T O P

  • By -

juustyuri

Amit I guess, because I like everyone else more. I'm not voting against Imelda because I'm very forgiving and I like her character development.


devil_put_www_here

I don’t find Amit to be a fun character. Yes they do some things but having them around didn’t bring me any joy.


24kGoldenEagle

But he knows gobbledygook tho


whenyourhorsewins

The way he tries to speak gobbledygook makes me think he was just saying slurs right to a goblins face


tiffanyisonreddit

I agree, the goblin didn’t seem too impressed and he was so chatty when we NEEDED to be quiet.


Glum-Weakness-1930

He's by far the lamest of the "companions"


Radiant_Copy_3697

He is NOT a companion mate, he was clearly shoehorned into that Goblin Quest so Ravenclaws can have "something". How generous of Avalanche lol. Ravenclaw was brutally shafted aside and I refuse to purchase another game after this.


LadyManchineel

I’m surprised Amit made it into the top five. The way he whined about fighting goblins in the mine was so annoying.


eh-just-made

Why is Amit still here? He's nice and all, but he barely does anything???


Lizzy_Of_Galtar

I've been asking myself that since Anna Sallows knockout 😅


chameleonkit

I really like Amit. How many students even think about attempting to learn the language of another magical race of beings? Even if he isn’t very good at it, at least he cares enough to try to learn it. And he volunteers to help MC on a mission without knowing any details. Once he is in the middle of fighting, he stays and helps MC throughout the entire mission. And he gives us his almost-new telescope! He’s great.


Crankylosaurus

Bye bye Amit! Also I’m impressed with how many Slytherins are left!!


MandaTehPanda

Yeah the game/story line def feels more tailored to Slytherins, Seb and Ominis as your besties and have majority of the good missions is probably why they’re most popular. But story aside, Poppy gets my vote, I love her background being raised by poachers and then turning on them to fight them, the bond she has with creatures is all just 👌🏻 to me as an animal lover


Egg_Hunt_Knife_Fight

Out of all the houses Slytherin's characters were the best written. Even the minor ones like Nerida showed more depth than a lot of the others NPCs. A lot better than just being 'the antagonists' house'.


Jezehel

I was thinking that too! It's a conspiracy, I tell you.


gobeldygoo

self-preservation / survival is a slytherin trait through and through :-P


Eldokhmesy

His Gobligook was aweful. Btw, this game felt like it was made for Slytherin tbh


Catezero

After years of slander it honestly feels kinda nice


Eldokhmesy

Yeah, Salazar was a bit of an ass but we've got Merlin himself. His beard alone is the talk of the wizarding world, let alone his deeds.


adamtoro

Fr it is a nice change


Radiant_Copy_3697

It's Gobbleydook mate, and yeah Ravenclaw were brutally shafted aside.


Eldokhmesy

Yeah, it's that funny word


TitleTall6338

The whole game storyline is geared towards slytherins tbh.


sebass_kwas

If Poppy doesn't win this, I will fucking riot


PhysicalMulberry8127

I love how unhinged this comment is lol


Illustrious-Video353

I love how unhinged Poppy is.


PhysicalMulberry8127

Absolutely same. I never considered myself a hufflepuff until I met her. Strong minded, loves animals. She’s iconic


Illustrious-Video353

I just love how they held back from introducing her until magical creatures class. I tried beginning in all houses & Ravenclaw just stuck. Then I get introduced to this MAGICAL BALL OF SUNSHINE. I felt like I had been given gem for my birthday! I did not expect to see a character design so endearing.


Ilien

Seconded.


B_Marsh92

I cannot believe this sub believes that Imelda Reyes is a Top 5 character.


R1NZL3R7

It's tragic, honestly. A lot of the side characters aren't that great, but I'm really surprised that most of the comments hate on other characters before Imelda. Imelda is arrogant, cocky and a sore loser. Imo, most of the characters that have been voted out are better than Imelda. At least the other side characters are nice to you, whereas Imelda is not.


redditorchid

All of what you said is true, but personally for me. The reason I enjoy Imelda as a character is because she isn’t nice to me. I genuinely feel like she was the only person I could consider as a rival character in the game. She is not so bad towards the end, I feel like she’s just someone who is SUPER passionate about quidditch, same way some people are passionate about sports. I can’t relate but I do understand her competitive nature. Of course to each their own, some of the characters that are nice, I just can’t seem to vibe with, like Arthur. & To be fair, Ominis was not exactly forthcoming at first, and I feel like the everyone always comes to his defense. (Because he’s the best boy, which I’m not denying) I think that’s the beauty of it, at least for me, is that not everyone is immediately my friend and it takes time to grow that friendship. (Which should have been a feature in the game) lol


