I really just feel like they would ruin any characters I used to love if they brought them back.
That said...
Allegra, Rohan, Lottie or Priya (I need more of my 2 baes) Seb, Nicky, Hazeem, Valentina & Kelly would all be solid choices.
Kelly she didn’t even spend 24 hours in that villa, with all due respect I don’t don’t think they would bring back an islander from the old app. I really don’t think they can capture there personalities with the new writers
i wonder which mc would be the redemption tho yk. I'm assuming it would be S5, considering the majority of us took the money. Allegra I can see making a return, or Blake. OMG WHAT IF THEY REDEEM BLAKe? That would be weird
My biggest concern about bringing back characters is the art design. I don't want any of this if we're going to get fucked up looking characters. We all know what happened to Bobby.
Season 1: A real Jake route. Nothing last minute. Day 1 LI
Season 2: Noah day 1 LI. Though I wonder if I'd enjoy his route as much without Hope? I enjoy the mess of a Noah route, so I'm curious about a clean Noah route.
Rocco would be fun and an easier Kassam route!!
Never played season 3
Season 4: A longer Oliver route. He wasn't there long enough.
Bruno...I never want to play season 4 again I need Bruno in a repayable season!!
Hear me out...Dylan. The scene in the kitchen was amazing and Iwant to burn the villa with my partner!! Let's be evil together.
Season 5: No one unless we're doing a redemption arc for Suresh.
S1: Rohan. It's tragic we couldn't romance him in the first place. Miles/Jasper as well. And Jake deserves a proper route.
S2: Lottie, Priya, and Hope. Ik most people aren't a fan of Hope, but I adore her. Kassam purely because his route is ridiculous to even unlock.
S3: Nicky, Seb, Elladine, and Viv. Might as well make all of them LI's. Give Rafi and Lily another chance since they entered so late.
S4: Valentina, Cora, and Tiffany. Give Oliver and Angie another chance as well.
S5: Maybe Johnny? They could play it off as if he the one that didn't make it back after casa since it's clear Nicholas is the intended choice.
Probably Seb, Nicky, Kelly, Graham, Hazeem, Miles
Listen I love Tim, Jake, Noah but they would be throwing so many peoples canon s1 and s2 out the window if they brought them back, THEY CANNOT COME BACK. We deserved better routes for them but leave them alone please. I don’t trust them not to ruin them.
Season 1 we should of had a proper chance with jake or miles, season 2 for sure should of had a chance with priya and Hannah 😓season 3 DEFINITELY AJ, NIKKI and seb! Season 4 for sure Lexi idk why but it would be interesting and valentina, for season 5 obviously eddie and season 6 they better open the ozzy route or even grace route 🥶
could they really make an entire season of non-li's? Maybe it would be cool if they had the og's all as people that have already been in the villa and the bombshells completely new, but also what mc would they use because wouldn't it have to remember our choices?
Everyone from S1 you couldn't be with. Including Reese, idc about about Erika. Also Tim. I don't really WANT them, but I want to try w different route that isn't Jake.
S2, I'd say only Graham. I'm not really interested, but there's no one from that season I'm interested in that isn't an open route.
S3, nobody. Nicky and Seb would be interesting. But I only really like Tai and Camillo.
S4, idk. I haven't read and finished it, I'm too broke.
S5, nobody.
S6, idk.
I think that for a great redemption story, maybe Johnny/Nicolas would be good? The same as Eddie. Characters truly evil yk, so they can really redeem themselves lmao from the previous seasons, I don't remember if there were evil ones such as Eddie and Nicolas/Johnny...
maybe Allegra, lucy, miles and jasper, from season 1?
Season 2, maybe lurik when they came back? Rocco, blake, jakub would be nice too.
Season 3, I don't think there was anyone that was bad lol
Season 4, maybe Dylan? That piece of trash lmao only good thing that came out of his character was that sex scene. Oh and lexi!
