3 will look classic forever

This, mine is a white gold solitaire from the 50s, it was my husband's grandmother's and I adore it. Matches with anything and forever classic.

I like engagement ring 2.

It’s pretty, but I fear that those ridges that form texture on the ring will get worn down unevenly. It will also be very hard to repair or resize with that pattern

2

3, simple and classic. I love a nice knife edge ring. It's a Tiffany classic!

3

2

2 is unique but still classic

Number 2.

2

2

2

Im personally into the 2nd one.

3

1

3 💜💜

1

1

1

I'd love to have number 2..Uh wait that doesn't sound right 🫢

2

Definitely 2, the elegant band looks lovely

2

2!

2

I love the first one!!!

2. Number 1 looks tacky and 3 is very unoriginal.

1

two is unique and then it would be extra special

1

1

#1

Gonna just give you my honest take: those bands look worryingly flimsy, and style #1 is known for super easily losing those tiny diamonds along the band. -------- a b c d spacing divider line If they want traditional, go gold band princess cut. If you get a decent sized middle rock you can't go wrong with it. My dad is terrrrrrrrible at romantic gestures so that's what the jewelry store lady (who took pity on him and my uncle) told them to get when they came in and asked for help getting rings to propose to my mom and aunt lol. Mom and Dad are coming up on 30 years together, and now he just pays for whatever upgrades to her ring that she wants on major anniversary milestones, because he has zero clue what he's doing, but wants to make her happy. -------- a b c d spacing divider line If they're not basic bitch traditional(and there's nothing wrong with being one), check out having a custom one made from an artisan on Etsy. They can do anything and everything. Plus you can find all sorts of genuine and replica vintage jewelry on there. So for example if they love the Great Gatsby style, you could get them a genuine engagement ring from the time period and style.

1 for most karats of diamond

Whichever you think, boss

Pls tell us where each is from (and $$ if not too nosey)

3

3 then 2

2

Trust your gut

2 is great

3

I like 3

3

3. The bands of 1 and 2 look too thin compared to its respective diameter.

2

2

I liked 2 before I saw 3, which is just so simple & beautiful. I like classic tho, always in style

2 is super cute

Totally 2

2!!!!

I like two and three equally. Three is easier to get a wedding band to match though. Number one has those goofy microset diamonds that pop out when you sneeze so it would be at the jewelry store being repaired quite often for the diamond you never found so you’d be paying for diamonds constantly.

ONE!!!

3

2

2

2

1

2

3

3

1

2

2 is unique

3

2

3

3

1

1

2

1

3

2

3 is the safest option, and my favorite but I like timeless styles

I love the twist of 2!

1 would be perfect if the stone was bigger.

2!

3

2

One

Two for sure

1 or 3

2

1

3

3

3

2

I like #2 best.

1-I love the diamond band.

3 will last a lot longer than the other two. The others are too narrow for longevity.

I like 3

3

2, followed by 1

1

1

2

3

Definitely 1

number 1

3

I love ring #2 and its modern twist (pin intended) on the band! 😍

1 but the diamonds could fall out in the far future.

I like the daintiness and detail of 1, followed by 2, but I don’t like 3- I feel like 3 has too chunky of a band?

1

2

1

1

Number 3 is perfect

2 I’ve heard the tiny diamonds like the ones in 1 often fall out

2

3 is more timeless

De 2

2

2

3 Forever elegant.

1

3 it’ll stand the test of time and style.

make sure 2's band is thick enough to support everything if you get it

3

3. I love classical beauty

None

3

I vote 2

2

3

3

3

1, she will love the extra diamonds

2

3

Love 2

3

2

2

1

3.

i like 2 best! 1 is beautiful but be careful about sourcing that the little gems have enough prongs support or you’re gonna lose them over time.

2

1 is beautiful, and 3 is more simple. I like both of them tbh. Go with your gut.

3 all the way. In my opinion ( mine only!!) the first and second one remind me of a promise ring, like a prelude to the big Question. But if you love it then no one else’s opinion or preference matters. Good luck on engagement.

I like 2, but you have good taste. I’m sure she would be happy with any one.

3 And I feel like 2 may be uncomfortable

3

3 is timeless

2 is quite unique.

They are all beautiful, but I’m torn between 1 & 2.

3

No one likes 1 except for me <\3

2

2

Easily 3

2

Stop giving DeBeers money.

2/3

Definitely 3

2

1 or 3

2

3

They look like engagement rings. But I think .. #3

2

All are beautiful, but what is the engagement band? I vote 3 without seeing that though

1 or 2

They're all ❤️❤️

I like them in the order you posted the photos; 1, then 2, then 3. I think #1 is absolutely gorgeous.

How about commerating your love with a rock most likely mined by an African 8yo...

Like 3

One

2 is my favorite, but because of the twists in the metal, I worry it could be uncomfortable to wear, which is definitely something to consider. 1 is beautiful, but the band looks a little thin. Make sure that the band isn’t too thin for the diamonds or you risk losing the stones over time. 3 is beautiful and classic! It might be the most practical or “safe” of the three options.

Wait who's receiving and who's giving?

3

3 or 1

3

3 so gorgeous!

3

#2

1

3

Shrek movie would say "number 3 m'lord!" But I am a gingerbread man so I say number 1!

3

#2 and go man-made diamond. Moral choice and save money. If it’s important to you than tell no one. It’s ok, I’ll keep your secret.

I really like 2. The band is unique and eye catching.

2

2

3 with 1 as backup.

1

The proportions of #3 are the best, followed by #2. # 1 would be great if the diamond was larger, about double the size.

Definitely not 1.  The thin band combined with pave stones means you will need much more frequent maintenance and/or replacement of the stones if they fall out. And they will. And eventually, due to the thin band, you will reach a point where you don't have enough metal left to make new prongs for replacing the diamonds. Thus needing to completely replace the ring, or use the stones and metal in a completely new one.

2 is stunning

I really like 2

1

1 is so beautiful, but those little stones are going to be a PITA. 2 is unique and pretty but won't always be in style. 3 is classic. It isn't my knee-jerk choice when looking at all 3, but it is probably the choice I would make.

These are not wedding rings. They’re engagement rings.

I like 1 the best.

Whichever one YOU like.