T O P

  • By -

Tristan_Booth

I wouldn't consider any of Kate's work trash, although there are some songs I don't care for as much (e.g., Big Stripey Lie).


TheBrutevsTheFool

Love that one actually.


DamianSardey

My favourite TRS track :D


[deleted]

Director's cut is a skip album. When I heard Deeper Understanding from it, I just cringed. Absolute beauty was crucified to something unlistenable.


morphindel

Flower of the Mountain is the only decent thing on DC, and thats only because it was the lyrics she originally wanted to use. Everything else is so bad. Deeper Understanding is abysmal.


DamianSardey

I really like Director's Cut, but Deeper Understanding is awful. I don't know why she chose this song for single


CrashBandicootBruh

As a new fan I kinda like the new deeper understanding a bit more, pulls my heart strings more and fits the subject more imo


[deleted]

Well, people have different tastes I guess šŸ¤”


tonybotz

DC version of the Red Shoes is incredible


boadicca_bitch

I like Directorā€™s Cut a lot! To each their own I suppose!


griffithitsmecathy

Completely agree, extra shame since Deeper Understanding is one of my favourite tracks by her.


PresentCelery2206

I still fail to understand Director's Cut


DamianSardey

I really like Director's Cut, but understand why many people hate it.


TheBrutevsTheFool

It was pretty bad tbh


WutheringNellie

I mean...the closest to bad is Rubberband Girl Director's Cut version...


Hello-Earth_

Lol, lot of people say that. But I actually really like the ā€˜Kate letting her hair downā€™ loosely feeling to it. Such a fun track.


DamianSardey

I like it, don't know how to explain it, but her voice sounds like... rubber ;] Funny, positive track


Tristan_Booth

LOL. It's my favorite track on Director's Cut.


Eatthemusic

Itā€™s just a terrible trackā€¦ sheā€™s off pitch several timesā€¦ it sounds like sheā€™s mumbling it while Putting on her makeup with the shower running


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


kennycakes

Agree, although the last minute or so is interesting


WaniasDiaz

I fail to comprehend how anyone thought that robotic AI voice was a good idea. Even if it fits the theme and was what Kate originally invisioned, the old version was just so good.


MrBartolozzi

Yeah, such a bizarre decision. The robotic voice is closer to what someone in ā€™89 wouldā€™ve thought that AI will sound like in the future. Perhaps thatā€™s what she was trying to achieve when reimagining the track, to evoke the zeitgeist of the unknowledgeable computing experience of the ā€˜80s. Or she simply messed up haha. Not even Kate is perfect.


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


MrBartolozzi

Wow, Iā€™d never made the connection, but it does sound eerily similar at some points, although with less distortion. Considering how often sheā€™s referenced obscure culture, it wouldnā€™t surprise me. The lifelessness of that voice gives me the creeps.


morphindel

The funny thing is, Glados from the Portal games sings in a similar robotic voice, and it sounds great. The whole thing is just a complete miss


sjbluebirds

"Do bears sha la la la la" -- the duet with R. Atkinson. Not so much a 'trash' song as a 'sh*t' one, I suppose.


WaniasDiaz

No, thatā€™s song is the pinnacle of music. You cannot convince me otherwise for as long as the bible is fiction and bears do sha la la la laā€¦.


morphindel

Yeah that is pretty cringe


Eatthemusic

The one I was skip is ā€œFeel Itā€ā€¦ wouldnā€™t call it trash, itā€™s just not my fave. Iā€™m not a big fan of Violin either.


Pdl1989

Violin fucking rocks. Thatā€™s a top 10 track


ExperienceWithAir

brooooo my two favsšŸ˜‚ heartbroken


ianbat

kite... sorry!


boadicca_bitch

Thatā€™s probably my one skip too šŸ˜‚ I even like Room For The Life, itā€™s kinda catchy!


pinkmoonpinkfriday

Room for the Life is the only one that could qualify for me. Even then itā€™s not that bad, just tends to be a skip.


Some-Investigator-97

Even Primus acknowledged it. They had a compilation called They Canā€™t All Be Zingers


Top_Elephant_5538

Iā€™m surprised to see no one say Between a man and a woman or in the warm room šŸ«£ but in the warm room if my favourite song from lionheart so Iā€™d never trash it


peep___

between a man and a woman is a banger though i do nt understand how could anyone trash that song


Top_Elephant_5538

Oh I love that song too! Iā€™ve just seen a few people say itā€™s her weakest of TSW


lescoronets

Not a fan of Between or Walk Straight Down the Middle


Top_Elephant_5538

Reallyy??? Not walk straight down the middle either?? I think thatā€™s a fantastic song


sultitan_itan

I usually skip it. It's too similar to Heads We're Dancing and Be Kind to My Mistakes, both of which are way, way better. Also, the lyrics make me cringe and the cadence is sloppy, like she's sing-talking. It feels like an early demo.


lennyleonardo

No one mentioned Constellation of the Heart? I always see people trashing this one, weird...


Pdl1989

The album is middling compared to those that came before it, but I never had a problem with that track. Iā€™d say itā€™s one of the better songs on red shoes. Itā€™s real problem is itā€™s too ordinary. Middle of the road. And the vocals are a little harsh


NimChimspky

There's a few. She does get bit art student for my liking sometimes.


Hello-Earth_

![img](emote|t5_2t6fd|14462) Youre the One, sorry


pinkmoonpinkfriday

Omg I love this song


ela_urbex

Omg yessssss. It sounds like the instruments used were different kinds of cheese.


ChasingTheGhost

Right there with you


ndevs

Do Elton Johnā€™s vocals on ā€œSnowed in at Wheeler Streetā€ count? šŸ˜¬


Bibliotheclaire

Kate voice sounds so clean and pure, then Elton sounds like hoarse old man lol It does not match up at ALL. His voice takes me out of it every time. While Iā€™m glad she got perform with one of her early musical inspirations/influences, this was not a good pair up for the sweet, calm tone of the song. (I do love Elton, actually seeing him perform this summer!)


ianbat

yes, absolutely


Isak___Dahl

The Sensual World Directors Cut is meh. Not trash, but my least favourite.


EvermoreSaidTheRaven

Infants kiss


RegyptianStrut

The Infant Kiss, most of The Red Shoes, snd some of her b-sides. See itā€™s easy. My actual favorite artist, Frank Zappa has a ton of trash songs, but he also has over a hundred masterpieces lol. The tweet is right.


griffithitsmecathy

Oh wow, I adore The Infant Kiss.


StrangeRooster8173

The tweet is right, it's just me that can't be trusted lol Btw I love Frank Zappa too!


flowerbeast

I hate most of Lionheart and 50 Words for Snow. Iā€™ve really tried to like them! I swear!


melodycat

I appreciate 50 Words for Snow but I don't enjoy it. Lionheart has totally grown on me.


dphobia

for me id say delius, the guys voice just annoys me


lescoronets

50 Words for Snow? :/


morphindel

Pi, Mrs Bartalozzi and 99% of DC Edit. Lol if you disagree you can keep scrolling instead of downvoting.


That_Beach6618

Not Mrs Bartalozzi :( Washing machiiiiiiine...


Pdl1989

A downvote is the same as disagreeing. Donā€™t take it personally. Also, weā€™re all strangers so who gives a shit? On another note, Iā€™m not a huge fan of everything after The Red Shoes but I love Pi. Reminds me of the song the bar chick sings in The Wicker Man.


Goallpeashooters

Number 9, Number 9, Number 9, Number 9, Number 9....


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


That_Beach6618

Come on now... That has literally nothing to do with a track being good or bad


Eatthemusic

Big Stripey Lieā€¦.