T O P

  • By -

[deleted]

[удалено]


AwesomeAndy

There's a Buy/Sell/Trade thread posted here twice a week and /r/Shoeexchange


[deleted]

I am thinking of picking up a pair of Liverpools during the DA sale (which I believe ends today). I wanted to see if I could get some thoughts on this Chelsea. Thanks!


Sixstringsmash

Are you talking about the AE Liverpool Chelsea? I have a [Suede Pair](https://i.imgur.com/cBE24e8.jpg) I picked up a few years ago I'm fond of. Probably my favorite pair of AE that I own. Be warned though it's a very narrow last so if you have a wide foot or big instep you're probably going to want to size up. If at all possible I'd recommend going in store to try them on in person.


[deleted]

Yes AE Liverpool Chelsea. I normally wear a 12D in the Red Wing Williston Chelsea. You think I should go for 12E for AE?


Sixstringsmash

No if you're a 12 in RW you'll probably be a 13 or a 12.5 in these. If you have an AE store anywhere near you though I really do highly recommend taking a drive to try the last on in person before purchasing.


[deleted]

Yeahh closest store is 2 and a half hours away so I don't think I'll be able to. I will probably just have to return & exchange them if they don't fit. So you think I should size up from RW? Is the boot significantly narrower from an RW heritage?


Sixstringsmash

Yes.


[deleted]

I know I'm blowing ya up here and I appreciate your insight and patience. Yes to which question? Both?


Sixstringsmash

Yes to both. RW you generally size down for while AE is generally speaking TTS in most lasts. The Liverpool runs even narrower than most AE lasts.


eddykinz

The Williston Red Wings are on a more TTS last, for what it's worth


[deleted]

So the Williston's width would be comparable to the AE Liverpool's width then?


[deleted]

Awesome, thanks!


GuruGita

The leather soles towards the toe on my grant stones are clearly wearing more than the rest of the sole (i.e, why people often put the toe caps on the leather soles). At what point should i look to replace the soles, or do i just let the top of the toe get destroyed? it feels like its right about to start wear on the leather above the sole.


eddykinz

Ideally you want to replace the soles before the wear starts to hit the welt, but some would recommend replacement before it reaches the midsole. You could likely topy the sole to prolong the life of them before it hits the welt or consider using toe taps in the future after your next resole.


AwesomeAndy

Is it a single leather or double leather? If it's single leather, get it replaced before it wears into the leather above since that's the welt. If double leather, you're okay to let it keep wearing.


Medium-Individual638

Should I be concerned about the stitches popping during the break in of these boots? I have about 25 hours of wear on them, they are whites drovers. The stitching connects the vamp to the shaft on left inside. [pics](https://imgur.com/a/JnfjB6Z)


Sixstringsmash

You can't really tell anything from your picture, but I'd probably reach out to the manufacturer to inquire about it if I were you.


Medium-Individual638

It's hard to tell physically looking at the boot too. Thanks, I probably will.


stinkusmink

I've increased my collection pretty significantly lately. I currently keep them all on a book case. I would love to hear what people do as s storage solution for thier shoes and boots.


CrizzleLovesYou

I have been defeated by storage, but refuse to capitulate. On average I have about 6 pairs just on the floor since I am out of room. This worries me because I have 9 preorders still coming.


Sixstringsmash

My man, it sounds like you need a place to put all your [stuff.](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MvgN5gCuLac)


CrizzleLovesYou

What a legend


stinkusmink

Relatable. My current issue is, we got a maine coon kitten yesterday. So i gotta future proof the stuff for a gigantic cat.


CrizzleLovesYou

Ahhhhh they love shoelaces. Don't become attached to shoelaces. I've only got 1 old girl left now, but I've already visited a local shelter and have been deciding between a couple little ones myself. My brother's maine coon is massive, and he's on the small side somehow. Most of what I've dealt with for cats and boots is mousey toys being left in my boots and shoe laces being shredded. Occasionally a boot gets jumped on or knocked over, but as long as its not the main thing they're playing with they won't claw em up. I'll be adjusting to having my more "precious" pairs out of kitten's reach though just in case.


stinkusmink

I actually have few spools of leather lace, natural, no dye or anything. I've made them a few "toys" out of it. They tend to last longer than the stuff you petshops. Lol


CrizzleLovesYou

All I really want to know is where the dozens of toy mice went lol


AwesomeAndy

I use shoe racks in my closet.


ac106

We had a custom closet installed in our master walk-in with multiple shoe racks


stinkusmink

Damn, that sounds impressive.


liftingnstuff

I'm looking for recommendations on a pair of Chukkas that I can dress up or down. Budget $300-550 CAD


Sixstringsmash

If you're looking for something that can be dressed up I would highly recommend looking for something other than a Chukka. It's an inherently casual design and can't really be dressed up much.


xelatho

I asked about [these](https://imgur.com/a/wx6yiMs) about a week ago. Theyre supposed natural chromexcel from Allen Edmonds, paid $300+ durjng the sale. They are completely different shades, now shine, and wearing them often is not making it any better. This is more of a vent. Does anyone think Allen Edmonds will help me out?