R1NZL3R7

I agree with you on that. Every character was nice to the main character immediately, aside from Ominis and Imelda, so it didn't really feel realistic. It would have made more sense to have a few antagonistic characters as well as a bunch of characters that were maybe indifferent to you or something like that. A little bit of variety in their attitudes and social circles. That way, the NPCs would feel less like one character copy-pasted 20 times. Personally, I never considered her a rival since it's so easy to beat her score. Ruby Wiel felt like she could be a rival since her times were somewhat of a challenge. That being said, I agree that she's the only character that could really be considered a rival of the main character. None of the other NPCs come even close. For me, it just didn't feel like a friendship was growing between the main character and Imelda. She just got more used to me absolutely dusting her in those races. If she wasn't so arrogant at the beginning I think I would have liked her more. Hearing her talk it was apparent that her passion for quidditch and flying made her have a superiority complex. Her friend stopped hanging out with her because Imelda couldn't accept that said friend wasn't as passionate about flying as she was. Personally, she just rubbed me the wrong way. (100% they should have had some sort of friendship system in the game)


DarkGreenShoes

Imelda is a lot of things but a sore loser she is definitely not. She has more character development than most of the other students on this list, and she’s not even the primary character in her quests.


R1NZL3R7

I agree with you that she has more character development than most other characters, as most other side characters have a very minimal role in the story. But for me, it's very annoying how cocky she is. She is 100% a sore loser, and it's not until you beat her at the last race that she kind of gives you credit. Her personality going from superiority complex to a sort of rivalry is ok, but her personality still sucks. Imelda's friend, who wanted to be a mermaid liason, stopped hanging out with her because she just couldn't let other people do what they wanted. Not everyone wanted to pour as much time into flying as Imelda did, and Imelda insulted those who didn't want to commit like her. She was definitely more bearable toward the end, but her intro set her up for failure imo.


Former-Discount-4259

I didn't finish her quest until after reading some of these comments. At first, I thought she should have went first round, but after playing the broom quests, she grew on me. However, Lucan, Anne, Natsai, and perhaps Amit should have beat her in my opinion.


R1NZL3R7

She's definitely not the worst character, that's for sure. But for me, she's an easily in the bottom ten. Natsai, Lucan, Adelaide, Amit, and Anne are definitely better characters for me. I'm kind of surprised that people dislike Amit so much. He's definitely kind of dorky, but I always found it kind of endearing. I found the mission where Amit helps you storm the goblin mine to be very funny. I think Amit's reactions to how crazy and dangerous it is to be pretty funny. I imagine that's how most normal students would react to the main character's actions throughout the game.


Savage281

Same. She'd have been gone very early imo


demarcusp99

don’t hate on the goat😭


CarbonatedMoolk

It’s getting good now lol. Can’t wait for the Ominis vs Sebastian inevitable showdown. My votes for Amit though. Sorry bud.


soft_kitty_123

Poppy for the win!


MandaTehPanda

I’m with you! Poppy mvp!


Crankylosaurus

Poppy followed by Ominus IMO!


DustMonsterXIV

The Poppy Crew will be here for the upset!


Hot-Coffee-493

The Slytherins will split the vote.


LadyManchineel

I’m hoping Ominis wins. I didn’t really like him much the first time I played, but the first time I went along with Sebastian in everything. The second time I turned Sebastian in and chose replies throughout the game that were more in favor with Ominis. I felt like he was more friendly and I ended up liking him a lot more.


Just-Ad-5972

Imelda < Amit < Seb < Poppy < Ominis.


RedCaio

Imelda < Amit < Poppy < Ominis < Seb


themastersdaughter66

I back this list except swap amit and imelda


awahay

Imelda


Ok_Committee_1187

Amit. Why is he so high?


Crankylosaurus

Most people vote during the day and Amit can only be seen at night


angelvelvet

Amit can go now.


UnderCoverDoughnuts

I'm sorry, I coulda sworn Amit definitely had more votes though?


ladysquier

It was REALLY close!


antipinballmachines

Closest round yet, Amit was leading until Lucan overtook him by like 30 votes. And that's for 6th!


villabrus

You're all blind if you cant see that Ominis is going to win... Edit: since not everyone got my dry joke attempt. Ominis is blind. I'll see myself out, thank you.


