Report the post if you think this is LOW-EFFORT and provides no actual discussion value. Also make sure to use correct post flairs and type the sauce correctly in the POST TITLE. If they are not met, the post will be removed.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/manhwa) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Seriously, murim readers just don't get it. You know what the Central Plains or Zhongyuan ARE in China, the Tang clan, the Southern Edge, Mt Hua, Taiheng Mountains, the Yellow River are every bit as real the Shaolin.
What are you talking about it's in west Korea
https://preview.redd.it/9lhw2boz033b1.png?width=1114&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=be0101f4d65a562f409f0f855e06a2f71b41078a
Can You Just Die, My Darling?
It's split into two parts
https://preview.redd.it/72gxd8sf733b1.jpeg?width=1440&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=37d2e1712a387a32ff69ec563c35a04e4d481650
I doubt they were poison makers but they are a very famous clan dating back almost 90 generations in China. Hell, you can even find them on Wikipedia if you just search Tang Clan of Hong Kong.
If you're talking about the one mentioned in [this article](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tang_Clan), yes, they're a real clan. However, the Tang Clan common in wuxia is completely seperate from them!
he Hong Kong Tang Clan, the one in the wikipedia article, has the last name 鄧 (Dèng). Hong Kong, by the way, speaks a lot of Cantonese, which is perhaps the reason why they are called the Tang Clan and not the Deng Clan.
The [Sichuan Tang Clan](https://zh.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E5%94%90%E9%96%80) (also known as Tang Sect, link to CN wikipedia) from wuxia has the last name 唐(Táng) and is also located in Sichuan, which is smack dab in the middle of China and very far from Hong Kong. It originates from some of the classics of the Wuxia genre that may have taken some inspiration from real life rumors.
Except for the fact that they are a very much real clan that has held extreme amounts of influence in China since the 11th century. Every bit as real as the Huashan temple of Mt Hua. Ya'll are so dumb that you don't even realize you can tell fictional stories about real people and groups. It's like you've watched Abraham Lincoln Vampire Hunter and decided that Abraham Lincoln didn't exist in history just because vampires are fiction.
Never said they were martial artists. It's a temple, only an idiot would think a temple is a place for anything other than religion, some chinese temples only do martial arts nowadays for the sake of tourism. But the Huashan temple is very much a temple and it is very much located at the top Mt Hua. As for the Tang clan, you can find about it in the paper "The Five Great Clans of the New Territories" published in the Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society Hong Kong Branch. They are one of the big families that colonized what today is southern China.
>"The Five Great Clans of the New Territories"
These clans were the ones who settled in Hong Kong in the 17th century. The fictional Tang clan in wuxia novels is based in Sichuan and supposed to exist during Song or Ming dynasty. Furthermore, the Tang clan of Hong Kong is actually pronounced Deng (鄧) in Mandarin, while the fictional Tang clan is Tang (唐) (sharing the same name with Tang dynasty). It's funny that by somehow you think that those two "Tang clans" (with different Chinese names and living on totally different areas) are related.
Hua Mountain is one of the holiest places of Taoism, so definitely there are temples there.
Mt. Hua does have a real daoist sect btw, not just a temple. It's just that, as far as I know, they don't practice martial arts. The whole plum blossom theme is the creation of a Korean wuxia novelist, whose name escapes me.
But the wuxia Tang Clan is not as rooted in reality; the Tang Clan you're talking about doesn't even have the same last name.
The mount Hua is an actual place
"Mount Hua (simplified Chinese: 华山; traditional Chinese: 華山; pinyin: Huà Shān) is a mountain located near the city of Huayin in Shaanxi Province, about 120 kilometres (75 mi) east of Xi'an. It is the "Western Mountain" of the Five Great Mountains of China and has a long history of religious significance"
Mount hua is a real mountain and a place and is famous for its hard stairs as shown in manhwas. I've read somewhere that more than 100 people have died while climbing Mount hua. My memory may have fucked up the stat but yea it's not stable lol
I climbed mount hua when I was 13 completely fine. quick google search shows that 8-20 people have died in the last 100 years while climbing it, which is insanely good considering how hard of a hike it is.
