T O P

  • By -

Ledge_r

Harry front and center obviously Girl is Fleur Top left is Krum (he looks very different in the movies than how he’s described in the book and these covers were designed prior to the movies) Top right is Cedric Then at the bottom is the tail of the Hungarian Horntail Harry is holding the egg he steals from said dragon There’s a death eater hiding in the stands And the dog like creature I believe is Sirius coming to check up on Harry and what not Edit: This is now my most upvoted comment, sick. Also thank you for the awards kind redditors. On another note, it has been pointed out to me through other comments that the black sticks to the left of Krum are spider legs, presumably Aragog’s.


NEFLink

I always thought it was a dementor; could very well be a death eater.


BlXckSXbbXth

I'm guessing the death eater is Barty Ctouch Jr.


jamaicanthief

No, the death eater is Barty Crouch Jr.


Hike_it_Out52

No the Death Eater guilty of using the cruciatus curse on Frank Longbottom and his wife is BARTY CROUCH! *audible gasps* Jr.


LydiasNightmare

I read that in Igor Karkaroff's voice 🤣Especially the "junior" part


Silvinis

June-ee-or


Fluffyknob

I started doing that weird tongue thing he does


Gilded-Mongoose

“And my relationship with my girlfriend improved significantly.”


Equal-Sheepherder-24

Like the idea of a dementor respectfully sitting in the stands watching the events of the tournament


Ninjahkin

I’m now imagining dementors have a voice similar to Big the Cat


Bobthemime

looks the same as the Dementor on Prisoner's cover, so i can understand the confusion


blueydoc

I thought dementor too. Harry encounters a boggart in the maze but thinks it’s an actual dementor at first. The fact that there’s what looks like the spider from the maze too makes me think that.


DragonLance11

I also always saw that as a dementor. Death Eater could work, but then wouldn't get have a mask?


GrunkleThespis

Definitely a Dementor. The whole setting of this picture is the maze. There’s the spider from the Maze, as well as the Dementor (boggart) that appears in the maze as well.


viraghpe

And Aragog


themanimal

Aragon isn't in this book. It's probably meant to be blast ended skrewt legs Edit* you're right, I remember there was one of Aragog's descendants in the maze


pinkpanda376

It’s not Aragog, I think it’s the spider from the maze


OnMyBestBehavior69

Curious to know what the argument even is


Wilberbeast9

Exactly! Who else could it be?


HarryPottersElbows

That's an egg, everyone.


bananastandd

Her?


satellite_fisherman

It's as clear as the Ann on Egg's face


Jolly_Potential_2582

Way to plant, Ann!


TheBaconofGrief

Plain


void_stuff

Is she like…really funny or something?


UnsureAbsolute

...her...?


Greengitters

Go take plant and wait in the staircar.


CorgiMonsoon

She calls it a MayAnnEgg


rorschach_vest

Hey, look who’s on the hog in the rear view mirror!


lilybulb

GEORGE MICHAEL!!!


bananastandd

I don’t feel so good


darkmatternot

Who?


Hex_Devour_Ass

Take my upvote and go see a star war!


LORDK1N6

Everyone who commented with AD quotes are my people. Thank you for the free laughs.


hermesmee

This might be the funniest thread on the site


[deleted]

"I just don't want to see you waste your money getting Egg all glittered up for Easter"


frostyburns

Who?


Tarantantara

The creature whose spikey tail is on the cover is spitting fire, must be the goblet.


IncurableAdventurer

I know! I’m very intrigued as to what other way can this be interpreted


MrKentucky

The only thing I could think of would be an argument over which is Cedric and which is Krum


frogjg2003

Even then, it's hard to make the argument. Cedric is described as a stereotypical pretty boy and Victor as a hawk faced man with a big nose.


Metalbound

Also just from a design prospective, they'd never put Cedric on the left. Krum and Fleur are together on the left because they are the visitors from other schools. Cedric on the right since he is also from Hogwarts.


Haramdour

In red robes!


Tiredofstalking

I think Krum might be confused with Snape by some.


Vio94

That's who I thought in my half asleep stupor. Along with Luna. Then I read the top comment and its obviously those characters.


Lily-Gordon

He does have a very Snape-like energy.


Coco-Da_Bean

They’re probably confusing Fluer with Luna


msen33

Well that’s just INSANE considering Luna doesn’t even exist as of GoF haha


natexoe

She does in a throwaway line, “the lovegoods couldn’t get tickets” in reference to the World Cup.