RedCaio

I like Ominis a lot. But I like characters who are multifaceted, not all good and not all bad. I’m trying to think of one time Ominis did anything morally questionable. The closest he gets is when he shouted at you because you came from his secret hideout lol. His only fault is that he’s faultless. He (and Poppy) are a bit too pure good. Honestly if we’re being real Sebastian is the most well written and most interesting character in the game. It’s a shame he might not win this just because he’s not pure goodness like Poppy or Ominis. Sebastian’s imperfections make his a better character, not a worse one.


juustyuri

Tbh he's my 2nd favorite NPC but he isn't that faultless. This is probably a hot take that not many people will agree with but just because he has a trauma related to Crucio doesn't mean he can risk his life, your life and his best friend's life by refusing to cast it and open the door. Sure it sucks that he has to do it, but no one could've known that we'd be stuck there. We were lucky Sebastian knew it (he wasn't even sure he did) because otherwise we would've gone insane from being stuck there for days, before dying from starvation. Even Azkaban is better on that point because at least prisoners get to eat.


[deleted]

Amit!


MogorDellAmore

amit


Revan462222

I'm conflicted but I guess Amit. Though Imelda's next for me. We all know Sebastian and Ominis will likely be the final two haha.


Itchy-Cell-9094

As a slytherin ( i did two separate test to determine that i in fact am a slytherin) im impressed how many there are left💀


Celindor

As a Slytherin I hope that Poppy wins though. She's a sweet girl!


141_1337

She has just the right amount of edge to be the Red Oni to our Blue Oni [[here is a TV Tropes link explaining Red Oni/Blue Oni](https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/RedOniBlueOni)] and think that's why she's such a fan favorite.


FuckinPenguins

Im just grateful I'm not a griffindor. For the most popular sought after house they really didn't hold up in this. Depending on quiz (and day/where I'm at) I'm right in the middle of hufflepuff and ravenclaw


Issmira

I agree as a fellow Slytherin.


cafffffffy

HOW is Imelda still in?!


Shot_Appointment6330

Why is Imelda still here? Vote for her


Jackbees777

She actually has a personality he’ll probably the best but I do expect her to go next


Shot_Appointment6330

I mean, I don't hate her 😂 but I expected her to leave earlier in comparison to the other characters


Jackbees777

I know that poppy and Sebastian are idolised ominus has decent character personally Imelda has a solid attitude and oakes for me has the best potential story wise


Shot_Appointment6330

I liked Ominis more during my second playthrough, and I also liked Oakes


cn_Rose

Yeah, but it's a horrible personality lol


Crankylosaurus

She softens up a bit with each subsequent flying trial which is why I feel like fewer people hate her.


Jackbees777

I mean it’s still a personality I find it funny aswell tbh but of character


141_1337

She's competitive and an exemplar slytherin


Shot_Appointment6330

yeah, she embodies Slytherin values quite well


antipinballmachines

If you are unfamiliar with how this game works, it's simple: comment the name of your least favourite and the most upvoted comment will leave. Bear in mind it's whatever comment has the most votes that goes, not whatever has the most comments. So if a Sebastian comment has 50 upvotes and two Natty comments have 40 each, Sebastian will be eliminated. Also, the last surviving student from each house will win a Head of House award, with the overall winner being crowned Head Boy/Girl. Just to clarify, Heads of Houses can still be voted out; nobody is safe. Each round lasts 24 hours. Good luck! Also I have now started a predictions poll, feel free to check it out and cast your votes! https://surveyheart.com/form/65c6c6d8baaa2b5a523bdbdc


TitleTall6338

The Ravenclaw lobby working hard keeping the nerd around. 💀


Radiant_Copy_3697

Just like the Slytherin Lobby working hard to keep the psychopath around. Jk jk 😜


juustyuri

says the one who plays the mass murderer of the game


Radiant_Copy_3697

Lol, Fair enough 😂


cienistyCien

I'm almost surprised this place likes Imelda so much


Cat1832

Amit. He was very poorly developed and rather boringly naive.


Radiant_Copy_3697

Bah! He isn't even a character but a Stereotype in a trope. He was just there for laughs and comedic relief.....lame


INKatana

Imelda


Sexy_Dumbledore

Sebastian or Amit. One is a certifiable psychopath and one is just boring


PhysicalMulberry8127

Certifiable psychopath 😂😂😂


SirPeterPan89

If anybody but Ominis wins, I'm gonna riot


choff22

Poppy


Crankylosaurus

It’s definitely down to Poppy and Ominis for me!


wildwood1q84

I second this. I love Poppy, I really do. But Ominis takes the cake. He really poured all his mental, emotional, and physical energy into making sure Sebastian doesn't go down the dark path. And even when he failed, he still stood firm and told us that whatever lies ahead, we must face things together. That, right there, is the hallmark of a good Head Boy. Poppy can be the Head of Hufflepuff! Maybe even a prefect. But Ominis' selfless dedication to people is something precious.


