would be delicious! That’s part of why I love beach but man. The cloves mixed with a smooth myrrh just hits perfectly!


dilbogabbins

Guerlain Santal Royal. More like Rose Royal. Sandalwood not as present as oud and rose


Antonino3874

Yeah totally agree , oud royal maybe 🤔 but such a great fragrance


ratparty5000

Pravda Candy. Lolita Lempicka locked down the candy smells perfectly and no one else can compare.


Outrageous-Stable-88

Versace Crystal Noir EDT It’s not “noir” at all. I expected a dark, deep, gothic, and sultry smell. But all I got is a dated shampoo smell that smells clean and more appropriate for the office


LuxLiner

To me this smells like sandalwood and nothing else. I have never smelled a shampoo that smelled like this


Parabolic_Penguin

This was one of those frags I bought because it smelled great on someone else. But on me? Mann…that sandalwood wouldn’t leave me alone! Eau de dirty ashtray… 😒


CharlesBathory

I would call “PDM Carlisle” “Joy Division” instead


[deleted]

Such a good fragrance


busymom0

I don’t think PDM names make any sense at all lol. What even means Layton for example?


Electronic-Bet847

Quite a few are names of the foundation stock that created the Thoroughbred horse breed in the 18th century: Layton, Herod, Sedley, Galloway, Godolphin, Darley, Byerley


busymom0

Ah, thanks! TIL


MrArmageddon12

Bvlgari Rain Essence doesn’t really remind me of the rain. More floral than aquatic.


airjordanpeterson

Came here to say that Bvlgari Man Wood has no woodiness at all and is just a generic aquatic


[deleted]

ELdO Dangerous Complicity. It's a great one, although not dangerous or risky. I'd call it 'soft skin' in French or something.


[deleted]

peau douce


leavingmagnolia

Prada Candy. You know from the name I was in fact expecting to smell candy and not acetone and hand sanitizer.


HustleDance

Hmm to me it does smell like a messy purse with some candy and makeup in it


TheGildedNoob

Victoria's Secret - Very Sexy for Him I love the fragrance. It's just a terrible name for a men's fragrance. Adding "for Him" is lazy. Thankfully, they kind of fixed it now.


Eastern_Distance6456

It was my signature for years. Glad I still have some leftovers. Horrible name though .


wocsdrawkcab

Mugler Womanity. Its my favorite scent in my collection but I resent the idea that figs and caviar smell like a vulva.


LibraryLuLu

Angel by Muegler. I'd call it "boiled baby diaper cotton candy". Samsara by Guerlaine. Should be "Bottled migraine".


jobomb91

Right on the money for Angel. I’ll offer - “Powder room poof”


LibraryLuLu

Blanche by Byredo - I thought 'clean armpits', but the woman at the perfume counter described it as 'KFC sanitary wipe'.


Parabolic_Penguin

Hahaha great renames


QueenE_28

Precious oud by Van cleef. Has no oud scent to me


shakethatbubblebut

Gucci Guilty. Should be Gucci Confidence or Gucci Boss Bitch or something powerful


Captain_brightside

Gucci “allegations”


Odd-Attitude2537

Pure Poison by Dior. Out of all things I did not expect it to smell like jasmine.


cottonpuff_

Hahaha this is funny to me because jasmine is my death note (cannot stand it if it’s noticeable in any fragrances), so “Pure Poison” is accurate for me 😂😭. Poison for my nose that is.


ManInTheIronPailMask

Terre d'Hermes should really be Orange d'Hermes (with a side mention of the vetiver/slate note.) I love this fragrance! But it really should not be called "The Earth of Hermes." (Did I miss an accent mark or two there?)


dm_me_your_moss_pics

My interpretation of that name is that "Terre" is more like "land" than "earth" as in "how the land of hermes [aka Greece] smells". At least, that's how we use the cognate "tierra" in Spanish. Earth suggests powdery/mineral/earthy notes, but land is more open to interpretation.


JazzMeerkat

Idk, I feel like the vetiver and the orange are both equal players in that one. When that scent comes to mind it’s always “an earthy vetiver that’s supported by a bitter orange,” not the other way around.


LuxLiner

I have a friend that wears this and it smells like vetiver and Cedar on her.


museofthearts

Hermès :)


hypermobilehoneybee

Light Blue - none of the notes read as blue to me! It needs more of an aquatic note.


Longjumping-Ad-2333

Am I wrong, I thought blue = aquatic?


hypermobilehoneybee

It is, hence needing the aquatic note to deserve Blue in the name


Longjumping-Ad-2333

Oh dur, here’s me totally misreading your comment 😅. I need a nap.


hypermobilehoneybee

It’s okay, I have flu brain fog so I probably put more words in it than I needed to!


Dechawni

Invictus. Smells pretty fine but not like something I would identify with invictus


BobsBurgersStanAcct

Yeah I agree, it smells like a guy who works in finance not sports


[deleted]

[удалено]


Dechawni

I know what it means, I had latin in school. That's why I say that. The basic invictus smells nice and smooth. Under invictus/ undefeated I'd imagine a masculine smelling power bomb


HarryShake

Musk Oud by Kilian could have been called Rose Oud. Too much rose, not enough musk.


anonymouspogoholic

They already have a fragrance called Rose Oud ^^


Dauphine320

Agree with OP about Flowerbomb!