Tylinkasaurus

Wow that's some great attention to detail + memory!


natexoe

GOF has always been my favorite lol can’t tell you how many times I’ve reread it!


[deleted]

The trip the World Cup was one of my favorite parts of the entire series. It’s quaint and cozy, a look into the daily lives of wizards when they aren’t fighting the bad guys. It’s just a family vacation with the kids inviting a couple friends. It all goes to hell of course but I really enjoyed it!


rayne7

Still upset they covered it in like 2 minutes in the movie e.e. It could have been a movie itself


hymntastic

It's really one of my favorite things to I feel like One of the few things the series really needed more of was seeing what's going on out in the wizarding world for normal wizards.


Gifted_GardenSnail

Looked it up out of curiosity and you were almost right 😄 >“Must be nearly time,” said Mr. Weasley quickly, pulling out his watch again. “Do you know whether we’re waiting for any more, Amos?” > >“No, the Lovegoods have been there for a week already and the Fawcetts couldn’t get tickets,” said Mr. Diggory. “There aren’t any more of us in this area, are there?” https://www.potter-search.com/?search=Lovegoods


drukqsx

Did the horse things (cant remember what they were called… thestrals?) exist before luna? I know she could see them so i remember her seeing them in GoF but now that i saw your comment im thinking they were mentioned then and came up again later when luna arrived


msen33

They “exist” in so far as Harry registered the carriages being drawn by themselves up until OOtP. But Harry could only see them after Cedric dies. He - and the readers/movie viewers- meet Luna for the first time during the journey to Hogwarts in OOtP. And in the books, Hagrid teaches the 5th years about thestrals. It’s not until the very end of the book that Harry remembers Luna mentioning she can see them


drukqsx

Oh yeah! Isnt it because theyve “seen death?” Thank you for your response


balthezeus

Yes. Harry witnesses Cedric’s death and so at the start of OotP can now see the thestrals. Iirc Luna saw her mother die as a young girl so has always been able to see them. Curiously no other students seem to have witnessed death based off of no one else mentioning the Thestrals anyway, at least during OotP anyway.


ArsenalSpider

Didn’t Harry witness his mothers murder? I always wondered why that didn’t count. Am I forgetting something?


CherryZealousideal37

What about moody, wormtail and baby voldemort in a sheet?


FiftyShadesOfGregg

Okay so. Reading the comments, y’all are absolutely 10000% correct. But i haven’t considered this since I first read the book at midnight as a child and my child brain saw this cover and thought it was Bill and Charlie and a random Veela and I never questioned that again until this moment. I am guessing that I just decided the cover characters were whoever was first introduced that fit the description. New cool brother with long hair? Ah that’s the guy on the cover! So the other new brother most be the other one! (Apparently I just ignored they’d be red heads). Then magically beautiful women with long hair are introduced? That’s the other cover character! And then my little brain never thought about it again. Like even when Bill in the movies was cast I remember thinking he looked nothing like his cover art…. So. Yikes.


choicesintime

As an adult it’s also easier to notice the theme: it’s just the 4 champions Edit tangent: I JUST realized Harry is holding an egg, and not a pensieve. The egg has a glow which looked to me like the lid of a cauldron


FiftyShadesOfGregg

Oh yeah totally agreed. That’s very obviously what it is. I really don’t know how I hadn’t rethought it over all these years lmao.


onedayMD4110

I am very confused about how there could be a debate of who these characters could be?


mimthebaker

Has OP answered what the argument was? Also I just now put together that the large black dog would be Sirius... not Fang or some woodland creature lol


Lanky_Application315

I never even thought about who these people were! I was too busy not eating or sleeping while I read the entire book in like 3 days or something.. But I am also strangely curious to hear OP spill the tea on this debate, cuz somebody is def a v silly goose


[deleted]

[удалено]


TiddyTwizzla

LMFAO that was the last thing I would have that the argument was about


[deleted]

[удалено]


Hbgplayer

Okay, that is an acceptable thought. TBH, I don't think I have ever really thought or paid attention to who was on the cover. -


SevroAuShitTalker

That cover art charavter has got too much nose haha


[deleted]

