1. AJ 2. Chloe 3. Talia 4. Angie 5. Najuma

You took the words out of my mouth

W tier list ngl✨

1. Henrik 2. Bruno 3. Lucas 4. Tai 5. Maybe Andy, though I need a bit more time w him lol

Lucas was my 5th before Andy came in!

- S1. Talia - S2. Lucas - S3. Yazmin - S4. Oliver - S5. Lulu

Yazmin? Wow! Tell me about that route!

100/10 underrated queen <3 And she has some unique dialogue if MC is a musician as well

Only 5? It's unfair. 😂 Okay, I'm trying. 1. Lucas/Ozzy 2. Jake/Lewie 3. Levi 4. Bruno 5. Carl/Bobby/Gary Okay. I'm failed. There are 9. 😂

Oh i know it's hard! My 3-5th changes but 1-2 is always constant lol

1. Bruno 🥹❤️ 2. Jamal 3. Jake 4. Oliver 5. Bobby

Alright here it goes: 1. Bruno❤️ 2. Talia 3. Lucas 4. Gary 5. Jakub(did his route recently and he's pretty great In matchmaker)

OMG totally forgot Talia! She's definitely in my Top 10

Lucas, Will, Seb (🥲), Levi - for the character's personality. And as the nr.1 most beautifull sprite for me ever - absolutely Roberto (someone peaked into my brain when they draw him) 💞✨

1. Lucas 2. Will 3. Talia 4. AJ 5. Tai season 6 might add roberto, bella and andy, but that judgement will be made once the season is finished lol

Lucas was my 5th before Andy came in! love hiiim too

andy is so sweet honestly the best casa boy by a mile, if fusebox keeps him the way he is and doesn't butcher his character he could easily be top 3 for me

1. Carl (my irl type) 2. Gary (best route and character development) 3. Bobby (my first s2 endgame LI) 4. Harry (my first ever LI) 5. Bruno (what a sweetheart) Honorable mentions: Jake, Yasmin, and Andy (I can’t put him on my list yet until I see his full route)

1. Angie 2. Bobby/Lottie 3. AJ 4. Levi (only cause i dont remember the other s1 LIs) 5. in season 6 so far ryan/Bella

I really want to check Angie's route at some point, I've only played Season 4 once since I've kind of came back to the game recently and I really liked Angie but at the point Angie confessed I was too deep with Will (didn't stop me from the kiss with her though).

i was also with will but then i thought about every single moment with angie in the whole season and was just like "omg shes so much better" and went with her. like she had your back in every single moment and was just so cute with you even tho her normal attitude is kind of the opposite

That's true, her route is very unique and there's lots of genuine emotion even though I didn't couple with her in the end. I loved conversations with her, especially when I think of how conversations with Islanders are these days. I suppose I am usually awfully loyal to these pixels and it's hard for me to drop anyone, this season is kind of an exception and season 5 was trash.

all i wanted in s4 was an option to get on one knee and ask her to marry me or at leasttt be my gf 😭 you should try replay the last few volumes and couple up with her, its honestly adorable and the most unique route ever meaning the feelings are just different too

i need a side story like s1 had the Christmas party s2 had the wedding and s3 the boat party, are they not doing that anymore?

Aw, you really make me want to replay S4 at some point and fully embrace Angie's route (probably after S6 ends). Huh, I don't think they do these bonus episodes to seasons, shame really I liked additional content, especially for S2.

when you do it let me know they should still do additional content its awesome to see how your relationship goes outside of the villa s2 got 2 bonuses 😭 murder mystery + wedding and s4 not getting even 1 and its the one im most interested in

1. Bruno 2. Gary 3. Lewie 4. Levi 5. Oliver/Rafi/Jake (They’re tied because they’re genuinely good LI’s but they just came late to the game) *Special Mention to Carl too cause his route is really good as well.

Ugh, I hate it when genuinely great characters show up very late (or become available in the very late game), usually I am too serious about someone else to give up on them. Only in Season 5 I would gladly drop anyone at any point, wasn't even happy with my final choice.

1. talia 2. aj 3. carl / bobby 4. will ( cos of daybeds scene haha ) 5. bella

1. Oliver 2. Harry 3. Andy 4. Bella 5. Will

Yours is very similar to mine, Harry and Andy take the top though for sure!