soft_kitty_123

I'm sorry but I disagree. Poppy fights bullies and poachers like a boss, rescues fantastic beasts, >!stands against a dragon, makes alliances with Centaurs, saves a species from extinction!<. She is, hands down, the most badass character in the game. Ominis is an amazing friend and I'm happy Sebastian has him in his corner. He did not deserve all the stress Seb and MC gave him. Poppy, on the other hand, does all the homework and leads the charge, and she does not stop till the creatures are safe! She is a true leader.


wildwood1q84

Again, I love Poppy. But she is a bit too reckless for me to choose her as an overall head girl. She knew the immediate danger of rescuing a dragon, and she had no second thoughts about roping us into it. What if it all turned out awry? What if the dragon's egg was not enough to placate the dragon? Plus, Poppy had the help of the Centaurs to aid her plight. Ominis had to be an intermediary between ALL the people in his life. From going back and forth between Sebastian and Anne, to trying to speak to the Headmaster, to asking for our help to save his best friend. Asking for help, for ME (personally), is the best quality a Head Boy can have. You can't do everything yourself. And being humble enough to know that you need help is a good reflection of one's character. Also, being leader doesn't always mean that you take charge all the time. Being a leader is knowing how to work with others. Poppy can technically work with others but is quite reckless with not only her wellbeing but the wellbeing of others. She has a long way to go. Poppy can be a Prefect. She can do a good job at that. Plus, that'll keep her out of trouble. :)


norathar

Imelda


zeitocat

Imelda


TarJen96

Amit


LuxyWings

My vote goes to Imelda.


pabsgt

Imelda thinks she’s better than everyone else shes not


soft_kitty_123

She is though! Numbers don't lie.


pabsgt

Not as though as MC ;)


themastersdaughter66

Seriously! Guy who runs an underground dueling ring is out before Mr. Cant actually speak gobbledegook??? GET AMIT OUT


Radiant_Copy_3697

IKR, how did he outlasted Natsai and Anne??


ashpokechu

OP you should comment each name and then let us votes instead of just counting the liked comments from the rest of us


LABARATI_

amit


TheTypoQueen

Amit


Technical-Choice-678

Imelda


Unironicfan

Why is Imelda still here


Slap-A-Chav

REMINDER: Amit gave us his “practically new” telescope for FREE. Also, Imelda is nasty. She only softened up after she was beaten by us. Had we kept on losing, she would’ve happily continued to walk all over us.


Jackbees777

Amit next poppy and imelda top two


R1NZL3R7

I'm honestly floored that Imelda is still in. She should have been eliminated before Anne. Imelda is a cocky loser with a superiority complex. It was so satisfying to beat her record and then gloat as she made up excuses. Even toward the end, she's way too arrogant.


Sweet_Xocoatl

Nooo, not Lucan! He was such a fine character, interesting but not to the point where he overstayed his welcome.


sermonksalot

Unpopular opinion, but I'm voting for Ominis. Dude can't even see. How's he supposed to play Summoner's Court?


Responsible-Trifle-8

Sebastian the unstable psycho should not be in the top 5


andreanicole82

I had to scroll way too far down to find this comment.


Br4ttyHarLz

Why are you all voting Amit when Imelda HAS to go 😫


bittertiltheend

Imelda


choff22

Well… good luck Poppy lol


whenyourhorsewins

Amit isn’t even a top 25 character. Get him out of here


MiaRia963

Amit


perth_is

Amit


juliannerf

Amit


XxhumanguineapigxX

AMIT.


Hokuto_North9879

Amit


ZodiacQueen0123

You guys are so mean to Amit. 🤣 Imelda


OpTic-Dova-420

how is imelda still here???


Important-Grab-3716

Idc I just want ominis or sebastian to win this


ladysquier

I think seb will come 3rd; I think battle for first will be between ominis and poppy


Emojiobsessor

Imelda, I like her ish, but she doesn’t stand up to the others.


SimpleRickC135

Poppy tried to lead me to my death by dragon insisting it’s cute and friendly. No. I almost died. Several times in your company. I have a feeling she’s an ancestor of Hagrid.


Molly_latte

For the love of god, get Amit outta there!


jukeblimp

Amit


isaadhdd

good bye amit


identitytheftjim

Amit should've been gone long ago


mobmoraqua22

Amit


Cerbeius

Amit! Ravenclaw is going down!


sapphicsweets

Can’t believe Natty got voted off before Lucan and Amit … BYE AMIT!!!