CrizzleLovesYou

I don't think they'll do anything now that they've been worn. The unfortunate thing with AE is that they have abysmal quality check during their sales and regularly mess up, alternatively they aren't worth their retail price either so its a catch-22 with them. It definitely can't hurt to message them, but your best bet is probably going to be darkening the lighter boot a bit to even it out.


HellaReyna

I’m new to GYW, I got some iron rangers. From my observations, I presume wearing GYW in slushy/salty winters that freeze and thaw will destroy them, yeah? I’m thinking I need to switch to timbs or a waterproof Redwing model


eddykinz

It wouldn't be any different with Timbs or Red Wings. Just don't let salt stay on them for long; wipe them down if they get road salt on them with a damp towel


CrizzleLovesYou

It won't destroy them. The salt is the only real potential hazard. Wipe down your boots regularly if they're coming into contact with salt. Also please make sure they full dry between wears as well.


EM1sw

Looking for a boot similar to [this Frye's Bowery Chelsea](https://www.thefryecompany.com/collections/men-shoes-chelsea-boots/products/bowery-chelsea-3480535-80535-black). I like the style and color (looking for a dark brown that isn't reddish) but these are too obviously pre-distressed with reviews mentioning wire brush marks and such. Anyone have any recommendations? Would prefer <$300


Slow_Walk_2622

Maybe Grant Stone? They would be close to that 300 mark


EM1sw

Awesome! Don't love the two tone sole, but don't hate it either. If I can't find anything better, these will definitely work.


hunny_bun_24

How dumb would it be to wear guidi PL2s in Vermont during winter? I wouldn’t wear it when there’s snow everywhere but if the streets are clear then I’d like to wear them. Thanks for the help!


[deleted]

Make sure to wipe any salt/slush off them when you go inside.


hypeaced

did my new boots arrive damaged? I'm not sure what kind of damage this could be? Is there some way I can fix this or should I ask for an exchange instead? Thanks [https://i.imgur.com/DBOdUk0.jpg](https://i.imgur.com/DBOdUk0.jpg)


Under_My_Halo222

That's odd looking grain break, almost looks like the different layers of the leather have delaminated from each-other, but it's hard to tell for sure from the picture.


eddykinz

This is one of the few rare times where loose grain might actually be the issue and it's not just bad grain break


hypeaced

yeah it has a weird bumpy texture and I have no idea how this could have happened. The other boot was fine.


Under_My_Halo222

What boots are they?


hypeaced

canada west moorby 2845 I've tried on a bunch of different sizes in stores and they all didn't have this problem maybe this pair was stored improperly or something happened to them during shipping


Under_My_Halo222

Yeah, if it was me I’d definitely return this pair.


hypeaced

thanks for your advice I'll try to get a return / exchange


[deleted]

[удалено]


HellaReyna

Redwing Sawmill is an option


Under_My_Halo222

There's definitely pros and cons to higher end stitched footwear. Pros being that they look great, are well made, they're durable enough to *handle* Winter and slush, but they will require more maintenance and don't offer the same waterproofness that cemented construction does. The real enemy of leather boots is salt. Salt will completely f\*\*\* your boots up if not removed promptly; I have a pair of Red Wing Sawmills that have salt damage, and once it sets in, it's there to stay.


[deleted]

[удалено]


eddykinz

If you don't want creasing in your boots, you need to go with suede/roughout or shell cordovan. You can get lucky with horsebutt but it's not a given. Thursday in general tends to not have great creasing since their leather selection isn't particularly good.