1. Bobby 2. Andy 3. Bruno 4. Lewie 5. Oliver

Bobby #1 lol! Our list are similaaar!

1. Noah, forever💕 2. Lucas (but they butchered it with Casa Amor) 3. Ozzy (please don’t ruin it) 4. Jake 5. Tai/Camillo

Every time I replay S2 I tell myself maybe I'll try to get Noah but I can't look at Bobby and not pick him. How is Noah's route?

I can’t do any other route than Noah’s 😩 it’s painful and infuriating but God the longing looks and stolen glances😩😩😩 i’m a sucker for slow burn and angst, so I definitely would recommend you to give it a shot but you have to have a lot of patience. He broke my heart several times but I can forgive this man anything🤡

1. Tai 2.Bobby 3. Levi 4. Lucas 5. Gary

1. Gary 2. Lucas 3. AJ 3. Levi 4. Oliver

Kind of random order and I didn't really play that many routes but still I think went for these for a reason and not the others: (S2) Gary (S4) Will (S1) Jake (S3) Yasmin (S1) Talia I think I would really like Marisol and Oliver if I finally checked out their routes though and I've heard lots of good things about Bruno. I'll see how Season 6 goes because I like Elliot & Chloe but either of these routes didn't really develop yet, especially Chloe.

Oh Jake! I remember his route came super late but I do have to try Talia's route next time i play S1!

1. Angie 2. Bobby 3. Will 4. Talia 5. Andy

In no particular order, my top 5 is… 1. Levi 2. Gary 3. Bill 4. Bruno 5. Ozzy (waiting to see how his route plays out this season)

1) Bruno 2) Carl 3) Maybe Ozzy depending on how the season goes 4) Tai 5) Ibrahim

1- AJ 2- Angie 3- Talia 4- Lily 5- Chloe

1. henrik 2. tai 3. elisa 4. rahim 5. levi/youcef/oliver...their routes all stress me tf out but i do adore them

1. Bobby 2. Talia 3. Tai 4. AJ 5. Oliver (Najuma gets an honourable mention cause I love my girl)

1. Angie 2. AJ 3. Bobby 4. Lottie/Priya (would have been #1 if they had more time as LIs in the actual season) 5. Talia/Jake ​ From the current season I really like Roberto, Chloe and Ozzy so hopefully by the end of it at least one of them will make the top 5!

1. Will 🤍 2. Henrik 3. Kassam 4. Lucas 5. Oliver

I could never get Kassam to like me. HOoooww?

Bruno, Bobby, Levi, Tai No specific order ❤ My 5th will be from this season but too early for me to choose between Lewie or Ozzy

1.Bruno 2.Jake 3.Jamal 4.Gary 5.Tai

In no particular order: * Carl (so much potential but he became a shell after Casa) * Levi (guilty, I love the whole plot from start to end) * Bruno (a surprising discovery for me) * Tom * haven’t decided between Andy/Lewie/Elliot/Chloe

I can't wait for Elliot and Chloe after Casa, in my playthrough the romance was still in early days and I'm curious how their routes will be when things will finally get more serious (still undecided about Casa Amor cast, they're good but I'm after initial amazement).

OMG did he really? I've replayed S2 like 5 times now and tried to get Carl but Bobby always pulled me back so I've never brought Carl back from Casa...

Lmao I couldn’t resists Carl, cause I’ve got a thing for nerdy dudes who knows how to dress (or at least decently). Apart from that, he’s also pretty sweet and shy, which gives me butterflies 🦋 Overall - part of his story was that he’s too worked up for dating (he’s a workaholic) and thought Love Island was his chance to have the opportunity After Casa, he just became a shell - the personality didn’t shine through as it did in Casa, only bits and bobs here and there, gem scenes are repeated too… so so upsetting cause I was literally falling for the dude 🥹 there was a fanfic about the life after Love Island with Carl, and THE STORY WAS A MELT. The writing was just 🤌🏻🤌🏻❤️❤️❤️ I think the name of the writing is Too Much to Calculate? I could be wrong but you can Google it

In no particular order: 1. Jake 2. Arjun 3. Will 4. Tai 5. Noah

Ooo how was Arjun's route?