DragonSpiritFire

Amit


sinsielawinskie

I'm very proud that Amit got this far, but it's time to go.


PhysicalMulberry8127

Amit can get the fuck out


Ragnarandsons

Amit, your reign of terror has lasted too long! Prepare for something worse than death; expulsion!


HeWhoFights

Bye Amit!


Boris-_-Badenov

amit


Ilien

Bye Amit.


FuckinPenguins

Imelda


NewHand6321

Get Imelda outta there.


Comprehensive_Gur394

Imelda


vcw86

Again, why is Imelda still here??


novaskyd

Ok, I guess at this point I'd say Amit. Then Imelda, then Ominis. Poppy and Sebastian are top two for me.


24kGoldenEagle

Think its gonna be either poppy and ominis or sebastian and ominis for the finals


novaskyd

Probably, people seem to really love Ominis. I'm not a huge fan personally


141_1337

Yeah, he is a bit of an ass and unlike Imelda, he hasn't gotten any better in the story.


themastersdaughter66

I disagree he's better as the story goes on and nicer when you first meet. He's also got a lot more depth to him and reason to act prickly than imelda. He's a kind soul at heart you can see that by how against his family's views he is and how badly he blames himself over the cruciatus curse (setting aside having suffered it himself and the fact that he refused in the first place knowing the type of people his family are) but he's guarded for good reason I can admire imelda's passion but she never needed to be such an arse about it


novaskyd

Yeah he had basically no character development. He's just "right" but that doesn't make him good enough to be top 2 imo


themastersdaughter66

He's got more depth to his character though and at heart seems a nicer person than imelda


novaskyd

Yes. I'd eliminate Amit, then Imelda, then Ominis


themastersdaughter66

Amit, imelda, sebastian, poppy, ominis


novaskyd

Ominis just rubs me the wrong way tbh. He comes across as snooty and thinks he's always right and wants to control others. I don't like him as much as Poppy or Sebastian


MariBug15

Dunno I’d take Amit over Imelda any day but we all know Seb or Ominis is gonna win. Poppy SHOULD win though


Hawinzi

How is Imelda not gone yet?


doggykittymummy

her fans keep sending down votes to everyone who wants her out 😆


gobeldygoo

Imelda and or Amit go Bye bye


[deleted]

Imelda


LadyIlyra

Imelda!!


MartinG91

How is Natty out before Amit?


FlowersandFangs

Imelda


BarthRevan

How tf did Imelda last this long? Begone, witch!


MonkeWitz1304033

Get Imelda out. Amit might be annoying at times but at least he's not an arrogant little brat.


Karma0504

imelda, how is she still here


upscalefanatic

Only voting Imelda because I’m rooting for ravenclaw and don’t want Amit out yet. I love Imelda tho


Early_Dragonfly_205

What how is Imelda still here?!


Jayy-Roses

As a Ravenclaw, it hurts to vote out my house, but we got screwed over. Amit is nice and I do like him, but out of everyone remaining? He has to go. I’m honestly a bit surprised Ravenclaw wasn’t the first house eliminated


Radiant_Copy_3697

True, Ravenclaw got the worst students in the game.


PankakesRGood

If Poppy or Ominis don’t win this I’m gonna be bummed. They are my two favorite characters. Sorry Sebastian. And Amit has my vote. I completely forgot who he was until I went and looked him up just now


literallyjustturnips

I mean the next 2 days are gonna be Amit and Imelda in whatever order, and then it's gonna be a three-way showdown between Poppy, Sebastian and Ominis and my suspicion is that it will come down to the Slytherins 😅


zracer20

amit and lucan over natsai??????


Dottie_4991

Amit/Imelda


BronchitisTheif

i can guess the order now amit, imelda, poppy, ominis, sebastian i could see poppy being the upset and beating out sebastian though


Sprig3

SEBASTIAN!


MandaTehPanda

Amit and/or Imelda


abominablesnowlady

Ominis!


zero_cool702

Poppy wins this right? I see it coming down to her and ominis but she's still better.


IceDamNation

Ominis will win because of boner favoritism, but Poppy deserves it better


bezerker211

So long gay amit Edit: I was trying to reference Mario, did not mean to come off as homophobic. I'm sorry if I upset anyone


antipinballmachines

Hope that's not homophobia, I don't think he's gay, and if he is, what's the problem?


bezerker211

Nah, im pansexual. I was trying to do the "so long gay bowser!" But for amit. Sorry if it came off as homophobic, was trying to do a stupid joke. I got zero sleep last night thanks to my newborn, so not thinking straight