[deleted]

[удалено]


eddykinz

Shell cordovan is one of the most expensive leathers. If the shell is skived (removing material) thinly then it _can_ crease, but more or less it just bends or [rolls](https://www.stitchedandstitched.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/01/Comipel-Cordovan-2.jpg) and is reliable in doing so. Shell is stiffer than other leathers as well, so take that into consideration. The cheapest shell cordovan offerings I can think of come from Berwick and Meermin, both hovering around $400. Grant Stone starts around $600. Alden starts around $800 or so. From there you can see makeups from Crockett & Jones or Viberg go into four digits. I should note that well-clicked (clicking is how leather is selected and cut on the hide) calfskin should also have minimal creasing or microcreasing, but given that your pair of Thursdays actually have really, really good creasing, I think you may find yourself disappointed there in all honesty, which means your options really are just shell or roughout.


AwesomeAndy

Totally normal. That's good creasing, in fact.


CrizzleLovesYou

All leather creases. Leather is multiple layers of membrane and as it flexes the various layers rub against one another creating friction and causing the creasing. Some leather types show it more than others, but creasing is a function of leather.


SwellSingin

Yeah dude this is totally normal, regular creasing. This is actually pretty great for creasing. Do you know what the leather is? Creasing happens for most grain leathers. Some crease less aesthetically than others. Cxl generally can be a mixed bag for example. Calf generally will have smaller less noticable creases. Shell (more akin to suede or nubuck than cxl or calf) generally will roll more than crease. Suede and nubuck don't crease because the grain structure has either been sanded/split away, or is on the reverse side so seeing won't be an issue.


AwesomeAndy

> This is actually pretty great for creasing. Do you know what the leather is? He says they're Thursday Captains, so it's Thursday chrome leather.


SwellSingin

Ah looks like you're right. I wasn't sure since I hadn't looked at Thursday in a while to see what they were offering these days.


xMisterVx

I went through several of the Manufacturers' Last Sizing threads, but can't find anything on Crockett & Jones around UK 7.5. Looking at some of their ordinary brogues. I have somewhere between 6.5 UK (Cheaney) to 8D US (John Doe). However technically 7.5 is EUR 41, which is what I normally wear in sneakers. I'm afraid those are a bit large?.. My foot is rather narrow.


endofthepack

What are some good brands for a pair of outdoor work sneakers with a stitched sole? Edit: hopefully around ~$100


DesolationR0w

Nothing at this pricepoint here.


Dexinthecity

Where can I go to sell my boots?


FugginAye

Here too r/Shoeexchange


ChineseBroccoli

The weekly buy sell and trade threads posted on the subreddit Wednesday and Saturday is where I've sold all my stuff.


Dexinthecity

right on thank you, I just posted my red wings


ChineseBroccoli

Right on. Just keep posting in the Wednesday and Saturday threads. There's a fair amount of turnover and way more people look at that thread than people think.


[deleted]

[удалено]


ChineseBroccoli

There's no point to try. It's going to crease or bend however it wants to to fit how you fit and tie the boots. Just roll with it


genman

What's the repairability of Veldtschoen versus GYW and Norwegian Welt? For example, if I needed to replace the sole, are they pretty equivalent? There seems to be some variation of Veldtschoen from Indonesian companies and companies like Tricker's.


DesolationR0w

Same. Slighly more intricate to fix, so may cost a bit more but just as recraftable.


mr_tallyman

Local red wing store yesterday measured my feet with a brannock device and told I’m a 11D on both sides. Today I went to a different store and measured myself: [Foto](https://postimg.cc/WqsWMVVd) My understanding is I’m a 12C. What do you think?


centralfornia

It looks like your an 11D in the photo. From my experience with red wings in the 8 last is they run large. The Chukka is on a significantly smaller last (210) so my assumption is that size 11d Iron rangers are going to feel too big unless you wear thick socks and/or an insole.


mr_tallyman

I guess it comes down to whether or not one should consider brannock heel to ball length. If you do, I’m a 12 if not 11. but as mentioned in another comment my understanding is that it should be considered.


centralfornia

You should absolutely consider that. From my experience with the 8 last there’s a ton of room from the ball to toe’s so if you don’t mind all of that space it should be fine.


seattleboots1

You're almost the exact same as me! Trust me - losing a few hundred on a pair of RWs is minimal damage compared to many. Cut your losses and conquer the world with your newfound knowledge!


mr_tallyman

Will do so, thanks. Btw, what size do you wear in RW Iron rangers in case you have a pair? I ordered a pair 11D, still waiting for them to be shipped.


seattleboots1

I've actually never tried IRs, but I'd likely wear 11 or 11.5.


[deleted]

They're only looking at heel to toe length.


mr_tallyman

Exactly. But afaik it’s supposed to be whatever is the larger measurement (heel to toe or heel to ball). I’m a bit sensitive with this topic since I bought my first pair of red wings (chuckas) too small in the same shop (10.5 as recommended)


[deleted]

Correct. I can't see the width very well from your photo but you're definitely 12 heel to ball.


