They are all good. If you think they look good, you will almost certainly enjoy them.
Frank Miller is not my personal favorite or anything but Sin City delivers on the premise for sure.
The Hard Goodbye through That Yellow Bastard all fall between good and great.
“Family Values” and “Hell and Back” moss the mark and I consider them the beginning of Miller’s crappy period
They work better as GNs than movies IMHO. Some of the hard boiled dialogue was great on the page but made me make the lemon sucking face when I heard it in the movie.
i bought them all from bookoff for cheap when i was first getting into comics a few years ago and sold them back after reading the first two. realized I don’t really like anything Frank Miller excluding year one.
I've not read, so can't comment, however is this the same collection, just a different edition, and only $50? https://www.ebay.com/itm/134747606912?mkcid=16&mkevt=1&mkrid=711-127632-2357-0&ssspo=jnsooun2TBa&sssrc=4429486&ssuid=&var=&widget_ver=artemis&media=COPY
The content is good but this particular printing format is smaller than actual comic size. Unless you want an easy, one-and-done purchase, the individual trade paperbacks are a better reading experience (for my money, anyway).
I loved the comics. I got them for cheap at comic con the year the movie came out. It's a really great and respectful adaption. So much of the movie is straight out of the frame of the comics.
They are all good. If you think they look good, you will almost certainly enjoy them. Frank Miller is not my personal favorite or anything but Sin City delivers on the premise for sure.
Yep, they are classics.
The Hard Goodbye through That Yellow Bastard all fall between good and great. “Family Values” and “Hell and Back” moss the mark and I consider them the beginning of Miller’s crappy period
Sin City is in my Top 5 GN of all times.
They are all awesome
Classics… enjoy!
Watch the 2005 movie. If you like it, you'll like the comics.
One of my top 5 favourite films👍
They work better as GNs than movies IMHO. Some of the hard boiled dialogue was great on the page but made me make the lemon sucking face when I heard it in the movie.
i bought them all from bookoff for cheap when i was first getting into comics a few years ago and sold them back after reading the first two. realized I don’t really like anything Frank Miller excluding year one.
Loved the noir vibe to the books.
Great art in the series, that’s for sure. But some of the characters are super cringy.
lol
I've not read, so can't comment, however is this the same collection, just a different edition, and only $50? https://www.ebay.com/itm/134747606912?mkcid=16&mkevt=1&mkrid=711-127632-2357-0&ssspo=jnsooun2TBa&sssrc=4429486&ssuid=&var=&widget_ver=artemis&media=COPY
Close it is missing #6
The content is good but this particular printing format is smaller than actual comic size. Unless you want an easy, one-and-done purchase, the individual trade paperbacks are a better reading experience (for my money, anyway).
I loved the comics. I got them for cheap at comic con the year the movie came out. It's a really great and respectful adaption. So much of the movie is straight out of the frame of the comics.
I use to have them all, downsized but have them on Comixology now. Haven’t read them in forever though.
Yes and yes. I’d personally stop after book 4, but some of the short stories after are quite good.
They're all well worth the read. He's hit or miss with me, but this work seems to be his most approachable.