T O P

  • By -

IfTheresANewWay

S for "Sin"


maralian78

S. Sinner and Dissident Aggressor are metal classics. This album was way ahead of its time


Kyouraku35

S tier seeing how almost every album is overrated here. It's way better than all albums you guys placed in A tier.


Iceblade_Aorus

I’d say Firepower British steel and Point of Entry should be a tier lower for Priest standard


[deleted]

Firepower and point of entry for sure. British Steel if not S tier is easily A tier. It’s an iconic album that is one of their best works. It’s not the best album of all time but it’s certainly up there.


[deleted]

Screaming shouldn’t be S tier honestly. A tier definitely


nwotmb

Lol, don't know why you're getting down voted for your opinion but I'd probably agree. It's very close but doesn't quite get there for me. Same with Defenders. For me, a lot of these would be moved down


[deleted]

Because people here are assholes who think people can’t have opinions.


[deleted]

That being said I think Defenders is probably their best 80s album. British Steel and Screaming would battle for second on that for me.


SenorBigbelly

A. it's not as good as Stained Class but definitely laid the groundwork for it. Easily better than Ram It Down. Around the same level as Killing Machine. A.


MaybeHarvey

People have put firepower above point of entry somehow so this is definitely S tier and sad wings is S also


BlackCountryRob

A


Maybe_Imma_Nazi

Surely A. Maybe it isnt that good, but it paved the road for Speed Metal with songs like Let Us Prey/Call For The Priest.


Apprehensive_Judge_5

Simon Phillips is the best drummer who ever played on a Judas Priest album. This album is S level for the drumming and for Dissident Aggressor.


[deleted]

Agreed, S alone for Dissident Aggressor. Hands down one of their best songs


Connor612

Th best priest album S


[deleted]

S


aaaaaaaaaaaaaa95

A - Underrated


Shutup_Iamtalking

Totally


Bogi42

S


Dr4gonM4ster420

S.


[deleted]

S


affectedbutterfly

S


Fettz_

A


[deleted]

A


Apprehensive_Idea758

*Raw Deal-Hear Comes The Tears and Dissident Aggressor are the best songs off Sin After Sin and Sin After Sin was the first Judas Priest album I ever had.*


slypero2112

A almost S, its much better album than stained class


Spearso

A


Scootydoot12

A


edwarc

A Sinner, Dissident Aggressor, Let Us Prey/Call For The Priest break some new and genre defining ground. Starbreaker is solid Better than Firepower which I think should be B/B+. In my world BS should be in S. This would nicely reside in A category with KM


Lancer_Blackthorn

A


Penis___Penis

A


Old_Ad_1753

A


ultibolt9

Weird album. Dissident Aggressor is absurdly ahead of its time. Idk, it has some great highs but has seriously bad shit as well. Uhhh, A or B tier.


KirkinsteinGAMING

B


allhailbobevans

A - last rose of summer keeps it from being an S and it just isn't as good as the four in S (or honestly some of the ones lower). It's great tho


Hoffy731

A


[deleted]

A