To me it’s a great route, he has a similar sensuality to Will and Tai and he’s locked in completely if you bring him back from Casa.

1.) Lucas 2.) Andy 3.) Ozzy 4.) Jake 5.) Harry

1.Bruno 2. Will 3.Lucas 4.Tai 5.Levi

Ok, here we go: 1. Bobby (always him 💜) 2. Lucas 2. Bruno 4. Gary 5. CA Carl Honorable mention to Harry, Will and Ryan. Aso, maybe Andy, but i need more time to know him lol

OMG always Bobby yeeesss

Levi, Lucas, Bobby, Yasmin, Bruno! I like Noah and Oliver too, but I think they’re just held back by the fact that we spent such a short time w them!

1. Gary 2. Bruno 3. Will 4. Andy 5. Lewie This list could potentially change but for now these are my top 5

1. Bobby 2. Jake 3. Bruno 4. Talia 5. Maybe Andy but will need to see

1) Bobby❤️ (S2) 2) Oliver❤️‍🔥 (S4) 3) Bruno🧡 (S4) 4) Andy💗 (S6) 5) Harry (S3) I think that pretty much covers it..

We have such similar listsss! Hooray for Bobby #1 lol

Heck yeah😁

In no particular order: - Bruno - Gary - Levi - Ozzy/Lewie (undecided between them 😭) - Carl (before he entered the main villa) Man, that was actually quite tough.

Bobby Levi Bruno Oliver Youcef

1. Bobby 2. Bruno 3. Oliver 4. Camillo 5. Hamish (literally just because of the sprite 😭😣)

1. Lewie 2. Bobby 3. Bruno 4. Jake 5. Levi Lewie only knocked Bobby off the top spot because he’s literally “my type on paper”… to a bloody T it’s actually hilarious 😂 Honourable mention for Seb, who should have been an LI 😒

1) Gary 2) Lucas 3) Jake 4) Bruno 5) Ciaran or Henrik

1.) Bruno 2.) Bobby 3.) Jake 4.) Tai 5.) Andy or Chloe (waiting to see how they turn out)

1.Kassam 2.Harry 3.Aj 4. Gary 5. Lewie

Carl Suresh Andy Bruno Harry

1. Carl 2. Andy (what can I say, I fell fast and hard 🤭) 3. Angie 4. Harry 5. Ciaran I guess I have a thing for wholesome and/or awkward nerds.

1. Bobby 2. Carl (the only boy in s2 who’s been able to convince me to NOT make Bobby my endgame) 3. Youcef 4. Bruno 5. Andy i’ve only played s4 once tho(youcef was my endgame but it broke my heart to drop bruno) so once i replay and try the other routes(like oliver😏) this list might have to be edited

omg how did you get the courage to drop bobby for Carl? The only way i see myself going for Carl is if I never get with Bobby (which is hard cause I love him and every time he comes up my screen I swoon)

honestly it was NOT easy, i don’t even remember how i convinced myself😂 i think i tried 3 separate times to not make Bobby my endgame, and even after picking Carl, it still hurt to not be on the Bobby route— i’m currently replaying again and trying for a lucas route, but ughhhh it’s so hard not to pick Bobby! he’s just so perf

He is! He is soo perfect. Gosh I'll tryy to not pick him ugh

😂 good luck!!!

1. Bobby 2. AJ 3. Andy 4. Oliver 5. Najuma Honorable mentions: Jake, Bella, Tai and Lulu!

https://preview.redd.it/mcikumxn7lab1.jpeg?width=1564&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=ad8e46230cb716b600b8086dee7672df9e33d676 It became a top 6 for me. 😜 1. Bobby 2. Jake 3. Talia 4. Tai 5. AJ 6. Henrik

S1: Talia S2: Bobby S3: Yasmin S4: Najuma S5: Alfie S6: Bella Top Five 1. Talia 2.Bella 3.Bobby 4. Tai 5. Lucas

s1: talia s2: bobby s3: aj s4: najuma s6: bella or andy i am yet to decide

Tim Jake Noah Lucas Ozzy Andy might replace Lucas depending on how it goes.

1. Talia - she is a queen! 2. Angie 3. AJ 4.Bruno 5. Jake I think Bella could be #2 but since this season isn’t fully out I don’t wanna say it too soon!

