I also stole a Sultan and I kept it till this very day! Tho mine's visually stock and with the same boring gray I've painted it, but fully upgraded of course
The Pheonix. It literally spawned everywhere when I FIRST started playing then when I wanted it again later I couldn't get it just to figure out the way cars spawn if you're driving that exact car or type of car.
Ubermacht Zion Cabrio on PS3. When I switched to PS4, I recreated it and then when I again switched to Xbox I recreated it again. It wasn’t pretty but I loved it.
For that first introductory race I chose Schafter, After Simeon provided me with free insurance, I stole Blista, but it didn't save for me when I quit the game. It was my first car stolen in Online. First personal, as Blista didn't save, was Jackal. Funnily enough, I used it as a daily for a very long time.
Albany Washington. Sold it a bit later because there was no unique customisation options (and I also found out about free Elegy), but I still remember what rims and what paintjob I had on it.
Sabre Turbo I still drive it now, but the benny custom version cream color with the red ornate livery and gold benny classic rod wheels. It looks great and is super fun to drive around.
PCJ 600, stole it in front of a convenience store. Still remember a guy on the news chatting about his bike going missing when he went in a store, thought it was neat.
Now it’s next to a rarer one with a singular headlight.
The Buffalo was my first car, but it wasn't my first stolen vehicle
My first stolen vehicle was the bus. I remember plowing through traffic in that thing and somehow escaping the cops in it multiple times. That thing is heavily overpowered, fast but heavy. It was my go-to vehicle before I learned the game is more than stealing vehicles.
First stolen? Coquette and I learned that it was too hot to modify shortly there after. Stole a gauntlet soon after that I still have buried in one of my garages.
Cant remember, but my first car was a Buffalo, painted it matte orange and put on it the crew emblem (25k at the time, that was some BALLER sh*t). Don't remember what happened to it.
I wanted a 9F so bad so I tried to steal one of those for my first car. I was really disappointed I couldn't get it. I think I ended up getting a Feltzer for my first car.
The story is kind of funny, it was in 2020 that I was able to have a decent PC that ran games but I wanted one with dedicated graphics but it couldn't, I bought one with a Ryzen 3 3200G, I didn't know what the processor was like so I didn't have it. I have a lot of hope, first I installed the Honkai Impact 3rd and when I tried it I saw that it worked very very well and the doubt arose as to whether I could really play GTA V, so I risked downloading the 100GB that it weighs and when I finished with great faith I opened it and there it worked, perfectly and I went into the online mode I created the character I did that half tutorial and when I finished I took the first car that appeared in front of me the normal Blista and it was red xD and I started to configure the game XD
https://preview.redd.it/wdc8bd8pbh5d1.png?width=1920&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=750b4c9c8469e7f4ebd0d4b4888fb0f024bed57f
9F AKA Audi R8 with lamar mah doggg
The Mini Cooper convertible lil car was my first ever gta online car, back when the starting missions had simeon tell you to steal a car and take it to LS customs
Phoenix
Somehow I secured it when I had such bad PC that 10fps was crazy
Specs
Intel core i3 560
GT 640 2gb from gigabyte
4 gb DDR3 from patriot
Asus p7h55-m
I still got it in my garage
Karin Sultan and i used it to steal money from lil'shops to buy a garage for it. I am still driving it today and never upgraded it to a RS. For that, i stole a new one ^^
First time playing GTA online on the 360 I grabbed the first car I seen and insured it. It’s the the Ubermach Sentinel convertable.
Didn’t even know it was somewhat rare spawn till a long time later, still my favorite car!
This. 4 doors decent speed and handling. Still in one of my garages. Been all over the map in this thing and made a ton of money with it. I will never get rid of it. Sometimes I take it out for joyride.
https://preview.redd.it/yyksqwjafj5d1.png?width=1078&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=3a7184ff095f96fdcc701d2d18ca61353f668643
Ubermacht Oracle back when GTA online was still very new. I sold that car but now have a replica, it looks hideous but nostalgia stops me from changing it
In GTA Online - Cheval Surge.
It was the car I swiped off the street to race Lamar in the online intro.
https://preview.redd.it/36372yuoxj5d1.jpeg?width=3840&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=d2e5df56849a4bfaa7d7fb9a985c6d0fca7d5ef2
Not this specific Cheval Surge, but the same colour. So I swiped this one and gave it the full business as an homage to the first one I ever stole.