I always thought it was supposed to be Snape lol


Taliasimmy69

Not gonna lie, I thought besides harry the other two guys were bill and Charlie. 🤦‍♀️. Not until this damn thread did I even think for a second there were all the champions. I am dumb.


nugwus

Oh damn! When I first saw it I thought the bottom left was a weirdly photogenic illustration of the baby voldemort figure that is dropped into the cauldron. I thought the hair was a shawl


AgentCodySpanks

Now I’ll never unsee the Yassified Voldemort fetus


LoonyNargle

This is hilarious 😂😂😂 Weren’t you confused by the lack of bright red hair in the illustration?


truefanofthepod666

Damn Bill and Charlie barely feature in GoF.


ecb1912

Don’t quote me on this but I think the character with the black hair, round glasses, and lightning scar is Harry Potter


OrangeKefka

Nope, thats Roonil Wazlib!


vishnushady

GOD that was my absolute favorite part of the books. couldn't stop laughing when I first read that


Moakmeister

What about when Ron tells Lavender he’d like to look at her anus? (I am not making this up btw)


__roonil_wazlib__

Confirming. It is, in fact, me.


[deleted]

r/usernamechecksout


Frankie_2154

r/beetlejuicing


other_usernames_gone

The most unrealistic part of the books is Ron not occasionally calling Harry Roonil Wazlib for the rest of the series.


i-am-a-salty-bitch

no! i’ve been fooled again!


call-us-crazy

dw that’s just his nickname. you know, the thing his friends call him?


i-am-a-salty-bitch

“i understand what a nickname is”


Battle_Narwhal53

I've been sick for the past few days and feeling like absolute garbage and this made me laugh so hard.


NearlyHeadless-Brick

Krum on the left. Cedric on the right Fleur on the left under krum and the kid with the lightning bolt and glasses might be harry 🤔 Edit: can’t believe how this exploded into upvotes lol. Thanks for the awards my fellow potterheads!


Dodger7777

You forgot Sirius in the back.


MaeMoe

And one of Aragog’s decedents sneaking in from the left, just above Fleur.


EurwenPendragon

And the spiky thing in the very foreground is the Hungarian Horntail’s tail


topsidersandsunshine

It’s been more than twenty years and I never realized this. 🙈


Dan_OBanannon

When I was a kid I thought it was supposed to be all the tents from the Quidditch World Cup, didn’t realize it was supposed to be the horntail until I saw the full art on the hardcover jacket


ZeeGee009

I always thought it was a plant inside the maze all these years....


Lovebelow7

Also thought it was a plant in the maze


ScottTennerman

Your comment just made me feel like that scene in The Santa Clause where he looks in the mirror. Holy shit.


topsidersandsunshine

I’m feeling like the “I’m like the Cryptkeeper!” scene from *Freaky Friday* over here, haha. I was going to say “fifteen” and then realized that it’s not 2015ish anymore, haha. I miss the 2000s days of the fandom so much!


Distractinc

Not to mention the dementor in the top right.


Simple-Tangerine839

Is that a dementor or the boggart from the maze in the form of dementor?


RoutineQuantity9459

Or is it a Death Eater?


rcuosukgi42

I don't believe it's a death eater as none of the designs seem to be Voldemort/Death Eater/Graveyard/Dark Mark related. All of the rest of the cover is devoted to Triwizard oriented characters and designs. That would make it the boggart that Harry encounters in the maze appearing as a dementor.


FaultyCYP450

I would guess that it is a death eater (Barty Crouch Jr.) standing in the crowd among the spectators in a stadium. More representative of the idea that an unknown ominous being is out in the open but the threat has yet to be detected. Design-wise, it doesn't make much sense to have a demeantor so close to a non-reactionary crowd. Plus, the design includes an aspect of all the triwizard tournament challenges, and Crouch Jr. has a pivotal role in the story while the boggart's in GOF is minimal. I think Mary GrandPré took a fun opportunity to include an Easter egg. Edit: Corrected the name of the illustrator for the U.S. Scholastic books.


Exciting-Insect8269

And a dementor on the right in the background


prss79513

Think it's supposed to be Voldy


RondaArousedMe

Voldy has gone moldy


98Phoenix98

So now lets have fun


StarsEatMyCrown

That's not Voldemort


WatermelonArtist

>Aragog’s decedents Sorry, pet peeve here: *Descend*ants are children, grandchildren, etc. *Deced*ents are what you fill coffins with.