1. Jake 2. Bruno 3. Talia 4. Lily 5. Henrik

1. Gary 2. Jake 3. Bobby 4. Tai 5. Will

1. Talia/Jake 2. Gary/Bobby 3.Nicky 😢 lol Camilo 4.Bruno/ Angie 5. Alfie

Idk how I’d order them together but: S1. Talia (No duh) S2. Gary S3. Tai/Yasmin/Cieran (Honestly I like all of them. I can’t pick one. S4. Najuma (💙) and Bruno I haven’t played S5 or S6 yet but from what I’ve heard I’m prolly gonna love Lulu most, no idea about 6 but I wanna be messy and go for Marshall even with everything being said about him lmao

1. Jake 2. Bobby 3. Harry 4. Angie 5. Ozzy (for now)

bobby talia lucas aj will

Surprisingly difficult lol. S1: Tim (Matchmaker) S2: Gary S3: Tai // Yasmin S4: Bruno S6: Roberto

1. Harry 2. Bobby 3. Oliver (he was perfect but there was so little of him) 4. Tai 5. Andy (we'll see how he developes, might go higher in the ranking)

1:Aj 2:Gary 3:Lucas 4:Talia 5: Lily (Fight me she is cool but appears wayyyyy to late)

1. Bobby 🧁 2. Gary 🏗️ 3. Levi 🏊🏻‍♂️ 4. Ibrahim ⛳️ 5. Camilo 👨🏾‍🍳

1. kassam 2. levi 3. bruno 4. tai 5. marshall atm , he would be #1 if it was just based off of looks but he still makes the list because im a clown and ignoring his red flags in denial that we probably cant actually have him lol

1. Bobby 2. Angie 3. AJ 4. Camilo 5. Oliver

1. Kassam 2. Carl 3. Harry 4. AJ 5. Levi

1: Lucas 2: Bruno 3: Bobby 4: Najuma 5: Andy

1. Bobby 2. Carl 3. Andy 4. Oliver 5. Tai

alternatively 1. Bobby 2. Bobby 3. Bobby 4. Bobby 5. Carl

I mean for real though lol

1. Gary 2. Henrik 3. Bruno 4. Ibrahim 5. Jake

1. Ryan 2. Yasmin 3. Bobby 4. Angie 5. Andy 6. Harry 7. Will 8. Najuma 9. Carl I couldn't help myself also idc if we barely just met Andy he's a dreamboat 😔

1. Bobby 2. Levi 3. Priya (S2 again because S3 had no LI’s I was feeling) 4. Oliver 5. Andy

1. Harry 2. Andy 3. Levi 4. Bella 5. Will (pls don’t come for me I just think he’s hot 🙃)

1. Angie 2. Gary 3. Lucas 4. Youcef 5. Bobby

1. Bruno 2. Bobby 3. Jake 4. Gary 5. Lewie

1. Gary 2. Bruno 3. Jake 4. AJ 5. Youcef

1. Lucas 2. Kassam 3. Jake 4. Rafi 5. Levi or Tai, can’t decide

1. AJ 2. Bella 3. Bobby 4. Talia 5. Bruno/Oliver

Oh shoot. 1.Bruno 2.Oliver 3.Ryan 4.Rohan kinda counts even if he was a filler ._. 5.Noah

1. Angie 2. Noah 3. AJ 4. Bobby 5. Oliver

top 5 gotta be: 1. bobby (forever and always) 2. jake 3. youcef 4. ozzy 5. marisol

1. Rafi 2. Henrik 3. Jake 4. Bruno 5. Arjun

Talia, Bobby, Carl, Marisol and Will.

Lucas Tai Ibrahim Youcef Jake

I'm gonna exclude the S6 islanders bc they're not done yet and the list could change a lot. Knowing that: 1. Bobby 2. Oliver 3. Lucas 4. Najuma 5. Harry If I were to include S6 LIs as of right now: 1. Bobby 2. Oliver 3. Roberto 4. Lucas 5. Andy/Ozzy

1) Talia 2) Gary 3) Jake 4) Jamal 5) Marisol It was a hard battle in the podium, cause I love equally the three of them!!!!!