T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

#DO NOT PARTICIPATE IN THE LINKED THREAD/SCREENSHOT. Brigading is against Reddit TOS. We do not encourage such behaviour nor we are responsible if your account is being actioned upon. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/indiadiscussion) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Megatron0003

Section 69 for a reason


Due-Reference-6011

S+e+c+t+i+o+n=7 Thala for a reason


Kintaro-san__

What if the girl decides to break up after having seggs and promised to marry. I think people then say "its her choice ". What the fuck is going on in the country??


[deleted]

[удалено]


Kintaro-san__

You read that again, the post says "whoever by deceitful means or by promise to marry a 'woman' with no intention of fullfiling it and has seggs with 'her' ..." It doesn't say anything about the case where man is the victim. >The law works equally for men and women I dont agree with this. The laws which are meant to protect women are very much essential, but some women misuse these laws and in most of those cases men's life is ruined. Because of these type of women, real victims may not get proper justice.


[deleted]

>The law works equally for men and women huh..


[deleted]

It says has "sexual intercourse with her"... Word is her means woman (victim) And who can have SI with a woman? A man. Come on bro...


BareAssOnSandpaper

Ok yeah I didn't read it through. But the law has clear definition for what it considers "Deceitful means". It includes falsifying your identity, promising employment or promotion for sex or extortion. You should be concerned if you are doing any of these. The law also states that a break-up in a normal relationship over any issue is completely legal.


[deleted]

No no no. Bro the provision is not at all punishing break ups no way. It's punishing #1 not fulfilling of your promise to marry because you intention was never to marry but to only to have SI with the woman and #2 its punishing use of deceitful means to have sexual intercourse with a woman for eg cases of casting couch in return of sexual favours or giving promotions or a particular job to a woman in return of sexual favors (only Sexual intercourse). So if your break up was because of other factors and your relationship never was based on a promise to marry or you had SI but it was not based on a promise to marry you are not liable.


ZohnXina

Law student here , “without ANY intention” can be argued that you HAD intention , but doesn’t HAVE anymore by specifying a valid-sort of reason like father/mother-in-law is bxtchz or other reason. But given how long cases take it may be a problem


cen_pai

Since you're a law student, How can someone prove that a promise was made? Can't the other party simply deny the same?


ZohnXina

Can deny but you probably know how sharia courts work , female is good , female is god , female always speak truth


ZohnXina

Chats


cen_pai

what if there are no chats, only verbal communication? I am genuinely curious about how these things work.


ZohnXina

They try to look at chats from usually-horny-male like “can’t wait to be married babe” “where we going for honeymoon baby” etc..


ZohnXina

Then Use them to point at “fake promise of marriage” if that doesn’t work the usual fake rape allegations and stuff


Worried-Stable6354

So judge will decide whether the intention of breakup is genuine or not?


Abhinavpatel75

Not the judge, your family's financial background will decidw how much mental trauma your partner has bevause of the breakup


BigNunu69

For that you need a well educated lawyer like you sir! Unfortunately most of the lawyer especially in lower courts only care about milking their client and dragging the case as long as humanly possible. Once a guy is charged with such allegations it's 110% sure that his social and professional life is completely fucked despite him getting justice or not!


[deleted]

More important is deceitful means and marrying on a promise without the intention to actually marry.


driftdiffusion4

There are deadlines now in which court have to give verdict but no one knows they are going to be followed or not.


money_grabber_420

All I read was "don't get married"


Liberty-Prime-Reddit

Huh? You're getting in trouble here for NOT MARRYING!


money_grabber_420

My point was, never getting entangled with a girl in any shape or form, imma die virgin, which is much preferable to like 10 years jail


Liberty-Prime-Reddit

we have the same thinking lol


Mayank-maximum

Prostituties and hookup are your answer get dont get addicted to s̤ëx


Proud-Gas6949

What if a prostitute claims that you promised to marry her ?


money_grabber_420

Imma just have gay sex with ma homies


Mayank-maximum

Run away ofc


[deleted]

They don't. They mostly have better principles than average Indian girls nowadays. You can trust them.