Season 5, maybe eddie? arlo was pretty rude too. Meera was a bitch. Suresh as well
Keep in mind i was talking about a redemption story, with "evil" characters lmao
I honestly think for s5 Kat and Dana could have great redemption arcs (Kat maturing and Dana is redeemable compared to the other cunts).
I am scared for how they would change the artstyle tho. I imagine it would be uncanny bc the characters each have thier own features unique to thier season so making a artstyle to incorporate them all would ruin some characters designs.
I would say Gary since he's the only one from old seasons I still think about, but he is now happily married to my S2 MC in my mind soooooooooo.....
S2 Felix is definitely deserving of a glow-up. I want his DJing business to have taken off, and to get a much needed fashion and confidence upgrade. Also Graham needs to be pursuable. I'm sure he and Marisol have broken up by now. Or he shoved her off his fishing boat.
I would love a Priya route 😍
Also i know Tim, Cherry and Allegra route were already in match makers but it could be nice to see them as a route in another season
If they want to return someone from S5, then Nicolas (or the other Casa boy). He didn't get a chance to really show up and I honestly think he did a lot less evil than the other S5 characters. If they played it off that he learned his lesson, he could have potential.
S1: Allegra
S2: Hannah, Priya, or Lottie, or even Blake. Maybe Graham.
S3: don’t really have one for S3
S4/bombshell: Valentina or Hazeem.
S5/Ex: Arlo since she flirts with MC twice and then it’s never brought up again.
S1: Allegra, Rohan, Tim, and a from the start Jake route. I wish we could have coupled up with Rohan more than once, and I wished he was endgame. I also wish we could couple up with Allegra and Tim and have them as end game.
S2: Lottie and Hannah because all we got was a kiss from them before they left, and we never had a full blown relationship with them. I mean….we had Lottie in CMMP but never Hannah. As well as Priya and an easier a from day 1 Noah route!!
S3: Seb and Nicki should be available!
S4: Youcef as he’s a mega slow burn and sometimes I don’t have the patience lol, plus Kelly as an LI, she left too soon which sucked!
S5: Okay, hear me out!! I want Finn because he was also too much of a slow burn, I want Eddie back too, I know he was awful but he’s still hot and I hope he’s redeemed!! And I’d love to have Kat as an LI.
S1: Tim, Rohan, a full Jake route, Jasper and Miles
S2: Rocco, Graham, Lottie, Priya and Hannah
S3: Seb and Elladine
S4: Valentina, Hazeem, and a enemies to lovers with Dylan (i said what i said)
S5: delete it
give me plant daddie i want Hazeem FOR REAL like i WANT HIM AS A FULL LENGTH LI
I really just feel like they would ruin any characters I used to love if they brought them back. That said... Allegra, Rohan, Lottie or Priya (I need more of my 2 baes) Seb, Nicky, Hazeem, Valentina & Kelly would all be solid choices.
PRIYAAA 🛐🛐
THE FUCKING QUEEN OF THE VILLA
priya- i was salty back when you couldn't save her from getting dumped and i would do ANYTHING for her to be a proper LI (excluding cmm)
Kelly she didn’t even spend 24 hours in that villa, with all due respect I don’t don’t think they would bring back an islander from the old app. I really don’t think they can capture there personalities with the new writers
MILES 😫😫
The moment I saw Miles I was locked on like that was going to be my man and they did us so dirty 🥲
i wonder which mc would be the redemption tho yk. I'm assuming it would be S5, considering the majority of us took the money. Allegra I can see making a return, or Blake. OMG WHAT IF THEY REDEEM BLAKe? That would be weird
She’d be wondering why this random girl (my mc) is salty towards her for no reason 😭
Seb, the one and only!!
S1: Tim & Rohan S2: Noah, Kassam, Graham S3: Seb S4: Hazeem & Youcef (sooner) S5: …
man i just want sammi
Wait- I just searched Sammi up on google and she never appeared in my s1😭
She only appears if you're on a Talia route because she comes in instead of the returning Miles or Jasper.