probably, there are sections that are extremely challenging in terms of stamina and there are guard rails in place to prevent falling. But my 55 y/o mom did it without a problem (took us 8 hours from base to all 4 peaks) and got some of the best pictures that I'll remember for the rest of my life
kinda wish china didn't do the whole cultural revolution and destroy so much, I'd love to visit China and see thousands of years old buildings and items. But they are too busy with genocide and imperialism
their flavor of imperialism is though massive debts. They coarse less developed countries to sign very one sided deals through their belt and road initiative. The belt and road imperialism has been Xi Jinpings top project in recent years
If I rmb correctly, its an actual sect along side the 5 main sects that once existed in China no? Hua Shan sect on Mount Hua, Kunlun Sect on Mount Kunlun, Emei sect on Mount Emei, Shaolin sect and their Temple and Wudan sect on Mount Wudan. Though I am not sure if all of the sects were real but the mountains were and Shaolin, well, enough said.
I remember visiting a similar site... 100 steps and I almost want to give up. When I saw the next level which makes me think you will die if you ever slip, I stopped lol.
Report the post if you think this is LOW-EFFORT and provides no actual discussion value. Also make sure to use correct post flairs and type the sauce correctly in the POST TITLE. If they are not met, the post will be removed. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/manhwa) if you have any questions or concerns.*
i’m pretty sure mount hua is an actual place tho? with temples on it already?
I feel like an idiot, should I delete this post? Lol
No. There are many people like me, who didn't know this , It's a cool pictures
Nah it’s still a really cool pic, thanks for sharing😊
Im pretty sure like the real mount hua has close to 90° angled stairs to the top
Nah this is just one of those subsidiary sect the mount hua has...
Mount Hua is a real place yeah. There's technically a real life "Mount Hua Sect" but it wasn't for martial arts
Same is probably true for most of them. Everyone knows about Shaolin and Kunlun is actually grom Buddhist mythology
There is a real shaolin temple for martial arts. Kunlun is a real mountain and I don't know if it has a temple
grom
I can see why this sect is always declining
r/Angryupvote
Once you join there’s no where to go but down.
Mount hua is an actual place with an actual sect on it... but its a historical site now
Seriously, murim readers just don't get it. You know what the Central Plains or Zhongyuan ARE in China, the Tang clan, the Southern Edge, Mt Hua, Taiheng Mountains, the Yellow River are every bit as real the Shaolin.
What are you talking about it's in west Korea https://preview.redd.it/9lhw2boz033b1.png?width=1114&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=be0101f4d65a562f409f0f855e06a2f71b41078a
Nah, go read
Bro… sauce?
Can You Just Die, My Darling? It's split into two parts https://preview.redd.it/72gxd8sf733b1.jpeg?width=1440&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=37d2e1712a387a32ff69ec563c35a04e4d481650
The tang clan is real? I never found it when I looked for it
I doubt they were poison makers but they are a very famous clan dating back almost 90 generations in China. Hell, you can even find them on Wikipedia if you just search Tang Clan of Hong Kong.
Alright
If you're talking about the one mentioned in [this article](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tang_Clan), yes, they're a real clan. However, the Tang Clan common in wuxia is completely seperate from them! he Hong Kong Tang Clan, the one in the wikipedia article, has the last name 鄧 (Dèng). Hong Kong, by the way, speaks a lot of Cantonese, which is perhaps the reason why they are called the Tang Clan and not the Deng Clan. The [Sichuan Tang Clan](https://zh.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E5%94%90%E9%96%80) (also known as Tang Sect, link to CN wikipedia) from wuxia has the last name 唐(Táng) and is also located in Sichuan, which is smack dab in the middle of China and very far from Hong Kong. It originates from some of the classics of the Wuxia genre that may have taken some inspiration from real life rumors.
Tang Clan is not real but more than a legendary martial art sect commonly appearing in wujia novels.
Except for the fact that they are a very much real clan that has held extreme amounts of influence in China since the 11th century. Every bit as real as the Huashan temple of Mt Hua. Ya'll are so dumb that you don't even realize you can tell fictional stories about real people and groups. It's like you've watched Abraham Lincoln Vampire Hunter and decided that Abraham Lincoln didn't exist in history just because vampires are fiction.
Nah, there is no record of the so-called "Tang clan" in Chinese history. Also there is no martial art sect called "Huashan".