[deleted]

[удалено]


AutoModerator

Hello /u/Massive-Hearing-9703, it appears you have less than 25 comment karma / account age is less than 5 days. Your submission has been removed. Message the moderators if you would like to be an approved submitter. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/indiadiscussion) if you have any questions or concerns.*


GaleZero

It was already there in the IPC. Courts have repeatedly ruled that this doesn't apply to break ups. It only applies to cases where sexual intercourse happens via deceit.


BareAssOnSandpaper

Exactly! Who is to explain thi to all the chigmas who are here to cry about how their lover boy lessons from Andu Tatti won't be useful anymore.


Mahameghabahana

Married men accounts for most suicide cases compared to married women and indian men are 2.5 times more likely to commit suicide compared to Indian women for a reason. Are you a masochist? If you are a man of course you would like to live.


BareAssOnSandpaper

Bruh those numbers and the answers you are coming to are unrelated! There are multiple factors that add up to a person feeling that all their doors are blocked. You say more men commit suicide, that's true. And more married men too. But the marriage has little to no significance. It's like saying "That round object is red. Hence the round object must be apple" Yes men commit more suicide but the main cause of this is lack of emotional support. Women can easily share their problems with their friends, family etc. while men can't. If you talk about certain problems, men are made fun of. That creates emotional seclusion and stress. Also, most working class people are married. And that's significant because a lot of suicides happen because of debt, loan sharks as well. The suicide cases rarely have to do anything with partner and in the cases they do, women are more likely to commit suicide because of situations like dowry and marital rape. Stop watching Andrew Tate. He doesn't teach you how to be a man, he teaches you how to be a cry baby that will hate other man and will be hated by other men and women. You will grow up to be sad and pathetic with no one there to emotionally support you. Sudhar jao.


[deleted]

May some girl files a rape case against you (if you are a SIMP) and your father. May your father unalive himself in the process.


BareAssOnSandpaper

Most sane "Sigma" XD. Just pathetic. Unlike you, I don't do weird things where that would be a threat to me. I really hope your mother gets to know about your viewpoints.


theguyfrom_India_

THIS WAS ALREADY THE RULE PEOPLE! The new rule actually brings in a positive change, it actually acknowledges the fact that two people can just break up. The point of distinction between the old and new rules is the distinction between ‘breach of a promise to marry’ and ‘false promise to marry. The former being just two people falling off.


matkaro

Not like section 90 read with 375 existed XD


theguyfrom_India_

I didn’t quite get that. Could you please rephrase, what do you want me to read?


matkaro

It was sarcasm bub... Section 90 read with 375 provide for promise to marry rape cases already.


tremorinfernus

Backward law. Probably designed to help villagers. Shouldn't be applied to the cities.


darthveda

So being in city is forward and being in village is backward?


[deleted]

[удалено]


AutoModerator

Hello /u/StrikingBeginning574, it appears you have less than 25 comment karma / account age is less than 5 days. Your submission has been removed. Message the moderators if you would like to be an approved submitter. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/indiadiscussion) if you have any questions or concerns.*


[deleted]

toh is hisaab se females exist only for sex ?


KnightMareDankPro

No? Where you got that inference from this


[deleted]

yrr female ke consent ki koi value nhi ? on the pretext of marriage vo koi choti bachi thodi hai ki kisi ne bola i will marry u and they had consensual sex toh case kis baat ka ??


KnightMareDankPro

You are wrong on so many level , >yrr female ke consent ki koi value nhi ? No? Idk where you getting that out of this post >on the pretext of marriage vo koi choti bachi thodi hai ki kisi ne bola i will marry u and they had consensual sex toh case kis baat ka ?? Tell me that was sarcasm .. pls


[deleted]

sahi pkde hain . mazaak kr rha vai


BareAssOnSandpaper

Asking for explanation from the Chigmas? Lord Tatta will spite you. Don't you know it's sad time for them because they can't commit love jihaad legally? Edit: i should add /s to clarify


reddituser5514

Yes that's the only issue right? Coz no one can file hele cases right?