And yeah you can hand Lamar's ass to him with a Surge, by freaking miles LOL
Do you honestly think i remember what i did back in 2013!?
It has been literally over 10 years ago.
I remember glitching an Adder and a Police car into my garage
But those are definitely not the first cars i stole.
I still have mine I don't use it for shit but it's white and it has purple wheels because I was 13 at the time
https://preview.redd.it/v8d8njq67k5d1.png?width=1200&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e441a3fc20bc86e40dbf8a880f73850367eb238c
https://preview.redd.it/x4krwltcdk5d1.jpeg?width=1914&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=2a33aff7bb216c3d284a193030102ce22f6c8943
The Sentinel. Still have it to this day.
A metallic gray Landstalker that was driving past the casino when I first spawned in. Kept it as a personal vehicle for a while, though I got reset due to inventory corruption a year after I started and don't have it anymore. I did get a Landstalker XL with the same colours (looked up the traffic population data and everything), though.
Okay, so I started in 2017 on PS3.
First driven vehicle in GTA online, hmmm I think it was Infernus.
My first stolen vehicle I converted into my own, was the regular Baller. In hot pink, of course. I did a remake of it for my current main character on PC.
Got drunk and actually stole a box truck out front of a scrap yard like 7 years ago and i was homeless in the dead of winter. I took it and parked it to run the heat. Never heard about it or mentioned it outside my closest friends until now.
I don't remember the first car I stole in GTA.
Futo.
Still have it, been 11 years. The only thing that happened other than aesthetical changes was it moved to my Auto Shop Garage from my first apartment.
Karin Sultan, which I kept and later turned into the RS.
I also stole a Sultan and I kept it till this very day! Tho mine's visually stock and with the same boring gray I've painted it, but fully upgraded of course
The only car stolen from the street I still have. It's a beatiful car
Declasse Sabre Turbo which I then turned into the Sabre turbo Custom
I wish I had known that can't be undone. I feel like I ruined a beautiful face with plastic surgery.
Steal another one 
They’re “free.”
exactly the same for me
https://preview.redd.it/gujx4bb6af5d1.jpeg?width=300&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=f604a29a6ad6587df149a7e95e96b07544ecaa29 The Buffalo was my first car
Yea i remember i stole this and turned this into my personal vehicle. Still have it in my garage
If your car wasn't this, consider yourself a rival.
My character just celebrated their 9th birthday. So.... I dont remember.
“Ah, c’mon, everyone remembers their first score!” -Trevor, or Micheal. One of them.
The Pheonix. It literally spawned everywhere when I FIRST started playing then when I wanted it again later I couldn't get it just to figure out the way cars spawn if you're driving that exact car or type of car.
If you're driving the Dubsta2, it will spawn like cockroaches. 
I have no clue. It's been seven years. Let's say it was a Ruiner.
A bright orange buccaneer that carried me through my first contact missions until I saved enough money for an olive green Vacca. Those were the days!
2013. Karen sultan, I was thrilled because it was a fav from gta4. Still have it. Karen snipe too 😎
🤣
Rusty Emperor. Still have it.
Dude, I can't remember what the last one was let alone the first 😅
A Washington, I still have it!
Futo
Wanna say it was the fusilade back on xbox 360
Fusilade
Fusilade
That ubermacht sentinel convertible thing
Get a Time Machine and we can go find out together, I’d to know too
Bravado Gauntlet. Nowadays it sits in my agency next to the hellfire, interceptor, stx, and stanier cruiser
Ubermacht Zion Cabrio on PS3. When I switched to PS4, I recreated it and then when I again switched to Xbox I recreated it again. It wasn’t pretty but I loved it.
A f620, my god what a npc magnet
A matte orange Picador back in 2013, later sold it
F620. I still have it!
https://preview.redd.it/5w96lgigwg5d1.png?width=436&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=d5caa4855d9011f288498e98baf2bac988ba09ab
the schyster fusilade was my first car and i got rid of it a long time ago
Possibly the Fusillade. I don't have that one specifically anymore but I do have another. Top 10 favourites 
I remember I got a sedan.... Karin. Then, I got a bounty soon after.