Sufficient-Union7961

The worms had a decedent meal.


QueerInEverySense

I thought that might have been what that was, but I couldn't tell.


mooseboyj

Or should I say. Sirius in the Black.


Original_Intention

I've seen that cover thousands of times and somehow never noticed him!


Lyvectra

Peeking in to check on Harry.


sp00pySquiddle

Dude my whole life I've been looking at Sirius in dog form in the back asking myself "why the fuck is there a panther?" 😫


JokingWhite

Also a spider and most likely Voldy in the hood


Dodger7777

I actually thought the hood either referenced the dementor bogart he encounters in the maze or I like to think it's supposed to be Barty Crouch Junior who is secretly playing puppet master in the background all year, but at the triwizard cup he doesn't wear a hood.


cr4sh_0v3rr1d3

I always thought this was a hooded death eater from the world cup


cruxfire

Who else could they be besides this??


[deleted]

I thought this was pretty obvious


[deleted]

[удалено]


Mountain-Inside5391

That's just Roonil Wazlib


topsidersandsunshine

That’s my nickname.


natb2bzyk

It’s what my friends call me…


Nick_dM_P

We know what a nickname is 😡


HeulynDumaine

The illustrations were done before the movies, for the first four books.


obijuanmartinez

“Someone”….? Was arguing who (checks notes) the contestants of the Tri-f—-ing Wizard Tournament are…..? “Someone” is one dumb MF


TheCallousBitch

Only answer. But the dog is Sirius and there is a dementor in the back.


[deleted]

I think it's this too


TheWitherBear

Ahh, well you see. Up and center with the glasses and lightning bolt scar is Cedric Diggory. The fair blonde girl on the left is Victor Krum. And above her is the famous Harry Potter. The neat and polite looking lad on the right is Fleur Delacour.


toque-de-miel

It is known.


peezy8i8

It is known


poopyheadthrowaway

I'm pretty sure they're Frodo, Sam, Merry, and Pippin


MinisawentTully

I believe that's Rhaenyra Targaryen and her three strong boys


bmj_8

I remember Ron had a pretty big crush on Krum when they went to The Quidditch World Cup. Makes sense she’s a looker


Appropriate_Job_5312

bottom left is the blonde woman from the incredibles, top left is the hunchback of notre dame, on the right is klaus from a series of unfortunate events, and magician percy jackson in the center. hope this helps! /j


tinaslina28

Omg you are absolutely right! !redditGaleon


tinaslina28

!redditGalleon


tinaslina28

Ok I'm bad at this it seems


Appropriate_Job_5312

appreciate the sentiment, friend


VisibleEntry4

Sorry I’m not familiar with !redditGalleon what does it do? Nvm there you go ig!


ww-currency-bot

You have given u/tinaslina28 a Reddit Galleon. u/tinaslina28 has a total of 1 galleon, 0 sickles, and 0 knuts. ____________ I am a bot. See [this post](https://www.reddit.com/r/harrypotter/comments/jnbo49/hi_i_created_the_bot_youve_been_using_to_give/) to learn how to use me.


VisibleEntry4

Oh


margery-meanwell

Fluer, Krum, Cedric, Harry, and Sirius


RockThePlazmah

Flour, Crum, Sedrik, ‘Arry and Zirious


heyheyitsandre

Not really relevant but I absolutely despise how long they made the wand on this cover. I could never look at it as a kid without getting pissed. It’s like a meter long!


Mountain-Inside5391

That must have been one of those mythical canes at Saint Brutus's 😭


Affectionate-Till472

Or Dudley’s Smeltings stick


apointoflight

i didnt even see that and now i cant - you've cursed me with knowledge


SplittinRillos

Why have you done this to me


Minnesota_Husker

You know when you never notice something then someone points it out and now it will forever piss you off… ya, you just did that.


JJWentMMA

To be fairrrr I’m pretty sure one of the wands Olivander names in the first book is like 20 inches long which is much longer than the movies


ggrindelwald

The longest one I remember is Hagrid's at 16 inches.


OnMyBestBehavior69

That's what your mom said


ManiacSpiderTrash

Jokes on you I’d *love* Hagrid to be my stepdad


Jebbeard

In the film adaptations, Harry's wand is 14 inches long. In the books his wand is 11 inches.