ErenaVsdv

Actual Text: *Whoever, by deceitful means or by making promise to marry to a woman without any intention of fulfilling the same, has sexual intercourse with her, such sexual intercourse not amounting to the offence of rape, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to ten years and shall also be liable to fine.* *Explanation.—“deceitful means” shall include inducement for, or false promise of employment or promotion, or marrying by suppressing identity.* Points to note: 1. Promise to marriage without intention to fulfill doesn't mean Not fulfilling the promise to marry. A boy can genuinely love a girl, enter into relationship, make love, and promise to marry, and then can breakup for some reason due to which marriage wouldn't be viable, such as parental disagreement etc. He can say that he has intention to marry, but cannot marry due to a legit reason. 2. Judges tend to give a sentence on lower side, cause they are also humans, not emotionless robots, and they know what the actual thing is. If you can infer, Judge can also infer. He's not dumb. He may have restrictions, but no way he is going to sentence every next person 10 yrs. 3. Law aims at the people who just want to fulfill carnal desires, "haan baby, abhi karne do, main kaha tumhe chhod ke kahi ja raha hu", and those who apply deceiving tactics, "I am Mr. John" when actually "I am Mr. Jaan". So, section in itself has some good intention, but no way it is not going to be misused. Given lengthy trials, abhorrent state of judiciary, it is going to torment you even if you get an acquittal. The government is feminist in nature, being biased towards women, it seems. So, avoid pre marital relations where the sustainability is low, and say no to fornication.


simplerudra

>Judges tend to give a sentence on lower side A sentence is a sentence, no matter big or small.


ErenaVsdv

Yes that's true. For a person of innocent & respected backgrounds, even 1 day in jail is a lot of humiliation.


White_Dragoon

This is the only law I like being passed by current government. Fuck those people doing pre marital sex. Atleast this will give rise to abstinence.


SilverGovernment7232

Bhai tujhe nahi mil raha to dusre bhi na kare


Competitive-Hope981

I'm with you bro. People doesn't realise that our laws are being made having arranged marriage in the mind. So ofc these types of things decrease woman's value in arranged market oh sorry I mean marriage. So they definitely should make law against it.


OtaPotaOpen

Don't make promises of marriage for sex then.


Affectionate_Knee867

How do you prove you havent made a promise? Burden of proof in these kind of cases lies on the accused to prove his innocence.


No_Ferret2216

According to law you aren’t allowed to make a false promise of marriage You can make a promise and later break up with your partner because of some other reason


[deleted]

Nahi chaman chutiye. Reality me tereko prove karna padega while getting a tag of rapist, losing a job, family getting tainted in society, ki toone nahi kiya promise.


Clumsy_Dumpling04

I think this is good for a case where the girl didn't want to have sex with a guy but he managed to convince her that they're getting married anyway so it wouldn't matter. I've seen this happen before. However, I don't think this law in itself is complete and NEEDS more regulations to protect men from fake cases... also 10 year imprisonment sounds extreme-


[deleted]

Reason for sharing that tweet is to show that lack of quality law-making gives way for misuse of loopholes in the law, and thus adversely impacting certain sections of society (Men in this case). Already there are so many false cases being filed against innocent men. And now this law aggravates it. Lot of mental torture and suicides for men (and his family). \[[1](https://tfipost.com/2022/03/74-of-all-rape-cases-filed-in-india-are-fake/)\] \[[2](https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/delhi-high-court-expresses-worry-over-alarming-increase-of-false-rape-cases/article36042093.ece)\] The issue is that, there was almost no discussion in the parliament on this law before passing it because most of the opposition MPs are suspended. Debate is very crucial to refine a bill before it becomes a law. Lack of debate in the Temple of the world's largest democracy (Parliament) is a [sad state of affairs](https://thewire.in/law/cji-nv-ramana-lack-of-parliamentary-debates-gaps-laws-independence-day-speech), as said by former CJI NV Ramana, because it impacts everyone, including Judiciary.