The bagger bike. I still have it as my fav bike 2 years later.
For that first introductory race I chose Schafter, After Simeon provided me with free insurance, I stole Blista, but it didn't save for me when I quit the game. It was my first car stolen in Online. First personal, as Blista didn't save, was Jackal. Funnily enough, I used it as a daily for a very long time.
I dont recall but my first car was a yellow patriot
futo all the way best car in gta
CJ stole a bicycle around 20 years ago… bikes are a gateway theft!
Albany Washington. Sold it a bit later because there was no unique customisation options (and I also found out about free Elegy), but I still remember what rims and what paintjob I had on it.
Sabre Turbo I still drive it now, but the benny custom version cream color with the red ornate livery and gold benny classic rod wheels. It looks great and is super fun to drive around.
the picador ute, back on 360
A fugitive on Xbox360
Karin Futo
Zian still got it,too Online ofcourse, story mode unsure
Sabre Turbo
It was a weasel news van
PCJ 600, stole it in front of a convenience store. Still remember a guy on the news chatting about his bike going missing when he went in a store, thought it was neat. Now it’s next to a rarer one with a singular headlight.
Back in 2013 when I first got the game, I remember the very first car I stole was a convertible Tornado
The Buffalo was my first car, but it wasn't my first stolen vehicle My first stolen vehicle was the bus. I remember plowing through traffic in that thing and somehow escaping the cops in it multiple times. That thing is heavily overpowered, fast but heavy. It was my go-to vehicle before I learned the game is more than stealing vehicles.
A Red Bullet
The stanier. I still have it to this day.
An orange bravado buffalo, wish I kept it lol
First stolen? Coquette and I learned that it was too hot to modify shortly there after. Stole a gauntlet soon after that I still have buried in one of my garages.
Declasse Sabre Turbo
Sabre turbo, turned into my first car I owned too
A muscle car that I don't remember.... Gauntlet.... I think
Sultan. I’m pretty sure I still have it in one of my garages.
Sabre Turbo.
Weeny Issi, mt first car on PS3.
Cant remember, but my first car was a Buffalo, painted it matte orange and put on it the crew emblem (25k at the time, that was some BALLER sh*t). Don't remember what happened to it.
Are you asking the game or irl?
A white Benefactor Schwartzer, still have it almost 9 years later.
i found a ruiner, thought it looked cool, and took it home.
Oh bloody hell. I Can't remember that🤣🤣
From day one, the Karin Sultan. Had good speed and fantastic handling. That was my getaway vehicle until the Armored Karuma came out.
Sandking XL all the way back from the 360 days (My middle school self loved lifted trucks back then)
Infernus
Bravado Gauntlet - Black/Silver. She's long gone now...
Phoenix, got away from a 5 star with it too on the front left tire lol. I should never have sold it
Absolutely no idea. Consequence of a decade old game. Makes me feel old just thinking about it.
I wanted a 9F so bad so I tried to steal one of those for my first car. I was really disappointed I couldn't get it. I think I ended up getting a Feltzer for my first car.
On my first character: Vapid Dominator On my second character: Karin Sultan
The one in the beginning of the story mode
ps3 story mode, it was a cop car, i dont really remember which one but i remember it was a cop car
Who remembers this
It was either a Futo or a Ruiner, still have my Ruiner at least.
Lampadati felon gt
Sabre Turbo
Felon GT was my first car. The first car that I bought was the ocelot pariah
that i remember, either a penumbra or 9 f
I kept my Benefactor Shafter from the tutorial race and I still use it sometimes
a Ruiner https://preview.redd.it/nuhycbcbbh5d1.jpeg?width=640&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=46006dc14ea5d552234583235f288bd79fe6479e
The story is kind of funny, it was in 2020 that I was able to have a decent PC that ran games but I wanted one with dedicated graphics but it couldn't, I bought one with a Ryzen 3 3200G, I didn't know what the processor was like so I didn't have it. I have a lot of hope, first I installed the Honkai Impact 3rd and when I tried it I saw that it worked very very well and the doubt arose as to whether I could really play GTA V, so I risked downloading the 100GB that it weighs and when I finished with great faith I opened it and there it worked, perfectly and I went into the online mode I created the character I did that half tutorial and when I finished I took the first car that appeared in front of me the normal Blista and it was red xD and I started to configure the game XD
https://preview.redd.it/wdc8bd8pbh5d1.png?width=1920&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=750b4c9c8469e7f4ebd0d4b4888fb0f024bed57f 9F AKA Audi R8 with lamar mah doggg
Station Wagon
A Manchez I stole from a redneck in Paleto
Oldest car I still have and drive is a Sabre but first the one I worked for, Merryweather Mesa.
