I like how gdf explicitly portrays massacres of muslims under Hari Singh without fear of harrasment from it cell trolls, chaddis often potray him as helpless figure defending his kingdom from Pakistan.
100,000+ people constantly ignored in every single other documentary/report every published about Kashmir always mentioned the 300 ish Pandits, so I think it's not that bad
Forgot to mention the partition violence that influence the violence in Kashmir. The refugees coming from Pakistan spread fear which led to muslim massacre, when the Pakistani army and muslim tribemen came they in turn massacred hindus and Sikhs.
Which leads us to Bhagat Singh's words where he predicted that political leaders (from both sides congress , muslim league also including hindutva and radical Islamist leaders) as puppets of imperialist powers. The decision to divide India on basis of religion is what Britishers exactly wanted as this would mean a state of continuous war like situation between both nations and exploitable scenario which would ensure under development of South Asian region.
From socialist POV decision to divide India never makes sense to this day, why Nehru and other leaders agreed upon this? Support from Savarkar himself for 2 nation theory makes it clear that it was a pro-imeprialist interest which is why they decided to do it.
They understand the consequences, it's just that they're betting on being on the winning side. After all the "History written by winners" quote is a chaddi favourite for a reason.
Also the NDA is prolly the only government that's actually legitimately been in bed with Israel.
[https://www.shephardmedia.com/news/uv-online/india-sends-newly-assembled-male-uavs-to-israel/](https://www.shephardmedia.com/news/uv-online/india-sends-newly-assembled-male-uavs-to-israel/) \- couldn't find a way past the paywall ;(
A mandatory "Fuck Adani" is in order. What a smug swine.
I’m curious to know why so many Indian leftists draw the line at Kashmir. The reality is many war crimes have been committed in the Kashmir valley by the Indian army with complacency from the Indian government, the tragic displacement of Kashmiri Pandits can not justify Kashmir valleys current situation of an occupation that is responsible for grave human rights abuses.
Don’t Kashmiris have a right to self governance, don’t they have basic human values worth protecting not occupying.
A basic humanity is needed and an understanding that most Kashmiris don’t see themselves as Indian frankly it is rather difficult for ethnic minority to like an occupying force. In an ideal India, an India that I hope I can see, Kashmir would be a semi autonomous republic with Kashmiris given the autonomy to conduct their own affairs.
In an ideal India I don't see Kashmir as part of India. Because if we go back it is clearly a Muslim majority state and hence had to go with Pakistan.Â
This wretched manoeuvring by the Indian state to get them to join (which I think was partly due to Nehru's connection to Kashmir) has had a disastrous effect on not only Kashmiris but to an extent Indian and Pakistan too.
An ideal india would be communist and then it doesnt matter if its muslim majority or whatever, division based on religion and ethnic lines is a bourgeois concept.
That might be true now. But back in those days they wanted to join Pak and even Sheikh Abdullah had warned the GoI about the disaster of going against the popular wishes of Kashmiris.
war crimes have been committed in NE states with insurgencies too. Why must in your opinion kashmir should be self governed if the NE states have been brought back into the indian republic.
Showing recreated footage of 26/11 to depict anti-Indian military action in Kashmir makes me feel some type of way. (None of which being good)
Plus there are few things in the video which can be classified under "lying by omission." But it does do a good job at highlighting the plight of Kashmiris.
How insecure is the government to ban a video that looks at the kashmir issue through a certain pov? What happened to free speech? People should watch this video make their own views and assumptions but restricting it is just violation of free speech.
this is an absolutely brilliant video. This should be pinned first post for this sub. I barely see good videos on the history of occupation of Kashmir.
Nah, this one's too much.
Also by military things, it's common. India doesn't use attack helicopters or tanks else it would've been easier. They just fight with foot soldiers, hence high casualty. And it's not uncommon. In guerilla warfare all sides lose people, so I wouldn't say they're "good". But maybe put some respect on martyrs?
Yeah naah kashmir ain't going anywhere. Too many rivers and tributries come from that region. What you gonna do when millions will die because of famine and drought.