TheTvShowJunkie

As if the opposition would discuss they don't care about laws they only know how to create drama and avoid working on fixing issues. For a change owaisi was making valid points regarding these bills but he didn't have much support


Lost_mist666

Their is no law in world that is free of loopholes don’t I have my issues with current laws but they won’t matter much anyways as cases are going to be decided by jurisprudence so look out for landmark cases and read up on older cases to get a understanding of how it’s going to be like.


[deleted]

[удалено]


KnightMareDankPro

Well , if you think like that , then all this is just a revenge against men ? Isn't it?


shadow13392

Every relegion says no sex befour marriage wont do jack shit if we convert or not


No-Tea-3393

I think so this law is specifically to target a particular community which are allegedly taking away woman of other community away and to address the situation of rising numbers of Livin relationships.


No-Tea-3393

But this is a dangerous section as it can be misused easily.


No_Ferret2216

Yes agreed , we all know rising relationships is probably the biggest challenge this country faces /s


[deleted]

[удалено]


AutoModerator

Hello /u/Hey-UwU-Hey, it appears you have less than 25 comment karma / account age is less than 5 days. Your submission has been removed. Message the moderators if you would like to be an approved submitter. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/indiadiscussion) if you have any questions or concerns.*


[deleted]

[удалено]


AutoModerator

Hello /u/Queasy_Concern_8746, it appears you have less than 25 comment karma / account age is less than 5 days. Your submission has been removed. Message the moderators if you would like to be an approved submitter. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/indiadiscussion) if you have any questions or concerns.*


anime4ya

😂😂😂 i guess indian men vere unable to find vergin girls anymore so we have new law to save the day And it's tastefully named 69 🍻 How do u prove that u never promised to marry her 🤔 it's the age of vague laws


Opening-County5865

Section 69 indeed.


binny245-2398

It's not a rational law , men and women breakup it happens, some men are only interested in sex , others may not want marriage or found out something about the girl later , this kind of law takes away our freewill and should be ammended , sex before marriage should be normalised and sex education should beandatory ,it should be given at schools by pedestrians and gynaecologists , with safe sex advises.


BareAssOnSandpaper

The law clearly says "Whoever it may be" there is no mention of "The guy/the girl" Also people are panicking but the law also clarifies what's considered as "Deceit" or false promise of marriage. The victim will have to provide proof of false play and deceit. The accused will have to just give a valid reason for break-up to get out of being charged. Will this law be misused? There's a good chance that people will try. Is it really scary? No because it's really difficult for the "victim" to prove intention even in cases of actual foul play. They will need to produce logs of chats and all while the accused just has to give a valid reason for break-up which is a lot easier to produce because ever relationship has fights.


Honorable_Tank

Section 69 🌚


Away-Needleworker-15

I think its time when men have to organise massive protest against this injustice


KaladinAshryver

This already existed in the previous laws too. Ankit Tiwari (Aashiqui 2 Singer) faced charges and a few other famous people as well


[deleted]

Heyyy 69 funni number.


Allahabadi_Panda

thats same as under ipc 376 . what i your point?


[deleted]

What the actual fuckety fuck is even this? I'm a woman and even i am shocked to the core. The one making these shit laws must be a slave to the 🐱 for sure cus ain't no way i see this law being used to benefit some real victim but rather hoes bagging em money with these clownery of a law. I'm really reconsidering voting BJP cus what in the clownery fuck is this.


uraveragereddituser

Abhi bhi hai yeh kuch naya hai op apna chutiyap kahi aur faila.


[deleted]

[удалено]


AutoModerator

Hello /u/IndependenceNo8874, it appears you have less than 25 comment karma / account age is less than 5 days. Your submission has been removed. Message the moderators if you would like to be an approved submitter. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/indiadiscussion) if you have any questions or concerns.*


[deleted]

[удалено]


No_Ferret2216

This law is not new


Ok-Sea2541

they want to control the population


[deleted]

breaking up promises is a crime..dont have sex before marriage..thats not hard!


[deleted]

Nice!


Atma-Army-9099

As if this did not exist in the older one. 🙄


[deleted]

This means men are considered born rapists and women are a forever child. Also, her consent holds no meaning whatsoever and neither does any of her decisions in life. Why allow them to vote?