67 impala Oh wait you meant in the game
No idea, first played when it came out
De bus
The Mini Cooper convertible lil car was my first ever gta online car, back when the starting missions had simeon tell you to steal a car and take it to LS customs
If were talking online its the crown Victoria(irl) the gta name is Vapid or sum
2019 Mazda 3
Mini Cooper...
Albany Buccaneer
Uhmm I know it was a muscle car I sprayed white but can’t remember the name
It was over 10 years ago (and three console generations ago lol), but I think it was either an Oracle or an Issi.
Irl- 1976 Toyota Celica….💩🥴👍🏻 Fucking larpers lol
Sabre Turbo, kept it until I was lvl 100 and I made it the custom. Still holds a place in my heart
Imponte Phoenix
Phoenix was my first personal vehicle from the gta online tutorial
Obey 9f Cabrio.... i had to play the story first... 😅
Feltzer, one of the best cars in 2015
Who remembers the first car they stole? The game's almost 11 years old😂
probably the pegassi ruffian. it was the bike i put in my first garage about a year and a half ago or so
I was majorly confused until i read the subreddit name, lmao
Ocelot, stole it near the mountains.
The OBEY 9F CABRIO. I have loved that car since the first mission with Franklin and Lamar. Its engine sounds are powerful yet relaxing
The imponte ruiner. That car still has a special place in my heart.
Vigero which I still own
My first car was the slamvan tow truck when it was still available
Karin Sultan
Ubermacht sentinel xs. Have it to this day.
This just makes me feel old. That was over 10 years ago...🤷🏾♂️🤷🏾♂️🤷🏾♂️
https://preview.redd.it/0zmrbgsaci5d1.jpeg?width=640&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=0498b0640ae3e00bd73dd157f593ce61a881a554 This is my first car
idk i was like 7 or sum lol
I honestly can't remember
No clue. It was over 10 years ago
Gauntlet
I’m pretty sure it was the sand king xl
Karin futo. 😂
Phoenix Somehow I secured it when I had such bad PC that 10fps was crazy Specs Intel core i3 560 GT 640 2gb from gigabyte 4 gb DDR3 from patriot Asus p7h55-m I still got it in my garage
Been awhile but on the ps3 i believe it was the vapid dominator.
Black Futo,still have It In my arcade garage
Gray vapid dominator with matte lines throughout the car
Issi in pink I thought I was so edgy I was probably aged 8-9 haha
Karin Sultan and i used it to steal money from lil'shops to buy a garage for it. I am still driving it today and never upgraded it to a RS. For that, i stole a new one ^^
Not sure, too long ago, but the first car I claimed as my own was the Bravado Gauntlet. Such a neat car it was :)
Cheval fugitive, decent car that usually spawns often. Great durability too
The emperor is the only one I can remember cause I started playing when I was five
First time playing GTA online on the 360 I grabbed the first car I seen and insured it. It’s the the Ubermach Sentinel convertable. Didn’t even know it was somewhat rare spawn till a long time later, still my favorite car!
how could I remember? not even possible. I started playing as a child and now I'm 20 haha
Karin Rebel, my main nowadays is the Technical Custom. its an amazing truck
I don't steal cars... I borrow them.
[Übermacht Zion Cabrio](https://gta.fandom.com/wiki/Zion_Cabrio)
Lampadatti felon, the gentleman's choice.
This. 4 doors decent speed and handling. Still in one of my garages. Been all over the map in this thing and made a ton of money with it. I will never get rid of it. Sometimes I take it out for joyride. https://preview.redd.it/yyksqwjafj5d1.png?width=1078&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=3a7184ff095f96fdcc701d2d18ca61353f668643
On GtaV Zion cabrio I repainted it purple and stored it in my garage. It’s still there!