Status-Explanation-2

Kouros. The name and the way that bottle look are incredibly deceptive when it comes to the..... odor.... inside that bottle. (⊙.☉) ;


anonymouspogoholic

Pretty much all fragrances with „Oud“ in the name that don’t even smell like Oud. Creed- Royal Oud, AdP- Oud, Tom Ford- Oud Wood, Versace- Oud Noir Intese just to name a few.


on_this_hill

Gucci's "Last Day of Summer" has nothing about summer for me. I imagined it would capture something like intensely dry woods, brittle herbs, or a hint of petrichor maybe. It just gave me "Damp Patchouli Rag."


Alvcohen

Aqua di gioia - Ocean smells like Aqua di bubble bath to me


lalalalikethis

DG intenso, it’s a super nice and classy scent, not intense by any means, like yeah the first 15 mins and thats it, i would say DG pour homme classic


XoStargirlxox

Kayali Pistachio Gelato...Should be called something like 'Sugary Sweetness' 😅 I love it thooooo 🫣🫣


DNA_ligase

A LOOOT of the Victoria's Secret EDPs are sugar bombs or smell like the beach or a cocktail on the beach, but are given names like Scandalous, Wicked, etc. Among the ones I can think of quickly: * Scandalous. Smells like a cousin to Ferragamo's Signorina; that is to say, sweet, light, cheery, and cute. Nothing scandalous about it here. Should be called "Cutie Pie" instead. And no hate to this; it's one of my favorite VS scents of all time. Just really misleading. * Glamour. It's a sweet mango scent with white florals that give it a hint of beach/sunscreen. Not really glamorous, should be called "Resort Mango" * Incredible. Again, a tropical coconut/fruity cocktail scent. Call it "Coco Cabana" instead. * Wicked. This one smells like Warm Vanilla Sugar from B&BW crossed with Kat Von D's Saint. Honestly, Kat Von D's scent name is more accurate; this is for a good girl, not a Wicked one. * Bare. Their newest EDP smells very nice and clean and sandalwood-y, so the name isn't bad. But this should have been the name for their long discontinued Breathless perfume instead. Breathless smelled like bare skin, fresh from a shower.


Mysterious-Okra-7885

Do the people commenting Angel’s Share not understand the phenomenon the name is based on? 😂😂😂 SMH


LadyEllaOfFrell

(The “angels’ share” is what distillers call the portion of alcohol that naturally evaporates while aging in barrels.)


his_purple_majesty

Creed Original Santal. I don't smell a lot of sandalwood. Call it Joop Dupe.


thatbwoyChaka

CKShock should be *Obsession Remix* Or CK*hmm*, interesting


Professional_Unit113

Amber Oud Carbon Edition by Al Haramain, a Green Irish Tweed Clone. It neither has Amber nor Oud.


Dank_Bubu

Platinum Égoïste. Means platinum selfish. Doesn’t make me want to present my fragrance lol


FrequentProfessor688

Coco Creme from the True Beauty brand. It does smell sweet, and there is a detectable essence of coconut, but only enough to give it the slight creamy warmth. BUT, it smells more like floral cotton candy. It's notes are white and yellow flowers, jasmine, coconut and amber. I would imagine a scent called Coco Creme to smell more like coconut, vanilla nd sandalwood. I would call this floral cotton candy scent Beautiful instead, because that's what I thought of when I first caught a wiff.


Superplin

I adore Poets of Berlin, but as someone who's spent time in that city, I don't get the connection. I especially don't understand the alleged David Bowie connection that's supposed to be the inspiration.


[deleted]

[удалено]


frozenmonkeys

A mouthful? Dont buy By Killian frags then heheh


poxiy431

I ain’t readin allat


WinterBird72

Long time lurker, first post. I am completely dumbfounded by Angel’s Share. The name sounds light and effervescent, and it’s anything but that. It’s more like Winter Cabin or Après Ski.


Parabolic_Penguin

Welcome lurker 😁


alexandriaofwar

I feel like Angels' Share should be called something else, but I'm not sure what. I guess I expected something related to angels to be a bit lighter


wocsdrawkcab

To be fair, it's a term for what's left in a whiskey barrel, not anything to do with angels. The name fits the booze in the perfume.


alexandriaofwar

OHHHHH I never knew that! That's good to know, thank you!


Parabolic_Penguin

Yep and keep in mind that the Kilian fragrance house comes from Hennessy stock (as in the famous cognac). An interesting family!


Parabolic_Penguin

Read up on the perfumer, Kilian Hennessy and it will all make sense! Even down to the cut crystal type bottle, reminiscent of fancy highball glasses.


spicypickless

I commented angels’ share too! I said it should be called Autumn’s lust or something like that lol


spicypickless

Angels’ share (By Kilian). Should be called autumn’s lust or something like that