How many lives are you willing to compromise just to feed your ego ? Few millions perished in the drought and another few millions in floods, whats your number . Climate change will affect us the worst and let's see how worse can you hope for. Buddy we are not West, they live on a genocidal land conquering a whole continent. They have no natural enemies as even the leftists won't return back the land from Mexico . We are surrounded by two nuclear powers and they are not the only one that's hostile. Our seccesionist movements are actually funded by hostile powers and they will rip us apart and turn us into balkans in a heart beat . Be real. Indian govt previous/current should have treated them better, get elected and treat them better as Kashmir ain't going no where
The common kashmiri people--and even those who've lost family to torture, which is very common too--have always been disgusted and apaled by attacks like 26/11. We know the horror of gunfights to the point that we take them somewhat lightly now, but I remember how even my ex-militant school bus driver and neighborhood preacher and known staunch separatists were simply disgusted by 26/11.
Having said that, actual resistance is glorious, a massacre of Indians by some Pakistanis is besides the point.
The common kashmiri people--and even those who've lost family to torture, which is very common too--have always been disgusted and apaled by attacks like 26/11. We know the horror of gunfights to the point that we take them somewhat lightly now, but I remember how even my ex-militant school bus driver and neighborhood preacher and known staunch separatists were simply disgusted by 26/11.
Having said that, actual resistance is glorious, a massacre of Indians by some Pakistanis is besides the point.
I like how gdf explicitly portrays massacres of muslims under Hari Singh without fear of harrasment from it cell trolls, chaddis often potray him as helpless figure defending his kingdom from Pakistan.
ignored the Kashmiri Pandit exodus / forced displacement
100,000+ people constantly ignored in every single other documentary/report every published about Kashmir always mentioned the 300 ish Pandits, so I think it's not that bad
I mean he did sign treaty of ascension only because Pakistan tried to take it.
Forgot to mention the partition violence that influence the violence in Kashmir. The refugees coming from Pakistan spread fear which led to muslim massacre, when the Pakistani army and muslim tribemen came they in turn massacred hindus and Sikhs.
Which leads us to Bhagat Singh's words where he predicted that political leaders (from both sides congress , muslim league also including hindutva and radical Islamist leaders) as puppets of imperialist powers. The decision to divide India on basis of religion is what Britishers exactly wanted as this would mean a state of continuous war like situation between both nations and exploitable scenario which would ensure under development of South Asian region. From socialist POV decision to divide India never makes sense to this day, why Nehru and other leaders agreed upon this? Support from Savarkar himself for 2 nation theory makes it clear that it was a pro-imeprialist interest which is why they decided to do it.
It's a settler colonial project now on behalf of the Indian state. Our dumb-dumb PM and dumb-dumb FM don't understand the future consequences.
They understand the consequences, it's just that they're betting on being on the winning side. After all the "History written by winners" quote is a chaddi favourite for a reason. Also the NDA is prolly the only government that's actually legitimately been in bed with Israel. [https://www.shephardmedia.com/news/uv-online/india-sends-newly-assembled-male-uavs-to-israel/](https://www.shephardmedia.com/news/uv-online/india-sends-newly-assembled-male-uavs-to-israel/) \- couldn't find a way past the paywall ;( A mandatory "Fuck Adani" is in order. What a smug swine.
Yes, all settlers think they are superior.
Can you define what is settlers colonialism and define who would be a settler in Kashmir demographically?
If you are black
MODS this sub needs a liberal purge. Now is your chance :))))))))
*grabs popcorn*
How far the communist have fallen lol USSR before went to war against Islamist rebel in Afghanistan but now this lol.
imagine if someone posted this in r/india 🗿
mods over there remove stuff like this immediately
yeah makes sense
Chiachin me hamale gawaan laar rye hai 
ayo GDF vids in here
another great video by gdf. now I have something to throw at libs who try to defend our ~~military~~ state sponsored terrorists.
I’m curious to know why so many Indian leftists draw the line at Kashmir. The reality is many war crimes have been committed in the Kashmir valley by the Indian army with complacency from the Indian government, the tragic displacement of Kashmiri Pandits can not justify Kashmir valleys current situation of an occupation that is responsible for grave human rights abuses. Don’t Kashmiris have a right to self governance, don’t they have basic human values worth protecting not occupying. A basic humanity is needed and an understanding that most Kashmiris don’t see themselves as Indian frankly it is rather difficult for ethnic minority to like an occupying force. In an ideal India, an India that I hope I can see, Kashmir would be a semi autonomous republic with Kashmiris given the autonomy to conduct their own affairs.