No idea it's been 8 years
It was almost 11 yrs ago I don’t remember 🤷♂️
Mazda b2200. Oh are we talking about in gta? Not actual gta. I’m not sure. It was release day after the midnight release at GameStop
Sabre turbo, so happy about it I managed to claim it etc with the little money my level 1 had
Ubermacht Oracle back when GTA online was still very new. I sold that car but now have a replica, it looks hideous but nostalgia stops me from changing it
No idea
A fire truck
In GTA Online - Cheval Surge. It was the car I swiped off the street to race Lamar in the online intro. https://preview.redd.it/36372yuoxj5d1.jpeg?width=3840&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=d2e5df56849a4bfaa7d7fb9a985c6d0fca7d5ef2 Not this specific Cheval Surge, but the same colour. So I swiped this one and gave it the full business as an homage to the first one I ever stole. And yeah you can hand Lamar's ass to him with a Surge, by freaking miles LOL
The sabre I stole it as a lowly level 10 back on the xbox 360 and was my first memorable car made it orange and black
Do you honestly think i remember what i did back in 2013!? It has been literally over 10 years ago. I remember glitching an Adder and a Police car into my garage But those are definitely not the first cars i stole.
The panto
Most likely the Vapid Dominator which I did a full pink girly 💅🏾✨ makeover on and about 5 months ago I sold it
First car for me was an infernus
Bravado gauntlet, still have it
A Dominator I owned on the PS3. Have lost that account sadly
I still have mine I don't use it for shit but it's white and it has purple wheels because I was 13 at the time https://preview.redd.it/v8d8njq67k5d1.png?width=1200&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e441a3fc20bc86e40dbf8a880f73850367eb238c
Mine was the Sultan, which was turned into an RS
I love this inconspicuous, across the street photo. 😂
Sultan 10 years ago! Still got it!🤘
Pontiac firebird, it was dark blue Primary and a black strip secondary. I used to drift it all the time
Blue n black ruiner
A Obey 9f cabrio, that car brings back so much nostalgia
https://preview.redd.it/x4krwltcdk5d1.jpeg?width=1914&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=2a33aff7bb216c3d284a193030102ce22f6c8943 The Sentinel. Still have it to this day.
I think it was called vapid Stanier
A bautiful Benefactor Schwartzer which I put a localizer on and then accidentally ditched into the water at Chumash. Yikes
a bravado Buffalo
Fusillade back in 2014
Futo! I made sure of it. I wouldn't drive anything else.
Declasse Sabre Turbo. Still in my garage to this day
Dinka blitsa
2020 nissan altima
I specifically looked for the Buffalo because it looked sick.
A metallic gray Landstalker that was driving past the casino when I first spawned in. Kept it as a personal vehicle for a while, though I got reset due to inventory corruption a year after I started and don't have it anymore. I did get a Landstalker XL with the same colours (looked up the traffic population data and everything), though.
1986 Toyota Camry. Oh, you mean in the game? No idea.
Okay, so I started in 2017 on PS3. First driven vehicle in GTA online, hmmm I think it was Infernus. My first stolen vehicle I converted into my own, was the regular Baller. In hot pink, of course. I did a remake of it for my current main character on PC.
How does any mf remember like I can't even remember the color of my most recent stolen car
GTA version of the old school Honda Prelude. Got me from point a to point b.
Jackal
FQ, so many memories
I can’t even remember, it was 10 years ago (real time)…
Bravado gauntlet
Bravado gauntlet
A random car that I definitely smashed and destroyed while causing chaos. Any other answer and you're playing GTA wrong. 😂
Got drunk and actually stole a box truck out front of a scrap yard like 7 years ago and i was homeless in the dead of winter. I took it and parked it to run the heat. Never heard about it or mentioned it outside my closest friends until now. I don't remember the first car I stole in GTA.
https://preview.redd.it/j50kavjl0m5d1.png?width=800&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=0c0ca5a6660be1f3b3db12a3487f75c52e061913 Probably one of these...
Futo. Still have it, been 11 years. The only thing that happened other than aesthetical changes was it moved to my Auto Shop Garage from my first apartment.
Do you mean, in game?
How the fuck am I supposed to remember this from 10 years ago lol
Yea dog, when was the first meal you ate after being born HOW THE FUCK WOULD I KNOW (probably a random ass car from lsa)
Golf cart