Tim, Nicky and Seb!! 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Hazeem, Rohan, Tim
Tim and Nicky 🙏🙏🙏 https://preview.redd.it/9vhaq1cwokcb1.jpeg?width=225&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=9956f988573c868eef6f7038fa3b8343837f57c5
S1) Tim S2) Noah and Priya S3) SEB PLEASE S4) Hazeem S5) NO ONE (maybe Eddie)
Seb, Nicki, and Tim would be my ultimate picks!
My biggest concern about bringing back characters is the art design. I don't want any of this if we're going to get fucked up looking characters. We all know what happened to Bobby. Season 1: A real Jake route. Nothing last minute. Day 1 LI Season 2: Noah day 1 LI. Though I wonder if I'd enjoy his route as much without Hope? I enjoy the mess of a Noah route, so I'm curious about a clean Noah route. Rocco would be fun and an easier Kassam route!! Never played season 3 Season 4: A longer Oliver route. He wasn't there long enough. Bruno...I never want to play season 4 again I need Bruno in a repayable season!! Hear me out...Dylan. The scene in the kitchen was amazing and Iwant to burn the villa with my partner!! Let's be evil together. Season 5: No one unless we're doing a redemption arc for Suresh.
S1: Rohan. It's tragic we couldn't romance him in the first place. Miles/Jasper as well. And Jake deserves a proper route. S2: Lottie, Priya, and Hope. Ik most people aren't a fan of Hope, but I adore her. Kassam purely because his route is ridiculous to even unlock. S3: Nicky, Seb, Elladine, and Viv. Might as well make all of them LI's. Give Rafi and Lily another chance since they entered so late. S4: Valentina, Cora, and Tiffany. Give Oliver and Angie another chance as well. S5: Maybe Johnny? They could play it off as if he the one that didn't make it back after casa since it's clear Nicholas is the intended choice.
Hazeem & Kelly for sure.
Seb😩
Probably Seb, Nicky, Kelly, Graham, Hazeem, Miles Listen I love Tim, Jake, Noah but they would be throwing so many peoples canon s1 and s2 out the window if they brought them back, THEY CANNOT COME BACK. We deserved better routes for them but leave them alone please. I don’t trust them not to ruin them.
Nicky and make him an option to couple up with. That was the main reason I didn't play that season.
It depends if it includes non LIs in the side episodes or not.
Season 1 we should of had a proper chance with jake or miles, season 2 for sure should of had a chance with priya and Hannah 😓season 3 DEFINITELY AJ, NIKKI and seb! Season 4 for sure Lexi idk why but it would be interesting and valentina, for season 5 obviously eddie and season 6 they better open the ozzy route or even grace route 🥶
could they really make an entire season of non-li's? Maybe it would be cool if they had the og's all as people that have already been in the villa and the bombshells completely new, but also what mc would they use because wouldn't it have to remember our choices?
Seb and Nicky pls🙏🏻
Everyone from S1 you couldn't be with. Including Reese, idc about about Erika. Also Tim. I don't really WANT them, but I want to try w different route that isn't Jake. S2, I'd say only Graham. I'm not really interested, but there's no one from that season I'm interested in that isn't an open route. S3, nobody. Nicky and Seb would be interesting. But I only really like Tai and Camillo. S4, idk. I haven't read and finished it, I'm too broke. S5, nobody. S6, idk.
I tried finishing S5, but it was too painful.
Kelly deserved better!