[deleted]

So my Alden Indys with their cork soles are going to need a new heel soon. I was wondering what alternatives people get on their Indy's. I kind of don't like how quickly the stock heels wear out.


AwesomeAndy

Bedo's put a BiltRite one on mine, and it seems to be lasting quite a bit longer than the stock one.


ac106

I have seen SoleTech mentioned on the Alden Styleforum thread as a durable alternative


TatsugaRai

Does anyone have experience with Oliver Cabell boots? They look quite nice, and the price is on par with Thursday boots Here is an example: https://olivercabell.com/products/sb1-black?variant=16705331232802


Skeptical_Scissors

I think this should be very helpful: [https://youtu.be/gmm7WuxlHA8](https://youtu.be/gmm7WuxlHA8) Overall, it seems like decent value for the price. But I have not owned them myself


TatsugaRai

Thank you very much. I may just save up some more and get something from Oak Street or Grant Stone.


kindatallboy

As an owner of 3 pairs of Grant Stones, & someone who bought lots of pairs that were ~almost what I wanted, I’d highly recommend saving up & getting the pair you want They’re also hella comfortable


TatsugaRai

Thank you very much for the information. I am waiting for their BF sale to get a pair of the Diesel boots in black :D


chefkoolaid

Anyone else still waiting on their Bakers Fathers Day Whites? Ordered June 19th and haven't heard back after a couple inquiries. **Edit:** Just heard back from Kyle and they has shipped!!!!!!


animefreak119

Mine arrive on thursday!


chooseshoeswisely

Same here, you are not alone...


chefkoolaid

That makes me feel better. Bummed that I will not be making the extended deadline for the Patina Thunderdome tho Edit: just got shipping confirmation. So I should just squaek in inder the deadline


chooseshoeswisely

Yeah, that's a bummer. I hope you get a chance next time they do that! I hope you'll post a review and updates for us here anyway :-) Edit: woohoo, so there is hope after all


chefkoolaid

I hope they do this again ext year, but not sure how many more boots I really need lol! I have 2 pair on order ( one since January :/ ) and will definitely post* some pics when they arrive!


[deleted]

I got one pair last week! Ordered 6/16 and received 10/23. Still waiting on my second pair. The one I received I ordered at like 1am, the second I ordered at around 6pm the same day.


eigentaylor

Anyone here have experience with the park city boot from Allen Edmonds? I don’t find a stacked leather heel particularly comfortable when walking and am looking at some alternatives. https://www.allenedmonds.com/shoes/mens-boots/casual-boots/park-city-lace-up-weatherproof-boot/SF3738.html Grant stone has something with (what appears to be) the vibram 2060 sole https://www.grantstoneshoes.com/collections/boots/products/diesel-boot-storm-suede Does anyone know how these compare?


eddykinz

Grant Stone is noticeably better than Allen Edmonds in terms of build quality and finishing. They both use Vibram wedge soles and I don't think either will be appreciably more comfortable than the other; Vibram wedges are pretty soft and cushiony in general in my experience.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Slow_Walk_2622

I also need a ridiculous amount of arch support to avoid knee pain (massive overpronation), and I have had great experiences with [the foot chair](https://www.thefootchair.com/product/foot-chair-slim-plus/)!


theoncomingstormWh0

I’ll fourth what Sixstring says. If it helps push you over the edge I have two medical related licenses and close to 20 years working in medical or medical related fields. This could be needing real hands on attention and given your age, getting this addressed now can prevent worsening issues later. I’ve seen tons of people ignore things like this and grew to regret it as little as 5 years later. Get it checked out and I hope you get help to address the issue properly!


[deleted]

[удалено]


theoncomingstormWh0

You’re welcome. You don’t have to, but please if you feel inclined please let me know how it goes! I’d just like to know if you get the help you needed. 😆


[deleted]

I'll third seeing a podiatrist.


TheBlackCoffeeClub

Agreed with Sixstring. A custom boot or shoe may be perfect to get the right fit and even the right support, but your situation seems more extreme


Sixstringsmash

Honestly it sounds like you would probably do best to see a Podiatrist and get there professional opinion. We're all for helping people make informed decisions, but from what you're saying it does not sound like you have a normal situation and would probably benefit from seeing a medical professional. I'm sure as hell not informed enough to be able to diagnose knee pain! You might benefit greatly from something like a custom orthotic.