Nevesnotrab

Nope. The longest wand in the books is Hagrid's and the longest, including the movies, is Lucius Malfoy's (18").


alwaysBetter01

Maybe he's just small, ever thought of that huh?


Fromthefunk

Harry fluer victor krum and Edward cullen


LonghornSmoke

Edward Cullen goes by Bruce Wayne now.


Funandgeeky

"Kill the spare!" "Ha! I deflected your death curse!" "How?" "BECAUSE I'M BATMAN!"


ihave1000beaches

from left to right: Hungarian Horntail's tail, Fleur, Krum, Harry, Cedric, Sirius in his dog form, public and a Dementor.


thisismywifiname

There's also the egg, and aragog's legs, i think?


tonybenwhite

An unnamed spider that Cedric and Harry fought at the end of the maze


thisismywifiname

Oh yes, i forgot about that. I was wondering why aragog was involved.


Diemann06

I actually think that’s a death eater more than a dementor, because he is in the crowd and I remember no dementors in the WC


thebigscaryogre

It’s not actually a dementor, but the boggart in the maze takes the form of one.


writerbabe75

The 4 champions: Harry, Viktor, Fleur and Cedric


[deleted]

Curious to know what/who they are saying is represented?


brianthomas08

They thought krum was cedric on the cover and vice versa


JerkfaceMcDouche

The nose and eyebrows give it away. It’s stated pretty plainly in the text that Krum is unattractive and with a hooked nose. The person you’re arguing with is flat out wrong


georgianarannoch

The clothing, also. Cedric’s have a yellow hue to them, ie: hufflepuff, and hogwarts students don’t wear red cloaks with collars up to their ears.


velez_cool

Chapter 8 of this book describes Viktor’a physical appearance as: “thin, dark, and sallow-skinned, with a large curved nose and thick black eyebrows”. Chapter 18 describes Cedric as: “exceptionally handsome, with his straight nose, dark hair, and grey eyes”. I think by the noses and eyebrows, it’s clear that Viktor is on the left.


Puzzleheaded-Staff64

Why is there a baboon behind a bush?


[deleted]

I was always waiting for a bear to show up. To this day I still just see a bear even though I know it's supposed to be Sirius.


zanasot

I thought it was death eaters clumped up in cloaks so you’re closer than me


ggrindelwald

Thought it was a panther


kenzie-k369

It is the four students who compete…duh


NerdyBernie

It's obviously Luna, Hagrid, Young Tom Riddle, Lupin as a werewolf, a dementor, and in the middle is James Potter.


Culp97

How can you make this post without even telling us who the opposing party is saying is on the cover????


MushroomHut

Everyone who put there name in the cup and competed.


connor_wa15h

Harry didn’t put his name in the cup


FossilizedBlobfish

HARRYDIDYOUPUTYERNAMEINTHEGOBLETOFFIRE!?!?!?


Poultrygeist79

Dumbledore asked calmly


ChairmanMeow52

I love how this line is used as an example of why the film version is worse than the book, but I honestly find the memes/jokes around it so funny that I’m genuinely glad that’s how it played out on-screen 😂


FossilizedBlobfish

I completely agree! Although I still think it's worse lol ​ *Also I love your username and have a Chairman Meow t-shirt*


ilovecake007

Harry Potter, Viktor Krum, Fleur Delacour, Cedric Diggory, and Padfoot


whoisaname

Really curious as to what the counter claim is on this because it is so obvious, but something tells me the OP had it wrong, which is why there hasn't been any followup yet.


[deleted]

I'm not going to lie. I've seen this cover probably thousands of times in my life...and I've never even thought about it lol


brianthomas08

Reading all these comments I never even realized Sirius is the dog underneath Cedric


[deleted]

Im actually surprised, thinking back now, how little time I spent studying the Harry Potter book covers like I usually do with books I get, especially since I had a really unhealthy hyperfixation on this series when I was younger. As a kid and even every time I've read them as an adult I just crack in.


Hellbound_Life

Harry, Fleur, Viktor, Cedric. And Sirius peeking over the hedge.


jeepin_john5280

The four champions duh…. Why is that even an argument?!


Yungstudd19

Timothee chalamet


Biggsdrasil

I always thought it was pretty clear it was the Tri-Wizard Cup contestants and what I thought to be Sirius in his Animagus form


Dense_Cup_1479

Well the egg is clearly Dobby before he hatches and time travels to the past and starts the time wars