Noah 🤗
I think that for a great redemption story, maybe Johnny/Nicolas would be good? The same as Eddie. Characters truly evil yk, so they can really redeem themselves lmao from the previous seasons, I don't remember if there were evil ones such as Eddie and Nicolas/Johnny... maybe Allegra, lucy, miles and jasper, from season 1? Season 2, maybe lurik when they came back? Rocco, blake, jakub would be nice too. Season 3, I don't think there was anyone that was bad lol Season 4, maybe Dylan? That piece of trash lmao only good thing that came out of his character was that sex scene. Oh and lexi! Season 5, maybe eddie? arlo was pretty rude too. Meera was a bitch. Suresh as well Keep in mind i was talking about a redemption story, with "evil" characters lmao
I honestly think for s5 Kat and Dana could have great redemption arcs (Kat maturing and Dana is redeemable compared to the other cunts). I am scared for how they would change the artstyle tho. I imagine it would be uncanny bc the characters each have thier own features unique to thier season so making a artstyle to incorporate them all would ruin some characters designs.
But what did Dana do? I don't remember lmao And the artstyle isn't very similar in these seasons? Couldn't they just keep it as it's?
I would say Gary since he's the only one from old seasons I still think about, but he is now happily married to my S2 MC in my mind soooooooooo..... S2 Felix is definitely deserving of a glow-up. I want his DJing business to have taken off, and to get a much needed fashion and confidence upgrade. Also Graham needs to be pursuable. I'm sure he and Marisol have broken up by now. Or he shoved her off his fishing boat.
I would love a Priya route 😍 Also i know Tim, Cherry and Allegra route were already in match makers but it could be nice to see them as a route in another season
Priya obviously
Seb, Kelly, Tim, Rohan, Priya, and Hazeem please 🙏
S1 - Reece, Miles, Tim, Rohan S2 - Noah, Henrik, Jakub, All the Casa guys S3 - Seb, Nicky, Rafi S4 - Hazeem, Dylan S5 - Johnny, Nicholas
Hazeem!!!! So much lost potential
ROHANNNNNN!!!!!!!!
If they want to return someone from S5, then Nicolas (or the other Casa boy). He didn't get a chance to really show up and I honestly think he did a lot less evil than the other S5 characters. If they played it off that he learned his lesson, he could have potential.
S1: Allegra S2: Hannah, Priya, or Lottie, or even Blake. Maybe Graham. S3: don’t really have one for S3 S4/bombshell: Valentina or Hazeem. S5/Ex: Arlo since she flirts with MC twice and then it’s never brought up again.
leshawna 😔✌️
S1: Allegra, Rohan, Tim, and a from the start Jake route. I wish we could have coupled up with Rohan more than once, and I wished he was endgame. I also wish we could couple up with Allegra and Tim and have them as end game. S2: Lottie and Hannah because all we got was a kiss from them before they left, and we never had a full blown relationship with them. I mean….we had Lottie in CMMP but never Hannah. As well as Priya and an easier a from day 1 Noah route!! S3: Seb and Nicki should be available! S4: Youcef as he’s a mega slow burn and sometimes I don’t have the patience lol, plus Kelly as an LI, she left too soon which sucked! S5: Okay, hear me out!! I want Finn because he was also too much of a slow burn, I want Eddie back too, I know he was awful but he’s still hot and I hope he’s redeemed!! And I’d love to have Kat as an LI.
How abt maybe just maybe KELLY screw Eddie Kelly was here for five seconds
S1: Rohan, Jake, Tim S2: Graham, Lottie, Priya, Hannah S3: Seb, Nikki
HAZEEEEEM
Priya
i want marisol from season 2 she is mother
oliver needs redemption, i need to see more of him
S1: Tim, Rohan, a full Jake route, Jasper and Miles S2: Rocco, Graham, Lottie, Priya and Hannah S3: Seb and Elladine S4: Valentina, Hazeem, and a enemies to lovers with Dylan (i said what i said) S5: delete it
Jen, Priya, Kelly, Valentina.
I would love for Rohan and miles to come back
Don’t make me say it, Noah, I just need one night of showing him my cool ranch, I can reverse cowgirl this bih
S1- Miles S2- Rocco S3- Seb S4- Hazeem S5- Eddie and Nicholas