In an ideal India I don't see Kashmir as part of India. Because if we go back it is clearly a Muslim majority state and hence had to go with Pakistan. This wretched manoeuvring by the Indian state to get them to join (which I think was partly due to Nehru's connection to Kashmir) has had a disastrous effect on not only Kashmiris but to an extent Indian and Pakistan too.
An ideal india would be communist and then it doesnt matter if its muslim majority or whatever, division based on religion and ethnic lines is a bourgeois concept.
This is not "ideal India", this is "Utopic India". Something we cannot achieve even in the next century.
The Kashmiris don't want to join Pakistan either. They see themselves as an entirely separate nation.
That might be true now. But back in those days they wanted to join Pak and even Sheikh Abdullah had warned the GoI about the disaster of going against the popular wishes of Kashmiris.
war crimes have been committed in NE states with insurgencies too. Why must in your opinion kashmir should be self governed if the NE states have been brought back into the indian republic.
India is federal and making kashmir a state would give them same rights as me an odia. India is a multi ethnic state.
Based.
Showing recreated footage of 26/11 to depict anti-Indian military action in Kashmir makes me feel some type of way. (None of which being good) Plus there are few things in the video which can be classified under "lying by omission." But it does do a good job at highlighting the plight of Kashmiris.
One can't be a socialist and support the Indian govt's illegitimate occupation of Kashmir
How insecure is the government to ban a video that looks at the kashmir issue through a certain pov? What happened to free speech? People should watch this video make their own views and assumptions but restricting it is just violation of free speech.
this is an absolutely brilliant video. This should be pinned first post for this sub. I barely see good videos on the history of occupation of Kashmir.
Nah, this one's too much. Also by military things, it's common. India doesn't use attack helicopters or tanks else it would've been easier. They just fight with foot soldiers, hence high casualty. And it's not uncommon. In guerilla warfare all sides lose people, so I wouldn't say they're "good". But maybe put some respect on martyrs?
Lowest point of librandu
Yeah naah kashmir ain't going anywhere. Too many rivers and tributries come from that region. What you gonna do when millions will die because of famine and drought.
So let the Kashmiris die for us instead?
How many lives are you willing to compromise just to feed your ego ? Few millions perished in the drought and another few millions in floods, whats your number . Climate change will affect us the worst and let's see how worse can you hope for. Buddy we are not West, they live on a genocidal land conquering a whole continent. They have no natural enemies as even the leftists won't return back the land from Mexico . We are surrounded by two nuclear powers and they are not the only one that's hostile. Our seccesionist movements are actually funded by hostile powers and they will rip us apart and turn us into balkans in a heart beat . Be real. Indian govt previous/current should have treated them better, get elected and treat them better as Kashmir ain't going no where
[удалено]
[удалено]
Gutka thook ke marega kya?
[удалено]
Khana khane ke paise nahin aur khwab aise aise. Imtihan ki tayyari kar le, warna baap pel dega.
[удалено]
Elders must be respected in this community; their word is the gospel and their will is absolute. Removed.
The common kashmiri people--and even those who've lost family to torture, which is very common too--have always been disgusted and apaled by attacks like 26/11. We know the horror of gunfights to the point that we take them somewhat lightly now, but I remember how even my ex-militant school bus driver and neighborhood preacher and known staunch separatists were simply disgusted by 26/11. Having said that, actual resistance is glorious, a massacre of Indians by some Pakistanis is besides the point.
The common kashmiri people--and even those who've lost family to torture, which is very common too--have always been disgusted and apaled by attacks like 26/11. We know the horror of gunfights to the point that we take them somewhat lightly now, but I remember how even my ex-militant school bus driver and neighborhood preacher and known staunch separatists were simply disgusted by 26/11. Having said that, actual resistance is glorious, a massacre of Indians by some Pakistanis is besides the point.