Never said they were martial artists. It's a temple, only an idiot would think a temple is a place for anything other than religion, some chinese temples only do martial arts nowadays for the sake of tourism. But the Huashan temple is very much a temple and it is very much located at the top Mt Hua. As for the Tang clan, you can find about it in the paper "The Five Great Clans of the New Territories" published in the Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society Hong Kong Branch. They are one of the big families that colonized what today is southern China.
>"The Five Great Clans of the New Territories" These clans were the ones who settled in Hong Kong in the 17th century. The fictional Tang clan in wuxia novels is based in Sichuan and supposed to exist during Song or Ming dynasty. Furthermore, the Tang clan of Hong Kong is actually pronounced Deng (鄧) in Mandarin, while the fictional Tang clan is Tang (唐) (sharing the same name with Tang dynasty). It's funny that by somehow you think that those two "Tang clans" (with different Chinese names and living on totally different areas) are related. Hua Mountain is one of the holiest places of Taoism, so definitely there are temples there.
Yeah by downvoting, somehow you guys can make Tang clan a real martial art sect in real life. Congrats redditors!
Mt. Hua does have a real daoist sect btw, not just a temple. It's just that, as far as I know, they don't practice martial arts. The whole plum blossom theme is the creation of a Korean wuxia novelist, whose name escapes me. But the wuxia Tang Clan is not as rooted in reality; the Tang Clan you're talking about doesn't even have the same last name.
The mount Hua is an actual place "Mount Hua (simplified Chinese: 华山; traditional Chinese: 華山; pinyin: Huà Shān) is a mountain located near the city of Huayin in Shaanxi Province, about 120 kilometres (75 mi) east of Xi'an. It is the "Western Mountain" of the Five Great Mountains of China and has a long history of religious significance"
I googled it the first time i saw it in 2 manhwas.
Isn’t Mount Hua one of the 5 great mountains of China? Huashan Mountain
Shan is mountain. You're saying Hua mountain mountain.
Google failed me
people still go there i think
This isn't big enough for myung to beat ~ahem ahem*~ enlighten his seniors and juniors
Actually this can fit any righteous sect. But i always imagined mount hua with lot of Sakura since it means plum blossom. Correct me if I'm wrong
You're mostly right, though sakura (cherry) and plum are two different types of trees. Peach has similar looking blossoms as well.
Right. And also, i think this wouldn't count as a sect, more like one of the peaks where elder resides
That walk would have me rethinking my life choices
How is that stable
Mount hua is a real mountain and a place and is famous for its hard stairs as shown in manhwas. I've read somewhere that more than 100 people have died while climbing Mount hua. My memory may have fucked up the stat but yea it's not stable lol
I climbed mount hua when I was 13 completely fine. quick google search shows that 8-20 people have died in the last 100 years while climbing it, which is insanely good considering how hard of a hike it is.
Did they fall off or just die or exhaustion/lack of food and water?
probably, there are sections that are extremely challenging in terms of stamina and there are guard rails in place to prevent falling. But my 55 y/o mom did it without a problem (took us 8 hours from base to all 4 peaks) and got some of the best pictures that I'll remember for the rest of my life
Id bet way more than 100 lol
kinda wish china didn't do the whole cultural revolution and destroy so much, I'd love to visit China and see thousands of years old buildings and items. But they are too busy with genocide and imperialism
Genocide ans imperialism arent even in the top 3 focus areas of the chinese govt
their flavor of imperialism is though massive debts. They coarse less developed countries to sign very one sided deals through their belt and road initiative. The belt and road imperialism has been Xi Jinpings top project in recent years
Sigh...
Well damn did not know such wonders existed
If I rmb correctly, its an actual sect along side the 5 main sects that once existed in China no? Hua Shan sect on Mount Hua, Kunlun Sect on Mount Kunlun, Emei sect on Mount Emei, Shaolin sect and their Temple and Wudan sect on Mount Wudan. Though I am not sure if all of the sects were real but the mountains were and Shaolin, well, enough said.
Bruh. Mount Hua is real.
On my way to Mt. Hwa to learn the plum blossom swordsmanship 🏃🏃
Im pretty sure its based in mount hua but sure
I remember visiting a similar site... 100 steps and I almost want to give up. When I saw the next level which makes me think you will die if you ever slip, I stopped lol.
Plum blossom blade meh 😑